Old crush, need advice.

Castress

New member
I probably need lots of advice.

First off, I am in an open relationship with my boyfriend. We have been together for about 8 years now. I love him and know that we will be together FOREVERRRR~ (I had to say that really dramatically.) Anyway, I knew I was poly for a few years now, maybe subconsciously longer. We are finally in a state where both of us is comfortable with the other dating someone else. At first it was restrictive, I can understand this. I was okay with this. I haven't, and really never have been actively looking for another partner. To make note he has been dating another woman for a little over a year now. I am so happy for them! They are quite adorable together.

I however have dated a few other people. None of them really lasted. Now I have an old crush in the picture. I finally after nearly 8 years, told this person I have a crush on them. I had already come out openly to my friends that I am poly. He seemed to be very receptive of this. He doesn't normally get involved with women, so I was really prepared for him not to be interested at all. That was not the case though, for about a week or so we heavily flirted. Now though, I have not heard from him for a good 5 days. Just the occasional hello.

Naturally I am a pretty nervous person. I don't think I have been this nervous and excited in such a very long time. However, I am not sure how to approach him. I won't ask him out, or pursue him. I want him to figure out if he is excited and wants the relationship. It's important for him to feel comfortable and want to invest time in 'us'. I did the hard part already and let him know I like him. But gosh darnit, is this not harder!? I am not sure what to do. Try to talk to him or just let him come around to talk to me? I feel like a high schooler waiting around by the phone for her crush to call!

Anyway, thanks for reading and thanks in advance for your advice. Hopefully I worded everything properly!

Oh, almost forgot to note. Without getting into details he has 2-ish primaries and a few secondary partners. What he does elsewhere no idea. So, he isn't exactly new to it all. (Thought I should probably mention that.)
 
You want him to mind reader you? Sitting around waiting for someone to realize something usually means you will have a long wait. If you're both poly and open, there is no reason to play games. I would ditch the anxiety and just ask outright if he is interested in dating you. The anxiety will then be quenched, one way or the other!
 
Hi Castress,

I have to agree with Bluebird on this one ... Don't wait around for your old crush to figure out what to do; tell him! Ask him out. Why not? Maybe *he's* waiting for *you* to make the next move!

Keep in contact with him, and keep on flirting. But don't lead each other on. Break the suspense.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Well, I have made a few steps in the right direction. I took the advice and spoke with him. No, sorry, I didn't ask him out. Honestly, I probably won't. However, I do plan on discussing what I am looking for in the future. No hints, no need to be a mind reader just plain old This is what I am looking forward to in the future. If it's something he wants then he already knows my answer.

I am getting butterflies just typing this out! I have no real expectations for where this goes, but I am crossing my fingers none the less. I've done a lot of thinking and I've learned a lot in the past couple days. So my anxiety has gone down a lot. (HUZZAH!)

I'll keep you all updated.
 
Sounds good Castress, glad you and he were able to chat a little.
 
Update:

Unfortunately, it didn't work out the way I would have liked. We just fell back into being just friends. Don't want to go into a long winded story. I am okay with this. Maybe in the future the door will open again, but for now it's closed.

But, you know that saying, when one door closes another opens? I'm finding that very true right now. Going through that door has led me to new discoveries and new people. So going to walk through this new door and see where it takes me.

Thanks guys for all the advice, I truly appreciate it.
 
Sorry the thing with your old crush didn't work out. It sounds like you have some new prospects though?
 
Actually, yes! Funny enough this old friend introduced me to someone. We really clicked and he asked me out! We are still exploring whatever it is we have but I am really loving it.
 
Back
Top