The Best Life Yet

I think that maybe you need to speak up for yourself. I think he was very selfish at your expense.

You get treated how you teach people to treat you. Is it possible that you have been the "flexible, fair" one and how he expects that always?
He asked you to stay home and spend time with him. How is he willing to fix this?
 
I think that maybe you need to speak up for yourself. I think he was very selfish at your expense.

You get treated how you teach people to treat you. Is it possible that you have been the "flexible, fair" one and how he expects that always?
He asked you to stay home and spend time with him. How is he willing to fix this?

Oh, believe me, I spoke up. I am indeed the "flexible, fair" one, and also the sweet, accommodating, easy-to-get-along-with one. But I'm not a doormat! I just ripped him about 34 new assholes via instant message: 17 when I realized how angry I was, and the other 17 when I realized that he still wasn't understanding why I was so angry after the first 17.

I don't know how he can fix this. This might be the sort of thing where I just have to tongue-lash him until he realizes that I was on the razor's edge of dumping him, then give him a pass and an ultimatum, choosing to forgive unless something like this happens again. It might be that only time can fix it. I'm not going to "make" him do the same thing to her—not that he would anyway, but I'm not going to try—because I possess a shred of empathy, unlike the two of them, apparently.

I am still PISSED. AS. HELL. though. Ugh.
 
I think instant message does not give a good read on feelings.

I think he doesn't get it unless it is clear. I think it isn't blackmail or anything like this. How about a simple thing of, gee I waited in a fair manner for an answer for thanksgiving. This was done with so you could consult with Claire.
However, you asked me to stay here for Christmas. I am deeply offended not only did you not give me a check in, before giving this up but you did it leaving me here without loved ones.So tell him the truth, your gut was to walk away from this gift package of poop he handed you. I have been fair in every way and now your abusing it. How are you going to fix this?

I think your bending over backwards to be fair needs to stop. It is his relationship with her. If he isn't concerned then why should you be? Because it is right? Honestly, from what you say she could give to shits about your relationship with him and appears to be very passive aggressive.
 
I think instant message does not give a good read on feelings.

I think your bending over backwards to be fair needs to stop. It is his relationship with her. If he isn't concerned then why should you be? Because it is right? Honestly, from what you say she could give to shits about your relationship with him and appears to be very passive aggressive.

Yes, I will tell him everything in person again. I think he was able to gather from my, ahem, colorful language (I did catch myself and leave off from cursing after a time) exactly how upset I was, but I do plan to show him as well.

And yes, there is no way I am ever trying to help him with her again. If he pisses her off, I'm just going to let him deal with the consequences. I am not willing to take any more for the team on this one. Never again.
 
So, Rider and I have made up. He pleaded with me to let him come over that night to apologize, and I thought about it for a while and relented. I made very clear to him the gravity of the situation, and that I will not tolerate one more incident even CLOSE to what he did there. He has promised that he will never do anything like that to me again, and I decided to give him this second chance.

Which, of course, requires full forgiveness. I can't walk around harboring a grudge, or I, myself, will be the one ruining things. I had to choose to forgive him and just have faith that he is capable of thinking things through a little better. We talked and cried and finally, we kissed. It took a while for things to return to feeling normal—for some time, when I looked at him, I saw a stranger, because the Rider I thought I knew would never have done something like that to me. But he did. And he is still him.

Our solution for the Christmas problem is that Rider bought me a Greyhound ticket to go see Sam, and I am going to be spending three nights with him: Christmas eve, Christmas, and the following night. Sam's mom died a few months ago, and I thought he might need the company as much as I do. Plus, it gives me some real time alone with him, which is something that I'd been hoping for at some point.

Buying the ticket is not "on par" with the seriousness of the misdeed, but really there's nothing that can be done to make it up other than to not mess up anymore. At this point, I'm just sick of thinking about it.

Tomorrow, Rider and I were supposed to be meeting up with Sam and Kelly for a concert, but Sam had to cancel for reasons outside of his control. That's a major bummer for me, because now I risk feeling left out, but we'll see. I suppose Rider will be extra solicitous of that whole thing after everything has happened this week.

Next weekend, I go to visit Jake. I am excited about it, but I feel a little subdued as well. I am almost afraid to get too stoked about anything guy-related, after finding out about Brandon's shady ways, dealing with Rider's cruel sacrifice of my feelings, and being disappointed by Sam's cancellation. I feel like getting my hopes up just leaves me more open to being let down by any number of things that could go wrong.
 
So many thoughts...

I guess the place to begin would be yesterday morning. Rider and I were leaving for our overnight trip to the concert, and we had planned for him to leave Claire's around 7:30 in the morning and pick me up at 8:00, drive to his friend's house where we were staying, and I'd work half a day there (I work remotely) before knocking off to party with Rider and friends. My work start time is generally somewhere between 10:30 and noon; my boss generally messages me around noon to check in for the first time. The city we were seeing the concert in is three hours away in good traffic conditions, and if we left at 8:00, that would leave me a comfortable hour's cushion in case traffic was bad, etc.

Well, 8:00 comes and goes, and I'm sitting on my couch with my bags all packed just waiting for Rider to knock. Around 8:25, he IMs me telling me he's running late but on his way. I knew he had to stop home and feed his pets and grab his suitcase, so I thought that was what he was doing at that point, and that I'd be seeing him in a few minutes (he lives about two blocks away). Around 8:45, he finally arrives, and he tells me that Claire had woken up sick and decided to call out of work, and he had to grab some stuff for her from her car, and that's why he'd been late.

I was NOT happy. I felt like AGAIN he had put her needs (spending extra time with her after she didn't go to work at the usual time, fetching items for her) ahead of mine (needing to get to a place with wi-fi in time for my work day to start). I asked him about it, and he said that she had set her alarm for a later time without telling him, and he had messaged me the minute he figured out he was already late when he woke up. OK, I can get that. While technically, he could have set his own alarm, if she told him she always sets if for a particular time and then neglects to tell him she's changed it, that's not really his fault.

HOWEVER, it did get me thinking about how many wild-cards are introduced by having a partner whose other partner is mostly DADT. In a communication-heavy relationship, he would have told her the night before that he needs to pick me up at 8:00 for our trip, and the whole thing would have been a non-issue. I really like being in as much control of my own life as I can be, and I had never before stopped to think about the fact that things like Claire randomly deciding she wants to sleep in might end up getting me in trouble with my boss. And I started wondering if poly is right for me after all.

But really, that's a silly question. Monogamy has NEVER been right for me, and poly has mostly been amazing. I realized that the real question is whether poly with *Rider* is right for me. Maybe I don't belong in a situation where my metamour needs a level of DADT and therefore we are not all looking out for each other. I brought this up to him—for the very first time, I discussed breaking up in a calm, rational, and well-thought-out way. It may be that I just need a different kind of poly than what he can give me right now.

This is even considering that he and I had a conversation a few days ago where we both acknowledged that our love for one another and our compatibility with one another is such that (before The Great Fuckup) we both felt that things were progressing toward real life-building things together.

I felt a lot better after we hashed things out on the car ride, and I actually did manage to log in to work by about 12:15, thankfully before my boss needed anything. I decided to let any negativity go and wholeheartedly abandon myself to the fun we had planned.

Around 6:30, we met up with Kelly and her friend. After a tiny bit of initial weirdness between her and me (nothing overt, just an odd tension), I broke the ice by purposefully placing Rider between the two of us at the concert, so that he could cuddle with both of us at once, and she could see that we were all cool. We got along well for the rest of the night.

A few times when I had wandered away to the bar or to the bathroom and then come back, I found her and Rider in very romantic-looking positions: forehead to forehead, or looking deeply into one another's eyes. I didn't think much of it at the time. We returned to our various sleeping arrangements after the show, and she and her friend came over to where we were staying for a couple of hours today and we all watched some sports. Again, I set it up so that Rider could be in the middle, because I know how amazing and cozy it feels to be between two people you like. At this point, I was still fine with everything.

Eventually, we all left to drive back to our respective cities (Kelly lives about an hour and a half north of the concert city, and Rider and I live about three hours south of the concert city). On our travels home, it comes up that at some point when I'd been out of the room, Kelly had been trying to convince Rider to come visit her. He'd not given her a definitive answer, but told her he'd look into it, and it was something he said he really wanted to do.

This is where things got weird for me. Previously, he'd told me he intended to have her as a long-distance FWB—someone he'd see when he happened to be visiting her town for other reasons (he generally goes up there a few times a year in the late summer and fall). If he changed his tune and started planning trips to her town for the sole reason of visiting her, that was going to put even more demands on his time than currently existed...and he has NOT been managing his time well even with only two girlfriends, evidenced by both Claire and me being on the border of breaking up with him just last week over time stuff.

I mean, I am not opposed to Rider being with Kelly overall. She seems fine and sane, etc.; the age difference gives him pause, but it's not a huge deal to me, since I've been in relationships with larger age gaps that I look back on rather fondly. I want Rider to get everything he can out of life, and besides, it's not my place to choose his partners. But I also know that he has barely crawled out of the doghouse with his two existing girlfriends—adding a third, long-distance girlfriend to the picture can not possibly end well for everyone involved.

If either Claire OR me were no longer involved with Rider, I'm sure the whole thing would be fine. But I had to remind him that pretty much every weekend is spoken for between now and mid-March. The drive to Kelly's town is too far to make an simple overnight worth it—it'd have to be a whole weekend. And to find a weekend for her, he'd be making things weird for either me or Claire.

I explained all of this to him, feeling pretty bad about raining on his parade, but he conceded that I was right: when you're already weathering shitstorms with two girlfriends, it is probably not the time to be adding a third; plus the time factor is a very real issue. At first in the conversation, he had still been trying to say that he'd have to look at his calendar, angling for a way to still make it fit, and then I pointed out to him that the VERY SAME MISTAKE that has gotten him into trouble so many other times—failing to think about the effects his plans have on his other relationships—the very same mistake that both Claire and I almost broke up with him for ONLY LAST WEEK was again at play here. He is thinking in crush-vision and only seeing the good that could come from his visit with Kelly, and not thinking at all about the aftermath, when he hasn't seen Claire in three weekends in a row due to traveling with me and then jaunting off to Kelly's town...or not seeing me before I leave on one of my trips and leaving me feeling neglected, or etc., etc., etc.

I love Rider with every fiber of my being. I feel as close as I can come to being certain that we belong together. But I'm just not sure if we belong together RIGHT NOW. He has work to do. At the very least, he needs to learn how to stop making essentially the same mistake (failing to game out consequences in scheduling issues) over and over again. Beyond that, he could stand to work on honest, frank communication with others in addition to me, and to leave off of some of his overly people-pleasing behaviors. If we do end up breaking up for now, I fully intend to remain his best friend, and therefore, I will be able to observe him as he grows and pick things back up again once he is no longer an accidental drama-generating machine.

He may be "wired" poly in his heart, but he has not caught his mind up to speed with the necessary communication, planning, and empathy skills to make it work. It's disappointing. And as much as I love him—I really, really do!—if he doesn't learn fast (and I intend to try to help him learn as much as possible), disentangling myself from him emotionally/romantically might be the healthiest thing I can do for myself. Through lack of careful consideration, he seems doomed to repeatedly set up drama-bomb situations where someone (not even necessarily me) is bound to feel left out and hurt. Love is infinite, but his time is not, and he can't have his hands in more cookie jars than he actually has hands.

One half of me is optimistic and has faith that he CAN learn these lessons, and before they do irreparable damage to the current incarnation of our relationship. The other half of me thinks that it is a really bad sign that all his problems revolve around a single theme that we've already talked to death. I told him I'm not making any snap decisions—I'll try to keep helping him understand and integrate things until I realize that it's not healthy for me anymore. I'll know what that looks like when it arrives.

I still think he's an awesome person, and he's my absolute favorite, but I can't stay in a relationship where the needs of the existing partners cease to be considered once there is a shiny distraction, and where the impact of one's actions/decisions is rarely considered.
 
Last edited:
I have been following your blog for a while and smiling at your tales and happy mood.

I very much hope that you and Rider can work things out. I agree that what has been happening recently sounds difficult to deal with. You likely would be happier in a situation where there is more scope for help and support between all parties. Or at least with a partner who is better able to be considerate of everybody they are involved with. Disappointing that Rider is finding this so hard to do.
 
Thanks for the kind words, IP. I, too, hope things work out. I guess only time will tell. In the meantime, I am going to use this blog to process things.

I don't mean to paint the picture that everything between Rider and me has been bad lately. If it were, then there would be no logical reason for me to continue to stay. I should make it clear that, other than this one particular issue, things are still great. Our sex blows my mind regularly. He cracks me up nearly every time I see him. We spend a great deal of our time together just grinning at one another and enjoying whatever adventure or quiet time we have created for ourselves.

So this isn't an issue of a basic compatibility problem; it's purely behavior- and situation-related. This is why I feel so certain that eventually (sooner, without a break in our relationship, or later, after some time spent apart) we will end up together. But I can't ride the rollercoaster of feeling forgotten, disrespected, and taken for granted, then feeling cherished and elated, then back down again. It's not good for my mental health.

As an offshoot of our conversation last night, he and I were talking about what it would look like if we were ever each other's only main local person, having secondaries in various other locations and playing casually with others here (mostly together but possibly apart). He said something like "maybe eventually that will happen"...but I don't know when that would ever be. Obviously, his connection with Claire means a great deal to him, or else he wouldn't have been willing to nearly destroy things with me in order to keep her.

When he says things like that, I feel so many conflicted emotions. Shamefully, the prominent one is hope. The idea of getting close-to-unlimited undisputed time with him is like a dream of utopia. All of the things that we always say we want to do but never have time for—those things would be possible. Every single week, there are things that we wish we could do, but then we run out of time. It's like the relationship that we "should" have is artificially capped by the time restraint, dammed down to a trickle when its natural state would be the roaring Mississippi.

Behind the hope lurks guilt and shame at the hope. I was the new addition to his existing relationship with Claire. He's known her for seven years, and me only for a year and a half. What kind of heartless beast must I be to feel hope at the idea of her no longer making demands on his time? The very notion of it is against everything that I stand for in polydom. But I must be honest with myself and admit that it is there. And then feel guilty about it.

Behind the hope and guilt and shame, there is another, even darker emotion: suspicion. There is something improper about Rider saying things like that to me, even if they are true, and even if we have a "no secrets" policy. How would I feel if he were saying things like that to his others—insinuating that there is a chance that eventually I will be gone and they will have him mostly to themselves? I know that he and I are super-special to each other, and we grant each other special status and privileges, but it still doesn't seem outside of the realm of possibility that one day I would find myself on the other side of that.

In my heart of hearts, I do not ever want to be mono with him. Neither of us is set up that way by nature, and I think we'd both wither under the pressure. But the idea of being committed "only" primaries with most of our time spent together and a great deal of peripheral freedom to chase the passing opportunity—that sounds like bliss to me. I don't know. I feel like an asshole for even considering it, and I feel mildly frustrated that he would dangle the possibility in front of my face with very little chance of it ever being reality.

I am all over the place with this one. Break up with him and pursue other partners? Keep things at the status quo and wish for a change in his poly skill level? Keep things at the status quo and wish for a change in his relationship structure? Actively push for a change in the relationship structure? I see pros and cons to every option. The only thing they all have in common is the need or wish for a change.
 
Last edited:
Even though last night was supposed to be one of Rider's solo nights, he ended up coming over because he was having an episode of the neck pain he gets sometimes, and I offered to rub him and also show him the music stuff I'd been working on all evening. While I was rubbing him, I put on a playlist that he'd made for me in the earliest months of our relationship. A song came on that reminded me of how things were in the very beginning—how unsullied and carefree. I looked down at his closed-eyed face, rubbing his neck from underneath, and he was so beautiful, and I felt so bittersweet. It felt like my heart was already gearing up to say goodbye to the romantic facet of our relationship, if that was what turned out to be necessary.

Having reflected on what I'd written here yesterday, and after thinking about the whole big picture, I realized that there is more to our troubles than just him fucking up lately in terms of his time mistakes. Part of it is my fault as well.

You see, when Rider and I were still only friends, I was going through the end of a four-year-long monogamous relationship. Things had been rocky on and off in that relationship for a long time, especially for the last year. I had met Rider pretty soon after my ex and I had moved to this city, and he and I had been only acquaintances for about six months before it blossomed into a full-fledged friendship. We discovered that we had a lot in common, and that we were perfect foils to each other musically. We started having a weekly jam session, then eventually, we added an extra night of going out with friends and whooping it up in bars. We were just buddies, though there was some sexual tension there; we never crossed any lines, not so much as a hug that lingered for too long, nor a wistful kiss on the cheek.

My ex was not happy about my spending so much time with another guy, even if we were keeping it above-board and platonic. He became convinced that I was cheating on him, because he knew about my history of cheating in previous relationships. He asked me not to see Rider for a while, so that we could work on our relationship. I acquiesced to this, and my ex and I tried really hard to fix stuff, but we eventually realized that there was no saving it—too much had been going wrong for too long. It pre-dated Rider, it pre-dated our move, and some of it even dated back to the very beginning of our relationship. So we broke up.

Of course, with Rider being my only real friend in my new city, the first thing I did upon being single was to start to hang out with him more. I moved to a stopgap efficiency less than two miles from him. We both crowed with delight at getting "unlimited" time to hang out together now—no longer were we limited to two nights a week. Our jam sessions could go until three in the morning with no one waiting for me and scowling at me at the end. We could party until nearly sunrise, and I could crash over at Rider's (though we still weren't fucking for a while). We started spending sometimes up to four nights a week hanging out, with sprawling weekends that were filled from start to finish with fun and, yes, eventually also fucking.

And I knew about Claire—I knew that they were seeing each other, and I knew that they were open poly—but if you'll go back to the beginning of my blog, you'll see that neither Rider nor I realized at the time that she was thinking of herself as primary to him. That didn't come out until after he and I had been seeing each other for about five months already, and it was just one more example of their poor communication.

So, at first, I didn't think there was anything wrong with Rider and I seeing each other for more than half the week some weeks. Claire would get her day here and there, and I thought that's all she wanted. It wasn't until I realized that I'd accidentally swooped in and displaced her from what she thought was her proper role that I felt guilty and started trying to make all these concessions to ensure that she got equal time.

But in doing so, I've been starving myself.

I was so happy when Rider and I would get 2–4 nights a week, every single week, with 4 being pretty regularly the case. It felt like we were able to do a lot of the stuff that we wanted to do—pretty close to all of it—and I was able to value my time alone, because I felt fulfilled in my relationship.

Since the Time Wars started, I've been feeling a little "thinner" each week that passes. I've felt a little lonelier, a little more sensitive, a little less satisfied. I haven't been getting my recommended Love Calorie Quota, and I have been slowly wasting away.

And this is a large part of why the Christmas thing and the Kelly thing both kind of made me flip my lid. Usually, I'm way more flexible and tolerant and understanding about things. But lately, I've been hangry. So yes, Rider has made mistakes. And yes, he does have personal work to do. But I think that part of the need for change that I feel comes from within myself.

Maybe I just can't be happy with a flavor of poly where I can't spend a lot of time with my lover. Maybe I need either a hierarchical situation where I have a mutual primary, or a situation where we are more of a cohesive group and all hang out sometimes. If either of those are the case, then Rider and I are doomed romantically, no matter how much work he does. Which is not to say that we couldn't try again later if his situation changes. But what I thought I was getting into with him and what I was actually getting into turned out to be two different things. And I am far less happy with the real situation than I was with the mistaken one.

After all, two nights a week—what the schedule has to be to make things fair for me and Claire—two nights a week was how much I was seeing of Rider even when I was in a monogamous relationship with someone else. And it wasn't enough then. And we rejoiced at getting more when that relationship ended. But now it's back to two again.

It may be an unsolvable problem. There is no ethical solution to it that I can see, other than walking away.

I've been trying since August to train myself to be fine with less than I was originally getting, for the sake of fairness. It is now December, and I am feeling worse, not better, for the passage of time. So "just getting used to it" doesn't seem to be the solution. And I'm guessing that since I came into the picture romantically in February, Claire has also been trying to train herself to be fine with getting less than SHE was getting before Rider took up with me. And she doesn't seem to be getting used to it either.

I've tried filling the holes with hobbies. I've tried filling them with dates. I've tried filling them with meditations and affirmations and self-love. But the fact remains that when I love someone as much as I love Rider, my natural state is to want a whole bunch of time with them. And a whole bunch of time is the one thing he can't give me.

I feel like I am in a similar predicament to how I used to feel when I was in mono relationships and really wanted to cheat: the thing that I want and the ethical thing are irreconcilable. There is no way to have more of Rider without taking from Claire. And Claire doesn't deserve to be taken from.

So if I can't have that with Rider, maybe I need to see if I can find it with someone else. ("But no one else is like Rider," my heart cries. "He's our love, our heart, our best friend.")

Rider swears that there is a way. That there has to be. That he will "burn the whole world down" to find it. But I don't want him to burn Claire on my behalf. Not because I am greedy and my needs are too much for his situation to meet.

I have no idea what to do right now except keep thinking, and keep writing every time I have a new insight.
 
Last edited:
I also realize that this whole existential relationship crisis could be the result of emotional whiplash from getting hurt and being afraid. But there is truth to it, nonetheless.

Here are the lyrics to the song I wrote after our first fight a couple months ago:

I sailed on a boat to uncharted waters,
to measure the distance—how deep this sea goes.
I stood on the deck feeling untamed and fearless.
I braced to the wind, but it near came to blows.

This freedom sometimes feels a lot like forsaken
when my radio statics and my spyglass spies naught,
so I reach for the ropes to secure a companion
but in my own tangled net, I hang broken and caught.

And this rocking ship’s
bound to founder and flip,
but I can’t let go,
and this undertow
might just claim me at last—
my hopes swallowed and dashed—
but I can’t let go.

In an effort to keep what I’d once been given,
five fingers clench desperately inside my chest—
squeezing vise-like to prevent the breaking,
instead building pressure, a drumbeat of stress.

So I pray to the gods that I don’t believe in,
I ask them to stop this beating heart.
Or give me a reason to make it seem worth it:
the pain that I feel when we must be apart.

And this clenching fist’s
gotta loosen its grip,
‘cause I can’t let go,
and this overflow—
it is too much to bear.
I am furrowed with care,
and I can’t let go.

I once painted a pretty mask, and I hung it on the wall.
But I never once wanted to use it.

And this tear in my eye
took me quite by surprise
when I couldn’t hold on
and I couldn’t be strong.
Is it too much to hope
to do more than just cope?
But I can’t let go.
 
Well. Things just got interesting.

Rider wants to give me all of his solo days. And when I argued to him that he would end up getting burned out again, he countered that being around me nourishes his soul, and that what he was burned out on was our "freestyle scheduling" when every day was always up for grabs. Now that Claire has her two scheduled days that she knows to expect every week, he can give the rest to me and actually feel good about it.

When I expressed guilt at things being out of balance if we do that, he said that if she is fine with two days now, how he uses the rest of his days is his business, and that she will be satisfied with that and with not being left out of holidays.

So...I guess I'm getting what I wanted? Me being me, I wanted to poke and prod at it and find all of the potential problems to make sure we were not walking into a landmine field, but I finally decided to not look a gift horse in the mouth and, to quote Dan Savage, "take 'yes' for an answer."

Rider says that it's silly—if what we BOTH want is to spend a massive amount of time together, then we should just do it, and he thinks we'll both be the better for it. He says that there are things more important to him than his alone time, and seemed to be implying that the preservation of our relationship was chief among them.

I guess if I am going to accept this gift, then all I have left to do is SQUEEEEE about it! I feel happier than I have in weeks. The idea of having lots of sex and multiple music nights, plus have time left over to socialize with friends and play video games and use the telescope and have our hair-dye parties and, and, and ANYTHING WE WANT!

I don't have to worry about rustling up dates and can deactivate my accounts! I can just maintain my long-distance connections and have Rider locally and those two nights he has with Claire will be my nights to practice music alone and work on my writing and talk to my other friends. Oh, perfection and glee! I am like a hungry little beast that feeds on time and was just offered the key to the buffet.

He really does love me.
 
Rider has been making good on his offer of more time. He asked me to come over last night after I was done with my previously planned date.

I had decided before I even left the house that that would be the last local, not-Rider date that I'd have for a while, and let me tell you, the date itself did nothing to change my mind. That was the most boring date I have ever, ever been on. The last 45 minutes passed like a visit to the dentist.

Afterward, I went over to Rider's, and we played music for about two hours, then watched an episode of The Walking Dead and ate some of the bread pudding I'd made late last week. We ended our night with some fantastic sex, and I just felt so connected to him again. It was like all of the bad feelings from the Christmas incident and subsequent blunders, and all the long-building stress from having too little time together all just melted away.

After we'd had our conversation yesterday—the one in which he offered me more time—I found myself smiling dreamily to music again, instead of worriedly brooding. It means soooo much to me, not only that he would give me the time, but that he says he wants it just as badly as I do, and that he could spend pretty much unlimited time with me and not get sick of me. I feel the same way about him.

He also started off a sentence yesterday with "if we ever lived together," which is something he has never, ever done before. The last words I'd heard from him on the topic some time ago were that he's been living alone for so long he's not sure if he'd ever want to live with anyone again. The last time he shared living space with anyone, it was when he and Claire lived together during the first incarnation of their relationship, and that ended in 2009. He still lives in the same apartment now that they did then, and he never got a roommate or anything.

It's amazing how what I thought was an impossible solution to the problem was a perfect one. I never thought that he would want to give up his solo days. I never even considered asking for them. I thought that in asking for time, I would be taking time from Claire, and I didn't want to do that, so I wasn't asking for anything. And then he goes and completely voluntarily sacrifices something of his own for me. But to hear him tell it, it's a bonus for him as much as it is for me, not a sacrifice.

He was telling me last night that he really didn't feel like two days was enough for us either. He also felt the tension, felt that feeling of a dammed up river that should be left to flow free. I'm going over to see him again tonight, after he's done with his platonic man-date and I'm done talking to Oona and Moss.

So now that things finally, FINALLY feel normal and good with Rider again (whew, that was a close one, y'all), I can finally start focusing on all the upcoming good:

1) Early Saturday morning, I leave for Hometown to spend four and a half days with Jake. Granted, two of those days I will be working from his apartment, but we still get to have evenings together. Tuesday night, we're going to cook a vegan dinner for my mom. I'm very excited to be close to him again.

2) The silver lining to the Christmas situation, which I have finally truly come to terms with, is that I'm going to be spending three whole days with Sam! And three nights hopefully in his bed with him. The idea of sleeping next to him for three consecutive nights is a crazy kind of bliss that I'd never really thought I'd get. Usually, when I am seeing him, Rider is there too, and I have to divide my attention between them. I don't MIND doing that, of course—I love them both!—but surely one-on-one time will unlock a new level of intimacy that we haven't yet found. I think it is going to be delicious.

3) And then three days after that, Rider and I are BOTH going to visit Sam...for FIVE WHOLE DAYS! Five days completely uninterrupted with the two of them. Five days to make music, sit around the bonfire, cook them delicious meals, cuddle, sip beverages, go kayaking, watch music videos, explore, go thrifting, maybe make some art...it's going to go by so fast, I just know it.

I am also indescribably THRILLED at not having to go on dates to try to find that elusive local second that I've been working on for, oh, nine months now on and off. Before, even when Rider and I were spending lots of time together, it was "disputed" time—I never knew whether I'd be seeing him for four nights or two nights or what, and I really wanted someone else for the two-night weeks. Now that I have his word that I can have him any of the nights he's not with Claire (only two nights), I really don't need to even find a second local person.

I get plenty of variety on my visits to Jake, Sam, Moss, and Oona and chatting with each of them long-distance. Plus playing with girls with Rider locally whenever the situation arises. Truly, as much as I do socialize and have learned to adapt to it, meeting new people is always awkward for me, and I rarely "click" with people right away. As long as I have sufficient time with Rider, I'm totally happy with the state of my branch of the polycule as it stands.

So maybe, with winter bearing down upon us, it is time to say goodbye to the drama and tumult that has characterized the autumn, almost from its Day One. I am again hopeful and optimistic. :)
 
Last edited:
Nice to see you worrying about your relationship with Ryder and not worrying about being "fair"!

I think by being "fair" with Claire, some of these recent issues have occurred due to you being the "laidback" one.

I always enjoy reading your blog!
 
I am so happy right now. Sleepy, but happy. I have seen Rider every night so far this week. Tuesday night, his platonic "man-date" was canceled, and it was supposed to be the first cold night here of the season, so he picked up a bunch of fixings for boozy hot drinks for us and I headed over there after I was done with my phone convo with Oona and my Skype date with Moss.

We cuddled up on the couch and drank hot chocolate with vanilla, Bailey's, and vodka, and then warm eggnog with blackstrap rum. We watched an episode of The Walking Dead, then made out for a while and moved to the bedroom for some hot sexytimes.

Last night, he drove me to IKEA so I could get a table on which to place my new TV. I actually bought a TV for the first time in my life on Cyber Monday, and it's been sitting in its box waiting for me to get the table. Rider put the table together for me while I mixed some more warm cocktails (spiced apple cider and blackstrap rum), then we set up the TV and watched another Walking Dead episode. We're almost caught up!

Then we went back to his place and played music for a while before my brain completely short-circuited and I suddenly was too zapped to play my instrument any longer. We cuddled up under the warm blankets and had some cozy, blanket-burrowed sex, then promptly passed the fuck out.

Another thing that happened this week was that, after we made our schedule adjustment, I had felt the need to ask Rider where he thought this all was going. What does his ideal future look like? Where, if anywhere, am I in it? Where, if anywhere, is Claire? What does he want in terms of outside dating/playing for the long term? We've been dating for nearly ten months now, and we've weathered some storms, and through it all, we've both decided that we want to be together more than we want to be apart, so I was thinking that it's time to start looking toward the future.

I asked him via FB chat, and I made it clear that he didn't have to answer right away. He took a day or so, and what he came back at me with was a 1600-word letter! It was sweet, deeply emotional, and it laid out a variety of different ways that he could see the future going. The thing they all had in common was that he sees us being together for hopefully the rest of our lives, growing and evolving together.

The one he listed as his "ideal" was he and I moving away together at some point to an area that has better opportunities, and becoming primary to each other (perhaps living together), and Claire would be long-distance to him but he'd still see her when he could. We would both continue to date other people in whatever capacity we felt like, but we'd work together to make sure that our mutual time-needs were always being met.

Another possibility was staying here and he would look for a better-paying job, and our relationship structure would basically remain the same unless things ended with Claire for their own reasons. He said that although he wants her in his life forever, he does see his relationship to her changing over time. (Presumably, he means segueing into friendship.)

He said that he feels like we were "made for each other" and that he's "so happy that we have made the decision to open up the floodgates and just let everything happen"; that he really does want to spend every possible moment with me, and he misses me in every moment that we're apart.

I was very emotionally moved by all of that. I guess he and I are basically on the same page, but with one small difference: in my response, I made it clear to him that the only thing that might be lacking in one of those scenarios for me is that I really do prefer communal living with a lover, eventually, and there is a possibility that if he and Claire are together for the long haul after all, and she doesn't mellow out about being in my presence, that might not be something that he and I get to do.

I've never pictured myself living alone (or with roommates) for the long term. I like having someone to come home to, someone to cook for, someone to share tasks with, someone who will automatically return to the same location as I do if disaster strikes. (OK, that last one is a little odd, but I take in a lot of apocalyptic fiction, haha.) I would not suggest that we take such a step now—ten months is a bit soon, in my book, even if there hadn't been major drama in the very recent past—but I do think we are at the point where it makes sense to decide whether that is something we might eventually be moving toward.

I told him that is something that I suppose is negotiable for me; though I want it very much, if it came down to not living with him and living without him (fine distinction there, hehe), I obviously still would want him in my life. I may decide to eventually find a additional partner more suited for domesticity, I mentioned, but there is then the worry that that person would begin to feel more primary. So that is a bridge that we will cross when we come to it.

For now, things are very, very good. I would almost say "better than ever," except I do hold the tiniest shred of nervousness about what actual Christmas week is going to be like for me emotionally, and I think we both will feel a lot better once that is behind us. I think we have (at least for the immediate future) solved the time issue, and we are at least aware of and working on Rider's thoughtlessness/inconsideration problem. Being aware of that and recognizing that it is the root of a lot of problems—really drilling that into his head—is a big step, I think. He has promised to try to take his entire situation into account from here on out, instead of making impulsive decisions under pressure.

And I've fixed things within myself, too. I think a lot of my "trying to help" and how I put myself in a situation to feel starved from the beginning is just that I felt a little guilty that Claire was there first, then I came along, and Rider and I became what we are together: a perfectly meshing power-generating magic machine of a couple. But thinking about it, I shouldn't feel guilty, because we can't help what we are—it's obvious to me that what he has with her is unique and special in its own way, but the fact that it isn't what WE have has nothing to do with me and would be true whether or not I existed.

So I am no longer letting my deference to Claire's seniority limit what Rider and I can become. I am going to ask for and push for everything that I want in my relationship with him, and HE can be the one to make the choice about whether or not he wants to give it to me. I will not shoot myself in the foot by preemptively assuming that things need to be a certain way. If I want big life steps with him, I will ask for them, and if he agrees to them, I will not feel guilty. And if he declines, well, then I will either do without, or get those desires met in other ways. But I will not NOT ASK.

It's kind of crazy and kind of neat how he and I always manage to bring good out of the bad—the worst the bad starts off, the more radical the good ends up. I hope it is always like this.
 
Last edited:
I have been so busy! And I still am, to the point where I don't have time to write about anything in any detail—that will have to come later!

Summary in brief:

Last Friday I had a great date night with Rider (drive-in movie, fantastic sex).

Saturday morning Rider took me to the airport to go to Hometown to see Jake. I spent a very nice four-and-a-half days with Jake, with only two little hiccups, which I will discuss later when I detail the trip. Every single thing about Jake is fantastic, including how he is always respectful of and happy about my relationship with Rider. Even after 20 years, I find that the more I learn about him, the better I like him.

While I was in Hometown, I got a very nice email from Sam saying that he's looking forward to our visits. *squee!*

Wednesday night, Rider picked me up from the airport and we spent the evening chatting and reconnecting, then had absolutely mind-blowing sex. Rider told me that Claire told him that she "isn't thrilled" that he and I are in love with each other, but she's glad he's happy. I remain mystified by that—why be polyAMORous at all if you're not keen on the notion of your lover loving others?

Last night, Rider played a show, and I attended even though Thursday is usually Claire's night, because I refuse to miss Rider's musical performances, and Claire refuses to share (even public) space with me.

Tonight, Rider and I are attending a holiday event together. We invited Allie to be our date, but she had other stuff to do, so it will just be the two of us.

Sunday, Rider and I were scheduled to clean his apartment together (one area of his life where he needs a lot of help and work), but he is thinking of canceling in order to attend a drum circle with Claire. I'm not stoked about the potential cancellation, because our days together before I leave for the holiday are limited, but at the same time, I get that a drum circle is way more fun than cleaning your apartment, LOL. I can't really blame him if he leans that way. Maybe I'll just clean my own apartment instead!
 
It's finally time for the incredibly long post that I've been putting off writing due to busyness, in which I detail my visit to Jake and catch up on all other recent happenings.

So early in the morning last Saturday, Rider took me to the airport to go visit Jake in my hometown. This trip had been planned since three days after my last visit (in October) ended, and while I had been looking forward to it, I wasn't in an excitement frenzy because my emotions tend to dull themselves after a certain amount of time apart.

When I arrived, Jake was waiting for me in the airport bar outside of security. He'd taken the train from the city to the airport to meet me. It was great to see him in person again; I often forget how amazingly attractive I find him until I actually have him before my eyes. We had a coffee drink, then took the train back to his neighborhood, where we grabbed a meal at a fancy Lebanese place. It was funny that when we stripped off all of our cold-weather gear, we were dressed almost identically, in olive green shirts and tight blue jeans. We were embroiled in lively conversation the entire time.

After the restaurant, we popped into the bar where he works. He's a busy fellow: he is finishing up his master's in social work, does an internship helping the homeless population, and tends bar a few nights a week. His coworkers plied us with whiskey, and we ended up being quite day-drunk, stumbling back to his place for an early evening makeout session. Being naked with him fuels so much desire in me.

Not only is he extremely aesthetically pleasing, but he's the polar opposite of Rider, so he pings my variety sensors. He's almost exactly my height (maybe a teensy bit taller), with perpetually tousled short, brown hair, eyelashes so thick and dark that they look fake and make it look like he's always wearing eyeliner, insanely intense blue-green eyes, and a striking, prominent nose. He's a thin, heavily tattooed vegan who wears zippers sewn into bracelets and has small, sturdy hands from working with them so much behind the bar. He's tiny and compact, perfectly trim. Conversely, Rider is a foot taller—a huge, freckled natural strawberry blonde (though he dyes it), with silky, straight hair that he's working on growing to chin length, spun-gold eyelashes, bright orange beard and pube hairs, giant, spidery hands, and a pale, squishy beer belly. And an amazing bubble butt. ;)

When I am with Rider, I feel like I am a small creature happily crawling over a jungle gym made of man. When I am with Jake, I feel like we are perfectly symmetrical beings cast from the same mold. Both sensations are wildly satisfying.

Before Jake and I took our clothes off, we had a conversation about safety that didn't go exactly as planned. From the last visit, I knew that he had trouble staying hard with condoms, but we had used them anyway to honor my agreement with Rider, even though I did trust him when he said that he'd tested recently and been OK, and that he is currently only with one other partner. For this visit, I'd gotten Rider's permission that we could go unprotected provided that a) I test before and after, and b) Jake test directly before and not hook up with anyone new in that window. As it turned out, Jake's results hadn't come back yet, so I had to text Rider and ask him what he was comfortable with. He told me just to go for it and get tested (as I was already planning on doing) when I got back. Jake was expecting to have his results on Monday, so we'd probably be fine anyway. It was really cool of Rider to make that concession for us.

After a bit of drunken fooling around (but no PIV sex), Jake and I decided to go back out on the town and meet some friends of his. We had a really good time hopping from bar to bar in his neighborhood, getting fed shots by all of his bartender friends, and getting quite intoxicated. We posted an adorable picture to Facebook with the caption "true love" and he picked me a piece of flowering shrub in a cute romantic gesture. We finally returned to his place and passed out.

In the morning, we decided to have the laziest hung over Sunday ever. We ordered Thai food in and half-watched comedy videos on YouTube while having scintillating conversation and occasionally making out. He's so brilliant, and it's always so nice to converse with him. After a while, things got heated, and we ended up fucking on the couch (his roommate was out of town), then moving to the bedroom. Just like last visit, though, things weren't really working properly. It was like...we'd get really hot and things would be going really amazingly, but then once we got a little ways into actual sex, things were just not quite matching up right. We gave up after a little while and took a little nap, then resumed our lazy hanging out.

Monday, I had work to do, and he had a school presentation to prepare for. We didn't really get to hang out much until after 10 pm. We were both really tired, and after a bit of making out and conversation, we just went to sleep.

Tuesday, Jake went to retrieve his test results, but it turned out the clinic had lost them! He had to get stuck and swabbed all over again, and he won't know his results for a couple more days. Rider was NOT happy about this. He was suffering under the strain of missing me, and getting the bad news that I wouldn't have Jake's results until I was already home, after he'd already given me the green light—it shook him. I had to spend some time talking him down and reassuring him that everything was likely to be fine, and reminding him that I was testing right when I got back, regardless. He eventually settled down.

That afternoon, once I had finished my work, Jake and I went to the area of town where we both grew up, an impoverished blue-collar suburb notorious for its "white trash" and waste treatment plant. We had planned to cook dinner for my mom, so we stopped at the grocery store a few blocks from where we used to live (we grew up about half a mile apart). As we walked through the store, hand in hand, selecting produce and deciding on ingredients, I felt so strange, like I was living in some alternate timeline where I'd never moved to Opposite Coast right after high school, and where we'd settled down together in our old neighborhood like so many other people we knew from high school had. We could have been married with middle-school-aged children—box wine and iceberg lettuce in the fridge, worry lines already etched into our faces, and ten years of the same depressing jobs under our belts.

Dinner with my mom was pretty good. Neither he nor I had seen each other's parents in fifteen years, and he was pretty nervous, but it turned out well. My mom is super-religious and a teetotaler, but she shares with Jake a deep passion for helping the homeless (she runs a group that feeds them on Sundays), so they had that to talk about. After dinner, we sat in the living room chatting. Everything was fine until my mom asked me what I was doing for Christmas. I should have been prepared for that eventuality, but I hadn't thought of it, so too much blatant truth leaked out, and she did NOT seem happy that Rider was going to be with Claire, leaving me to fend for myself. I pleaded with her to not be mad, since I wasn't anymore, and she rolled her eyes and said that she is just going to "pretend that everyone is just friends, because that's the only way [she] can understand 'that lifestyle.'" Two steps forward, one step back, I suppose.

After my mom's house, Jake and I went to his parents' house for drinks. It was a real trip seeing them again after so many years. It was a really nice time, other than the part where I killed my phone by it falling out of my pocket into the toilet. His parents wanted pictures of us putting decorations on their tree, so we posed for a few of those. I don't know how out as poly he is to them, so I didn't mention much about that aspect of my life as we were catching up.

Once we were done making the rounds, we headed back to his neighborhood and went back out to his bar. We had a bunch of drinks and fun, and I confessed to him on the walk home that I was really concerned about how we couldn't seem to get the sex thing together—something about it just wasn't working. He agreed, but he said he was pretty sure we could figure it out. We went to bed without trying it, though.

The next morning was my last morning there, and we finally had some good sex. Or at least, good for me. I managed to squeeze out an orgasm, thank fuck. He still didn't, but he swore that it doesn't really matter. I'm just glad that I did, because I had started feeling quite frustrated by the whole thing. We finally forced ourselves from the bed and to the train. He reminded me that I was supposed to bring some of the famous Hometown beer back to Rider, and he escorted me all the way to airport security, even though it meant over an hour each way for him. I really did not want to leave his side, and we just kept kissing every chance we got. I spent the entire plane ride messaging with him and Rider. They each had messages for the other that they were relaying via me, even though they are Facebook friends. It was cute.

Rider picked me up from the airport and bought me dinner, then we went back to my place to cuddle with my cat and have insanely mind-blowing sex. I wish sex with Jake was as good as sex with Rider is. Everything about it is perfect. It was so good to be back with him, even though I had started to miss Jake already. But I'm going back the second weekend of January!

And that is the long-ass story of my visit to Jake. I think I should save all the other info for another consecutive post.
 
With the story of my Jake visit out of the way, I can focus on more current stuff. The most important of these is what's going on with Sam. While I was in Hometown, he emailed me saying that he's looking forward to our visits. I was very pleasantly surprised, as most of the time, I am the one who initiates the conversation.

After that happened, I asked Rider when the last time he'd talked to Sam was. I was wondering if some communication between the two of them had triggered the email, but it turned out that they hadn't talked for a bit. That got Rider thinking that they should probably have a chat, so he messaged him and they talked about the thing between Sam and me, among other things.

Rider thanked Sam for keeping me company for the holiday, and Sam expressed some small fear that Rider might end up getting jealous, but Rider explained that he totally isn't—that he is happy that we have found a connection, and he is glad to be a part of it. All of that was really cool.

I am so excited about my trip up there. Any bad feelings I had about not seeing Rider for Christmas have completely given way to nervousness and excitement about spending so much time with Sam. I am pretty freaking nervous, actually. I really, really, really like Sam, and I feel like a kid about to go on her first date or something. Which is probably a little silly, given that we've already had sex a couple of times, but hanging out totally one on one is new.

I messaged him last night telling him how excited and nervous I am, in the interest of transparency, and he messaged me back this morning saying that it will be good and fun, and that we will go have dinner with his dad, and asking if I could send him a grocery list to shop before all the stores are closed, so that we could make Indian food. SQUEEEE! I just adore him so much.

Rider and I will be going back up to Sam's just three days after I return, and there was some talk that Kelly and a friend might be joining us up there for a couple of days. Rider wanted to make sure that I'd be cool with that, and I don't see why not. I should be comfortable enough with Sam by then that if he wants to spend the night with Kelly then I could just sleep with Sam. The only thing is that that damned air mattress on the futon frame in Sam's spare room is about the squeakiest thing ever. I don't know if I'd want to actually HEAR them as they have sex for the first time...? The idea kind of turns me on and revolts me at the same time—odd mix of emotions. I absolutely like to share in threesome situations, and I don't mind when he is off somewhere fucking someone, but I'm not sure I want to be aware of the particulars when I am not going to be directly involved. I'll have to talk through it with him.

Another good thing that happened is that I decided to try one more time to extend an olive branch to Claire, in the form of a beer. I know she also likes fruity shit like I do, and I had bought these tasty peachy holiday beers, and I sent one to her via Rider yesterday. He said she was weird about it at first, but then she relaxed and even gave him a Christmas cookie to give me. So, yay for a tiny little bit of progress there? What I really want to do is to write her a heartfelt letter explaining that I think we are teammates more than competitors and giving examples of the shit I've done for her behind the scenes. But I am going to wait a while longer before doing that. I figure once my one-year anniversary with Rider rolls around, that would be an appropriate time—we'll have been at this whole thing for a year, and hopefully most of the drama will be history. I just feel like she has the wrong idea about me, and maybe some direct communication will make things better.

So basically, everything is going amazingly in my poly life. I may be poor in money and poor in time, but I am incredibly rich in love. I have Rider, who is my very heart, most every day I want him. I have Jake, who is so amazing in so many ways, only a 2.5-hour plane ride away, and I get to see him again next month. I get to spend the holiday with Sam and get to know him better and meet his dad. I have my cyber connection with Moss and will be talking to him tomorrow and seeing him in March. I have my weekly phone date with Oona scheduled for tomorrow night. My mom was relatively cool about hanging out with Jake, and I got to see Jake's family for the first time in years. And Claire actually reciprocated an act of kindness. I feel like things are coming together and falling into place just how I want them. What a great way to wrap up a chaotic year.
 
I've been missing Jake pretty fiercely in the past day or so. It's been nearly a week since I said goodbye to him at the airport, and I feel like I'd do almost anything to be next to him again. Almost anything except, you know, abandon my job, rack up more credit card debt buying an insanely priced plane ticket, and break my plans with Rider and with Sam. It's just that feeling of long-distance longing, with nothing to be done about it.

As for the holiday plans, tomorrow at noon, I board a bus headed to College Town to see Sam. I'm going to bring my instrument, in case we decide we want to play music. He'll be picking me up from the bus station around 5 pm.

I talked to Rider about my reservations about potentially overhearing him having sex with Kelly at Sam's house over the New Year's visit. The more I thought about it, the more it creeped me out. Rider is rather loud during sex, and I have no clue how loud Kelly is, and the idea of hearing them together just raises my hackles.

I tried examining my emotions to understand what exactly about it bothers me, and I haven't quite figured it out. I did some thought exercises, and the idea of being in the room doesn't evoke the same negative emotion (though I still don't want to do that, because I'm not attracted to her, and it would be weird to just watch); nor does swapping out other people I know he's been with before (Oona, Allie, etc.). So I think it's maybe something about the newness of her, or my not knowing her well, or something. The idea of them having sex off somewhere where I can't hear them and when I don't know exactly when it's happening does nothing to faze me—it's just the idea of HEARING and knowing the exact-when that makes me feel unpleasant.

He thought about it, and mentally put himself in the same situation, and he said he'd probably feel the same way, so he understands. It's one thing to be in the room or to know conceptually that it is happening, but another to be on the other side of a closed door and "ear-witnessing" it. He said he doesn't want to do anything that would make me uncomfortable, because I am very important to him.

He said maybe the two of them could just find a moment to sneak away when everyone else was otherwise occupied at the bonfire. That's a bit better, I guess, but I still worry a little bit that they would be gone for a long time, and I would just know that's why and feel weird about going into the house if I needed to for some reason.

It's like...if he were to be gone for a weekend with her, or if she were visiting while I was out of town, then I wouldn't know exactly WHEN stuff was going down. And the knowing when is part of what bothers me. I don't know WHY that is true, but it is. How can I be totally cool with something when it is nebulous, but uncomfortable with it when it is exact? It's like the same thing with when Claire's Pandora station posted to Facebook over the summer—knowing the exact moment when it is happening feels like a gut-punch, for some reason, even though when it is just an abstract idea, I am actually happy for him.

I think that over time, I will get used to the idea, and it will be old hat to me, and I won't care anymore. Maybe after I get to know Kelly better, and she is familiar to me. Because I really am not jealous of her in general. I want Rider to have fun. I don't want to be an impediment or a disappointment. So we're still talking it out.

I think part of it might also be the fact that Rider had painted that trip to me like a joyous five-day stretch of mostly just me, him, and Sam, which I absolutely love, and I was all giddy and squeeing about it. And now, it's looking like that might not be the case after all, so I am grieving it a bit. I get stressed out by changes of plans.

I dunno; I'm just pre-processing things here. I suppose I'll have more to report back later.
 
Last edited:
Oh, also, I created a small collage with me and my peeps in it that I'm going to put up, for a limited time, in an album. If you're curious about what my sweeties and I look like, add me as a contact, and you'll be able to see it. :)
 
Last edited:
I am currently on the Greyhound on my way back from visiting Sam for Christmas. Rider will be picking me up from the bus station, and I am super excited to see him.

My visit with Sam was really nice! Wednesday, he picked me up from the bus stop shortly before sundown, and I was so glad to see him. Usually he is so quiet, but he must have been excited to see me too, because we had no shortage of things to say to one another. There were even times when he cut me off in his eagerness to interject something!

We got back to his place, and immediately we cracked open a couple of beers. He showcased his substance collection to me, and we indulged in a bit of this and a bit of that. I messaged a bit with Rider, who was off having his own substance-fueled voyage with Claire and the couple that they sometimes hang out with (with whom they've talked about hooking up, but it hasn't happened yet).

Sam and I chatted and drank and drank and chatted, listening to music and watching YouTube videos together. Eventually, we kissed a little, then just went back to chatting. At one point, he looked at me and said, "If I seem a little weird, it's because I am not used to love. You're used to love. I'm a lonely bastard." And in that moment, I was so glad that everything went down the way that it did and I got to be there to keep him company.

Before it got very late, we both decided that it's time for bed. We were both tired, but beyond that, I think we were both feeling the unspoken slow burn of desire ramping up. He'll never say as much out loud, and my saying it out loud would force him to acknowledge it, so I didn't. Once in bed, we finally had sex for the first time in a real bed without Rider there. In his silent way, he used his body to speak to me. We played for a while, then both realized we were too tired to keep going, and we settled to sleep.

Sleeping next to him isn't easy like it is with Rider. He doesn't tolerate cuddling well, and I automatically sleep-cuddle. He is so passive, he wouldn't tell me no, but I noticed that he rested easier when I wasn't touching him, so I kept waking and forcing myself to my own side. Neither of us slept well, I don't think.

When it was sufficiently daylight, we established that we were both awake and resumed cuddling. Sober, deliberate, daylit, I decided that the first thing he'd get for Christmas should be a blowjob. ;) He responded well, and it was super-hot to know that I'd finally gotten him off, after five months of sporadic hooking up and things never having been comfortable enough. I held that memory in my mind in the days that followed, turning it over like a prize.

We got up, and I cooked breakfast: huevos rancheros. We poured Kahlua in our coffee and watched kids' Christmas movies. We sat on his porch and played with his cat. Eventually, it was time to get ready to go see his dad. I asked him up front whether it would be cool if I showed affection in front of his dad, and he said his dad was an "old '70s guy" who was really chill and wouldn't care. Part of the reason I'd asked is because I'd met his brother not long ago when Rider and I came up to visit, and we'd kept things pretty down-low. His brother I think mostly thinks of me as Rider's girlfriend, though he did at one point come outside to find me topless in the hot tub with both of them. So that conversation was me giving Sam an "out" if he'd rather not open that can of worms.

Almost from the moment we pulled up, I knew that I was going to like Sam's dad. Much shorter than Sam, with a long white ponytail and a strong resemblance to Sam's brother, he returned my hello hug like he meant it, not as though it were a perfunctory greeting. His house was really interesting, with lots of eclectic art everywhere and a big, beautiful, wild yard. He gave us (mostly me, with side commentary to Sam about changes) the grand tour while we sipped drinks.

Eventually, Sam and I collaborated on cooking a tasty Indian meal (well, he mostly separated cilantro from its stem and refilled my cocktail, but that was still helpful). It was fun working in the kitchen with him and sneaking little bits of affection here and there. We had a nice dinner, just the three of us, at a small, round dining room table. His dad remarked on how nice it was to have a woman around when he was used to their Christmas dinners just being "a couple of bachelors with a roast chicken and instant potatoes."

After dinner, Sam and I cleaned up while his dad relaxed with coffee, then we all retired to the sofa for beer and conversation. It was pleasant, stimulating conversation. His dad is a real talker, the exact opposite of Sam, and it was interesting to ask him a question and get him off on a 10-minute story, with barely a pause to breathe. I nestled in close to Sam on the couch, and he put his arm around me. It was cozy, and I felt like part of their family. His dad must have thought so, too, because he eventually started dropping hints that he thought Sam should marry me, LOL. I hope he's not too mad when he finds everything out—but he seems like a very open-minded, unconventional guy himself. We stayed for almost seven hours, and by the time we got back to Sam's we were so tired that we just went straight to bed and to sleep.

Friday morning, Sam woke up before I did and made coffee. I got up about an hour and a half later and cooked us a tasty omelet. We watched some more kids' movies and sipped some rum coffee, and I was just wicked, wicked horny. I think Sam felt it too, because he talked about needing a rub, which was a convenient excuse to get in the bed. I rubbed him a while, then we had really hot sex that I think was equally as good for both of us. We lay around for a while longer, basking, before heading out to the store to pick up stuff for our meals for the rest of the time.

We got back, I made a guacamole, and we partook of a substance. Sam started a bonfire and we watched the nature creatures at play in his yard. After the events of the previous 24 hours, I felt so hot for him, so close to him. Time passed, and we were feeling pretty lazy, so we flopped out in front of some nature documentaries. We started to fall asleep, moved to the bed, and I told him that I loved him before we fell asleep. He didn't return it—and I wasn't expecting it—but he smiled and squeezed me tight before we both retreated to our sides of the bed.

This morning, we woke up around the same time. I cuddled into him and we ended up having some more fantastic sex. He is so strong and nearly silent, reserved in his passion until he turns a corner and it seems to consume him. After sex, I made breakfast, and the pall of my having to leave crept over us. Even though I'm coming back with Rider in three days, that feeling of leaving is always a bit melancholy. It was for the best, though, because our silences were becoming longer—not out of anything negative, just that we both tend to introversion and were feeling the need to recharge coming on. He took me to the Greyhound station around sunset, and I've been on a bus ever since.

Visit to Sam aside, another thing that happened since my last post was that Rider and I resolved the whole Kelly-down-the-hall thing. Thinking about it, Rider realized that there was actually nowhere to put the extra friend to sleep; even if I slept with Sam and Rider slept with Kelly, that fifth person would have no bed. Additionally, I pointed out to Rider that it was kind of rude to make it non-optional for me to share Sam's bed for more days—Sam was probably looking forward to having it back to himself, and for Kelly to take my place at Rider's side would sort of "throw me in" with Sam without giving Sam a choice in the matter, potentially making him uncomfortable in his own house. These are just more examples of things that Rider does not tend to think through.

Rider admitted that it was actually a terrible idea all around, and that he was just champing at the bit to get some time with Kelly while he perceived that window as being open. I guess she's graduating in the spring and may be moving somewhere even farther away. That or she may just lose interest, being 25 and in a transitional time in her life. He wants to "strike while the iron is hot," as it were.

He also felt super-bad when he realized that I had been so excited about the trip just being me, him, and Sam (since that's how he'd originally painted it to me) and also when I reminded him that he'd repeatedly mentioned to me while we were hashing out the Christmas thing that that time would, in a way, "make up for" the time he'd sold me out for Christmas. As we got deeper into the discussion, he really started beating himself up that he hadn't thought of any of those factors, and he started really stressing at how bad he was at scheduling and thinking ahead.

I offered to take his scheduling over for him, if he really was that incapable of it and stressed about it; I'm kind of a master planner, and I subscribe to the belief that part of the things that relationships are good for is that each person's innate strengths can pitch in to cover the other person's innate weaknesses. There are plenty of ways in which Rider helps me, so I don't mind doing that little part if it keeps everyone happy. I told him just to tell me what he requires and I'll Tetris it all in there. And I will absolutely find some time for him to visit Kelly when everything calms down; right now, it's looking like the weekend that I visit Moss for his 40th is the likeliest option.

In the meantime, Rider has coordinated a day trip for all of us (me, him, Sam, Kelly, friend) to some brewpubs not far from College Town while we are over there next weekend. That should get him a little of his Kelly fix, and it should be a lot of fun.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top