This is a long one, bear with me.
I’ve been in a non-monogamous relationship with my boyfriend Felix for a year and a half (together for 3). The relationship has been more polyamorous on my end and more open on his end, but neither of us have had any notable physical action going on besides some kissing and making out (in public with our clothes on). I fell in love with someone else a year ago, but it didn’t work out because she was already in a relationship and after negotiations her partner didn’t want to go poly. They stayed together.
Felix cheated on me almost 2 years ago while we were on a break of sorts, but still sleeping with each other and under an agreement that we’d tell each other of any new dating situations and when I found out, lied about what happened multiple times (trickle truth). Although the situation was blurry (and we were stupid to even go there), I still consider it cheating because he broke the agreement we had and lied to me about it. We went through hell and back, fixed our trust issues and decided to be fully together and open under the premise that anything is possible, as long as it’s negotiated, agreed upon and we tell each other the absolute truth.
Last weekend Felix went on an overnight trip that included alcohol consumption with a friend (Susan) who he’s very attracted to (and she is to him) and another platonic friend (Tom). I asked before the trip what the sleeping arrangements were going to be and he said he’ll most likely be sleeping in the same room with Tom and that he doesn’t think anything is going to happen with Susan. Before this trip, he had been telling me that nothing further (there had been some kissing before) is ever likely to happen with him and Susan, since Susan can’t do open relationships. I trusted his assessment on the situation and because of what he told me, I didn’t think I needed to get deeper into the matter and discuss what I was comfortable with. My mistake, that I fully accept responsibility for. We have an agreement in place of no sex before we check with each other first on how each of us really feels about the possibility (because we’re still pretty new to this and I want to take it slow on that). While he was away, he kept messaging me all night (in a very good spirit) and I thought that he obviously wasn’t very interested in her since he’s not even giving her his full attention.
When he came back from the trip, he told me that he had slept naked in the same bed with Susan and they had spooned each other all night with the blanket in between and kissing each other and that they talked about the possibility of sex being back on the table again but he had told her that he needed to check with me first on how I feel about it, so they didn’t actually have sex. I sincerely thought I had dealt with the whole cheating thing in my mind, but all of the trust issues and feeling sick to my stomach came surging back. I felt like I was blindsided with the whole thing, with him telling me nothing was likely to happen (and well yeah, sex didn’t, but that to me wasn’t “nothing”) and if I had known he was planning to sleep naked together with her, I would have told him I wasn’t ok with that yet, not on that trip. With all the trickle truth from before where this exact situation (telling me they just slept together but nothing happed) was one of the things he lied about I would have much rather given the full ok for the sex when I was ready than having to now think whether he’s lying to me again or telling me the truth. It’s a full on flashback. I keep bouncing back and forth with “He has gone above and beyond to fix our trust issues for the past year and a half and I have no reason not to trust the person he is now” and “He lied to me about this exact same situation before, he might as well be lying to me now”. My mind keeps telling me there is no way that two people who are very attracted to each other just sleep in the same bed naked while being intoxicated and nothing except for some kissing happens. He knows fully well that I consider genital touching with someone (be it our own or someone elses) sex. It is awfully risky to get in a situation like that and he fully admits that had she started touching him in some way, they would have been having sex and he wouldn’t have even had the strength to pull away. I feel like he was THIS close to cheating on me again, or he might actually have already but is just lying to me. Again.
I take full responsibility for the fact that I didn’t properly communicate what I was ok with but I sincerely didn’t think I had to. Lesson learned I guess. I also feel like he should have communicated with me better on where he’s at currently with her, and rather than telling me nothing was going to happen, tell me he doesn’t know and that he’s keeping his options open. That would have given me the incentive to tell him what I was ok with on my end. I feel a bit stupid even, since during the time he was away, I felt genuinely happy in the fact that I now trust him 100% and if he says nothing is going to happen (except for some kissing, which I was fine with), nothing will and I have no reason to worry about anything, and so I didn’t. I was happy and proud of us, that we had gotten past our trust issues and that I fully trusted him again. Now I’m not so sure anymore. I also feel stupid in thinking that nothing like this was going to happen on an overnight trip with alcohol involved. Should have I known better? Should have he?
Now he’s saying that he doesn’t think he wants to be non-monogamous on his end anymore, since he is inevitably going to fuck up again and he just doesn’t have the bandwith to deal with my limitations on him (which I don’t think are unreasonable at this point) and the consequences of me being upset. He says I’m too controlling, which I admit I can be, especially when trust is broken, cause it’s a defence mechanism that I think is actually very understandable under those circumstances, when I feel like the ground beneath my feet is shattering. I also admit that getting very little sleep will make anyone frustrated and we’ve been talking 2 nights in a row now (yeah, I have some anxiety issues). He says he’d much rather deal with me being upset about issues in our relationship and not about someone else. I feel like this IS an issue in our relationship, it just involves that someone else, but that someone else is not the real problem, trust in our relationship is. I feel like him giving up on non-monogamy is a cop-out that puts the blame on me. I also admit that him being monogamous scares me, because I’m afraid it will just make him bitter and resentful of my relationships with other people. I do admit though, that he has always been the more monogamous one and he says he’s perfectly happy with only me, that he doesn’t really feel like he needs anyone or anything else anyway, but that he’s also ok with me having other relationships.
Now that I know that sex with them is back on the table (he says he still might go there but is just not so sure anymore) and we have talked about it, I have given him my ok with it, but I’m not so sure that’s a good idea anymore either, since the trust issues are back. I just feel like they should just go and get it over with, so that I wouldn’t have to worry about whether they already did it or not, but I know that’s mainly my frustration talking. I am curious though, on how we both would feel about it and handle it afterwards.
I could use an outside opinion on all of this. Am I too controlling? Is he untrustworthy and blame-shifting? We certainly should have communicated better, I do know that.
I’ve been in a non-monogamous relationship with my boyfriend Felix for a year and a half (together for 3). The relationship has been more polyamorous on my end and more open on his end, but neither of us have had any notable physical action going on besides some kissing and making out (in public with our clothes on). I fell in love with someone else a year ago, but it didn’t work out because she was already in a relationship and after negotiations her partner didn’t want to go poly. They stayed together.
Felix cheated on me almost 2 years ago while we were on a break of sorts, but still sleeping with each other and under an agreement that we’d tell each other of any new dating situations and when I found out, lied about what happened multiple times (trickle truth). Although the situation was blurry (and we were stupid to even go there), I still consider it cheating because he broke the agreement we had and lied to me about it. We went through hell and back, fixed our trust issues and decided to be fully together and open under the premise that anything is possible, as long as it’s negotiated, agreed upon and we tell each other the absolute truth.
Last weekend Felix went on an overnight trip that included alcohol consumption with a friend (Susan) who he’s very attracted to (and she is to him) and another platonic friend (Tom). I asked before the trip what the sleeping arrangements were going to be and he said he’ll most likely be sleeping in the same room with Tom and that he doesn’t think anything is going to happen with Susan. Before this trip, he had been telling me that nothing further (there had been some kissing before) is ever likely to happen with him and Susan, since Susan can’t do open relationships. I trusted his assessment on the situation and because of what he told me, I didn’t think I needed to get deeper into the matter and discuss what I was comfortable with. My mistake, that I fully accept responsibility for. We have an agreement in place of no sex before we check with each other first on how each of us really feels about the possibility (because we’re still pretty new to this and I want to take it slow on that). While he was away, he kept messaging me all night (in a very good spirit) and I thought that he obviously wasn’t very interested in her since he’s not even giving her his full attention.
When he came back from the trip, he told me that he had slept naked in the same bed with Susan and they had spooned each other all night with the blanket in between and kissing each other and that they talked about the possibility of sex being back on the table again but he had told her that he needed to check with me first on how I feel about it, so they didn’t actually have sex. I sincerely thought I had dealt with the whole cheating thing in my mind, but all of the trust issues and feeling sick to my stomach came surging back. I felt like I was blindsided with the whole thing, with him telling me nothing was likely to happen (and well yeah, sex didn’t, but that to me wasn’t “nothing”) and if I had known he was planning to sleep naked together with her, I would have told him I wasn’t ok with that yet, not on that trip. With all the trickle truth from before where this exact situation (telling me they just slept together but nothing happed) was one of the things he lied about I would have much rather given the full ok for the sex when I was ready than having to now think whether he’s lying to me again or telling me the truth. It’s a full on flashback. I keep bouncing back and forth with “He has gone above and beyond to fix our trust issues for the past year and a half and I have no reason not to trust the person he is now” and “He lied to me about this exact same situation before, he might as well be lying to me now”. My mind keeps telling me there is no way that two people who are very attracted to each other just sleep in the same bed naked while being intoxicated and nothing except for some kissing happens. He knows fully well that I consider genital touching with someone (be it our own or someone elses) sex. It is awfully risky to get in a situation like that and he fully admits that had she started touching him in some way, they would have been having sex and he wouldn’t have even had the strength to pull away. I feel like he was THIS close to cheating on me again, or he might actually have already but is just lying to me. Again.
I take full responsibility for the fact that I didn’t properly communicate what I was ok with but I sincerely didn’t think I had to. Lesson learned I guess. I also feel like he should have communicated with me better on where he’s at currently with her, and rather than telling me nothing was going to happen, tell me he doesn’t know and that he’s keeping his options open. That would have given me the incentive to tell him what I was ok with on my end. I feel a bit stupid even, since during the time he was away, I felt genuinely happy in the fact that I now trust him 100% and if he says nothing is going to happen (except for some kissing, which I was fine with), nothing will and I have no reason to worry about anything, and so I didn’t. I was happy and proud of us, that we had gotten past our trust issues and that I fully trusted him again. Now I’m not so sure anymore. I also feel stupid in thinking that nothing like this was going to happen on an overnight trip with alcohol involved. Should have I known better? Should have he?
Now he’s saying that he doesn’t think he wants to be non-monogamous on his end anymore, since he is inevitably going to fuck up again and he just doesn’t have the bandwith to deal with my limitations on him (which I don’t think are unreasonable at this point) and the consequences of me being upset. He says I’m too controlling, which I admit I can be, especially when trust is broken, cause it’s a defence mechanism that I think is actually very understandable under those circumstances, when I feel like the ground beneath my feet is shattering. I also admit that getting very little sleep will make anyone frustrated and we’ve been talking 2 nights in a row now (yeah, I have some anxiety issues). He says he’d much rather deal with me being upset about issues in our relationship and not about someone else. I feel like this IS an issue in our relationship, it just involves that someone else, but that someone else is not the real problem, trust in our relationship is. I feel like him giving up on non-monogamy is a cop-out that puts the blame on me. I also admit that him being monogamous scares me, because I’m afraid it will just make him bitter and resentful of my relationships with other people. I do admit though, that he has always been the more monogamous one and he says he’s perfectly happy with only me, that he doesn’t really feel like he needs anyone or anything else anyway, but that he’s also ok with me having other relationships.
Now that I know that sex with them is back on the table (he says he still might go there but is just not so sure anymore) and we have talked about it, I have given him my ok with it, but I’m not so sure that’s a good idea anymore either, since the trust issues are back. I just feel like they should just go and get it over with, so that I wouldn’t have to worry about whether they already did it or not, but I know that’s mainly my frustration talking. I am curious though, on how we both would feel about it and handle it afterwards.
I could use an outside opinion on all of this. Am I too controlling? Is he untrustworthy and blame-shifting? We certainly should have communicated better, I do know that.