Our marriage was fine and still is. We have been like this since 2012. Dawn has had several lovers over the years and they've always been casual affairs. I think it’s me that’s being silly. Karl is madly in love with Dawn and it’s that I struggle with. Before they started dating they knew each other from work. She’s still with him in Stratford at the moment, but she will be back later and I’ll apologise for being jealous.
So you two have been polyamorous for over 10 years, but this is the first time a guy has been this in love with her? Is this also the first time Dawn has felt so strongly about another man?
It can be hard in life to find someone who really loves you and you love them back and everything seems really good. I guess since they've been friends for so long, adding in the romantic part is really exciting. They are quite compatible. And now Dawn is sharing TMI about Karl with you. You can ask her to stop telling you about how wonderful he is, in bed and out. She can share those details with other friends of hers.
You may think you're OK with having him over and listening to them having sex, but maybe that's not really good for you.
Meanwhile, it's perfectly OK to ask for reassurance. You can want this. However, think about what she can do to help you feel like you're still important to her. Maybe you want acknowledgment that you've been her partner for a long time, through thick and thin, and that this matters to her, and she values you. You really sound like you need some special dates to make more positive fun memories together, despite her new relationship.
That's what I've tried to do recently. I've got a bf of 20 months and in all my time of dating polyamorously, he loves me more than any other man has, and vice versa. It's awesome. At the same time, I love love love my long-term nesting partner and make sure to make time for us to have fun, cuddle and have sex, go out to museums or arboretums, etc., have nice dinners at home, get her a little "just because" gift, or whatever.
I remember when my (ex) husband and I first opened our relationship in 1999, and he met a woman he was really excited about. She was a long-distance gf, and spent Valentine's Day at our house. My ex h gave her the same present he gave me, and gave our 3 kids that same thing too: a box of chocolates and one rose. He wanted to be fair and prevent jealousy. I actually did feel dissed though, since I'd been with him for 20 years and he'd only been with her for about 4 months! (I thought I should've gotten a bigger bouquet lol) It was definitely a mistake for him to try to share that romantic holiday with both of us, even though we were trying to do kitchen table poly. We both made other clumsy mistakes, as well. I have learned from them.
I wonder if you've ever read the book
Opening Up. Even though you say you're experienced at polyamory, somehow it seems you're experiencing many things for the first time and are feeling kind of lost, upset, sad and frightened. This book covers all the bases of poly, how things can go wrong, how to keep things fair and balanced, etc.