New at N-configured non-open (?) poly relationships

Awoken

New member
Hello there,

I am new to this forum, but also really excited that such a community exists. As I have realised and experienced, polyamory is so diverse, and people's experiences are so varied, that I thought I would share my thoughts and situation in the hope that someone with more experience can give me some advice, or at least some peace of mind on my situation. My story starts like this:

My husband and I have been together monogamously for 12 years now, polyamorous for 6 months or so. The first 6 years were blissful, then we decided to have children, which no doubt will put a strain on any relationship, however this is when things did start to change. Our relationship took many dips and spikes, though we never decided it was worthwhile ending it. We persevered. Or more so, I was too scared to walk. We married two years ago.

I feel like I should also point out that I have had many people come into my life for whom I have felt attraction or even love, whilst being in my relationship. I never felt that was weird, and always just acknowledged the existence of this attraction without ever following through with anything.

After six months of marriage, I decided to stand up. It was Mother's Day and I was again forgotten. No card, no acknowledgement. He was lazy and made very little effort over the years to show me that he cared. I told him it was over. At that point, he realised what he was standing to lose, and made me a series of promises that waxed and waned over the following few months. We found ourselves in a similar position six months later, only this time, we agreed to try an open marriage as a way to find happiness together, or as a Band-Aid.

We both got online. We fought and worked through jealousy. We both met people, had dates, had sex. It was fun. It even spiced up our sex life in a way that I never expected. Hubby discovered his dominant side with an extremely submissive partner. I generally had a hard time finding a Mr Right, realising that the sex-only scene really wasn't for me. I suggested building relationships, even love (to his shock), and eventually he came around (though I believe his relationship with his sub partner was getting a little more serious, simultaneously).

In January, I met Ben online. I was open about my relationship and what I was looking for, and he admitted that he was not sure about it all, but was willing to go with the flow. When we met in person I liked him immediately. He is an artist, intelligent and handsome, and our chemistry was like sparks between us. Since meeting him those 4 months ago, we have spoken nearly every day, by various media, and have both opened up to each other intensely. I have fallen in love. And see, this is where it gets tricky.

As I am seeing my Ben, Hubby (Chris) is seeing Grace. I have met Grace once (while she was drunk) for only a few minutes. Chris has never met Ben. I have a keen interest in breaking down barriers between all of us-- to share our lives somewhat. I fantasize about living in a house together, sharing food, love, my own little commune. Chris doesn't. He insists on keeping everything very separate, even asking me to 'unfriend' Ben from Facebook as he didn't want him seeing our life/photos/kids, etc. Grace is happy with the current situation, though she has expressed to Chris that she would like to see more of him. I have been bringing it up almost daily and feel like there is hope of getting us all together, at least for dinner.

While all of this is going on, I have felt very distant from Chris, Having read all about NRE, I know now that I was lost in that energy. I was pushing Chris away, and having fantasies of moving out to be with Ben, and having an exciting new life and path. I know that these ideas are fantasy and I am trying my hardest not to get lost in them, and to try and re-kindle what I have with Chris.

Meanwhile, Ben is feeling strongly towards me, though unwilling to love me, as he feels he's leaving himself too vulnerable. He says no one has ever made him so happy before. Not being naturally polyamorous, he wants me all to himself, though completely respects that I'm married.

The mistake I have made with Ben is that I have shared with him all of the problems Chris and I had and have, and I believe this has not painted a nice picture of Chris for Ben. He wants to see me more, feel less restricted, show me to his family and friends, but he feels that what we have is doomed to fail, so he holds back from those things.

I want to feature in Ben's life as much as I'd like to show him off in mine, I want Chris to let down our walls. Am I mistaken to believe that breaking these barriers would make our difficulties easier?

I know that was a lot to read, but having three hinges in this equation does complicate things.

Any thoughts would be so greatly appreciated. Cheers!
 
Whoa. Correct me if I am wrong, ok? That's a lot.

If I understand it right, the problems you have identified are:
You want to cohabitate.
  • Hubby/Chris does not want to.
  • Ben prob does not want to.
  • And Grace?

Grace wants more time with Hubby.
  • You are willing for that to happen, and also want to have dinner as a foursome.
  • Chris?
  • Ben?
You want to rekindle things with Hubby now that you realize you were NRE drunk.
  • Is Chris willing or not willing to rekindle?
  • Is Grace supportive or not supportive of this?
  • Is Ben supportive or not supportive of this?
Chris wants to maintain separateness.
  • You do/do not want to maintain separateness?
  • Ben?
  • Grace?
Chris wants you to unfriend Ben on Facebook.
  • You have/have not unfriended Ben on FB?
  • How does Ben feel about this?
  • How do FB's policy changes with metas affect Grace?

Ben wants to see you more, feel less restricted, show you to his family and friends.
  • You also want to be more "out" to people.
  • Chris?
  • Grace?
Ben is afraid this polyship is ultimately doomed. For him to feel better he needs _______?
  • You are willing/not willing to meet the need. (You cannot at this time; need is not known.)
  • Chris is willing/not willing to help you meet this need. (ex: if what is needed is more time with Ben, can Chris be ok sharing your time?)
  • Grace?

You have a lot going on there, with a lot of people having different kinds of wants. You have some limitations you have to work with, and then there are other wants that may/may not work together. There are also missing puzzle pieces.

I'd suggest taking it one thing at a time. Ask the people what the missing pieces are, and then negotiate to solve them, or let go of some of the wants at this time, because they cannot happen.

One example of that is the cohabitating thing. It's much too soon anyway. You're only a few months in with Ben and Grace. And you have kids and may not want them in coparenting roles. You and Chris are the parents. Chris doesn't want Ben to see them on FB. That one at least you can knock off your plate for now by letting go of that want at this time. I made it grey.

Is Chris pushing for more "separateness" because of you being NRE drunk? I'd deal with the green one first -- repairing with Chris, now that you see you were neglectful of that relationship in your polymath because of the NRE. That's a hurting one rather than a wanting one. (Ex: Grace is happy, just wants more time.) I wonder if "Chris wants separateness" and "Chris's no-Ben Facebook want" fall under the umbrella of "building back with Chris" things or not. I indent them that way in case they are conditions you have to meet as part of the rekindling. Ask him about those. Are they conditions he'd like you to meet, or are they entirely separate issues to the rekindling?

Then deal with Ben feeling this is doomed. That's another hurting tier. Sort the hurts first.

OR... tell Grace you are willing to for her and Chris to have more time together. There. That's your part in that. Then leave it to them to sort out the rest of the way. It's his calendar. Then maybe you can grey that one off your plate too.

HTH,
Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi Gala Girl,

Thankyou for taking so much time to reply. I know - I have quite a lot going on.

So, to answer your questions:

Cohabitation - as I said, it's a fantasy and certainly not something I'd rush into.
- Chris not open to it, doesn't think he'll ever be.
- Ben is conventional, however, open-minded.
- Grace is not interested.

Maintaining separateness
-Ben is open-minded.
-Grace not keen. Would do if Chris wanted it also.

Facebook
- I unfriended Ben. I respect Chris's wishes. But both Ben and I were sad to cut that off.

Grace wanting more time with Chris
- I believe it would be easier if walls were dropped, as we could both spend time with our partners at the same time, therefore allowing for more time together. Currently we see our lovers once a week.
- Ben is keen for dinner.
- Grace is keen only if Chris would like her to come.

Rekindling with Chris
- Chris is very happy that I'd like to work on us.
-Ben likely feels disappointed somewhat that I'm not prepared to leave Chris for him, though hasn't actually said this to me.
- Grace is unaware that we have some work to do on our relationship. She accepts our marriage and appreciates her position as his secondary.

Ben seeing me more - coming out
- Ben's still coming to terms with his position, but slowly telling his friends and becoming open. He doesn't want to introduce me to his friends, as he feels that would create a shift and leave him vulnerable and hurt. He feels that his relationship with me is as enjoyable as it is painful!!:confused:
- Grace and Chris have been seeing each other for over 6 months now and she and Chris regularly catch up with her friends. They are quite open.

What does Ben need?
Ben doesn't know, and neither do I. I believe letting down these barriers would help at least as a process of elimination. All I know is that he's looking for a life partner, and though that doesn't necessarily mean that needs to be mono, I'm just not sure that he feels good as a secondary partner.
- Chris is happy to give me more time with Ben, but appreciates that we need to spend a little more time together to help strengthen our bond. So at the moment, once a week is enough for him.
- Grace has all she needs in Chris, and has decided not to pursue other relationships at this time. She would just like to see him a little more.

I don't believe Chris is aware of the NRE. I have suggested he reads more about it, though I did not really tell him that I was 'drunk' on it. We were already hanging by a thread, and I didn't want to overcomplicate his thoughts by adding in that Ben (NRE) was the cause of our troubles.

Thanks for putting so much energy into my questions.
Cheers.
 
Just thought I'd follow up on this-- Ben has decided to exit our relationship. Now I am lost and heartbroken. Chris is amazing. He is my shoulder to cry on. But I'm not sure I can endure this again. I'm also not sure if I can be on the other end of the now V.

Why does this have to be so hard?
 
You always were on the other end of the V that placed hubby in the hinge position. That is not new.

I am sorry for your break-up pain. :(

Do what you have to do for self care as your move through the grieving process for the loss of the romance. You will be ok. Hang in there.

GG
 
Back
Top