Am I poly or not?

Dream21

New member
I am new to the servers and found this server while searching for help with a current issue I'm experiencing. I've been in a poly relationship for 2.5 years. I have one partner. My partner is married. My partner's wife and I are best friends, but not sexually or romantically involved. She has two other men besides my partner, whom I am friends only with, which brings my family count up to five. She has always been bisexual, and recently announced she would like to discuss opening the family to a new female for her. I was supportive until she said that this partner would need to be open to being sexually active with all of her partners, as well.

Here is where my problem lies. I became terrified at the idea of sharing my partner. But I already do! This created such emotional duress in me that I ended up in a panic attack, (which i'm prone to, especially since I usually do not open my mouth, but poly has actually helped me battle this, with open communication, support, etc.) and made me really start questioning just how poly I am. This was my first experience with poly and so far it's been wonderful. Of course, I still feel some bouts of insecurity and jealousy. But considering the friendship I have with my partner's SO, and considering how little time they actually end up spending together, I am usually excited for them when they spend time together.

I've been told by everyone involved that i will be part of the process, that only a person that completely fits into our family dynamic will hit the door, and even then, there will be tons of time to adjust. But this fear will not let up. I finally talked to my partner and told him i had to shelve this discussion for a while. I also told him I wasn't sure if i could ever share him with someone else. I also said I know how stupidly unfair that is of me, given that we live this lifestyle, and told him i would understand if this was a deal breaker.

He has told me we're going to shelve this, and that he didn't want to end this relationship. He also said if this was a deal breaker for me he'd rather be with the two of us and be done, tho he did think i was being short-sighted, and that his partner was asking for something that we could potentially never find.

But still, for me, it illuminated the issue of not wanting to share him further. I did say, however, that if someone amazing ended up entering who fit all dynamics and who he felt he could fall in love with, I would definitely reopen the discussion.

But I can't help feeling like a fraud. Am I monogamous? Or are these deep-rooted issues coming to the surface?

I can say right now that my biggest fear is less time spent. I also fear that by allowing this to go on, I've compromised myself somehow, and am "less" because of it. This thought kills me. Please give advice and insight.
 
Last edited:
I was supportive until she said that partner would need to be open to being sexually active with all of her partners As well.

So this unicorn that your metamour is looking for not only needs to be into her, but her husband, and her two lovers (and presumably you, if you want to "take her for a spin" every now and then)? Sounds like she's looking for a new chew toy for the group.

This is one of the risks inherent in dating as a group; looking at people as though they are puzzle pieces who need to fit perfectly into a predetermined shape. People don't work that way, which is why these types of scenarios end with really sad stories of how "poly just doesn't work." The problem does not lie with polyamory in this instance; it is entirely related to people not being able to relate to one another as adult individuals.

I became terrified at the idea of sharing my partner.

We can only share things which we own. While you continue to view your boyfriend as something that you have some kind of say over, I expect you will be resistant to living in a healthy polyamorous situation.

I also said I know how stupidly unfair that is of me, given that we live this lifestyle, and told him I would understand if this was a dealbreaker. He has told me we're going to shelve this and that he didn't want to end this relationship. He also said if this was a dealbreaker for me he'd rather be with the two of us and be done, tho he did think I was being short sighted, and that his partner was asking for something that we could potentially never find!

This part sounds right. The two of you seem to have encountered a fundamental difference in how you want to live your romantic lives, and recognize that this may not be a compatible issue.

Who knows? Maybe you guys will find the right unicorn who meets all of your requirements and all will be happy in the land. That seems pretty unlikely, but I guess unlikely things happen every day.

While I find these types of relationships to be horrific, I hope that you will continue to speak up for yourself and decide what you want out of relating and what you will put up with. If you decide you are not willing to "share" your boyfriend, then it may be time to put up your poly spurs and go get yourself a mono boyfriend.

I can say right now that my biggest fear is less time spent.

I want all manner of things which I'm not going to get, simply because I want my way. I'd love for IV to spend the night in my bed 2 or 3 times a week, but that isn't going to happen. Her work and romantic interests will be a drain on her time; as it should be. While I pout every now and then because I'm not getting the time with her I want, I am forced to remind myself that I can go out and entertain myself, and that she is not accountable to my boredom or loneliness. I am a grown adult, who was fully capable of taking care of myself before she came along, and nothing has changed since we started dating.
 
I appreciate your feedback very much. I admit, I still harbor monogamous tendencies, and for me, "deprogramming," so to speak, has been difficult at times. Said unicorn would not be for me, as I am straight. I am not involved with any of the other men in my poly family, though I certainly consider them family. We all live together, as well, so the bond between us is very unique and full of camaraderie.

I believe the main goal she was going for was the opportunity for those relations to exist. I don't disagree that this ideal situation is a stretch, at best, but I leave that to her.

I suppose then that part of poly is being able to focus solely on my relationship with person x and not worry about what they do when they aren't with me. In other words, it's my insecurities that are hurting me more than my partner's actions/desires. Would any one else agree?
 
I suppose then that part of poly is being able to focus solely on my relationship with person x, and not worry about what they do when they aren't with me. In other words, it's my insecurities that are hurting me more than my partner's actions/desires. Would any one else agree?

You nailed it. And what you just said puts you way ahead of the curve, btw. Focusing on what they are doing when they aren't with you, what they are getting instead of you, what they are giving to someone other than you, is looking at relating as if it were a competition. Depending on what your goals are, this will only hinder you in getting what you actually desire.

I desire intimacy and effortless romance, so turning my relationships into a competition will get me exactly the opposite of what I want.
 
Back
Top