"You call me a fool, you say it's a crazy scheme
This one's for real, I've already bought the dream" -- Steely Dan, "Deacon Blues"
When I lived in Tucson I made a friend I'll call Dan, because he reminds me of a character in a Steely Dan song, to be honest. I met him at a writer's group there. Dan got divorced around the same time I did, so we had a few things in common, and after the writer's group broke up after COVID we stayed in touch.
In a lot of ways, Dan is kind of like a typical successful, but divorced, guy of his age. Business-wise, he went from strength to strength when he was younger, and about 10 years ago he started his own company and made a decent amount of money.
His home life didn't go as well. I won't go into all the details. Anyway, like a lot of divorced people, Dan ended up spending a lot more time by himself. He tried to fill that time by writing novels, and to some extent that worked. He's completed one which is with an agent now, and he's nearly completed a second. Truth be told, they're pretty good, although they're not in a genre I read much of. He's been disciplined enough to take criticism from editors and re-write large parts of his work to good effect. I haven't been able to write anything since I left the group myself, though I'm thinking of re-writing a short story for an anthology this summer (it would be my second publication there).
Now that Dan sees himself more as an author than a businessman, he's been thinking about living an itinerant author's lifestyle. He works from home, so he's not stuck in any one place, and he's considering renting out his house and traveling from one city to another on the proceeds. The problem is, he's been thinking about this for a few years now and it hasn't happened. He is getting closer to renting the house out, though... maybe in a few months. He says. He's thinking about moving to Washington state for a while. Or maybe Rhode Island. Or New Orleans. He hears the South of France is pretty nice. At one point he was even thinking about Montevideo in Uruguay. (For the record, he is fluent in neither Spanish nor French.)
Wait, why am I talking about this? OK, so at one point Dan was considering writing a story featuring a poly character. Without thinking, I asked him what kind of poly he foresaw for the character. "What do you mean?" Well, you know, are they going to be in a triad, a quad, a cluster? Maybe they're into anarchic polyamory? He asked for an explanation of all of those. After I explained, he said, huh, you seem to know a lot about this. How is that?
It occurred to me that I had never mentioned that I'd been in a poly relationship to anyone outside the relationship, this board, or (as I've mentioned) to therapists, who seemed baffled by it all. I figured that Dan and I had already talked about a lot of strange stuff by then, so I admitted that I'd been in a poly relationship myself. Of course he had a million questions, only about three or so of which I really wanted to answer. The others I fended away with a mix of half-truths and no comments. Either he didn't notice, or he didn't care... Obviously I'd learned the lingo, so I must know what I was talking about, right?
Dan looked at the ceiling for a while, as if thinking about something in his past. Then he looked at the floor and said, "I wish my wife and I had done that."
I've often wondered how people on the outside of polyamory (I'm not going to say "mono", because I want to include the polycurious) look at people in poly relationships. It feels like there's an odd mix of anger and jealousy. ("How dare you have a relationship with more than one person? ... Because that might be fun and that's not fair.") But it also feels like there are people like Dan. Again, I'm not going to go into his past, but there have been other times when he's suggested that if there were a socially-acceptable "safety valve" to their relationship, maybe they'd still be together. Like, if it were OK for them to be with other partners for a time, then they could have maintained their marriage.
Is that reasonable? Well, probably not; I never did tell Dan about how awful a lot of the relationship was, and how long after it ended it chewed at the foundations of our marriage until the whole thing collapsed. But it was interesting how he treated poly as a sort of might-have-been: if only we could have tried....
Really, though, Dan-- near the end, you and your ex couldn't agree on where to go for breakfast. You think you two could have hammered out a poly agreement that would have suited you both?