I've been dating a woman for about 7 months now and have grown significantly emotionally attached to her over that period of time. We are active in a very busy local support community here in our area and have grown closer through our co-participation in this community and it's events throughout each week. She has also introduced me to the world of BDSM (I'd dabbled a touch before) and we've grown into kink together. I've only ever been in monogamous relationships before, although I've had one-off threesomes in a couple of them, but I tend to be more the monogamous type. I grow very attached to my S.O. and have feelings which I have a hard time imagining sharing. At first we had agreed that no sharing would be a rule, but over time she has come to realize that she is more polyamorous in her orientation (which in the past had led to cheating) and now feels like she needs to explore this in order to be happy. We're both terrified of losing the other and both stressed out to a crazy degree. She feels like she just wants to be 'normal' in order to be with me but she can't, and I feel like I just wish I could be 'poly' with her in the specific way she needs, but everything in me screams against it.
Let me be more specific. I'm open to exploring some situations together. Threesomes with another woman, threesomes with another man (I am straight, but our BDSM play goes into the realms of sexual degradation and the idea of seeing her fucked by more than 1 guy (me and another) is a (albeit risky) turn on), and that eventually I may be open to having more partners involved in our relationship. But she's fairly clear that what she really needs is her own separate relations with another man or two that are outside our relationship. She stated that we would probably need to meet, know each other, and talk about rules and such, but that the relationships would be individual and separate, and this scares the crap out of me. We're both very busy as is, and barely have the time and energy to keep up what we have. The idea of her splitting that time even more scares me senseless. And furthermore, she seems to have this tendency come naturally to her, which means its in her nature to seek and find these situations. I don't. So in my mind it's going to be me stressing, sitting at home, knowing she's screwing and bonding with another guy, while Im just stuck in my own crappy little world taking it.
I know that to many poly people this perspective probably sounds messed up. But I'm trying, I really am. I really care for this woman and want to try and make things work. Have any non poly people here who've ever been jealous or very tightly monogamous types ever truly opened up to the poly lifestyle? Is it even possible? Is she being too rigid in the specifics of what she needs? Am I being unreasonable in wanting to explore third person relationships together first?
I need help. We're in crises right now and we're both frazzled and stressed. All either of us seems to know is that we want to be with the other but can't be exactly what they want us to.
I need help!
Let me be more specific. I'm open to exploring some situations together. Threesomes with another woman, threesomes with another man (I am straight, but our BDSM play goes into the realms of sexual degradation and the idea of seeing her fucked by more than 1 guy (me and another) is a (albeit risky) turn on), and that eventually I may be open to having more partners involved in our relationship. But she's fairly clear that what she really needs is her own separate relations with another man or two that are outside our relationship. She stated that we would probably need to meet, know each other, and talk about rules and such, but that the relationships would be individual and separate, and this scares the crap out of me. We're both very busy as is, and barely have the time and energy to keep up what we have. The idea of her splitting that time even more scares me senseless. And furthermore, she seems to have this tendency come naturally to her, which means its in her nature to seek and find these situations. I don't. So in my mind it's going to be me stressing, sitting at home, knowing she's screwing and bonding with another guy, while Im just stuck in my own crappy little world taking it.
I know that to many poly people this perspective probably sounds messed up. But I'm trying, I really am. I really care for this woman and want to try and make things work. Have any non poly people here who've ever been jealous or very tightly monogamous types ever truly opened up to the poly lifestyle? Is it even possible? Is she being too rigid in the specifics of what she needs? Am I being unreasonable in wanting to explore third person relationships together first?
I need help. We're in crises right now and we're both frazzled and stressed. All either of us seems to know is that we want to be with the other but can't be exactly what they want us to.
I need help!
Last edited: