I need some experienced guidance: PART ONE

stimpackaddict

New member
I am a 32 year old female graduate student that lives in southern New Mexico. My brother, sister, and I grew up around pagans and hippies and all sorts of people from different religious and philosophical backgrounds. It was not uncommon to see people moving from tent to tent at big community Solstice gatherings. We weren't told about it nor was anything hidden; we were told things when we asked. We never cared lol. As I grew older and neared the end of high school, among my many library visits, I discovered polyamory. Off and on through college I read about and it and regardless of my then unawareness of myself or my emotional awareness I felt this was something for me, that I was capable of, but would need to learn myself and emotions and communication before I ever did. I don't actively date hardly at all, am more of an introvert than an extrovert that has increased slightly over the years, have been through therapy many times, no kids yet. I have had a few poly experiences and relationships the past few years, most without real solid emotional connections or ties. I have anxiety disorder, a low level panic disorder, off and on clinical depression since I was eighteen, off and on bad self esteem and self worth, a tom boy, a pagan, bisexual, empathic, nerd, gamer, I like to draw, I like reading books and graphic novels, I am back on medications for the first time since 2007 due to being back in college after eight years and a tumultuous past year of compounded emotional stress from various life events. I am getting better and better and happier and am begrudgingly glad I let my friends talk me into going back on a low dose of meds for a while. But a relationship I am now is going well and I am and have been in a stuck place about poly for a while. I have a small story to tell to explain where I am and what I need some experienced voice guidance with.

In December 2012 I began a relationship with a long time friend of my sister and I, who was married, and the wife, he and I spoke and we found out we were all into open marriages or poly. What my sister and I didn't know (who was my roommate at the time) is that their relationship was heavily troubled by the wife: emotional abuse, making up lies in general, severely emotionally unaware and controlling, and other things. We learned later they opened their marriage to spice up their marriage and try other things, which was hard for the husband as this was his first marriage and all ready 40, and was a serial monogamous dog in his younger days in and after the navy. He loved this woman and for ten years denied her true nature and thought he could help her by leading my example. He grew up with a navy pilot father, a mother who was a teacher with a masters in psychology, and an amazing communicating loving family. He lived in denial for many years with her and my sister and I had no idea, we were not told about any of that until he and I began seeing each other.

We learned we both had a strong attraction to one another and began dating. The wife saw other people but never talked to me directly about issues she was having with he and I and always spoke through him and didn't like how close we got, to the surprise of us both, in a few weeks. It was a few days after we dated we realized we fell in love and were compatible on many levels and in many ways and needed those things about each other more than we realized. It scared the shit out of me. After proposing a sort of contract that I had read about in The Ethical Slut (that she refused to read) she freaked out. She asked us to end it. She said she didn't want to do any of it any more. Three days later she told him why don't they still do it but do a "don't ask don't tell" after she seduced him for sex like she was happy. He was appalled and angry and said no that's cheating. Then she said to do She met me for dinner at my request to tell me he was using me and a liar and telling me things I knew to be a lie. It was then my sister and I saw her true nature and everything went to shit. Long story short, they were headed to a divorce, showed up at a scheduled first couples therapy appointment with divorce papers. I told him I was angry he didn't tell me their problems before I got involved as I had seen this happen many times with couples suddenly jumping into alternative lifestyles as a quick way to think they will solve their marriage issues or a cowardly way out. I didn't see it coming. At a casual dinner with he, my sister, and I after we ended it, she called my phone and his phone, after telling us she was working late after still going to see a man she met online, and it turns out she the date ran short and she didn't work and grabbed her teenage son and drove by my apartment. She screamed on the phone how I was a home wrecker and he was a cheating whore and called his parents and spilled the secret of their two year life choice. Then he and I had to stop talking by my choice because I didn't want to be pulled into an adultery charge at the beginning of a divorce and learned what an unstable crazy woman I never knew her to be, and she was a friend.

Three months went by and somehow I got involved with a couple I only knew through an acquaintance from another friend. They were heavy into BDSM and had a M/S relationship, and I do consider myself kinky on a small level, had never seen the lifestyle experienced firsthand. It didn't take long to realize they were in an abusive situation and I was dating the husband and he reminded me too much of my exhusband and a bad bad man.

Then and I get a call from my exlover. We began speaking. In that time I left the couple and my friend and I talked again. In may 2013 we decided to try real casual dating. But he wanted to stay poly and open and not be tied down and knew he had issues from his marriage and so did I. We wanted to just enjoy each other and we did for almost two years. But I had never experienced poly with a person I was in love with and wanted to be with. I want children and a family and he raised his step kids and has no bio kids of his own and it wasn't long when it came out he was adamant about not wanting kids at all or being another stepdad (which severely limits his dating pool for my area honestly). He rarely stayed at my house, never left personal articles there, I almost always stayed at his house, he dated other women regularly and I was always jealous, afraid, scared, and didn't know it was bringing my anxiety back. I always pretended he was home alone or I wouldn't sleep at night. He embraced our love for each other but kept me at arms length and wouldn't commit as my primary but acted like it. We went through some wonderful times and hard lows in our lime due to events not about us or we were drawn into.

Then I decided to go back to school last fall, it was a hard decision. I also tried my hand at stepping outside my comfort zone and dating myself with a couple of men I met online and never went past a first date. I did began flirting with a man that came to where I worked for three years, a massage school, and I had known who he was because of local pagan events and he was in a couple of classes with my sister while she was in college, and knew who he was but not his name. He came to the school to become licensed to take over his mother's long time and successful massage practice and he was out of a five year relationship almost a year at that point, with a woman who cheated on him and lied when they decided to open up finally to poly. We found out within a month we had a lot in common and liked each other a lot. But he was a student and by ethics and school, we did not persue a relationship until he was complete with it and we kept our attraction as much under wraps as possible, but we did talk to my boss about it as he is a wonderful man and a friend and he was cool. I told my partner at the time and he was happy for me and encouraged by it. That was something I was never able to do for him. I never felt happy when he dated or happy for him, I always felt scared and feared he was going to leave me at any time because of facts stated above. I was kept so far from him I never felt embraced into his life as a part of him yet he tried to make me feel like I was.

This other man and I shared texts and secret kisses here and there but we never dated until the end of november when he was finished. Then my partner at the time began seeing a woman he met through a friend of a friend that he had absolutely nothing in common with. But he was attracted to her, and she had a kid. As was the habit that came with his dating, he seemed to attract broken women or women with issues or women that said they knew what poly was or had been involved with it, yet would see how he and I and out priorities to each other were and would freak out and leave and realize they wanted mono. I was happy each time they did and felt terrible about it. He pursued this woman, they had a brief two month fling while I and my new man pursued ours but we still saw each other. But I felt something from him but didn't push it because he would tell me when he was ready. In December my new man had sudden hard times for his family: one of his brothers passed over Christmas. I had to fly out for my first in person school visit for this online program to Dallas, where my sister now lives, in January and my then partner went with me for a few days for his birthday. On his last day his fling dumped him over a text, the worst way possible, and was scared and freaked out seeing how real it was him flying out with me and being with her. She didn't want to have anymore to do with him. Yet he chased her and wanted to talk to her and to this day he doesn't know why, he just liked her, and knows he was stupid.

(CONT NEW THREAD)
 
I need some experienced help: PART TWO

Not long after I returned home he said he had to talk to me and I felt it was something bad. He broke up with me. He said he knew it may be stupid and I could be angry with him and yell at him and he didn't know if he wanted to be poly or mono, that he was tired of summing up The Ethical Slut when he met women, he said he couldn't handle my anxiety monster and realized for a while he had been treated me like he did his ex wife, like a project and lead by example and that isn't ok at all and he felt like shit for it, and he didn't know what he wanted in his life at 43. But he didn't want kids or to have a family with me and it was always a hard thing for me to talk about and we avoided it a lot, and we just enjoyed what time we had without discussing it. He said he still wanted to be my close friend and ally and be in my close circle of trusted people and be there for me, and that he did love me. I told him I wanted it but it was going to take a long time and that is new for me and I had never been through this and couldn't make promises. We have had a couple of emotional talk outs since, mostly me talking about shit I realized and wanted to say about our relationship. So totally stressed from that, in my first semester of grad school and without proper advising managed to take the hardest class of the program with no background in it, I was heartbroken and hurt and my depression and anxiety flared up even more and I didn't even realize it.

It affected my job, school to a degree, and yet my new partner was there with me. He has been empathetic, supportive, loving. He is a nine year army vet with PTSD, a pagan shamanic practitioner, works with wood and metal, an amazing cook, funny, long hair, a compassionate lover, a massage therapist, a nerd, and so many other things I have wanted in a man and never thought I would have. I have been back on meds two months and feel more balanced and in control. I have talked a lot with my new partner, who knows my recent ex, about my feelings and fears and issues related to him and he hasn't flinched or judged or can't live with my issues. He has embraced me into his life and tells me all the time since then how he cares about me and how amazing I am and what I bring to his life. He even watched my dog when I had to work and she loves him to death.

A couple of weeks ago he said he had to talk to me about things he had been thinking about and I automatically flinched in fear. He said they were good things. He said he had been thinking that he wants to live with me, he loves me, he wants kids with me (he has been married twice with no kids and both women cheated on him while he was in the service), his mom asked when we were, that he wants to make me his primary and bring me into his life and do things with me, to fill the empty picture frames on his wall with us, take down the pictures on his never touched facebook of his other relationships and put things up with us. He said he wants to practice poly with me. I told him I've been on the fence about it for months, mainly because of my two years with the other man, that I was afraid and found it threatening and I didn't know if I wanted it in my life any more or why or what I wanted with it anymore. I have a community of people I know and can talk to but I feel compelled to talk to strangers anonymously who may have more experience than I do. I do love him and have found myself loving him more since that day even if he suddenly had a woman friend who came out of town for custody visits who didn't have anywhere to stay this first visit and I didn't like it or was ok with it and hated suddenly it happening at the last minute even if he had told me a few times when she was ready he wanted to be with her because he cares about her and feels pulled to healing and sexual healing (which I respect but am scared about).

He still talked to me during that visit and told me how amazing I am and how he loves me. I don't know what I want from poly or what I am scared of or what to do. We haven't discussed poly really yet or how it would fit into this potential scenario of he and I, my current rooommate/friend, and his current roommate/friend, how I feel about it, why I am afraid, or why I am stuck. I don't know what to do or where to being figuring it out or what I want or feel about poly right now and am afraid to work on it honestly.

Help and advice requested.
 
Hi stimpackaddict,

It seems like your current boyfriend is a good guy and I would stick with him at least for the time being. Since you aren't sure what to do with poly right now, I wouldn't worry about it, just focus on being present in the here and now.

I'm curious what books you've read on poly, have you read Opening Up and More than Two. What knowledge and information you have about poly affects how I should advise you. I think you said you had plenty of exposure to open type relationships while you were growing up?

If you're not already seeing one, look for a poly-friendly counselor and set up some regular appointments. You need someone you can talk to and receive professional counsel. We can certainly help you on this forum but we are just a partial help, the counseling is the other part.

It is obvious to me that anxiety has haunted you for a lot of years. It is good you're taking medication for it, we all need that from time to time. You can be poly and have happy relationships, you just need to believe in yourself.

I'll keep posting here as the thread continues.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
I have not heard of those books, thank you! I have read Love Without Limits and The Ethical Slut. I will give those books a look.

And thank you for reminding me of an advertisement I saw recently for a local counseling center that caters to alternative lifestyles and poly and has one of the only certified sex therapists in the state, I completely forgot! I will give them a call! THANK YOU!
 
No problem, I'm happy to help.
 
Back
Top