Evolving and growing with polyamory

JuneauHiker

New member
This story isn’t completely comprehensive, as 3 years of a relationship is pretty hard to distill into an easy-to-read snapshot. But it hits all the main stuff between me and my partner, and you can get a pretty good feel of things.
I’m not posting this for advice, necessarily, though feel free to advise away. I do have a therapy session coming up, for that sort of help. Mostly I want this to be out there so people can perhaps learn from my experiences, or find something they resonate with, and because I just need to open up more than I have been, traditionally.

-Kyle

“When did you first become poly?”
It’s a common question between those of us that consider alternative means of love, sex and relating with other people. The answers are myriad and valid in all of their forms, and one of the reasons we ask is to learn the kind of polyamory others practice. Another is to learn what kind of experience(s) your prospects have had with non-monogamy.
This story is the latter answer to that question.
For myself, it all started with a book (like so much of my life has): Stranger in a Strange Land. Within its pages were concepts that challenged my presupposed notions about sex, love, and jealousy.
For those of you that haven’t read it, the story is about a human that grew up on Mars, and eventually was brought back to Earth as a sort of celebrity. Through the course of the book, the main character meets other humans and, perhaps through his “alternative” upbringing, introduces the concepts of shamelessness, sharing good feelings, and denouncing the ideas of jealousy - his thoughts being that anything that feels good and brings further goodness into the world should be celebrated.
For anyone considering a read of this book, know that it is rather dated. But it undeniably altered the landscape of alternative means to love, and today’s poly community probably wouldn’t look like it does without it.
After reading Heinlein’s Scifi story about a loving Martian-raised human, I came back to the idea of sharing love and lacking jealousy often. But for the next nearly decade and a half I stuck with the tried-and-true, exclusive monogamous structure, not realizing I was missing something by denying what I had felt for so long.
When I broke up with my then girlfriend and started searching for likeminded folk, I only had a vague picture of the kind of open relationship I was looking for. Sex was, admittedly, on the mind - my previous relationships had all been very vanilla, and eventually devoid of sex in their latter stages. Beyond that, all I knew was that I wanted off of the escalator to find those that I could connect with organically and without structure.
I dated around for nearly a year without much success. That changed when I met someone that would become very, very special to me, and continues to be.
As supposedly open-minded and alternative as I was, she challenged me in ways I never thought I needed to be, and widened my eyes on aspects of my life I never thought to examine. After a long period as friends (she was taken, in an exclusive D/bg relationship for the first few months, then worked a summer away at a remote location), we became partners and began living together.
The sex was fantastic, and we started exploring a Sir/kitty relationship, which neither of us had experience with, although as I’ve said, she was a babygirl for a few months. About a month in, we were screamed at by our landlady for having sex that was too loud, so we moved out. To this day both of our sex lives (together and separately) are affected by this experience. It interrupted the natural progression of our relationship and our come-down from NRE, and perhaps laid the foundation for further grief later on in our lives.
One of her main passions in life is to travel, a passion we both now strongly share. For three years now, she and I have crisscrossed the states several times and worked seasonal jobs every summer and winter.
She and I both have had issues with being able to communicate effectively with others, something we have both worked on since but in the interim provided some unfortunate misunderstandings, tears, and arguments. We’ve also very much discovered a difference in our natural communcation styles; I have a tendency to try to “fix” things, or provide wisdom and advice, a holdover from being raised by my mother, who doesn’t understand how to say no or to not bend over backwards. This conflicts with my partner’s independent streak, and her need to simply be heard and supported.
One of these communication errors occured during our first occasion completely seperate from each other. While finishing our first seasonal job together, she met and slept with a man while she was traveling. This was my very first test of compersion and polyamory - and I failed it spectacularly. My first feelings of inadequacy, which would become a recurring theme off and on, cropped up during this experience.
 
As we continued to work and live together, working different jobs and traveling, my feelings of “not enough” both in the poly sense and the kink sense increased, while her sadness over losing her solo adventuring life also increased. It became a common thing for us to work a season, both of us dissatisfied with our erratic sex life and arguing, then she would have a brief fling with someone she met off OKCupid or Tinder, and I either would have no luck or convinced myself not to even bother trying to meet others because to me there was no point. This made her nostalgic even further for her old life because she enjoyed connecting with new people, while simultaneously I considered my own lack of success further proof of my unworthiness and tarnished my self-image greatly (not because I was jealous of her success, but rather because I was envious, as I later realized). The sex we did have being mostly vanilla (some choking, spanking, and dirty talk was as far as we got) also greatly contributed to our issues.
This all came to a head during a Very Unpleasant Argument we had together, where I was drunk and became very angry, violently moving furniture. I did not hurt her, but it understandably terrified her and we didn’t speak for a couple of weeks. Afterwards, I was incredibly ashamed, to the point that I irrationally thought if our coworkers even looked at me they would know what happened. I started sleeping elsewhere, and for the first time in my life had suicidal thoughts (which I have conquered since). After much time alone, we slowly reconciled and began speaking together, but this situation drastically altered the shape of our relationship.
As said before we had a Sir/kitty relationship for a long time, and while that had mostly been phased out already, we still had a very Primary-type relationship before the Very Unpleasant Argument. While we were finishing the season at the job we were at, we restructured it to be “sort of together but not completely and mostly just friends.” Which worked pretty well for that time frame, sans a couple of arguments here and there, and we have ever since been sleeping separately. It’s very telling that during this “friends but a little more” span, we had the best sex in our entire relationship, and began exploring exhibitionism together, taking pictures in the woods.
While this all occured and was taking shape, for the first time in our relationship I connected with another woman, and we slept togther. This was the first time my partner had had to face the circumstance of me being with someone else, and despite the fact that we weren’t fully “an item” at the time, she was very jealous and distraught over it. She feels terrible for thinking this way, and struggles with it even though I have no current lovers or even prospects.
After this last summer season, we made it a priority to travel solo for an extended period and not constantly keep in touch with each other, besides bidding each other good morning and good night. I have been feeling much better about myself, working to accept and love myself, and I’ve been at least conversing with a few people outside our circle of friends. She has immensely been enjoying her return to true solo adventuring and her independence. Overall, we are doing much better apart.
Which catches us up to today. I’ve been preparing for something like this for most of the month, having felt a shift in what communication we do have. It’s been a gradual, natural progression to move away from our old dynamic into something more like just friends that used to be lovers. She called, and confessed that she had fallen in love with the man she stayed with when we parted earlier this month (they’d been communicating for months before they met). I wasn’t terribly surprised, honestly - her lack of talking about him since they met subconciously clued me in. I am, truly, very happy for her - something she doesn’t understand because, even though we are “just friends” now, she still feels like her heart will break if I fall in love with someone else, and because she wanted me to hate her for “doing this”. I told her she hadn’t done anything, because you can’t plan to fall in love with someone else.
At this point, we already had a winter seasonal job planned out, one that we both worked last year. I did encourage her to change her plans and pursue her new love and her passion for solo traveling, but she refused to make that decision over the phone because she still loves me and wants to be face-to-face before anything is decided. It has definitely been decided that we are no longer a romantic pair, and the closest we can come to a label that we agree on is Best Friends.
I am sad… but to be truthful, not desparately. It’s a more melancholic feeling, knowing that what we had is gone and we’re still transitioning into something else. I feel not being “an item” in any capacity is better, because I’ve seen a tremendous amount of growth in each of us individually. We were, perhaps, simply so wound up in each other that we couldn’t grow, and definitely could not pursue our separate desires.
I don’t know what the future holds for us. Perhaps, after an indeterminate amount of time, we can come back together into some kind of romantic setup. But, maybe we needed to just be Best Friends all along.
Keep loving, living, and growing, my friends.
 
It is a beautiful story. Quite insightful and respectful and accepting of both self and her.

Out of curiosity, what sort of "that sort of help" are you seeking in therapy? Or maybe I'm asking what's the catch driving you to share it here as well as go to therapy over it.
 
Thanks for saying so.

I'm sure there's plenty I haven't really processed from all of this, and I still struggle with self acceptance from time to time. I also want to break down some of the persistent societal hang ups I have about sex and how it's affected by being polyamorous (I'm going to a therapist that specializes in the lifestyle).

No catch. I just want to share, because I feel like that's part of the healing process.
 
I've been forcing myself to feel everything that this... I guess, separation, is creating. To that effect, I've disabled all of my dating profiles (FetLife, Tinder, OKC, etc), so that I have no distractions and I can accept the new turn my life and my relationship is taking.

There are other things I've thought of, but the one big thing I'm having a hard time getting over (and maybe it's just time I need) is this:

I expected things to end. I saw the patterns, I knew what was coming. I expected her experience finally being able to solo travel to be the main reason we ultimately decided to call things.

I did not at all expect the final nail in the coffin to be that she fell in love with someone else.

The thing is, even with that feeling, I still am so very happy for her. I think it's fantastic that she's reliving her solo adventures, and it's great that she connected so strongly with someone. It's just... it hurts that the romantic aspect of our lives didn't end wholly because of just us, and the things we've been through together.

I'm trying to alter my perception of this. I'm trying to acknowledge that it was ending, and that this just sped things toward the inevitable.

It's just fucking hard, you know?
 
1. You don't sound over at all. You sound like things "ending" between the two of you is a new phase in your relationship and are disappointed that another person is a part of that transition, and you describe her as not prepared to see you love another. She also doesn't want to make decisions on plans for your shared job without being face to face with you (not her love?). I mean seriously, if it is over, what does it matter if it ended with her finding another partner or if you find someone else or if she chooses how to spend her time mutually with the person she's in love with? What is so hard to explain about falling in love and making new plans that it needs face-to-face discussion?

2. Does her falling in love mean she's switched to monogamy? It is unclear what exactly has changed.

3. At best it sounds like your poly partner has found another serious partner, perhaps a primary, while you've been going through a reinvention of the relationship between two of you. And that you are seeing the end of the world in it, because garden variety jealousy and trying to take it philosophically, but not quite managing it. You are feeling rather dumped, which also makes no sense if the two of you were approaching the end anyway.

4. The two of you need to talk instead of using distance to buffer differences you can't discuss. Even if it is over, detangling your views of the relationship may be in order.

I suppose the face-to-face talk when you meet her and discuss the job thing will also help you get an idea of where things stand.
 
Last edited:
1. You don't sound over at all. You sound like things "ending" between the two of you is a new phase in your relationship and are disappointed that another person is a part of that transition, and you describe her as not prepared to see you love another. She also doesn't want to make decisions on plans for your shared job without being face to face with you (not her love?). I mean seriously, if it is over, what does it matter if it ended with her finding another partner or if you find someone else or if she chooses how to spend her time mutually with the person she's in love with? What is so hard to explain about falling in love and making new plans that it needs face-to-face discussion?

Frankly no, I'm not over it - this just happened a few days ago. I'll get there, certainly, but I definitely need time to feel it all out. I am disappointed that another person has become part of this process, because I was expecting things to end because of us, because of the things we need to talk about. Yes, it doesn't matter how it ended, and I'm leaning toward that perspective. It's just taking a little time, ya' know?

2. Does her falling in love mean she's switched to monogamy? It is unclear what exactly has changed.

Definitely not monogamous, still very poly. What has changed/is changing is our romantic involvement, if any.

3. At best it sounds like your poly partner has found another serious partner, perhaps a primary, while you've been going through a reinvention of the relationship between two of you. And that you are seeing the end of the world in it, because garden variety jealousy and trying to take it philosophically, but not quite managing it. You are feeling rather dumped, which also makes no sense if the two of you were approaching the end anyway.

This is just the gut-wrench feeling, and by no means constitutes how I will feel about it after some time to reflect. I just spoke with my therapist and already we're starting to work on that.

4. The two of you need to talk instead of using distance to buffer differences you can't discuss. Even if it is over, detangling your views of the relationship may be in order.

I totally agree on this, and I'm sure she does, too. Part of the reason is she's still deep in solo adventure mode, NRE with this new person, and we did have this season planned out to work at the job together. If for no reason other than to tell our boss she is not going to work here, she needs to come to CO.
 
I am disappointed that another person has become part of this process, because I was expecting things to end because of us...

Is he part of the process or just another poly partner? From the sound of it, she is very much still looking for one-on-one closure with you. If at all it is closure. Being jealous if you have another relationship ain't sounding like seeking closure on her end. Sounds very much like a stakeholder.

I'm going to go on a limb here and hypothesize that the two of you have a fuckload of unresolved shit and it is easier to avoid it than address it. Neither you nor your description of her is sounding "done" with each other to the remotest degree.

Or maybe it may be me seeing Spexy's symptoms in the two of you. He is very much into this distancing thing. He also has Avoidant Personality Disorder. Which is his excuse, not yours. In fact, I shared the link with him, because it sounded like a distancing success story initially, and I thought maybe he'd enjoy reading about distancing working for once. But right now, it is just sounding like two pathetic adults not looking at the elephant in the room. Or a whole lot of hallucination on your end.

Maybe ending things and moving on is right for you at this time, but even that doesn't appear to be done with any boundaries. If the two of you are over, and it is sounding very much like her idea, then either you hallucinated her jealousy over you falling in love or there's mega bullshit going on, or you did the reverse male possessive thing and assumed that her falling in love meant that the two of you were over.

If the two of you are so entwined that even a breakoff is a new level of intimacy/possessiveness, then you need a new name for what the two of you are up to. Neither break off nor "best friends" quite covers it. I'd joyfully dance my feet away at a best friend's wedding to someone else, you know? (aren't the monogamy metaphors handy for making a point...?)
 
Last edited:
Is he part of the process or just another poly partner? From the sound of it, she is very much still looking for one-on-one closure with you. If at all it is closure. Being jealous if you have another relationship ain't sounding like seeking closure on her end. Sounds very much like a stakeholder.

He was not, at least initially. I believe her falling for him accelerated the process, and nothing more.

As for the distancing avoidance... I guess I don't see it as distancing, because we've more or less scheduled our talk for when she gets here. No, we're not done because we have a job to figure out, whether we're at all together still, what kind of friend we are - yes, boundaries setting.

I definitely did not hallucinate her jealousy - she used the word when she expressed how she felt after I was with the other woman in AK. Also, I did not fall in love, it was just a quick connection since traveling, remote lodge etc etc.

We've actually had that exact conversation, about how best friends didn't quite cover it. We even looked up foreign words, but haven't come up with anything yet.
 
Hi Kyle,

Thanks for sharing your story, it sounds like your relationship is currently transitioning. Maybe not to the point where you are breaking up exactly, but neither are you exactly an item now. Maybe this is a way of learning and growing, try not to think of it so much as a breakup.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Hey Kevin,

Thanks for your words. That is what I'm looking at it as, now, but of course that doesn't mean emotions don't crop occasionally as I mourn the relationship we had =)

It'll definitely be good, for both of us, regardless of exactly what we look like together after this transition.
 
Re:
"It'll definitely be good, for both of us, regardless of exactly what we look like together after this transition."

I believe you're right.
 
Back
Top