Well, I was weak. The split didn't last long. When we broke up, side chic asks to move in with Sam. Ultimately he broke things off with her.
I went to his play where she was a lead in a short. (It was similar to tales from the crypt.) She had attempted to get him to tell me I could not come, but I did anyway. She avoided looking in my direction.
Well, the next day, he tried to get me to come over, later than I normally would, and basically lied about his plans. I discovered that he had planned ongoing to watch her roller derby, so I insisted we go together. Afterwards she approached us and introduced herself. She then proceeded to ask him to the after party when I had stepped away. He broke things off with her the next day. She said she threw up from being so upset and sent him a pic.
I had considered what it would be like if Sam and I were together monogamously and I determined that living with himis not an option. I would never be happy in a traditional relationship with him. Unfortunately, I can understand why he cheated, as I had done the very thing to my ex. I just want to have fun with him and still have my life with Nate.
5 years ago, Nate and I met a poly couple on ok cupid and friended them. We hung out one time a couple years later, but there really didn't seem to be any friendship chemistry there. I eventually unfriended them as I wasn't engaging with either, but Nate still kept them on his friends list. Well the guy, Mike, was out of town with the kids and Nate asked the gal, Anna, if she wanted to hang, since they have stuff in common and he wanted to see her drawings. He went to her house and ended up spending the night there. He told me next day that they were watching shows, then that led to cuddling, which led to making out, which led to them almost having sex. Neither had a condom, so it didn't happen.
Maybe we shouldn't have sex with her. She told him flat out that she and her husband have a rule that, although poly, she is not allowed to have sex with other guys. It is to be anything but sex. Yet the next night Nate went there and ended up having sex with her. He totally felt like s*** afterwards. They both talked in great detail about why having sex with each other would be a super bad idea.
Then the next night, she was really pushing to come over to our house, because she said the next day her time would no longer be her own. I didn't think Nate would have sex with her, but he ended up having sex with her again. To make matters worse, not only did she cheat on Mike but she didn't use a condom with Nate, because he is not circumcised. She'd never been with a guy who wasn't circumcised and honestly, when you throw a condom on there, it doesn't make any difference.
The next day, she told her husband on the long drive back from the airport. He was not happy at all, but he's acting very nice to Nate. She made an appointment to get tested for STIs. But it's going to be a while, so therefore she will not have sex with her husband, who'd been gone for 2 weeks, until she gets tested.
Nate is going to go ahead and get tested on Monday. She texted me and was like oh boy. I got to talk about our new relationship to Mike, which kind of bothered me because, imo, there isn't going to be a relationship. It's going to be the same as it is with all the rest of his f*** buddies. But then Mike specifically said that he wanted the three of them to get together and talk it out. I'm like, where do I fit into all of this? I'm Nate's wife. If they're all getting together to talk about the logistics of the friendship between Anna and Nate, shouldn't I be involved too?
I want ahead and messaged Mike. We talked about some stuff and it made me feel a lot better because he told me that they have a very committed 11 year relationship and he just needed to talk in person with me to try to feel better about the situation. Because even though Anna has cheated on him before like this, he is willing to forgive her. Honestly, the way Nate was making it sound, Mike didn't have a choice in the matter, like Anna had decided that she was going to continue seeing him, regardless.
It's just a really messed-up situation. This is completely new to me, because every time he has had sex with somebody before, it was ethical. So now we have to deal with a husband who was really upset his wife cheated. I don't know what expectations Anna had, because in the past when they have had boyfriends it was a triad. But Nate is straight and not looking for more than FWBs with a woman or trans person.
It seems like once I start feeling comfortable with one friend with benefits, suddenly there's another one popping up that I have to deal with and be scared of. I just now got comfortable with Deanna coming over to my house. Nate told Anna that he has multiple f*** buddies and that he's not going to stop seeing them.
I really wish this hadn't happened. It really sucks for Mike to have to deal with this emotional turmoil.