Unicorn? Or horse with a fake horn?

sortafairytale

New member
Here is my issue. I'm just going to throw it out there and hope you guys can muddle through the mess of my mind and help.

I started a blog here a few months back, when things were rosy and bright. I had decided to let go of issues that were mine and just let the relationship with our girlfriend develop how it would. Things were good, for the most part. Drunken times led to drunken arguments, but for the most part, we were a wonderful little triad full of love love love.

Nails and I are very affectionate people. Giggles claims to be and yet, though I have reassured her a million times it's okay to kiss us, hug us, hold our hands when she wants, it just doesn't happen-- when it comes to me. She has no problem showing affection when we are with Nails. At times I don't even have to be the one to initiate it. But when we're alone, or when we are in her neck of the woods (she lives an hour away from us) It all changes.

Example: a few weeks back, there was a big event in her town. She invited both Nails and me to go. Nails pulled us both into him and kissed us both. If we would have been in our town, we would have kissed each other after that. But she actually turned her cheek to me. Hmm... okay. So I chalked it up as her not being overly comfortable on her own turf showing her bisexual side.

I didn't confront her with it right then, even though it hurt. Later in the week, I brought it up. Not accusing her of anything, I just simply said I want to know what she was and wasn't comfortable with, because I didn't want to put her in an awkward situation and I didn't want to get hurt. She said she was fine with whatever display of affection I wanted. Fine, I accepted that. But then I started to notice little things. We only kiss when I kiss her. We only touch when I touch her. We are only sexual if I start it. I started to feel very unwanted. It was almost like to have Nails, she had to have me. So, fine!

Then we went on vacation. It was beautiful. I thought this would be a time to bring us together. We were in Key West, so it was nice for the three of us to move through the streets as we wanted, with no one even looking twice. Nails decided to stay in one day and let the two of us go shopping. I tried a few times to steal kisses from her, but she wasn't having it. I tried holding her hand and within seconds she switched her shopping bag to the hand I was holding. What?

I didn't say anything. Nails has a tendency to take my side, and I didn't want to sour our vacation, so I kept my mouth shut to both of them about it. We went out that night and I made a point to keep my drinking in check. I did drink-- I just made a point to get a comfy little buzz without having my head swim around in my emotions. I can get highly emotional and it's harder to keep my mouth shut with rum in me. However, this did not stop a fight from happening.

The bar we settled into was crowded with people. Some older ladies, I'd say late 50s to early 60s, asked if they could share our table, and we obliged. Giggles and I went to dance and it was like I wasn't even there. All she could do was look around me and watch what Nails was doing with the older ladies, which was nothing but talking and watching us. I think the oldest one ruffled his hair at one point. It was all cute and innocent.

I asked Giggles what was going on, and she was like, "What is he doing?" I glanced over my shoulder and then looked back at her. I can not tell anyone to ignore how they feel. That's not right. But I didn't want a scene and I could see it brewing in her eyes. I was careful what I said. "It's okay, Giggles. He's just talking. We can go back to the table if you want."

Her reply. "Hmmphf-- watch this." That is where I draw a line. My husband and I have a very very open relationship, but I'd be the first to say if he was being out of line. I asked Giggles to please not cause a scene. Let's just say if looks could kill, I'd be dead. But she behaved herself. She walked back to the table and just hugged him and kissed his cheek. I turned my attention towards the ladies, who were all full of questions about how open-minded I was about having a girlfriend. None of them were disrespectful, only curious.

Within moments, I was being yanked away by Giggles and dragged back out to the dance floor. She said she was fine, that the old ladies were nothing for her to worry about. We danced a bit and then BAM, she started the little lookie-loo game again over my shoulder.

I asked her if she and Nails had discussed yet what she's okay with and what she isn't when it comes to attention with other ladies. She said no. So I said for her to please let it go for now and the three of us will have a conversation when we are all sober and all in our right mind. For now she was upset with him for something he didn't even know he was doing.

Her response, "Two can play at this game! Let him have his old ladies. I'll find a 20-year old." I was floored. What the hell was going on? This was a side of her I had never seen. To be honest, I didn't like it a whole lot. But she was super drunk, and I can be very very forgiving. Once again I asked her to calm down and focus on me. That we would talk to Nails together and work out what is okay and what isn't. She obliged for a few minutes, though anyone looking at us on the dance floor would have thought I was with a friend, not my girlfriend. I kept trying to snuggle into her, but she wasn't having it. I wrote it off as her being upset with him.

The music ended and I had to go to the bathroom. I noticed Nails coming towards us. I asked Giggles nicely to please wait to confront him until I was back. Do you think she listened? I have never peed so fast in my life. I was away from them less then two minutes and when I came back she was snuggled up to him, grinning from ear to ear. The moment I approached them, she said, "We talked; it's fine."

This flicked a switch in me. I was pissed. I had asked her nicely to wait mainly because I didn't want it to blow up into a fight between two drunks. But also, I'd asked her to wait because earlier in the day she and I had agreed things need to start being discussed between the three of us, not just her and me, or me and him.

I stated I was pissed and that she was now messing with the dynamic of my husband and me. Of course I get that was the wrong wording. As soon as I said it, I tried to explain what I meant, but she wasn't hearing it. She told me to fuck off and she left. I threw my hands up, ready for Nails to come to her defense, which he did. And then he was gone after her.

Feeling like a complete idiot, I tucked my tail between my legs and followed. I walked slow, thinking he'd get back to the room and be able to calm her down and get her to bed, maybe get a quickie in to settle things…

I was wrong. I forgot the gate to the damn room needed a key, so I needed to be let in. I sent Nails a message. As I approached, I heard the door to our room slam and open again and the two of them screaming at each other. Then a beer can came flying at my husband's head. I kept my cool, though in the moment I wanted to rip the woman's eyes out. (Sorry, but you do not even attempt to hurt my husband or kids, or else I go instant mother bear on your ass.)

Ugh, this has turned into a long-ass story. Sorry. I'll try to speed it up. Screaming, yelling, clothing being stuffed into luggage. Giggles was going home. I finally calmed her enough to get her to sit so we could all talk. There were a few things said, mainly by me. She said she was tired of being the third wheel. So I asked what she wanted. She didn't answer, so I asked again, "Giggles, what do you want?"

Her response floored me. "I want him!" I shouldn't have been that surprised, but to have her actually say it stung me to my core. "Well, that's not going to fucking happen, honey. So you have a choice," came flying out of my mouth before I let myself process too much. "It's either all or nothing. We said that from the beginning."

She just looked at me.

I said it again. "All or nothing!" She said, "Nothing, 'cause I don't need this drama."

That was it for me. I grabbed a blanket and a pillow and went down to the pool to lie on one of the lounge chairs. I felt like I was going to suffocate. I don't know how long I was down there. I know I started to doze before Nails showed up. He brought me up to bed and held me while I cried. We both passed out.

The next morning, we all talked. I didn't bring up what was said or how she hurt me. I just wanted to finish our vacation in peace. I made no effort to have her alone, no effort to be the one to show her affection. I just floated by, smiling through it all, and enjoying my time with Nails and my friend.

I have an odd ability to separate Giggles into two people. I can see her as my girlfriend or as my friend, as needed.

So here we are back home, back to reality, and I don't know what to do. I know I have to talk to her, but I also know I'm going to get the same sideways talking from her I always get. I'll get no real answer on how she feels or what she wants. Whatever generic thing she tries to say to smooth things over, well, I don't know if they will.

I really don't know what to do, people. I love her… Nails loves her. I just can't keep this up if this is how it's going to be. If she wants Nails, well, I can't do anything about that.

Nails has already made it very very clear that he wants no side relationship with her on his own, if she and I are not in a relationship. He isn't looking for a girlfriend for himself. He only wants a girlfriend for us.

Help… please.
 
If you two are a package deal, and she is just not that into you, please do her a favour and tell her it is over. Sounds like a nightmare all around, to be honest.
 
I read your blog a few weeks back, but I did not get the chance to reply.

From all that I have read in your blog and in this post, it seems like she is just not into you. If ever you had any doubts, her saying that she only wanted him should have been the flashing neon sign. You having to issue any kind of "all or nothing" type of deal should not have ever been an option. Turning away from kisses from you, but happily engaging in PDA with your husband any time is a red flag for me. Talking something over with your husband and making them right without including you in the conversation? Red flag. You mentioned in your blog that if you treat her like a friend as opposed to a girlfriend when you are out, she "freaks out," but if you are in her area of the city, she pulls away from PDA. If I did not know any better, I would say she was only dating you to be with your husband.

I may be the only one who thinks this, but as much as you love her and care about her, I believe the relationship might need to end. It seems like a miserable existence.

You and Nails presented yourselves as a package deal, and she only wants the contents of the package, the ribbon/the paper, or the box it came in. Do yourselves and her a favour and end it now. She is not what you both want, and you are not she wants.
 
What do you mean you "get no real answer how she feels"? You got the answer-- she wants him, not you, and her actions agree with her words. You refused to believe her. You are in denial.

The End.
 
You're all right, and I know it. It's been a long long time since I've broken up with anyone, and this time I have three people to consider, not just two. So I think this need to give her a chance to fix it might be more for Nails than for myself.

The truth is, I know I would never put up with this crap from a man, so I'm not sure why I'm letting her handle me this way. It's sad though, investing a year of your life into someone and then reality sets in.

Thanks for the replies.

On a side note, Ry, I read your blog religiously. It's one of my favorites here. I love how you open up everything without holding back.

BoringGuy, no one could ever accuse you of being full of shit! You're always blunt with everyone and I love that!
 
Most of the time I'm just repeating back to people what they already wrote. Sometimes I do a little reading between the lines, going out on a limb, assuming, juxtaposing, etc., and I'm prepared to be mistaken and have it pointed out to me. But I realize what I am doing and purposely try to phrase things in the most "vulgar" (pedestrian, working-class) way, because that's how people think before it goes into the "filter" of brain-to-mouth-or-keyboard.

tl;dr: I appreciate the compliment. I know I'm not full of shit, this time, and even if I am, I bet I'm not, really.
 
after over a thousand posts, I am pretty sure folks know you by now

I appreciate the compliment; i know I'm not full of shit, this time, and even if I am, I bet I'm not, really.


But the million dollar question is: why?

Hang in there, Sortafairytale. Some people do the exact opposite of the behavior that would get them what they want. But either way, whether she is only into your man, or really wants you more, but is just playing games, she isn't worth it. People that do that kind of crap in regards to matters of the heart only cause pain for everyone around them. Consider yourself lucky you found out sooner rather than later.
 
Dirtcustard

The "million dollar answer" is "because."

Because why? Because people cannot get enough of this fabulous thing I see in the mirror every time I look, that's why. I won't bother explaining it to you. You either get it or you don't.
 
Knowing that some relationships work out and some don't, when you tell someone it's "All or nothing," i.e., two relationships or neither, you're putting them in a cruel situation, where there's so much weird pressure that I think it decreases the chances of either relationship working.

"Hmm... I'm not sure how I feel about this person. But I guess I have to continue opening my body and heart to them in order to be with this other person I deeply love. It's worth it for love, right? Sure does feel uncomfortable, though."

I'm not saying Giggles has been perfect in this situation. It sounds like some of her behavior was messed up. But I really think your approach is the driver of all the problems here. I hope you consider that "side relationships," aka, "relationships that don't put people in the position of feeling like they have to simultaneously make two brand-new hard things work in order to have either," might actually be the smarter, more ethical, and more functional choice.

Further reading:
http://davidlnoble.com/so-somebody-called-you-a-unicorn-hunter/
http://www.morethantwo.com/coupledating.html

I know this is harsh. I'm just so, so, so, so tired of reading variations on this exact same story.
 
Last edited:
So I think this need to give her a chance to fix it might be more for Nails than for myself.

Give her a chance to fix what? To show you that she really is into you? As others have pointed out, you've had a very clear answer. Words and actions match. She's there primarily or only for him.
 
In the end, you didn't care what she wanted. You only cared that she didn't want you. Would you have insisted that your husband continue to be affectionately demonstrative with her, even if he had realized he really wasn't into her, because it's "all or nothing"? Somehow I don't think so. Somehow I think you would have respected his feelings and autonomy more than that.
 
"I started to notice little things. We only kiss when I kiss her. We only touch when I touch her. We are only sexual if I start it."

The reaction of a person who cares about genuine consent: "Oh wow, this person doesn't really seem to be into me, but is going along with it anyway. The rejection stings a little, but far worse is the thought that they might be doing something they don't want to do because they feel pressured. That's the last thing I want. I'll give them some space so I can be sure that I'm not pushing anyone to have sex they don't want to have. That would be awful."

Your reaction: "I started to feel very unwanted and almost like to have Nails she had to have me, so fine!"

Paraphrased: "You're here to fill a role. I have access to something you want. I am willing to use that power to manipulate you into filling it in order to assuage my hurt pride and feeling of entitlement to your body and heart."
 
AnnabelMore, The "both or nothing" reaction was more out of shock she actually said "him" than anything. I had come to both of them several times since I'd been feeling left out, about them branching off without me, and her and me trying to focus on just our friendship only. Both of them said, "No, it wouldn't feel right."

I encouraged them even more by setting up a day where they could be alone while I was at work, thinking that if I gave them a chance that they would see they could work without me. Still both said no. Maybe I should have mentioned all that in the beginning, but I was starting to get long-winded, and tried to just wrap it up.

It doesn't really matter anymore. Giggles beat me to the chase and last night called and broke up with Nails and me both over the phone, claiming we didn't give her enough affection and attention. I'm not sure where she's getting that from, but if that is how she feels, it's how she feels. I'm sad that we didn't give her enough, even though we felt like we were giving her everything.

I again offered Nails the opportunity to have her on his own, and he refused, stating that most of what he was feeling was for the three of us and not just her, so he would let things end how they are. He also admitted that over the last month he has been trying to figure out how to end things with her without hurting both her and me.

So there we have it. It's over. And while I'm saddened by it, heartbroken by it, I know relationships end. I just want her to be happy with or without us.
 
Last edited:
Good for you for seeing the obvious solution. It's a shame they weren't willing to consider it. I'm glad for you all that you can move on. It seems like it'll be much better. *sigh*

I'm sorry for getting so worked up.
 
AnnabelMore, don't apologize ever for how you feel. Whether I agree or not with what people say, I completely respect their right to say it! It gives me a chance to look at things from other angles then my own.

FYI, I love reading your blog and your replies. Your words always sorta gave me the opportunity to see things as Giggles might.
 
I think it is all for the best. But please understand that just because a woman might not be into you, doesn't mean she is not bi or 'not so bi.' She was just not gay for you. In other words, she fancied Nails more.

I really hate women being slated as being 'not really bisexual' because they were not into both members of the couple. Sometimes some people just mesh better with one or the other.
 
Don't apologize ever for how you feel. Whether I agree or not with what people say, I completely respect their right to say it! It gives me a chance to look at things from other angles other then my own. FYI, I love reading your blog and your replies. Your words always sorta gave me the opportunity to see things as Giggles might.

Aw, thanks. That's nice to hear, and I respect your attitude.

I suppose, then, I'll say one more thing that was on my mind. The title of your thread actually encapsulates the problem for me. A horse is a cool, beautiful, strong, useful animal. Trying to make it into a unicorn (whether it's the "rider" or the horse itself that has the idea) is just going to lead to frustration, feelings of inadequacy, and the squandering of the really cool opportunity to enjoy the horse for the awesome thing it is!
 
Natja, Giggles was the one who said she was not bi, that I was the exception. I meant no offense to her or anyone else by changing my signature. She stated in the breakup that women are not her thing. I was her thing, and Nails and I as a couple were her thing. We just couldn't give her what she wanted. More then once during our relationship, she told not just the two of us, but people who asked, that she was not bi.

Hell, I started off claiming the same thing myself. "Oh, Giggles is just a fluke thing. I don't know why I kissed her back, but I did, and I liked it. I will never kiss any other girl." Of course, now I realize that isn't true. I don't know how soon I'll get into another relationship with a woman, but is something I would be open to in the future.

Annabel, the unicorn title was something Giggles placed on herself. I never wanted her to be anything but Giggles. I understand your point. All I meant by the title was the beautiful creature we had, while still beautiful, was an illusion that she made. Not because she lied-- I don't believe she had malice at all in this. I think it was an illusion because she was caught up in it, and then realized I wasn't what she wanted.

I'm okay with that. The last thing I would ever want is someone to be with me because they felt like they had to be, or because I try to mold them into something they are not.
 
Natja, Giggles said she was not bi, that I was the exception, I meant no offense to her or anyone else by changing my signature. She stated in the breakup that women are not her thing, I was her thing, and Nails and I as a couple were her thing. We just couldn't give her what she wanted.

Sometimes when people have a bad experience with one, it is easy to feel that it is women all around, not just that one woman. So bear that in mind.

Also, why have her in your sig, anyway? Exes who are still in your life (if she were still with your husband, for example) would be different, but she broke up with you both. Just remove her.

I don't know how soon I'll get into another relationship with a woman, but is something I would be open to in the future.

I hope you will consider looking for a woman without the condition that you come as a package deal. It's a hard ideal to live up to. It's hard to maintain. You could very well be in the same position you are in now, again, over and over.

Natja
 
I'm mainly keeping her in my signature as a reference for my blog. I will eventually remove her completely. I have no other reason.

As for the package deal, that was just how it went. It caught all three of us by surprise and we went with it. We all made mistakes, and I hope we all learned from them. Nails and I talked and right now he's pretty certain that if this happens again, the woman will have to either want just me or both of us. He doesn't want another woman and he doesn't think he's poly to the degree of running two or more relationships. Friendships with the possibility of sex now and then is more of what he wants. It doesn't mean that won't change later, it's just how he's feeling for now and how he was feeling for the last month or so.
 
Back
Top