Refining my story

JonValjean

New member
Hi everyone!

Thanks for being here and for reading this!

I will be as brief as possible, however I am opening up in a major way here, with the hopes that you will relate your experience and thus lend me some much needed awareness and community.

I'm a straight male, new to the forum, and not exactly new to polyamory, although that is loosely relative and perhaps what I seek is to broaden my perspective in order to have a better grasp on my own life and how I relate to others.

Let me start with some examples of my poly experiences and work out from there...

I understand the concept of serial monogamy as the dominant relationship trend. I believe in marriage as a sacred union, and before I truly considered responsible relationships I imagine that shortsidedness and close mindedness governed my relationships. After some hard lessons I began to openly accept reality as being poly (at least compassionate and responsible reality in an ideal sense).

So I began presenting this idea in relationships as a gesture of respect and confidence for myself and my partner(s). As with anything, having an ideal does not suggest that ideal circumstances are all that take place. With very few exceptions, my relationships made train wrecks look bearable. Even in the exceptions, my partners would be gone before long, though they had the respect to do so with integrity and compassion.

As for me, I generally do not prospect around when I am in a serious relationship where commitments and resources have been intermingled. I generally offer the poly viewpoint to my partner when I notice them struggling to control their promiscuity. This has most times backfired on me, perhaps because of the personality of my partner, who had no conceptual intent of a lasting healthy relationship, sexual or not, and the result for me when the partner makes an exit has varied from getting a solid beat down from them out of the blue, to having their side lovers break in and fight me, and so forth. Now, let me clarify that I am by no means perfect, however I believe if we find flaws in others or differences, we can and should make adjustments to how we relate in a compassionate and nonviolent manner. I think you will agree that doing otherwise suggests a severe personality flaw and lack of maturity to say the least.

The exceptions for my relationships have been beautiful and woefully short lived. On rare occasion I might hook up with a woman and have fabulous chemistry, conversational and conjugally speaking, though for various reasons these encounters would not last longer than a night or two before we never saw each other again. I travel a lot, so there's a reason, my resources fluctuate, and also perhaps their appetite changed or was unchanged as it were. I have had one "poly" relationship to speak of, but even though we had other lovers and even had a magnificent threesome, we lacked foundation and shared no tangible resources, we were just chemically therapeutic to each other at work and occasionally in the bedroom. For other reasons we both changed jobs, and she moved on. So much was gained and so little lost in our relationship that I feel this to be the best example I have of almost doing things right, but I often wonder if I could've done something different to stay in her life.

Since then I've been on some rollercoasters. In fact I became very opposed to a sexual relationship at all for two years, mainly because the mother of my children, whom I love no matter what, and who inspired me to learn about polyamory indirectly as a possible solution to our situation, found the most divisive and demeaning ways to repay my tolerance and compassion. My fault for making a family with this person, I know, but I was young and naive and believed my compassion could overcome her abuse. She was never monogamous nor willing to be responsibly non monogamous, and that's just scratching the surface. After severe damage was done to me physically, emotionally and socially, I had to make drastic changes to protect myself. So I moved and let two years pass.

My next relationship I really tried to avoid. I was abrupt about my poly beliefs, and to me that includes being responsible to ones self and a primary partnership. I held off sex for as long as I could but she persisted past my boundaries. Honestly I wanted the friendship and resource sharing to develop responsibly before getting laid but I eventually caved to her persistence. She was sexually active with other men, but I had not met a woman whom I was so attracted to her personality before, at least not an available one, and I did not want to lose her. We became very close and were more or less exclusive for a year. I proposed and she wore the ring, I took time for her family and so forth, and did my best to give her space when her wild side flared. She would tell me later that she planned the violent ugly break up, though I never understood why. I would venture that it was her fear of commitment coupled with new opportunities and a dash of a really difficult childhood. Save to say that it was not a pretty scene. It was on the heels of her birth mothers passing, whom she first met with me (as an adult, she was a foster child). I tried to be available and compassionate, but it was like a switch went off and her feelings stopped, not to mention that beating the f#&k out of me in public is intolerable. Anyway that was a year ago. I haven't been sexual or dated at all since.

I'm honest with myself about my need for a partner and/or sexual activity. I'm healthy and athletic, not poor or rich, and generally find people who genuinely enjoy my company. However, some of the train wreck breakups have really left an impression on me. Now, its difficult for me to approach the idea of dating. There is a feeling that perhaps everyone (especially women) hate and despise me. If I meet someone who can be affectionate towards me, I feel it is solely for the purpose of taking resources from me until it is more suitable to make a scene out of dumping me. I know there is a better viewpoint and position than this, I just do not know how to arrive there. Celibacy seems like an option yet I do not believe it is truly what will nourish my body and spirit.

I am sure most of you have experienced things you could relate to this. I value your advice and experience, as I move forward in life to find the partner or partners who will honor themselves and me as well. How do I find such a human? Where do I look? I see potential everywhere yet do I move too slowly or too quickly? Am I too concerned with finding lasting attachment? Should I shift into one-nighters? I know what I want, its just all theory or fairytales to me at this point, and I want the community to want it for me.

Polyamory is a huge concept to me. In my understanding it is a conscious and compassionate choice that does not mandate nor rule out additional partners. It is an idea I present to offer freedom and support to the moods and manners in any potential partner. Seasons change, and more than anything I am grateful there is a community of people who strive to make healthier more conscious choices to love more and love better. Your presence and energy nurtures my growth, and I hope mine does the same for you. Being able to open up this way is healing for my bones, I am not the type to discuss these topics with anyone. Realistically it seems I must if I mean to overcome the obstacles in this portion of my life. Thanks for your attention and input. Forgive me for licking old wounds.

Cheers

JonValjean
Austin,TX
 
I'm honest with myself about my need for a partner and/or sexual activity. I'm healthy and athletic, not poor or rich, and generally find people who genuinely enjoy my company. However, some of the train wreck breakups have really left an impression on me. Now, its difficult for me to approach the idea of dating. There is a feeling that perhaps everyone (especially women) hate and despise me. If I meet someone who can be affectionate towards me, I feel it is solely for the purpose of taking resources from me until it is more suitable to make a scene out of dumping me. I know there is a better viewpoint and position than this, I just do not know how to arrive there. Celibacy seems like an option yet I do not believe it is truly what will nourish my body and spirit.

This sounds like a very defeatist position to hold - why would a stranger despise you? They don't even know you. :) Is this a self esteem issue?

It sounds as if you have dated a lot of drama queens, or perhaps women who do not know how to gracefully exit a relationship. Perhaps it is the type of woman you unconsciously seek out? Are you expending resources to keep them with you? If you don't make funds available, they can't take advantage of you.
 
Hi JonValjean,

As far as I can tell, you've had some bad luck in love, but I don't know if there were any red flags to look for in the beginning. I would not be in a hurry to seek out someone new to date, and I would suggest continuing to post here and maybe we can help you detect those red flags.

Then too, maybe it's just time for your luck to look up. I hope so. You seem like a nice fellow who deserves better luck in love.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Bluebird:

Thanks for the reply. Yes self esteem has taken a downswing after these events and other factors, that's why I allow such a long duration to build myself up again so I don't drain others, and also why I'm grateful for this forum. And yes, drama queen is probably a euphemism. I appreciate the tip to not pour resources into relationships, however I have a question... How do I find a relationship otherwise? I mean maybe in high school or college it was possible for me to date someone without buying everything, but as an adult I am really not sure that women go in for that sort of thing these days...?

KDT

Thanks for the encouragement, perhaps things will turn around for me soon, and I am grateful for the experience and community offered here. I'm not great at spotting red flags or backing out when I do spot them, mainly because I just don't meet too many woman who are available and without any flags. Also I'm not great at catching the catches. Maybe I'm being too hard on myself and like you said things will click when the time is right. I just don't understand how I am either perpetually single or otherwise being screwed over whereas I see others with new faces every week or the same person happily for years. Oh well. Stoked for them and glad to be alive.
 
If there's a problem that can be fixed, we'll try to get to the bottom of it.

As for who buys everything on a date, perhaps you can go Dutch? Not that that's necessarily the problem anyway, but ...
 
I don't know who these women are that use men solely for financial gain. I have never encountered one, either romantically, or platonically. All the women in my life are interested in being an equal partner, and that's just not compatible with this kind of thing. Therefore when I hear things like 'how do I get a woman without paying for stuff?' I kind of shudder - you have other qualities than that surely? Why is that one placed front and centre? Who on earth made you feel like that was more important than, say, your passion for travel and adventure, or your ability to be honest and forthright with your ideas, your cheeky smile, or whatever it is that you are skilled at? I have always felt like this kind of stereotype is just a trope that gets churned out now and then in order to both maintain traditional gender roles and turn genders against one another - the kind of thing that the pick up artist/manosphere culture likes to emphasise in order to further this whole alpha/beta male nonsense. Women are not there to be 'caught' any more than you are. Romance is not a game you can win or lose at. Intimacy is not a prize, or a weapon.

Whilst I have no experience of women treating men, and men treating women, as you describe, I do know this: people generally treat you the way you expect them to. If your expectations are that relationships are in some way transactional, that to get love you have to be the provider, that it should always be you bending over to accommodate the other, then the people you attract are going to expect the same. We are creatures of habit. Even a nice and caring person can get used to the status quo. If I am never allowed to pick up the bill, I might get used to that. Then if you are hiding the fact that you find that irritating (perhaps because you don't trust that I am with you for reasons beyond you always picking up the bill), and one day you blow up at me, then I am suddenly in a wholly strange and new situation. I may feel guilty for not picking up on it sooner, even if initially I did try to offer to pay. I may not be able to afford to treat you right now, because I hadn't known to budget for it. It may make me feel disappointed in you, as something I felt to be solely altruistic suddenly feels (rightly or wrongly) to be an attempt to buy my love all along. I may simply be angry that you didn't speak up sooner and share your concerns and fears with me. I'm not saying that any of this actually applies to your previous situations, I'm just trying to illustrate that when you see repeated patterns in others' behaviours, it's sometimes good to look at repeated patterns in your own behaviours to see if there is a correlation. Having strongly entrenched ideas about 'How Things Are Meant To Be', in any context, can usually account for a hell of a lot of the interaction dynamics between two people. Often you can only appreciate the sources of conflict and negativity when you are outside of the toxic relationship, which is one of the reasons why it's always important to take time (as it sounds like you are!) between relationships to reflect.

Anyway, I think exploring polyamorous relationships could be very good for you. Although it's a bit of a generalisation, one thing that I think is true for the vast majority of polyamorous people is that they value their independence and personal autonomy. Not everyone is out there looking for a relationship to ride up the escalator with (http://offescalator.com/what-escalator/). Experienced poly people are often unusually self-aware, clear on their personal boundaries, good at communication and conflict resolution. I have learnt an awful lot about these things from friends within the poly community, as well as via the good old fashioned 'hard way' of actually being in my own relationships. And really, these are skills, and they come with practise. Someone once compared poly relationships to the invention of the parallel processor: whereas monogamy teaches you love lessons one at a time, polyamory can teach you n-times the number of love lessons simultaneously. There is value in that. However, as in all things in life, put on your own oxygen mask first before reaching out to help others. If you don't love yourself, you cannot love someone else. It does sound as if you feel you are ready for something new and wonderful in your life though - and that's a really good place to be. :) Welcome, and good luck!
 
I don't know if this helps you any. FWIW?

You seem to keep picking out "drama" partners. That end up in cheating, abuse, fights, etc. What makes you think that cannot happen in a poly model? :confused:
It isn't the relationship model you practice that spares you dealing with lots of wonky people. It is your judge of character and how you choose to behave that spares you from dealing with lots of wonky people.

I generally offer the poly viewpoint to my partner when I notice them struggling to control their promiscuity.

So your partner cheats, and rather than dump them for cheating, you offer to poly? If they cannot keep agreements before poly, what makes you think they can keep it after agreeing to poly? :confused:

I would not offer that. Poly is not the bandaid for a cheating partner. I would walk away from a cheating partner.

This has most times backfired on me, perhaps because of the personality of my partner, who had no conceptual intent of a lasting healthy relationship, sexual or not, and the result for me when the partner makes an exit has varied from getting a solid beat down from them out of the blue, to having their side lovers break in and fight me, and so forth.

Why are you taking up with violent people in the first place? Much less offering to poly with them after they cheat? :confused:

Don't get serious so fast -- slow it down so you can get a better sense of their character.

Now, let me clarify that I am by no means perfect, however I believe if we find flaws in others or differences, we can and should make adjustments to how we relate in a compassionate and nonviolent manner.

Hitting is not ok. I think if I mistakenly take up with a violent, angry type partner? I could non-violently walk out the door and get away from them.

Not keep adjusting myself or the relationship model to keep on staying with them until they turn me into the punching bag.

You could leave way BEFORE that. Do you know what your deal breakers are before "hitting me" -- or is "hitting me" the only deal breaker? :confused:

On rare occasion I might hook up with a woman and have fabulous chemistry, conversational and conjugally speaking, though for various reasons these encounters would not last longer than a night or two before we never saw each other again.

A hook up is a hook up. It is not a long relationship. Were you expecting to grow a long relationship out of a one night stand? :confused:

Could adjust your expectations. Either don't expect more from hook ups than a good time, or stop hooking up because they lead to you wanting more than they can provide.

If what you want is a serious relationship, go for that.

If you want hook ups, have hook ups.

Neither is wrong, but get more organized with what you are after so you are less confused.

The mother of your kids is a person who hurt and abused you badly.

severe damage was done to me physically, emotionally and socially, I had to make drastic changes to protect myself.

So bad you had to move. But you claim to love her no matter what? :eek:

Dude, you could be ok with no longer loving her.

You are not supposed to love others at the expense of yourself. If you love your abuser no matter how much they abuse you? It's not very nourishing for your spirit. It's you telling you that you do not matter.

Have you full healed from the abuse the mother of your kids dealt? I see where you spent 2 years after that not dating but that's just not dating.

I'm not reading you have been to counseling, gone to “healty dating class” as part of healing from abuse/domestic violence, been to "how to recognize abuse" class, or developed a better standard for vetting future potential dating partners so you do not fall into a new abusive thing just because it feels familiar.

I held off sex for as long as I could but she persisted past my boundaries. Honestly I wanted the friendship and resource sharing to develop responsibly before getting laid but I eventually caved to her persistence.

Was this rape? Emotional abuse to get her way? What? I cannot tell from how you write. It def does not sound "joyfully consensual."

It sounds “against my will.” And instead of walking away, you stay and propose to this woman? And then she breaks up with you in a dramatic way by beating the fuck out of you in public?

I think "going past my boundaries" could be on your deal breaker list. Don't wait for them to hit you. Leave when they do not respect your boundaries.

I meant this kindly, ok? :eek:

  1. I think this goes beyond anon internet people help.
  2. I think you could invest in counseling to help you heal from these bad expereinces first. And help you developing a better dating yardstick. You do not deserve abuse. But if you keep being attracted to abusive types, you have to figure that out so you can recognize it way sooner and don't go off with them.
  3. I think you could benefit from “healthy dating class" and "learn to recognize abuse" class.
  4. I think you maybe don't like yourself all that much if you keep picking out violent/drama people to be with. You could stop dating until you like yourself. And can offer yourself as a healthy dating partner.
  5. I think you might have some “white knight” syndrome. Where you try to rescue these drama people, in order to make yourself be the “Hero” so you can feel better about liking you.

Healthy people will not want to date a person who is like this right now. It would be great for you to date the healthy person maybe, but for the healthy person? What would they get out of it? :confused: They probably would prefer to wait til you are better first.

And you if look like a soft target? All the unhealthy people, who have no qualms about using you up? They will come sniffing around. You have to learn to defend yourself from that. And not get sucked in by "love bombing" or "sweet pie honey bunch" talk designed to lure you in. Esp if you are lonely and vulnerable to hearing that stuff.

Right now you sound like you go from accepting anyone to date – including violent/drama people -- which does you no good because you get trampled.

To wanting to go celibate and accepting NOBODY to date – which does you no good either. Building high walls around yourself keeps you safe... and lonely.

You have to find a way to develop your standards and vet dating potentials more accurately. Develop healthier boundaries. Like a waist high fence with a gate. No so high you block everyone out and view all people like they are out to get you. But not so low ANYONE and their crazy can just waltz and make a mess. Get to know people, chat over the waist high fence a while. Get a sense of them and their character. Then invite them in for a visit and open the gate.

Here's what I am hearing so far. I quote just to visually set it off:

WHAT I WANT IN A PARTNER

  • I am straight.
  • I hold marriage as a sacred union.
  • I'm "meh" on hook ups.
  • I want my dating partner to honor themselves by doing ___ behavior.
  • I want my dating partner to honor me by doing ___ behavior.
  • I want to honor myself by doing ____ behavior.
  • I want to honor my partner by doing ___ behavior.

My deal breakers are:

  • Not respecting my boundaries
  • cheating on agreements
  • hitting me

Very threadbare. I think you could see a counselor and flesh that out some before you try dating with your new set of standards. In a poly model or not, you need a better tool for vetting potentials.

Your dating practices could use revamp too. There is nothing wrong with splitting the bill. You do NOT have to pay for everything. There is nothing wrong with each taking their own car to meet in a public space, and leave in the own cars either.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Back
Top