Breach of Trust with STI info of partners

Qarzan

New member
Hey everyone, you may remember my thread from a few months back, about GF and MA.

Here's the other thread (not necessary for understanding this thread): http://www.polyamory.com/forum/showthread.php?t=87776

Brief synopsis of that thread: GF started seeing MA; we discussed fluid bonding; GF promised not to fluid bond with either of us until we were all in agreement. She then had unprotected PiV sex with MA prior to any further discussion with me. MA got tested and had a positive result for HSV.

New situation:
I met someone from out of town (OT), about two weeks ago. We went on a date in the afternoon. There was snuggling and making out. I had a date with GF that evening and told her that there was snuggling and making out on my other date. I had a date with OT the following day as well, where we had oral sex and manual sex. No PiV sex. OT told me she has tested positive for HSV, and she wasn't having an outbreak right now.

GF and I didn't see each other for another week. I was at a leadership training. She was at a dance event. When we got back, we got ready for a 5-day camping trip.

New info: GF and I have been fluid bonded for about a month now.

Needless to say, we had lots of sex in the tent. Then the trip was done. We had another date just last night (Wednesday), more sex. Then I remembered I hadn't told her about OT's STI status yet, so this morning I just sort of blurted it out: "OT tested positive for HSV."

She replied, "Why are you telling me this?" She didn't know that OT and I had had another date the day after our first date.

Basically, her reaction was that it was a breach of trust. I didn't provide her the necessary information to make that decision about her own body. And I definitely can see that point of view.

Also, she sees a double standard: my standard of safety for STIs has historically been much more strict than hers. (If you want more details, you can read the thread linked above.) And now that I just forgot to tell her before we had sex again, that holds her to a higher standard than I hold myself.

I definitely see both of her points of view. I totally messed up here. I don't want to make excuses or justify or anything. I really just messed up and did a shitty thing.

Upon considering why it didn't occur to me as something urgent: in the past few months of GF telling me that my standards for STI safety were not in line with hers, that they were too strict for her, it had me re-examining my standards around that.

After doing more research, and hearing GF tell me things like, "HSV is really just a skin condition," my safety standards were in flux. I was in the process of removing the stigma of HSV, and metaphorically, "threw the baby out with the bath water" on this one.

I was okay with oral sex with someone who was HSV positive, and who wasn't in the middle of an outbreak. And I guess in my mind I kind of extrapolated that if GF's standards were lower than mine, she'd be fine with it, too.

Anyway, I just really messed up here, guys. She says we'll talk about it when she gets back from her weekend trip. Right now she's angry.

Any perspectives on what to do next? I love her to death, and don't see this as the end of our relationship.
 
Well, isn't this a two-person job? :confused:

You did not bring it up before sharing sex with her. Okay. A faux pax.

I don't see where she asked, "Since we last shared sex, is there anything new I should know about?" before sharing sex again. Where her body goes and how/when she shares it is her responsibility. If she's assuming things and not actually checking, that could be a faux pax on her part also.

To me, it is kind of like both parties could have done better.

Rather than be all mad about it, or pointing fingers over who fell down on the job worse, you could move it forward and agree from this point forward, that it has to be seen as a two-person job, because two people looking out for sex-health hygiene is better than 0 people looking out for it.

You could apologize for your share of the situation, and suggest that going forward in future, it be called a two-person job. Best if you remember to bring it up on your own, but if you forget somehow (people are human)... if she's also holding up her side of the stick, asking, "Before we share sex again, is there anything new since the last time we shared sex that I need to know about?" Then that could jog your memory.

And you too could ask her, "Anything new I need to know about on your side before we share sex again?" And if she had new stuff she forgot it could help jog her memory.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
I had a date with OT the following day as well, where we had oral and manual sex, no PiV sex. OT told me she has tested positive for HSV, and she wasn't having an outbreak right now.
You are aware that herpes can be transmitted (by oral sex or even by touch) even if there's not an obvious current outbreak site...? It's called viral shedding.

You mention two people of four who "tested positive for HSV." What about the other two?

And if you mean HSV-1, an estimated 100,000,000+ people in the United States are positive -- 1/3 the total population, more than half the adult population. (Some estimates say at least 80% of the over-50 population is positive for HSV-1.)

Setting all that aside, it does sound as though "fluid bonding" is a recurring (constant?) stress point for the two of you. Maybe it's about time that the two of you put it aside, and simply attempted to keep yourselves to high standards of avoiding "accidental" pregnancy and contracting STDs. Then you can also continue to work on both your communication skills and your respective self-disclosure abilities.
 
Hi Qarzan,

One thing I observe is that GF is angry at you for something she herself did, in fact when she did it it was PIV sex not just manual/oral. She is kind of being hypocritical, and getting defensive about it, at least that's how it seems to me.

As for what to do to move past this, I guess you and GF both should avoid sexual contact with others, until you and GF have discussed it between the two of you, and have come to an agreement. And maybe, all parties involved should get tested before having sexual activity with one another.

Just some of my thoughts.
Regards,
Kevin T.
 
Back
Top