Suddenly In Three-Person Relationship

Thistles

New member
Hi, everyone. I'm a 29-year-old bisexual female from the northeastern US who has found myself rather unexpectedly in a poly relationship.

Looking through the intros, I guess the situation bringing me here is a bit unusual. In October my long-distance girlfriend, "S", moved in with me. Right after my ex-fiance, "A", came to stay with me because he could get a good job here but not on the left coast where he'd been staying with family since we broke up over a year ago. We'd become close friends again after the break-up, but there was zero romance and him staying at my house was supposed to be temporary until he could rent his own place. This had been planned for months and S was fine with it.

As you're probably guessing, strong romantic feelings quickly re-formed between A and I once we were together in person. We tried to ignore them, but I was miserable and decided that was never going to work. I still cared about S but was also heavily resenting her for preventing me being with A, so I actually broke up with her. Nobody could afford to instantly move out, however, so the living situation remained.

Note that when we were engaged before, A and I had a theoretically open relationship, though neither of us ever wanted to act on it, so the idea of poly relationships wasn't totally bizarre or new to us. S, however, had mentioned in the past that she totally didn't 'get' poly relationships and would never want to be involved in one, so I viewed breaking up with her as the only way to be with him. But just a couple days after the break-up, she wrote me a letter which clearly implied she wished we could still be romantically involved while I was also with A. After making sure it was okay with A, I asked S to be in a poly relationship and she said 'yes' in an extremely definite way (the implication in the letter was intentional and she wanted to ask me to be poly but was afraid it would just sound desperate).

That was less than a week ago so now I’m in a poly relationship, what I think they call a “V” triad, since S is 100% lesbian so there is not and never will be anything romantic between her and A. The three of us have known each other for over three years (S and I were best friends the whole time I was dating/engaged with A the first time) so it’s not all quite as sudden as it sounds, though it’s still weird.

The fact that a three-person relationship was so unplanned, and also that it seems to be an unusual situation, has left me definitely flailing a bit for how this all should work, though I won’t deny a sizable part of me likes being at the center of the “V”. I also don’t feel I’m the personality type you’d expect to be poly nor the type most naturally equipped to do it. I’m an introvert, I tend towards being pretty unemotional, I’m not very sensual or romantic (actually, I suck at romantic gestures), plus I have a terrible history with maintaining mono relationships which supposedly require less skill to navigate. Though I’m definitely wondering if mono relationships are really easier in the long term. The one positive I have going is that about ten months ago I started working extremely hard to improve my communication skills in all types of relationships and have been successful enough for everyone who knows me to remark on the striking change and improvement.

Anyway, I’m here to meet more experienced people who will hopefully have lots of good advice, since I feel a ton of pressure being at the ‘center’ of the V even though I also like it. Plus I know how helpful it can be to just type things out to a supportive, uninvolved audience. I won’t weigh this introduction down with specific questions since it’s long enough, but really look forward to getting to know you all!
 
Greetings Thistles,
Welcome to our forum. Please feel free to lurk, browse, etc.

We'll try to help you in your early poly meanderings; it sounds like you and A and S have a lovely poly V going. I suppose your best bet for getting advice is to start a thread in the Poly Relationships Corner.

Nice to have you here.
Sincerely,
Kevin T., "official greeter" :)

Notes:

There's a *lot* of good info in Golden Nuggets. Have a look!

Please read through the guidelines if you haven't already.

Note: You needn't read every reply to your posts, especially if someone posts in a disagreeable way. Given the size and scope of the site it's hard not to run into the occasional disagreeable person. Please contact the mods if you do (or if you see any spam), and you can block the person if you want.

If you have any questions about the board itself, please private-message a mod and they'll do their best to help.

Welcome aboard!
 
Hi Thistles.

Using initials for partners is hard for the members here to read and remember who is who. It seems to me you are a woman, and your ex fiance is male. For now I will call ex fiance A, Adam, and gf S, Susan.

You seem to have a lot of confusing emotions going on, as well as a less than comfortable living situation with both Adam and Susan.

You might consider why it is you broke things off with Adam. Does this relationship suddenly seem viable to you now? What has changed?

Was it wise to have Susan suddenly move in with you after a period of long distance relationship? Some people in LDRs wisely choose to have the partner move to your town, live nearby but separately for a year or so, date normally and see how that goes before taking the plunge to being together 2/7. Especially might be wise in your case since you have Adam there now in the space that was supposed to be for you and Susan only.

Basically, things sound to be changing rapidly and without much forethought. Emotions have won out over being calm, careful and rational. I am not saying you three are doomed, but you are taking on a lot:

Reforming a love relationship with Adam
Going from LDR immediately to living together with Susan
Having Adam's temporary stay turn permanent
You becoming a hinge in a V with little knowledge of how to keep things balanced and both partners feeling safe and appreciated

You might be in over your head. What do you want to do now? Get re-engaged to Adam and plan a wedding? Just stay bf and gf?

Do you have plenty of space in your house/apartment for everyone to not feel crowded and stressed? Do you have a good dating/sex schedule so everyone's need for connection is well-met? Are both your partners fine with seeing you kissing and cooing and cuddling the other? Are they fine with overhearing sex noises when you go off with one or the other for that? If not, living in 3 separate places for a year might be a better transition to forming this V.

Are your family, colleagues, and friends aware that you are romantically involved with both Adam and Susan? Or do you plan to let people think you are living with your ex-fiance, now bf, again, and that Susan and you are still "just friends?" How would Susan feel about that?

Can you do PIAs in your town or will people see you doing that with one or the other when you're out and about and wonder and gossip?

How about typical roommate issues like household finances and sharing chores?

By the way, you will get more responses and advice if you PM our moderator NYCindie, and ask her to move this thread to the Poly Relationships section.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top