Half open, with lies

JenW88

New member
Recently my husband and I discussed opening up our marriage, on his side only. We've been talking about it for a month or so now. We've been discussing boundaries, expectations, etc. He knows how unfair it is that he's asking for his side to be open while mine remains closed. He wants to include me, and we're also looking for a FFM situation in the meantime. Our sex life has been fantastic over the last month, like, we can't keep our hands off each other type of thing. We're more open and vulnerable to each other than we've ever been in the almost 5 years that we've been together.

I've told him repeatedly that I want to know what's going on, not be left in the dark when he gets a solo partner. A few nights ago, I told him I would be more comfortable with a threesome first, just because the thought of seeing him with another woman, if I were to be there somehow, I thought it might make it easier to grasp.

Anyway, the whole reason an open marriage/threesome was brought up was because of his desire to have sex with an ex (that left him, the only one that ever has), with or without me there. This is an ex that I also know. He was unsure of his reasoning for wanting to be with her again, if there were feelings (at one point they thought they were soulmates), or if it was just vengeful feelings for her dumping him. That scared both of us.

Also, he didn't want to feel restricted to sex with just one person anymore. He explained it as ours is more passionate, for the most part. Sometimes it was just good old "need it, down and dirty" fucking. He wants just down and dirty fucking with someone else, his own boundaries being no kissing, cuddling, feelings (other than friendly ones), and that he always comes home to our stability, which he genuinely doesn't want to lose. At the same time he assured me repeatedly that he would tell me (though he didn't think it was a good idea) if something were to happen with someone, but that he wasn't looking right now.

I travel a lot with my job; this summer I was gone at least 1 night a week every week. One of the weeks when I was gone multiple nights, I texted the lady mentioned earlier, just to see if I could meet up with her and talk when I got back to town. I think I would've done anything to make his dreams come true of having a threesome with the both of us, because of how hot it made us for each other when sexting about it earlier in the week. She thought it was weird that I reached out to her (which duh, obviously it was). I never got to the point of discussing anything sexual with her. I tell my husband about this and he is in shock that I actually texted her.

She kept cropping up in our discussions for the next couple weeks. Last week he sent me screenshots of him texting her to see if she would be interested in meeting up. The screenshots and conversation with him made me believe that she wasn't interested, so he was going to drop it for the time being. But he might try again in 10 years or so, once her kids are out of the house.

We then discussed how I felt like a place holder. I thought he would leave me as soon as she decided she wanted him again and left her husband. He didn't deny it. He said he didn't know what would happen, because he didn't know if there were feelings, or what was going to happen with us down the road. He did indicate that if it were to happen right now, he wouldn't leave me, because things were good. He just couldn't assure anything in the distant future.

This week I've been struggling with not feeling as close to him and I've been acting strange. I could feel something was off, so I did things that weren't normal. I was in bed waiting for him at one point, with one of our toys. He thought I was excluding him and we were both upset at each other the rest of the night and into morning.

I texted while at work letting him know I hoped he would have a good day and that I didn't want him to be upset with me anymore. He dropped the bombshell that he had been having sex with the ex mentioned earlier. 4 times, with 7-10 meet ups in the last 2 weeks, the first time being while I was out of town for work.

The most recent time something happened was the Friday before his birthday. I'd planned a getaway for us that weekend. We went and it was fantastic, so much talking and discussion, and great sex. He said he almost told me while we were there, and then a couple more times since they had been meeting in secret. He didn't know how to bring it up, so he opted to do so through text. He came clean and told me everything. The screenshot conversations were fake exchanges between them, because she was worried that I knew about them, and she has a marriage she doesn't want to lose. Any question I had, he answered.

We both worry about the trust issues we will have now. My issues are obvious. He thinks I will have sex with another guy out of vengeance, which is just not who I am.

While the person it is hurts, the lies hurt the worst. Since day 1 with him I've been up front about how honesty was my biggest non-negotiable. I hate lies more than anything. When you lie to someone it's because you think they're stupid.

How do I get over the lies?
How do I accept that this is the woman he is having sex with, outside of me?
 
How do I get over the lies?
How do I accept that this is the woman he is having sex with outside of me?

I'm sorry you're going through this, it sounds very painful. Let me briefly recap what I just read:

Your husband of 5 years is cheating on you with his ex. He would like to continue doing that, and also have your relationship be one where you are required to do all of the substantial emotional labour of supporting him having other partners, while he would not have to do the equivalent emotional labour for you.

I'm sorry, stranger, I don't know how to answer your questions; I would neither get over nor accept this situation.

Is "getting over" the lies and "accepting" that he's fucking his ex behind your back definitely for sure the option you want to go with?

...Just to add, this:

He wants just down and dirty fucking with someone else, his own boundaries being no kissing, cuddling, feelings (other than friendly ones)

Is a very common agreement with an extremely, extremely high failure rate. Good luck "just" fucking without ever giving in to the temptation to cuddle or kiss. And good luck fucking and not developing feelings, as if developing feelings wasn't the natural and predictable outcome of physical intimacy.

So I wouldn't trust a trustworthy person to uphold that agreement, even if they meant well in making it. And I'm afraid your husband has already proven himself to be untrustworthy.
 
Last edited:
Anyway, the whole reason an open marriage/threesome was brought up was because of his desire to have sex with an ex (that left him, the only one that ever has), with or without me there. An ex that I also know.

I texted the lady mentioned earlier just to see if I could meet up with her and talk when I got back to town. I think I would've done anything to make his dreams come true of having a threesome with the both of us, because of how hot it made us for each other when sexting about it earlier in the week. She thought it was weird that I reached out to her (which duh, obviously it was). I never got to the point of discussing anything sexual with her. I tell my husband about this and he is in shock that I actually texted her.

She keeps cropping up in our discussions for the next couple weeks. Last week he sent me screenshots of him texting her to see if she would be interested in meeting up. The screenshots and conversation with him made me believe that she wasn't interested so he was going to drop it for the time being. But he might try again in 10 years or so once her kids are out of the house. We then discussed how I felt like a place holder, I thought he would leave me as soon as she decided she wanted him again and left her husband. He didn't deny it, he said he didn't know what would happen because he didn't know if there were feelings or what was going to happen with us down the road. He did indicate that if it were to happen right now, no he wouldn't leave me because things were good, he just couldn't assure anything in the distant future.

I texted while at work letting him know I hope he would have a good day and that I didn't want him to be upset with me anymore. He dropped the bombshell that he had been having sex with the ex mentioned earlier. 4 times, with 7-10 meet ups in the last 2 weeks. The first time being while I was out of town for work. The most recent time something happened was the Friday before his birthday, I'd planned a getaway for us that weekend. We went and it was fantastic, so much talking and discussion, and great sex. He said he almost told me while we were there, and then a couple more times since they had been meeting in secret. He didn't know how to bring it up so he opted to do so through text. He came clean and told me everything. The screenshot conversations were fake exchanges between them, because she was worried that I knew about them, and she has a marriage she doesn't want to lose. Any question I had, he answered. We both worry about the trust issues we will have now. My issues are obvious, he thinks I will have sex with another guy out of vengeance, which is just not who I am.
While the person it is, hurts, the lies hurt the worst. Since day 1 with him I've been up front about how honesty was my biggest non-negotiable, I hate lies more
How do I accept that this is the woman he is having sex with outside of me?

Are the parts in bold all the same person? If so, does her husband know she's fucking your husband?

This isn't a polyamory situation. It's cheating. What Albert Ross said.
 
I'm sorry you're going through this, it sounds very painful. Let me briefly recap what I just read:

Your husband of 5 years is cheating on you with his ex. He would like to continue doing that, and also have your relationship be one where you are required to do all of the substantial emotional labour of supporting him having other partners, while he would not have to do the equivalent emotional labour for you.

I'm sorry, stranger, I don't know how to answer your questions; I would neither get over nor accept this situation.

Is "getting over" the lies and "accepting" that he's fucking his ex behind your back definitely for sure the option you want to go with?
I think our relationship is worth fighting for, so for the time being I want to try to get over it, or at least see if I'm able to. We're both new with this situation. I agreed to it being half open, though I did explain why I don't think it's fair. He understands, but for some reason is still possessive over my body like that.
 
Are the parts in bold all the same person? If so, does her husband know she's fucking your husband?

This isn't a polyamory situation. It's cheating. What Albert Ross said.
It's the same person. Her husband doesn't know. She doesn't believe that I know either. My husband has said if she did know she would probably put a stop to their dalliances.
 
I think our relationship is worth fighting for, so for the time being I want to try to get over it, or at least see if I'm able to. We're both new with this situation, I agreed to it being half open, though I did explain why I don't think it's fair.

What do you want from this forum? No one here is going to tell you how to "fight for" a cheating relationship. We can't make him stop cheating.
He understands but for some reason is still possessive over my body like that.
Gross.
 
I'm sorry you're going through this, it sounds very painful. Let me briefly recap what I just read:

Your husband of 5 years is cheating on you with his ex. He would like to continue doing that, and also have your relationship be one where you are required to do all of the substantial emotional labour of supporting him having other partners, while he would not have to do the equivalent emotional labour for you.

I'm sorry, stranger, I don't know how to answer your questions; I would neither get over nor accept this situation.

Is "getting over" the lies and "accepting" that he's fucking his ex behind your back definitely for sure the option you want to go with?

...Just to add, this:



Is a very common agreement with an extremely, extremely high failure rate. Good luck "just" fucking without ever giving in to the temptation to cuddle or kiss. And good luck fucking and not developing feelings, as if developing feelings wasn't the natural and predictable outcome of physical intimacy.

So I wouldn't trust a trustworthy person to uphold that agreement, even if they meant well in making it. And I'm afraid your husband has already proven himself to be untrustworthy.
Thanks, Albert. That was my thought too. I've worried and expressed my thoughts to him about developing feelings, especially with someone he's already been close with.
 
He feels possessive, sure, I get it. Just because he feels that way doesn't oblige you to agree. You could say, "Hey, if this relationship is gonna be open, it's open for both of us. If I'm gonna do the work of supporting you in having other lovers, I'm going to need you to do the same work for me. Will you?"

By the way? Both of you agreeing to do that work would be "fighting" for the relationship. If it's just you accepting what you do not want while he gets what he wants, that isn't "fighting", it's capitulation.
 
It's the same person. Her husband doesn't know. She doesn't believe that I know either. My husband has said if she did know she would probably put a stop to their dalliances.
How can she think you don't know if you called her?

Anyway, no one here is going to help you help your husband cheat successfully. There might be a forum for that on reddit.
 
What do you want from this forum? No one here is going to tell you how to "fight for" a cheating relationship. We can't make him stop cheating.

Gross.
You're right and I told him I considered it cheating. I guess I'm here for some clarity about how open relationships work. I've not known anybody in one.
 
This isn’t polyamory. Your relationship isn’t yet ‘open’ because he is lying and cheating behind your back with a woman whose husband presumably(?) doesn’t know she is also cheating. I suggest that if you sincerely want a polyamorous relationship that you ask him to agree to stop this immediately. Then spend some time together really investigating what you both want and agree on the parameters before either of you jump the gun. That’s if you can trust him in the future. It sounds as if he’s just using the excuse of being ‘open’ to explore unresolved feelings around his ex. You deserve honesty and respect. And you deserve better.
 
How can she think you don't know if you called her?

Anyway, no one here is going to help you help your husband cheat successfully. There might be a forum for that on reddit.
I didn't call her. I had texted her before everything with them started.
 
This isn’t polyamory. Your relationship isn’t yet ‘open’ because he is lying and cheating behind your back with a woman whose husband presumably(?) doesn’t know she is also cheating. I suggest that if you sincerely want a polyamorous relationship that you ask him to agree to stop this immediately. Then spend some time together really investigating what you both want and agree on the parameters before either of you jump the gun. That’s if you can trust him in the future. It sounds as if he’s just using the excuse of being ‘open’ to explore unresolved feelings around his ex. You deserve honesty and respect. And you deserve better.
That sounds like a good solution. I thought I trusted his motives and then he lied. I feel pretty stupid.
 
He feels possessive, sure, I get it. Just because he feels that way doesn't oblige you to agree. You could say, "Hey, if this relationship is gonna be open, it's open for both of us. If I'm gonna do the work of supporting you in having other lovers, I'm going to need you to do the same work for me. Will you?"

By the way? Both of you agreeing to do that work would be "fighting" for the relationship. If it's just you accepting what you do not want while he gets what he wants, that isn't "fighting", it's capitulation.
You're right. I need to take a step back from this.
 
He just wants down and dirty fucking with his ex wife? But he already resents her for breaking up with him. No one ever broke up with him before, and his pride is hurt. He's getting a thrill, and "revenge," by fucking her in secret behind her husband's back. He's getting a boost to his (weak) self-esteem by insisting he can fuck his ex and you can't also fuck others.

He already HAS FEELINGS for his ex-wife. They are negative feelings, but they are definitely feelings. Therefore, so much for the "not developing feelings" bit. lol

How long have you been with this guy, dating and then married? It almost sounds like you're a rebound relationship. He's never dealt with the pain (and other emotions) of losing his ex.
 
Want an honest opinion?

You're being walked. all. over.

Leave him. He's just hedging his bets so he can have his choice of women and won't be left alone if one of you smartens up and walks away.
 
This isn't poly. Poly includes talking about everything and creating a solid foundation in your relationship before you even think about seeing other people. And it can't be one-sided by force. He's using poly as an excuse to sleep with both you and his ex without consequences. He did cheat on you, by both mono and poly standards. And his ex may be cheating on her spouse as well. I would seriously look at if you should stay in this marriage. "Fighting" for your marriage is not putting up with your partner's selfishness. I advise counseling for yourself and as a couple.
 
I’m aware you’re getting some very frank opinions from us on this forum. Just to also say ‘sorry that you’re in pain and in a quandary’. If you set clear boundaries now and expect them to be respected, you may find a way through. If you don’t, you risk being hurt now, hurt while his affair goes on, then hurt again in the inevitable fallout.

I hear that you felt even closer and the sex was spicier when you were discussing opening up with him, but what you weren’t to know was that you were just feeding into giving him licence to explore sex with his ex. Sure, that was exciting for him.

Try to untangle the emotions from the facts of the matter. If he wants your marriage as much as you do, he will be as equally prepared to communicate (at this stage with counselling would be a good move); if he wants true poly he has to consider what you want to and agree not be to be possessive (even if you don’t chose to act on it). Stand your ground, and use us as a sounding board if it helps. Good luck 🤞🏼
 
Hello JenW88,

My vote is to divorce your husband, he is not being respectful towards you with the way he is lying to you, and the fact that he won't let it be open on your side. I know your sex life is good, but he should be showing you more respect. His relationship with his ex doesn't sound healthy. Also he is talking about leaving you for her.

You can stay with him for a while, and see if things improve. In case they don't improve, I would suggest setting a date on which you will break up with him. If they do improve, you can cancel breaking up with him on that date. I'm sure he doesn't want to lose you. One of your conditions might be that she must tell her husband about what's going on, and get his consent.

Sorry you're going through this.
Kevin T.
 
He feels possessive, sure, I get it. Just because he feels that way doesn't oblige you to agree. You could say, "Hey, if this relationship is gonna be open, it's open for both of us. If I'm gonna do the work of supporting you in having other lovers, I'm going to need you to do the same work for me. Will you?"

By the way? Both of you agreeing to do that work would be "fighting" for the relationship. If it's just you accepting what you do not want while he gets what he wants, that isn't "fighting", it's capitulation.
You're right.
This isn't poly. Poly includes talking about everything and creating a solid foundation in your relationship before you even think about seeing other people. And it can't be one sided by force. He's using poly as an excuse to sleep with both you and his ex without consequences. He did cheat on you by both mono and poly standards. And his ex may be cheating on her spouce as well. I would seriously look at if you should stay in this marriage. "Fighting" for you marriage is not putting up with your partner's selfishness. I advise counseling for your self and as a couple.
You're right. The selfish actions are getting to me and I just never really thought he was this selfish before all of this happened.
 
Back
Top