Feeling like a big poly baby

CleverMoniker

New member
It’s 1:27 am and I am crying in front of my computer when I should be studying. I am listening to pitiful emotional music to eek the tears out of my head that will release the pressure building behind my eyes. My boyfriend is in Mexico and just revealed he “did the nasty” while away. After a few minutes of conversation, he drops the bombshell that he, in fact, had a threesome. I can hear my husband snoring in the bed across the room from me over the music in my headphones, tears rolling down my cheeks. He hugged me before bed and told me I was beautiful and that my boyfriend didn’t feel any differently about me because of the threesome.
This is Polyamory at its most difficult.
Many view polyamory as some weirdo orgy. Something that lies between a swinger key party and polygamy. But it is so many different scenarios to so many. My scenario is that I have a husband whom I have been married to for almost 20 years, we have 2 beautiful clever children and are both full-time nursing students. We are best friends who have built a relationship built on mutual respect and open communication.
I also, am lucky enough to have a boyfriend, in addition to my husband. When I met first him the intention was sort of a “friends with benefits” arrangement, but we quickly connected and grew an incredible relationship. He is 12 years younger than me and fills my life with adventures, new exciting learning opportunities and challenges. Something I never anticipated when I first started “dating” him was the jealousy that I would experience at the thought of him being with anyone else. For the first year of our relationship he was “monogamous” with me and seemed happy about it. But on New Years last year I encouraged him to “sleep with a few people” in the coming year, because I wanted him to have fun, and in a way I wanted to face the thing I had been dreading….how I would feel after. He waited 5 months before doing the deed with someone else and if I’m honest it hurt like hell. My chest was tight, my heart physically hurt, and I felt betrayed. I used logic, and coached him on how to help me work through it and we came out better on the other side after very little time. Then 2 weeks later he did it again…and I was like…hey….wtf….It still gets to me, as I sit here weeping over some meaningless sex thousands of miles away. I can logic it away, but the reality is that this will always be a part of poly for my boyfriend and I, and here is why:
I do not feel jealousy at all when my husband ventures out. He had a 2 year relationship with a lovely poly woman who met our children, would come to dinner, and often slept over in our bed with both of us (non-sexually). They would show affection in front of me and it wouldn’t phase me. The reason for this I figure is because I trust my husband implicitly. He says he is mine and I am his and we have agreed to live this life out together, the end for us, is death (dun,dun,dun…). So when he goes out, even if he falls in love with someone else, I know that love will not mar his love for me.
Whereas when my boyfriend ventures out, he may very well never return. There is no certainty. He loves me deeply; I know this to be true. But he is 25, and not polyamorous. He is okay being open, because what man doesn’t want to the freedom to sleep with whomever they want, with a good woman waiting for them at home with dinner and acceptance lol.
So, here I sit, crying, like a big poly baby because my boyfriend got to have sex with 2 women at once. While my poly side wants to high five him and bro out with details, my insecure little heart wants to lock him up with a tag on him that say “mine”.
 
Wow, I really feel this. I feel so much more jealousy over my shorter term relationship than my longer term one, even though both are now getting to be pretty long term and both are very committed relationships. I am in a different situation than you, we are all polyamorous, but the imbalance of feelings is still there. I struggle with it a lot, but I know this is my thing to work on.

Is your boyfriend happy in your relationship? How does he feel about you being polyamorous and him being monogamous? Are both of your relationship needs getting met?
 
Like you, it's easy with my husband. And I'm fortunate that it's easy with my new partner. But I got terribly hurt and jealous about a previous partner dating, which I now realise was because I felt insecure in that relationship.
When I feel totally secure, no jealousy, it really is that black and white for me.
 
It’s 1:27 am and I am crying in front of my computer, when I should be studying. I am listening to pitiful emotional music, to eke the tears out of my head, to release the pressure building behind my eyes.

My boyfriend is in Mexico and just revealed he “did the nasty” while away. After a few minutes of conversation, he dropped the bombshell that he, in fact, had a threesome.

I can hear my husband snoring in the bed across the room from me, over the music in my headphones. He hugged me before bed, and told me I was beautiful, and that my boyfriend didn’t feel any differently about me because of the threesome.

This is polyamory at its most difficult. Tears are rolling down my cheeks.

Many view polyamory as some weirdo orgy, something that lies between a swinger key party and polygamy. But it is so many different scenarios to so many. My scenario is that I have a husband, to whom I have been married for almost 20 years. We have 2 beautiful clever children and are both full-time nursing students. We are best friends who have a relationship built on mutual respect and open communication.

I also am lucky enough to have a boyfriend, in addition to my husband. When I met first him, the intention was sort of a “friends with benefits” arrangement, but we quickly connected and grew an incredible relationship.
He is 12 years younger than me, and fills my life with adventures, new exciting learning opportunities and challenges.

Something I never anticipated when I first started “dating” him, was the jealousy that I would experience at the thought of him being with anyone else. For the first year of our relationship he was “monogamous” with me, and seemed happy about it. But on New Years last year I encouraged him to “sleep with a few people” in the coming year, because I wanted him to have fun, and in a way I wanted to face the thing I had been dreading: how I would feel after.

He waited 5 months before doing the deed with someone else, and if I’m honest, it hurt like hell. My chest was tight, my heart physically hurt, and I felt betrayed. I used logic, and coached him on how to help me work through it, and we came out better on the other side, after very little time. Then 2 weeks later he did it again. And I was like, "Hey! Wtf?"

It still gets to me, as I sit here weeping over some meaningless sex thousands of miles away. I can logic it away, but the reality is that this will always be a part of poly for my boyfriend and me, and here is why: I do not feel jealousy at all when my husband ventures out. He had a 2 year relationship with a lovely poly woman who met our children, would come to dinner, and often slept over in our bed with both of us (non-sexually).

They show affection in front of me and it doesn’t faze me. The reason for this, I figure, is because I trust my husband implicitly. He says he is mine and I am his and we have agreed to live this life out together, the end for us, is death (dun,dun,dun…). So when he goes out, even if he falls in love with someone else, I know that love will not mar his love for me.

Whereas, when my boyfriend ventures out, he may very well never return. There is no certainty. He loves me deeply; I know this to be true. But he is 25, and not polyamorous.

He is okay being open, because what man doesn’t want to the freedom to sleep with whomever they want, with a good woman waiting for them at home with dinner and acceptance? lol.

So, here I sit, crying like a big poly baby, because my boyfriend got to have sex with 2 women at once. While my poly side wants to high five him and bro out with details, my insecure little heart wants to lock him up with a tag on him that say "mine."

It must depend on several factors. I've felt insecure with some lovers' other relationships, but secure with others.

It could be age, sketchiness, reliability, length of relationship, and if and how your partner shares TMI, or even triangulates you with their other partners. And how good they are at reassuring you of your place in their heart.
 
Like you, it's easy with my husband. And I'm fortunate that it's easy with my new partner. But I got terribly hurt and jealous about a previous partner dating, which I now realise was because I felt insecure in that relationship.
When I feel totally secure, no jealousy, it really is that black and white for me.

That's exactly it for me. I know I am insecure because of our age difference, and him not being poly, so to me it seems like an eventual end is inevitable. Even though our relationship has been going strong for 2.5 years.
 
I've struggled with this a lot with Ponytail. Last year, Ponytail declared that he didn't identify as polyamorous and wanted the stability of just being in a relationship with me without other partners (aside from my husband, Glasses). I wasn't willing to do that because I was already dating Whiskers and so Ponytail and I nearly broke up.

Then Ponytail came around, started dating more, and eventually (in the last couple months) entered into two other sexual relationships.

I had a much harder time with this than I had expected. Suddenly I felt super insecure and irritated.

I'm doing a little better now, but I struggled a lot for a few weeks. I felt like I had lost something pretty significant and the fact that I knew he didn't identify as polyamorous made me incredibly anxious that he would leave me once he became serious with one of these other people.

I have since calmed down significantly. Yes, things are different now (scheduling, etc), but for the most part when we are together it feels just the same.
 
Many of us who have dated monogamous people have probably gone through this, especially in the beginning of the relationship. We are never quite sure that the mono person won't get tired of "sharing" us, especially when there is essentially no chance of co-habitation or similar relationship escalators. However, your BF has been with you for 2.5 years. It seems like he has accepted that you have a husband. It seems like he is fine with being open. Maybe at this point you should try giving him the benefit of a doubt. Has he given you any reason to not believe him?
 
Back
Top