Luckiest Dude in the World...

Ferrin

New member
Hello, I'm Ferrin, and I recently found myself in a polyamory situation as if by chance. So I thought I'd get involved with the community and educate myself on this more. Seek advice, that sort of thing. A little about my situation.

I've been married to a wonderful woman for 8 years. Before we were married she was single polyamory. And we began our relationship with the understanding that it would be open. The thing is, it never came up. Neither one of us ever even tried for a one night stand after we got together. We've had kids, built a life, and have an extremely strong marriage.

And then we decided to get a roommate. My wife was working with this woman who was looking for a place, she was just out of a seriously dysfunctional relationship with a guy who claimed to by polyamory but I suspect just liked to manipulate women. Anyway, we invited her as a roommate to live with us. Didn't have any expectations or goals in mind as to adding anyone as a third when we did so.

But after about a week, this woman starts flirting with me. Nothing to overt or sexual, but she was definitely letting me know she was attracted to me. So I tell my wife. Who laughs at me and tells me if I think I can, I'm more than welcome to try. Our new roommate is ten years younger than I am. She's 21, extremely attractive, and bi-sexual. So naturally my wife of 8 years thinks its all in my head. We hadn't talked about being open in years, but really our feelings on it hadn't changed, we just hadn't been to interested in anyone. So I got the greenlight.

I begin flirting back with this woman, and it eventually gets to the point where I can't be mistaken. She's into me. So I call her out on it, straight up, "you're flirting with me" and she doesn't deny it. And we talked about it, I told her about my wife and I's views on polyamory. And then asked her if she would be interested in dating me. She says yes.

It's been a few weeks since then. And so far I think I'm doing pretty well. Jealousy hasn't really been an issue lately, I've connected really well with this girl, and so has my wife. They hang out, they play games together, and take turns teasing me. In fact my wife takes a certain pleasure from her blunt humor making me blush in front of my girlfriend. Who finds it hilarious as well.

I'm not sleeping with the new girlfriend yet, because we had basically just met, and she lives here. Plus the really messed up nature of her last relationship, she wants to take the physical part slow. Not to say that she isn't interested, her body language, our conversations tell me that she is. I think she just needs to be more comfortable in her place before she takes that leap.

A goddamned Unicorn literally walked into my living room, decided she liked it there and stayed. I mean if I sat down and made a list of everything I needed in a woman, she hits every item on the list. I don't want to mess it up. But, I've been married for 8 years, and I'll be honest here I'm a little out of practice on the whole dating thing. And that's only compounded by the fact I've never been in a poly situation before, wife has and she helps, but it's all really new to me.
 
Welcome, Ferrin, and congratulations on your new situation!

The way you and your wife have been open from the start but had a long spell on not taking advantage of it really resonates for me—there’s a lot of similarity to parts of my story. I hope you find that the transition into open-in-practice goes as smoothly as possible! All joy to you.
 
I'll explain my own experience at the end of the post; I am NOT unsympathetic. Mostly, it sounds like you're doing the smart thing: taking your time.

If there's any yellow flags, I'd say it's your new roommate's flirty behavior. The two of you had barely met, yet "after about a week" she's dangling that bait. Yah, she just got out of "a seriously dysfunctional relationship" -- that is not only NOT an excuse, but in fact (to me) would indicate a big possibility of her acting out, making uninvolved others pay so that she can rebuild her damaged self-estem.

In close quarters, teasing & flirtation is sexual harassment. However, if you respond -- at all! -- it's YOU that will generally be seen as the aggressor, because men are guilty 'til proved innocent.

I wouldn't pursue it further until she is in a position where it'd be easy for her to move out, where staying in your home is a desirable option rather than necessity.

And in the meantime, the THREE of you had better talking A LOT, digging deep into everyone's underlying motivations.
________________

My fiancee's girlfriend Tracy moved in with us just before my own lover moved back to town. Tracy generally had one or two boyfriends for occasional social outings & sex. She & I lived together for more than a year, becoming very close friends & even saying "I love you" regularly. She got tired of her boyfriends' demands for attention when her social/work schedule was so full, & said she just wanted some companionship & to get laid once in a while... & we looked right at each other, & called our partner into the discussion, who laughed at us for taking so long to get around to that. :D
 
Greetings Ferrin,
Welcome to our forum. Please feel free to lurk, browse, etc.

A little caution is a good idea and you seem to realize that ... but by and large I think you have a really positive situation there, and I am happy for you. I encourage you to read and post a lot here, Polyamory.com has a lot of opportunities to learn more about poly and to get advice. I'm glad to have you with us.

Sincerely,
Kevin T., "official greeter" :)

Notes:

There's a *lot* of good info in Golden Nuggets. Have a look!

Please read through the guidelines if you haven't already.

Note: You needn't read every reply to your posts, especially if someone posts in a disagreeable way. Given the size and scope of the site it's hard not to run into the occasional disagreeable person. Please contact the mods if you do (or if you see any spam), and you can block the person if you want.

If you have any questions about the board itself, please private-message a mod and they'll do their best to help.

Welcome aboard!
 
But after about a week, this woman starts flirting with me....Our new roommate is ten years younger than I am. She's 21...we had basically just met...the really messed up nature of her last relationship....A goddamned Unicorn literally walked into my living room, decided she liked it there and stayed.

Caution: A very young (by poly standards) and troubled woman walked into your living room and has put out her massively attractive sexual invitation to you. She has not "stayed" and she can't possibly have transformed herself in such short a time into someone who is emotionally healthy enough to live peacefully in a poly relationship. She's young, she just got out of a distressing relationship (that no matter who is to "blame," she co-created) AND you just met her. This is perhaps a fabulous emotional whirlwind of a sexual opportunity for you, but this is not "staying." I foresee a lot of drama.
 
Back
Top