sorry, I only want your wife

LoveBunny

Active member
A man contacted me on OKC. He seemed interesting. He said he and his wife "often date together." She was too young to show up in my matches, so I never read her profile, but did see a pic of her in his profile. I told him I thought his wife was very pretty.

First thing I did was ask him what would happen if I met them both and was only interested in one of 'em, and he said they'd talked about that before and thought it would be fine. But he also said his wife is still working (he's retired) and she seemed less interested in women lately, more into men.

He and I chatted a bit, we seemed reasonably compatible, so I agreed to meet both him and his wife at a restaurant. By evening's end, I knew I wasn't attracted to hubby. He was physically meh and his libertarian views clashed with my socialist ones.The wife on the other hand, I liked. She was mature for her age, we shared some interests, and I found her quite attractive.

After dinner, one of them set the 3 of us in a facebook "group" conversation. The wife invited me out on their sailboat to have dinner with them. Perhaps at that point I should have made myself clear, but I kind of wanted to just get to know them more. The guy is, after all, smart and accomplished.

Unfortunately, I am just not a sapiosexual.

A couple times while on the boat, the husband tried to put his hand on my knee or touch my back, I just sort of gently pulled away. I spent a lot of time making conversation with the wife. I learned she'd been with a male-female couple for years before meeting her hubby, and I believe she said she had a long term lesbian relationship once too. She and I did not make moves physically towards each other, so I cannot assume she's even interested in me.

It all began to feel awkward, so I didn't stay overly long after dinner. I told them I'd made late plans with a friend, and the husband took me back ashore on a dingy, I gave just a peck on the cheek for goodnight.

The next day, I messaged them a thank you for dinner, and only wife replied with niceties.

So what the heck is the protocol here? I don't even think I need to say to the husband, privately, "Great to meet you, but I don't feel a spark." I'm pretty sure he got the gist of that when I avoided his touch physically and left early.

Would it be out of line for me, then, to contact the wife, privately "Nice to meet you, if you want to hang with me alone, I'm game, but I'm not interested in a threesome with your husband?" Or is that too cowgirly?
 
You don't have anything invested in them, so i'd say you should do that and let the chips fall where they may. Let her do the rejecting if she isn't interested.
 
Yeah I would just message the wife. Either she'll be interested or not. Probably no point in going on of she's not.
 
PS -- To add that it's not "cowgirly" to want to date only one member of a couple unless your intent is to try to lure the person away from their relationship (usually with the goal of being monogamous). I wouldn't worry about being that in this case.
 
I think you should message both of them individually. He may have gotten the gist of it, but since you intend to contact the wife, you're not 'ghosting' as you would otherwise. So I would give him the formal "I am sorry, you are a smart guy but I am not attracted/interested." but I tend to be very blunt with people.
Depends on the kind of metamour-relationship you want, should you get something going with the wife. I'm not sure unspoken subtleties are the best way to go about it, maybe you want polite but direct communication from the get-go.
 
Hi LoveBunny,

I think it would be okay to contact the wife, and let her know you are interested in her. At first, you are just finding out if the feeling is mutual.

Good luck!
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
I think you should message both of them individually. He may have gotten the gist of it, but since you intend to contact the wife, you're not 'ghosting' as you would otherwise. So I would give him the formal "I am sorry, you are a smart guy but I am not attracted/interested." but I tend to be very blunt with people.
Depends on the kind of metamour-relationship you want, should you get something going with the wife. I'm not sure unspoken subtleties are the best way to go about it, maybe you want polite but direct communication from the get-go.

I agree with this. I also tend to be pretty blunt and don't like to chance that something could be misinterpreted at all so like to make things very clear.
 
Interestingly, she just showed up as a match for me on okcupid and we liked each other and I started a conversation there. I think this might give me an opening to tell her I'm interested. For some reason this feels more organic to me than reaching out to her on facebook. Like maybe we would have met each other anyway.
 
Sounds like things are coming together, that's good to hear.
 
I did it!

Unfortunately, turns out they're sailing away as we speak and have no plans to return. They're home base is a bit too far for me, so that's that.

Proud of myself for being honest and brave. Was an easy let down because it was nothing personal.
 
Good for you; you did the right thing. Too bad they aren't staying close by.
 
Back
Top