Trying to respect boundaries...

tussock

New member
Hey all. This is my first time on this site, but it looks like a great environment and I'm excited to be a part of it.

I'm a pansexual female, married to a wonderful straight man. We are both poly and have been openly for pretty much the duration of our relationship. For the most part, this has amounted to little more than the occasional fling or brief attempt at dating. Honestly, it usually doesn't work out when the third party gets uncomfortable with the idea of the spouse - no matter how much either insists we are in agreement about it!

We recently moved and I began a new job, where I met a girl at my office. I was attracted immediately, but I tend to assume everyone is 1) straight and 2) monogamous so of course I did not pursue it, simply laughed a bit with my husband about my new crush. However, this has developed into something much deeper. It turns out she is bisexual AND poly, and attracted to me to boot. We are best friends now, spending hours together talking, texting, at work and outside. She is well aware of my feelings for her, and hers for me. The issue is her boyfriend.

They have been together for a few years and are an established couple living together. He is solidly monogamous, and very traditional. She participated openly in poly relationships before him, which he knows about, but he was insistent that he is uncomfortable with polyamory and would expect a full monogamous commitment from her. She agreed and they have been very happy, but she has confessed that our friendship and specifically my open relationship with my husband has made her question the decision.

I'm at a point where I'm not really sure how to proceed. It's so difficult for me to be casual and non-sexual around her. If her relationship were not as it is, we would absolutely be dating right now. As it is, I feel like we almost are. There has been no sex (almost no touching at all - it feels like crossing a line when we are already so close to the edges of her relationship) but we spend lots of time alone together, and our friendship is very much an emotional relationship.

I feel like even if I can't BE with her, our friendship is really important to me, and I certainly want to respect her and her bf's relationship and sexual decisions. But at the same time, I just don't know if I can keep on being around her without feeling miserable. My husband is, of course, super supportive of whatever we do, but I feel like just bringing it up is pressuring her and I don't want that. She oscillates between talking about wanting to return to a poly lifestyle (either by breaking up with her bf or some unlikely scenario where she talks him into it or at least being okay with it) and being so convinced that she can't let him go.

I don't feel like anyone's lying to anyone else really. I just feel like we're at an impasse. I don't know, it all sounds kind of crazy typed out. Thanks for reading this novel of a post. Any similar experiences or suggestions are greatly appreciated.
 
At the end of the day, you have to do what's best for your own stability and mental health. Your friendship with her as it stands is not doing either of you much good, and life is just too short to spend it pining over 'what ifs', no? I think in your shoes I'd be starting to put a bit of distance between myself and her, and be looking for other people to focus my attention on - people who are free to reciprocate. I know that that may sound easier said than done, but honestly, if her boyfriend is not up for it, and she is not up for renegotiating that or walking away from him, then anything else is just going to turn into a painful drama-fest for all concerned. You're not the only one being affected by this carefully repressed treading of the line dance with her - so probably best for you, her, your partner (who's dealing with a mopey preoccupied you right now) and him (ignorant though he may be, he might still classify this as emotional cheating and be hurt by it if he did know) if you end this now.
 
I am sorry you struggle.

I think YOU need to SET some boundaries for you and for her to follow. That you are not the guy to process all this stuff with:

she has confessed that our friendship and specifically my open relationship with my husband has made her question the decision.

Because it was after that point that you stopped enjoying your friendship and crush.

You could tell her to stop sharing these things with YOU. You are too close for the situation and it makes you uncomfortable.

You could tell her she could process all that with other people or a counselor.

You could tell her that she can tell you her final decision on it:

1) That she's decided to stick with her monogamous relationship, and you guys not longer talk about crush stuff on each other.

2) That she's decided to end it with her BF and wants a break from you to sort that out first cleanly and then she will get back in touch. (Keeping in mind that depending on the size of your company, dating a coworker has its own bag of problems.)

But until such time, you guys are NON-DATING friends who do not talk about crush-y feelings for each other, make googly eyes, and so on.

She processes all that internal conflict of hers with other people not involved in the situation. Leave you out of it.

YOU can maintain that boundary for yourself. If she goes off into crush talk, makes googly eyes, or dumps her back-and-forth processing on you? You could say "We do not talk about this. I am not the guy to process with. Please respect my limit. At this time we are friends only. Keep it in the friend bucket. "

If she cannot respect YOUR boundaries that you need to stop feeling miserable when around her? Then you could choose to not pal around with her and not see her because she does not respect your limits. That's not friendly behavior out of her.

That's all I can think of that you have control over -- how close you allow yourself to be to her. That is you behavior choice.

I feel like just bringing it up is pressuring her and I don't want that.

It is not "pressuring her" to make her aware of where YOUR boundaries lay so that you can feel comfortable and not miserable.

Speak up.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi tussock,

I think GalaGirl is onto something in the sense that maybe you and your new friend can "just be friends," and not even worry about some hypothetical romance, unless/until she makes a firm decision to split with her boyfriend or "talks him into it" so that she becomes free to be poly. No need for her to mention it to you in the meantime.

Because she made a very conscious choice to give up poly for her boyfriend, she's got to take responsibility for that choice. Whatever that means, for her. But I don't think you have any jobs you have to do in this area. If you can just be her friend without being miserable, do that, and don't even mention the poly to her.

Does that help a bit?
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Back
Top