recurring scripts of "problem poly"

Ravenscroft

Banned
I started writing this in another thread, & decided that it would only be unhelpful there.

(FWIW: http://www.polyamory.com/forum/showthread.php?t=96602)

It's a fairly common script with all the usual setups, melodrama, & outfall.

The socalled "relationship escalator" is a script: find your Soul Mate, marry, buy a house, spawn, retire, die -- leaving out the last step, it's pretty much every show on The Hallmark Channel. :eek: Even the musical cues are interchangeable (& the network could save itself a few bucks by simply buying a few tracks & reusing them on multiple episodes).

Some people persist in calling certain scripts "drama," but that's not true, any more than Hallmark movies are proper drama except in an extremely superficial sense. Drama is FUN... when undertaken by people who are aware when they're going for gut honesty & when they're totally hamming it up ("chewing the scenery").

I've long argued that the proper term is cheap melodrama,
in which the plot -- typically sensational and designed to appeal strongly to the emotions -- takes precedence over detailed characterization. Characters are often simply drawn, and may appear stereotyped.

Melodrama consistently displays "key constitutive factors": pathos, overwrought or heightened emotion, moral polarization (good vs. evil), non-classical narrative structure (e.g., use of extreme coincidence and deus ex machine), and sensationalism (emphasis on action, violence, and thrills).

Melodramatic films tend to use plots that often deal with crises of human emotion, failed romance or friendship, strained familial situations, tragedy, illness, neuroses, or emotional and physical hardship.

Victims, couples, virtuous and heroic characters or suffering protagonists (usually heroines) in melodramas are presented with tremendous social pressures, threats, repression, fears, improbable events or difficulties with friends, community, work, lovers, or family. The melodramatic format allows the character to work through their difficulties or surmount the problems with resolute endurance, sacrificial acts, and steadfast bravery.

Film critics sometimes use the term to connote an unrealistic, pathos-filled, campy tale of romance or domestic situations with stereotypical characters (often including a central female character) that would directly appeal to feminine audiences.
There are times on this site where I suspect that we are being played, that the story has been cooked up by someone who fancies themselves An Author &/or likes the idea of making "the poly community" look like a squawking gaggle of gullible morons. FWIW, I don't believe that to be at all true about the thread I cited above.

However, it's no less scripty (to use the Transactional Analysis term). To follow Eric Berne's example (i.e., Waiting For Santa Claus), the script that brought me here really ought to have a title because it appears on this site so regularly, but I've got no suggestion.

Among other scripty elements, it involves monogamy + 1, serial wing-walking, "support you in exploring your (heretofore nonexistent) bi side," & fortuitous accidents.

I'm not being cynical to point out that, now the BF has accidentally (indeed, sorrowfully :rolleyes:) cowboyed the OP away from her husband, he wants to lock her down to monogamy... except of course for using her as bait to lure a Hot New Chick (married, maybe?) into having a threeway, "just this once, honey, as an experiment" (of course) but after a few fun nights leading toward "she ought to just move in with us."

The only way to not be played by a script is to REFUSE to act it out. And that means first recognizing that it's a SCRIPT. Anyone who defends their playing a character does NOT want solutions except maybe how to sit back & enjoy being a Virtuous Loser, who at the end of the bad romance novel will be Sadder But Wiser. :rolleyes:

If anyone wants to suggest a brief title for the above-presented script, or to introduce other scripts they've noticed in the category "Poly In Trouble," hop in.
 
As I work around the kitchen, I'm clearing out my "shows to watch" pile, & have worked down to CW's Crisis on Earth X. Being as I find Supergirl annoying & The Flash getting there AND find crossovers to generally be not only pointless but stultifying, this isn't high on the list. But, heck, four episodes while I do dishes, & the occasional smile-worthy bon mot.

And was surprised to see an interesting conflict over the "relationship escalator" script.

Okay, so basically Oliver & Felicity are lovers who keep getting tripped up by fate. When they last tried to get married, someone attacked them & Felicity was shot. At the moment, they're back together, honestly seem to be in love (kudos to the actors), & are living together & co-parenting Ollie's teen son.

In this mini-series, they're attending the wedding of friends. First episode, Oliver (uncharacteristically nervous) stammeringly tries to ask Felicity to marry him. To my surprise, she firmly turns him down. Next ep, Ollie is crushed at getting bumped off the escalator. Felicity is unwavering: "I love you. I just don't want to be married."
We have something so good, we have something so great going. Let's not change that. Let's just stand pat with the cards we're holding.
Oliver's response pretty much sums up Escalator blindness:
I want to move forward.
She (calmly & gently yet emphatically) swears her commitment to him, then ends with "Please respct me on this."

:eek:

Well, now I really HAVE to watch the rest of it...:rolleyes:
 
I was thinking recently of suggesting a prominently placed flow chart with the recurring problems and suggested solutions. Doesn't seem like it would take our long term members much effort to chart it out.

Unfortunately I suspect that all unhappy families believe they are unhappy in their own way (good ol' Tolstoy) and/or want the reassurance of being heard, so it mght not help.

Leetah
 
Something I forgot to add...

While not so complex as scripts, tropes are often well-developed arcs themselves, & surprisingly consistent across time & media & cultures. When I'm looking at scripty behaviour & searching key points, I often wind up at some entry of TV Tropes, a long-running wiki. When paired up with Snopes.com, it's often invaluable for deflating airheaded fake news that takes off on Facebook or Twitter.

Unless you've got a trope (or meme) that's stuck in your head, the best way to get a feel for the TV Tropes site is just click on any phrase that looks interesting -- seems like half the words in any given article are hot. The "visual browse" page is a good beginning. Considering our collective commonality, Happily Married might be both amusing & instructive.
 
Back
Top