Broken rules, poor communication, feelings of inadequacy

TheBlackSwede

New member
My wife and I recently decided to explore our sexuality more. We opened ourselves up to other partners. We have done this in the past, but wound up hurting each other. With the growth we've experienced in the years since, the comfort we have with each other, and confidence we have in ourselves, we decided that we could overcome the obstacles that hindered our polyamorous explorations before.

Her work schedule is very intense now, so our son and I took a trip for over a month, with family out of town, since we wouldn't really see her anyway. It was only a week or two after I left town that she took her first new lover in a long time. The news excited me, though I was a little caught off-guard by the intensity and length of their interaction. They stayed out late, had many drinks, and banged pretty much all night long, and then again the next morning before she left for work.

Already there are some broken rules, mostly her own rules:

They didn't use a condom.
He stayed over (not expressly forbidden, but something that we viewed as further down the line, and as a maybe).
It was a weeknight, and she hardly slept.
She went to sleep without calling me to say goodnight.

That right there got me worried, though she insisted I have nothing to worry about:

She says she loves me and wants to be with me as much as ever.
She is just exploring something new.
I have no reason to feel inadequate.
I'm "better endowed" than him (not that this really makes a difference to me).
She told me that while they had very good sex, I was still tops.

She was with him again the very next night, and two nights after that. They've seen each other numerous times since. He stayed the night again in our home once or twice more.

Their lovemaking sessions continued to be lengthy, involved, passionate, and rough, too. She used words to describe him like "vigorous, dominant, takes what he wants, virile, persistent, extremely driven," etc. This makes me feel a little uneasy.

More facts came out that bothered me a little, and each time I thought I had completely processed everything and was 100% okay, there was something new that I found out that threw me for a loop, and I had to process all over again.

Apparently he slaps her in the face, and she likes it. (I tried that once during sex and it ended badly.) There are some other things in a similar vein that she'd never enjoyed before him. She insists that it isn't "him" that made her enjoy it, but the "way he did it, and his attitude."

I also found out that he was on cocaine the first night they were together. (No drugs for anyone involved was another of her rules!) Then later on I found out he was on steroids, which triggered an "Aha!" moment for me, and further contributed to my own building feelings of inadequacy.

She recently came out to where I am for a visit. She needed to travel nearby for work the next week, so took a weekend with myself and our son. and the first two nights were good. We had very good sex, and even got a hotel room for a night for a romantic getaway, with the boy at my folks' house.

The third day, her story started to change a bit. She owned up to what I'd suspected all along, that her lover is superior to me in the bedroom, though she says only by a small margin. This is not something that in and of itself would bother me. I don't need to feel superior to everyone in the world to feel good about myself, and I know there are many far superior lovers out there to me.

But this confession made me question everything else we've talked about, and brought up all my other worries and concerns, again. When it all adds up, I feel emasculated, because:

He's physically larger than I am (not in all ways, though, and he's chunkier).
He's a better lover.
He's on drugs that greatly improve one's sexual prowess (and that she'd kill me if I were to do).
He's reduced her inhibitions more than I was able to.
She's broken her own rules.
She doesn't like it when I do the same things he does. She says it's because I don't do it the same way, but I have to wonder if the difference is not the technique, but the man.

This all came to a head Sunday night. I was very rough and dominant in bed, and she said she felt "trashed" afterwards. I thought I was giving her what she wanted. Afterwards, she was very upset, and I was very upset, and we had a big discussion that turned into a fight about all of the issues. It really sucked to end her visit on such a bad note. She said she felt like she was being interrogated, and that I was blowing things totally out of proportion. She might be right. I don't know.

We've talked since, at length, and I've discovered that I had some creeping feelings of inadequacy before all this began, though maybe I buried them:

I haven't been feeling 100% sexually lately, which contributes to it.
I've been overtraining in the gym.
I'm getting older. I'm 30 now.
I'm feeling the effects of my masculinity beginning to wane.

She insists that I have nothing to worry about:

No need to feel inadequate.
I'm a very good lover.
She loves me very much.
It's just fun, no strings attached, NRE sex with her lover.

She just wants me to fuck her brains out this weekend when she comes back for a visit, and wants to see her lover from time to time when we're all back at home again.

I worry because if she felt the need to hide the truth about his superior skillset, what else is she hiding? I've asked myself what she'd have to gain by hiding anything from me, and the answer I've come up with is freedom from guilt when she's with him. That's a powerful motivator. She's feeling hurt because my confidence has taken a blow. She feels like its her fault, though it certainly is not!

I have zero jealously over her receiving pleasure from another man. In fact, it turns me on to see her so sexually liberated. It's the little things that added up one after another that brought me down, and the one big thing, in my mind, the fact that she hid something from me. Our primary rule is to be completely open and honest with each other about everything. She thinks she was in denial about it, and that's why she didn't tell me-- a plausible explanation.

I'm probably blowing everything out of proportion. This has been a mostly positive experience. In many ways we've been communicating better than before, and I'm glad that these feelings have been dragged to the surface so that we're both aware of them, which can't be bad.

The tough part now is overcoming them, without resorting to drugs.

My confidence is recovering, and my mojo is on its way back up. I've met a new lover myself, more recently than my wife, and we have a passionate connection. But she's in a tough situation (and I'm staying with my parents) so we don't get together much. The NRE from that is a big help, to be sure.

I guess I'm just looking for support and reassurance, and a new set of eyes on these circumstances, to tell me whether I should be worried or not.

Sorry to post all this here and not in the Introductions forum. This seemed like a more appropriate place to air all of this out.
 
Alrighty. Well, it is very common, once any kink gets involved, for people to have an easier time doing it away from the person they live with, and love the most. Sometimes the brain cannot process or separate things. When you do those things to her, she sees the man she loves and lives with hurting her. She does not see you trying to give her what you think she is looking for. On the flip side, many husbands find they can't get rough with their wives, because of that love and emotional bond, yet they can with their girlfriends.

This is based only on who we are as people. Neither way is right or wrong. That internal wiring creates a need to keep certain aspects separate from others, much like some of us mix our food up and eat it, and others eat each portion of their meal separately.

Can she overcome this? Maybe, if she wants to.

I am going to try hard not to inject my personal opinion on people who use hard drugs while screwing. (I only partially succeeded, as I obviously felt a need to mention my dislike. ;))

My guess is she is having the time of her life with raw, exciting sex. She couldn't care less about his cocaine use because she has no plans of shacking up with him.

I would say forget the specific things that are bugging at you, and look at the bigger picture. You two need to seriously discuss the breaking of the rules.

At the least, you two need to discuss whether your initial rules were appropriate. After that point, you might want to discuss her disregard for those rules she helped set in place. You are entitled not to be swept aside. It's disrespectful, what she did. Good news is, she feels comfortable telling you the truth, even though it may be hard to hear.

Edit to add: have a heart-to-heart chat with your wife, about what seems to be her need to feel like a wild child. With her work load, she seems to possibly be experiencing some daredevil desires. She is enjoying the freedom and lack of responsibility. Sex, drugs, rock 'n' roll, and rule breaking. That's all well and good, and can be fun, but it stops being fun when she puts her stable relationship with you at risk.

P.S. please don`t call 30 "older." :p
 
Last edited:
Honestly, not everyone can offer everything sexually to a partner. This is reading more like a sexually-open relationship than polyamory. You are her lover. He is a dominant fuck friend. You can each give her what she wants and still be strong individually.

Boy oh boy. If you feel your masculinity fading at 30, you are in for a lot of trouble. Age has nothing to do with being masculine. It's in your head. Once you learn that, the idea of being "old" kind of goes the way of the dodo.
 
Can I second or third the condom rule? Some STDs are completely invisible and don't scream, "Hey! Look at me! I'm going to kill you!" HPV can lay dormant for twenty years, and is being linked to all sorts of nifty cancers. Maybe not as frightening as AIDS, but take it from someone who had a large portion of her cervix removed, it's still scary.

Don't worry about the fact that he gets away with things you don't. You don't get away with them because she cares about you.

He's a fuckbuddy.

In my relationships, part of the attraction between my husband, Easy, and our girlfriend, Asha, is that they like to be rough. Early on, I tried to keep up and play as rough, but I found it frightening to see him in that role, and it made me feel tense around him in our real life. I depend on Easy to be a caring husband and loving father and caretaker when I'm sick or scared. I couldn't handle seeing him as a scary person.

She felt "trashed" when you treated her rough because she counts on you to show her respect. I'm guessing that with him it's all about sex, and with you it's about feelings. She doesn't care how he sees her, and she doesn't see him as a big part of her life.

I worry about this complete tossing aside of responsibility. You guys have a kid, and it kind of scares me that she's involved with someone who is on cocaine.
 
Sometimes I get so into wanting to respond I don't read what others have said, so if I repeat anything, I apologize. I might come back and say more after.

First off: HELLO???!!! They didn't use protection and you are worried about the kind of sex they had?! You have a child to think about! Let me guess, you and she didn't use protection after she had sex with this other guy, either? Now you both could be infected with something. I am surprised at your lack of concern over that fact, especially at your age. :cautious: That, to me, shows huge lack of responsibility. I would suggest getting tested as soon as you can, and then tested again in 6 months. This guy sounds like he has done this kind of thing before, and has probably not used protection with numerous women.

It sounds like he is using your wife for a good time, not a long time, and that he is taking advantage of the fact that you aren't at home. I bet if he meets you, reality will set in, and he will be gone shortly after.

Sex like that does not last. You are the baby daddy, not the lustful stud. You are the one she is attached to. That is long lasting, not what she has with this guy. Who cares if he is good at sex with her? It's new, of course it is good. It is someone she hasn't had before.

It bugs me that she broke so many boundaries or rules. To me, that's cheating, not an open relationship, which is what this sounds like, more than polyamory, as I don't remember the mention of love, or any kind of steps to commit to knowing her in any way other than drunk and high in bed. When boundaries are broken, then resentment, distrust, deceit, denial, and disrespect set in.

You seem to have a long journey ahead to get this polyamory or open thing. Lots of trust is broken now. I feel for you. Protect your child first. He is your best interest here. Not either of you.
 
Last edited:
Wow. Thank you all for the replies. There's a lot of good things to think about in there, some very solid advice.

Open vs poly: yeah, this is primarily an open relationship/swinging, I guess, if we're getting really specific with labels. She and I are primary, but we're open to secondary lovers and affairs, even some lighter emotional involvement, but we're not fully polyamorous.

STDs: HPV can be spread easily even when wearing a condom. It affects the entire genital region and spreads through skin-to-skin contact. Condoms only cover the penis, not the surrounding area. HPV has even been known to spread through kissing and handshakes. It can also be vaccinated for now (some strains).

We actually had HPV 10 years ago, but have shown zero signs of it still being in our bodies for the past 5 years. So... yeah, we know HPV sucks, but it's a risk you take even if you do wear a condom. She assures me that they had a talk about STDs, that he had a test done less than 2 months ago, that he's free and clear, and hadn't been with anyone other than her since the test,

Breaking trust: I'm not particularly worried about STDs in this instance, for the reasons I gave above. But it does worry me that she broke her own rules and our trust, and she did so hardly thinking about it. This was tough, and we talked through it. It was the first of a number of things that I didn't like about everything. As I said before, they kinda kept coming one after the other.

Neither of us likes condoms at all, so it's difficult for me to blame her for not wanting to use them. Maybe she felt like she could break that rule at will, since it was she who was so insistent upon it in the first place. She later told me she was mostly afraid of me getting someone else pregnant.

Drugs: She told him she doesn't want him doing coke around her at all, or before he's going to be with her, and she says he agreed to that. In fact, she said that he has stopped doing it altogether. Whether that's true or not, I don't know.

The steroid thing, she still has not pressed him about. I suspect it's because she knows that the 'roids are a major part of the reason she's having so much fun, although she was rather surprised by how small his testicles are compared to mine.

In any case, I certainly don't want him around our son, and don't expect that he will ever be. Were he to make an unexpected visit to our home in an aggressive and drugged-up state, he would very rapidly discover the fact that I am more than capable of defending my family, and will not hesitate to do so.

Very interesting notion that it may be easier for her to be treated that way by someone she doesn't care about. I never looked at it that way. In many ways, it makes sense. I've honestly always been uncomfortable being particularly rough with her, and other women, simply because I'm afraid I'll hurt someone. I don't like hurting people, and have never taken any pleasure in it, even when it was necessary to force submission out of someone who was armed and dangerous during a physical confrontation. When my wife and I are rough in bed, I have never felt 100% comfortable with it, though I like how some of it turns her on. That's what gets me going, her being turned on, and that's one of the reasons I'm fine with her enjoying another man. The fact that it turns her on turns me on, and it snowballs.

Again, thanks so much for the replies. We're going to talk again tonight. The rule-breaking/trust/betrayal is going to be a topic of conversation. I think that's part of why I felt emasculated, as though this guy must be superman to make her throw the book out the window so quickly.
 
Wow, you seem way more worried about the fact that this guy fucks your wife better than you do, than the fact that you could get or give STDs to all of you, and that he is a coke head, and is juicing. I wouldn't want my child anywhere near someone like this. I would be really fucking angry if this shit was brought into my life. It would be a deal breaker. I think I would say, "End it, or I'm gone, and taking the kid with me."

I have no tolerance for that kind of thing. Then again, I don't get swinging or the whole open thing in terms of casual fucks. So maybe that's why.
 
Wow, you seem way more worried about the fact that this guy fucks your wife better than you do than the fact that you could get or give STDs to all of you, and that he is a coke head and is juicing. I wouldn't want my child anywhere near someone like this. I would be really fucking angry if this shit was brought into my life. It would be a deal breaker. I have no tolerance for that kind of thing.

I don't have any reason to call him a liar, so I'm not going to assume that he is one. There's also a difference between someone who has done coke from time to time, and someone who is a cokehead.

I think, in regards to steroids, that most people have a strongly negative connotation with steroids, and one that is not entirely deserved. They can be done in a healthy manner, and often are. It is true that they can greatly damage your health if abused, and that some people experience rage and other issues with them, but they are in a minority. People who are well-educated on the subject tend to share my non-freaking-out stance on 'roids. Drugs are less of an issue to me if they're something that does not adversely affect the rest of one's life.

I do also trust my wife's judgement. Despite the fact that there are some things I don't like about this guy, I can't jump to conclusions, because nobody is perfect, and I'm no exception.

My wife, in the past 12 years that we have been together, has always been a good judge of character, and I'm not ready to throw out 12 years of good decision-making history over something that is easily blown out of proportion.

I've also already come to grips with the drugs and bareback sex, at least for the most part. The revelation of his superior skills were a far more recent development, and something that, in congress with everything else, threw me into a tailspin. Does that make more sense?

Certainly, looking at things from a wider perspective, it does seem a far smaller issue.
 
You don't know anything about his drug use. Can you say whether or not he uses anything else? Can you say for certain he doesn't also shoot up while sharing needles? Seriously, dude, if you don't know for certain what he does or doesn't do, the responsible course of action is to use as much protection as possible. For me, should my wife do anything so irresponsible as what you've described your wife doing, the course of action would be simple: no sex until he's gone and after getting tested, with protection used for six months or so to make certain he left nothing behind.

As for the lies and such, well, there isn't much of a relationship in the aftermath of that, and certainly not a marriage. There'd have to be a lot of apologizing and serious communicating, and probably serious counseling for her, to keep me from a date with the divorce attorney.

I can see why you'd feel emasculated, because it appears to me she chopped your balls off. That you seem to be okay with that is something I find sad, though it's your life to live. You appear to be bending over backwards to make excuses for her, so I have to wonder why you posted here to get feedback.
 
Okay, now I think you're blowing things further out of proportion than I did. I'm not so sure it was intentional that she hid the ball on the guy's skills. She may have been in denial. We have a very open honest relationship and we talk everything through. One of the reasons she got upset with me is because I insisted we talk this out so thoroughly, and it made her feel very defensive.

It's not like she went behind my back, and then tried to hide it from me. If I asked her to stop seeing him, she'd do so at the drop of a hat.

Furthermore, this is my wife you're talking about. We've all made a few irresponsible choices, and apart from this, she's an amazing woman, who is quite successful and has proven herself time and again to be highly responsible. I'm not going to kick her to the curb because she finally let her hair down and let it go a bit too far.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Okay, SvartSvensk. What is it that you are looking for in this? A lot of us have responded to your thread, and apart from a few things that resonated for you, there doesn't seem to be any questions you want answered or opinions that work for you. Is there some kind of feedback you do want? Perhaps starting with that would be better. I think we all have a sense of how we would deal with this. We know how you are, so far, and a lot of that seems to be different than most of us. So now what?
 
Reading down through the posts, it got me to thinking how your wife went wild and broke a lot of rules, and cocaine was included in the equation. I had a problem with that, when I was 20, for a year or so.

I'm now 46 and have never touched a hard drug since. After trying that stuff once or twice, you start getting that grinding feeling that you can't wait until the next time you can do it again. I would be very concerned that you could be being lied to on this level, also. It doesn't take but a few times to get a habit going. Once that happens, she could decide to ditch her old life. It could change the wife that you once knew into someone you don't know at all. Not to say this is what is going on, but zebras hang with zebras.

I'm not going to delve into the rest of the story, but I would just be careful and keep my eyes wide open. This kind of situation, and how it's been handled so far, leaves the door wide open for lots of problems, and you don't want that for your once happy family.
 
HPV can be spread easily even when wearing a condom. It affects the entire genital region and spreads through skin-to-skin contact. Condoms only cover the penis, not the surrounding area. HPV has even been known to spread through kissing and handshakes. It can also be vaccinated for now. We actually had HPV almost 10 years ago, but have shown zero signs of it still being in our bodies for the past 5 years. We know HPV sucks, but it's a risk you take even if you do wear a condom. She assures me that they had a talk about STDs, that he had a test done less than 2 months ago, that he's free and clear, and hasn't been with anyone besides her since the test.

While it is true that HPV can be spread even with condom use, recent research indicates that condoms are more effective at preventing the spread than previously indicated. Also, the vaccination only works against two forms that cause cervical cancer, the two most common, and only works on women who have not already been exposed. In addition, the vaccination has not been tested for and is not recommended for women over 30. Lastly, the forms spread through kissing and handshakes are not the same strains which cause genital warts and cervical cancer.

I'm certainly glad that he had a test and came up clean, but boy, I hope she's not just taking his word for it.
 
My wife is very anti-drugs, and is not doing any of them. She even insisted that he not do them around her.

As I said, he says he has stopped altogether. But knowing cocaine like I do (to quote Rick James, "Cocaine is a helluva drug"), I have a hard time believing he's quit altogether after years of use just for someone he's sleeping with.

Redpepper, I guess what I was looking for is an outsider's perspective on our situation, and insight as to why she did what she did, when it's very out of character for her. Her explanation is that she was a little drunk, and a lot horny. She feels terrible about breaking the rules, and that's one of the reasons she got very defensive when I pressed her for the details.

The other is the fact that she didn't want to hurt my feelings by letting on that her lover is a little bit better in the sack than I am, and the reason she didn't tell me initially is that she was still processing the details and not really sure what the truth was. It's amazing how sometimes it can be a grey area.

So far, the replies have been very insightful. The truth is, I am more upset by her breaking our trust and our rules than I am by the fact that he's giving her such amazing pleasure. I think the two got wrapped up in my mind and added to my own feelings of inadequacy, and got me wondering, if she's willing to throw everything out the window for this guy, and had better sex than with her husband, what am I doing wrong?

Having talked with her at length, I think the truth is that even though the two of us do have very good sex together:

We were kind of in a rut (as many married folk tend to be).
She hadn't been with another man in many years.
She had been apart from me for a week or two.
She was very lonely.
She was stressed out from work.
She was very horny, and when she let herself go, she went too far, in a huge explosion of pent-up passion and sexual energy.

She knows that this level of recklessness is unacceptable and has pledged not to let it happen again. She's never done this before, in 12 years of us being together, and I have no reason to think she'll break her word and bring upon herself the shitstorm that will ensue if she does it again.

What I'm still undecided on is whether to let her see this lover again. On the one hand, they had a great time together, and I know she wants to see him again, so that makes me feel like if I deny her that, it'll just make her want him more.

On the other hand, I just don't think he's the kind of guy I want in my home. I'm still coming to a decision on this one.

Either way, we're instituting a new rule: when choosing a lover, consider how you would feel about them meeting both of us. Don't choose a lover you would not want me to meet, and vice-versa.
 
SvartSvensk, you sound like a very special and understanding man and I hope your wife appreciates what she has in you. I also hope your sex life together gets a "jump-start" from this whole experience.
 
Sex like that does not last. You are the baby daddy, not the lustful stud. You are the one she is attached to. That is long lasting, not what she has with this guy. Who cares if he is good at sex with her? It's new. Of course it's good.

I still stand on this, and here is why. I had a similar experience. That pent-up energy, I get that. Years of holding it in to raise a child blah blah blah... I get that, totally.

It's not that she doesn't enjoy you and your sex life, just that it's different. Connected, loving, comfy, warm, special, feels good to snuggle into love and sexiness, even if you are fucking like rabbits. This guy is just a good lay. He means little more than pure lust. If she wants more of that, then I would think it very big of you to be able to let her go do that.

My husband PN did that for me. When I was with several men on dates, I just sat and stared at them and felt nothing. I realized that I need depth, connection and lustful passion.

This could very well be a beginning for her, discovering that. You are an incredibly patient, loving, giving man. PN is like that too. Men like you are to be admired. Tell her from me that she has a gem in you, and she should be taking care not to damage that for her own good time.
 
You are an incredibly patient and loving man... very giving. My PN is like that too. Men like you are to be admired. Tell her from me that she has a gem in you and she should be taking care not to damage that for her own good time.

He reminds me of my husband too, just from what I've read here.
 
...What I'm still undecided on is whether to let her see this lover again. On the one hand, they had a great time together and I know she wants to see him again, so that makes me feel like if I deny her that, it'll just make her want him more. On the other hand, I just don't think he's the kind of guy I want in my home - I'm still coming to a decision on this one. Either way, we're instituting a new rule: when choosing a lover, consider how you would feel about them meeting both of us. Don't choose a lover you would not want me to meet, and vice-versa.

I'm reading this as, give your blessing instead of let her. Honestly, at the very least, if you're uncomfortable having this guy in your home, you have that right, and I think it would be reasonable to start the negotiations with that. I don't know if you want to consider her seeing him elsewhere. Frankly, I would not be understanding of lovers who I didn't feel were safe around my kids. But I think you have the right to ask that he not come to your home.
 
Back
Top