Okay, so not a very clear thread title. I was trying to make it relevant without being wicked long...The *post* is wicked long, so there's a tl/dr at the end.
I'm aware that my emotions in this situation might be caused by, or causing, irrational thoughts. I'm also aware that I'm probably being a bit hypocritical, and that some of the problem is caused by my mental health issues and the baggage I haven't managed to unload yet from my last relationship. But knowing things doesn't always mean knowing what to do about them, and I could use some advice here.
I've known Woody for two months now. We've been involved for about a month and a half. On his OKC profile at the time I first contacted him, he mentioned having a partner who had moved "farther away" with her husband. I interpreted that--apparently incorrectly--to mean he didn't see her frequently. And since she was the only partner he mentioned on his profile, I assumed--also incorrectly--that she was the only one he had.
Fast forward to November 10, when he finally got around to telling me he and Highlight were involved. Over subsequent weeks, I learned his "farther away" partner, Stella, really isn't that far away, and he sees her about once a week schedules permitting. At the time he told me about Highlight, he said he started seeing her around the same time as me, but he told me over this past weekend that he started talking to her back in December of last year and met her for the first time in June of this year.
Here's where I'm struggling with a few things.
First, I feel like he wasn't fully honest with me about Highlight.
Second, some of the things he's said about Highlight, and the way he's said them (tone of voice and facial expression), lead me to believe he's putting more priority on their relationship than on his and Stella's or his and mine. This, again, may be entirely my wonked-up perception. He insists that he doesn't do hierarchy, that the only way a partner would have any higher priority at all would be if she lived with him. He insists that he loves Highlight and me equally and we're equally important to him.
Third, the big thing that contributes to the other two. I have not previously had a partner who had other partners, other than one FWB I saw for about a month. And I didn't *want* a partner who had other partners. This is the part that's arguably hypocritical, since obviously *I* have more than one partner.
I contacted Woody initially because even though his profile said he had another partner, I interpreted his phrasing to mean he saw her rarely if at all. I figured I could deal with that, because I wouldn't feel like I had to compete for his time and attention. If I had known Woody was involved with Highlight, or even that he sees Stella as often as he does, I wouldn't have gotten involved with him. But by the time I found out, we were already involved
I could have walked away when I found out the truth, but I wanted to try to become more comfortable with it. So far, I'm failing spectacularly at that. Woody is a good person, and he has been good for me, but I constantly fear that he's only tolerating me because I'm the one who's most available to get together with him. That if he finds another partner, I'll lose what I have because I'm not important enough to keep around. I don't believe him when he says I'm as important to him and he loves me as much as his other partners. When I'm with him, usually everything's good. When I'm not, I keep crying and wanting to break up with him because this is too hard and I don't know if the benefit is worth the cost.
I keep thinking I should be okay with it. I should be able to handle Woody having other partners. I should be confident enough to believe I matter to him as much as they do. But that isn't how it is. I've been honest with him that I'm feeling this way, but that's making it worse because on top of the other fears, I fear that he's going to get sick of the bullshit if I can't wrap my head around it soon.
tl/dr: How can I better handle being involved with someone who has other partners, when I'm having trouble believing him when he says there's no hierarchy or disparity in his feelings for us? Or should I stop wasting my time and his?
I'm aware that my emotions in this situation might be caused by, or causing, irrational thoughts. I'm also aware that I'm probably being a bit hypocritical, and that some of the problem is caused by my mental health issues and the baggage I haven't managed to unload yet from my last relationship. But knowing things doesn't always mean knowing what to do about them, and I could use some advice here.
I've known Woody for two months now. We've been involved for about a month and a half. On his OKC profile at the time I first contacted him, he mentioned having a partner who had moved "farther away" with her husband. I interpreted that--apparently incorrectly--to mean he didn't see her frequently. And since she was the only partner he mentioned on his profile, I assumed--also incorrectly--that she was the only one he had.
Fast forward to November 10, when he finally got around to telling me he and Highlight were involved. Over subsequent weeks, I learned his "farther away" partner, Stella, really isn't that far away, and he sees her about once a week schedules permitting. At the time he told me about Highlight, he said he started seeing her around the same time as me, but he told me over this past weekend that he started talking to her back in December of last year and met her for the first time in June of this year.
Here's where I'm struggling with a few things.
First, I feel like he wasn't fully honest with me about Highlight.
Second, some of the things he's said about Highlight, and the way he's said them (tone of voice and facial expression), lead me to believe he's putting more priority on their relationship than on his and Stella's or his and mine. This, again, may be entirely my wonked-up perception. He insists that he doesn't do hierarchy, that the only way a partner would have any higher priority at all would be if she lived with him. He insists that he loves Highlight and me equally and we're equally important to him.
Third, the big thing that contributes to the other two. I have not previously had a partner who had other partners, other than one FWB I saw for about a month. And I didn't *want* a partner who had other partners. This is the part that's arguably hypocritical, since obviously *I* have more than one partner.
I contacted Woody initially because even though his profile said he had another partner, I interpreted his phrasing to mean he saw her rarely if at all. I figured I could deal with that, because I wouldn't feel like I had to compete for his time and attention. If I had known Woody was involved with Highlight, or even that he sees Stella as often as he does, I wouldn't have gotten involved with him. But by the time I found out, we were already involved
I could have walked away when I found out the truth, but I wanted to try to become more comfortable with it. So far, I'm failing spectacularly at that. Woody is a good person, and he has been good for me, but I constantly fear that he's only tolerating me because I'm the one who's most available to get together with him. That if he finds another partner, I'll lose what I have because I'm not important enough to keep around. I don't believe him when he says I'm as important to him and he loves me as much as his other partners. When I'm with him, usually everything's good. When I'm not, I keep crying and wanting to break up with him because this is too hard and I don't know if the benefit is worth the cost.
I keep thinking I should be okay with it. I should be able to handle Woody having other partners. I should be confident enough to believe I matter to him as much as they do. But that isn't how it is. I've been honest with him that I'm feeling this way, but that's making it worse because on top of the other fears, I fear that he's going to get sick of the bullshit if I can't wrap my head around it soon.
tl/dr: How can I better handle being involved with someone who has other partners, when I'm having trouble believing him when he says there's no hierarchy or disparity in his feelings for us? Or should I stop wasting my time and his?
Last edited: