Working triad?

Neo

New member
The other day I started a post on here about being introduced to poly and starting a triad (and about my panic and fear as ive only ever previously been mono)

Now i've had a lil look through the forum but time and time again I'm coming upon stories of triads failing. Or the addition to the couple ending up with one of the original pair (i cant think of a better way to phrase that sorry) I was wondering if anyone out there would be happy to share with me a triad success story instead!
 
Our triad lasted 38 years and only distance separates us now. However, we did not have an open relationship. We never dated our g/f or had sex with anyone individually. My wife knew her g/f since they were teenagers; I knew her even longer. We entered into a relationship that included sex. We did not have sex and then build a relationship. There is a big difference.

None of the 5 couples who we knew with open relationships survived long. Each had one or both spouses fall in love with their lovers. Interestingly, they all were married and divorced multiple times. Seems that they could not remain faithful. I think what happens is that your lover is there only for the fun part of live while your wife is there for all the boring and necessary day to day things. Your lover does not nag you to mow the grass or stop spending money on boy toys. That makes your lover very attractive. As I tell people, if you try enough times, you will always find someone better that you will love. It is inevitable with most people.

My advice is to share any lovers and take it slow. Establish limits. Do not spent an hour with the new girl and 5 minutes with your wife. You need to make all the women feel equally pretty and desirable. I guarantee you that if your wife is left there watching you getting all excited by another female and doing stuff that she considers reserved to the marriage, she will not be a happy camper. Good luck.
 
I suppose I should point out im one of the females. Both my partner (m) and our addition (f) are experienced with poly. He will be spending time with each of us (including sex) on an individual basis as well as together and me and her will possibly spend time alone together too (as friends and intimately?) as our bond hopefully grows.
 
Last edited:
I was part of a V triad, until S2 entered the mix.

For us, it worked because we communicated. I was the hinge of the V; Guy and Hubby are friends, but that's it, and they rarely talk to each other. Just an occasional text message here and there. So in our case, it was *expected* that Guy would be with me, Hubby would be with me, and it was up to me to make sure each was comfortable and felt they were getting the amount of my time and attention they wanted/needed.

I've also known open marriages that failed because one partner fell in love with an outside partner; that's why Hubby and I set boundaries when we opened our marriage. But I've found that, at least among the couples *I* know that failed with open marriages, the marriage was in trouble before the opening. In all but one of the 8 cases I know of, the marriage was opened in an attempt to save it. (The 8th couple split because of physical violence between them during a fight about an outside partner...)

Every relationship is different. The only "wrong" way to approach a triad is the way that doesn't work for all members of the relationship. And there is no single *right* way.

But short answer... the best way to make sure your triad doesn't fail is to keep all lines of communication among the three of you completely open. Talk about concerns; talk about what isn't working; talk about what *is* working. No one can read minds; you have to be willing and able to discuss things if you want to make it work.

And that's true of mono relationships as well; it isn't just a poly thing.
 
My gf, my bf and I were in a lopsided triad. He and she were more FWBs than full on gf and bf. Even though I broke up with bf recently, I consider we had a successful thing for over 2 years. I didn't leave my gf for him, she didn't leave me for him, and he didn't leave his wife for either of us.

The problem was, he wanted even more lovers than me, my gf and his wife, and took up with a married couple. Now it seems they've broken up with him 3 times, maybe for good this third time. Their triad was rocky. The couple were poly noobs and the husband was jealous and tried to make a rule all sex had to be 3ways.

So, there you go, one success, for 2 1/2 years. And his triad lasted 4 months and wasn't smooth sailing.

You may see a lot of "failures" here. But define success! Is it measured in time, or something else, like enhancing your life greatly while it lasts?
 
KC43, how long did your triad last?

It started officially in September 2013; Guy and I were seeing each other before that, but I refused to acknowledge that it had grown beyond friendship until September. It hasn't ended. It just isn't a triad anymore because of the addition of another partner.

I don't know what that would be called, honestly. Hubby, Guy, and S2 are all involved with me and not with each other. (S2 hasn't even met Hubby or Guy.) A quadrad?
 
Keep in mind that most monogamous relationships don't last forever either. Or even if they do last an entire lifetime, that doesn't mean that the people in the couple are happy or fulfilled. Length of time in a relationship is not the same thing as a successful relationship.

I think its good to come to peace with the idea that not all relationships are meant to last forever. It adds a lot of pressure, and in some ways makes relationships something that people continue out of obligation, not because they are actually happy. Just because a relationship has run its course, or changed into a different sort of relationship, does not mean that it has failed.

Lots of poly relationships are going to end at some point, not only because that's just how relationships go, but because it is especially difficult - at leats to begin with. It's REALLY hard learning to love in a different way, and to communicate well, and to act with love. If one couple is having a difficult time, it is so easy for those problems to have a ripple effect on other relationships (ie if my boyfriend is fighting with his wife, it also negatively impacts my relationship with him, and so forth).
 
Oreadne, thank you that is a very valid point :)
 
I was wondering if anyone out there would be happy to share with me a triad success story instead!

I know (IRL) two triads that have each been stable and cohabiting for over 15 (perhaps both closer to 20) years. One triad has young children together, and have always been polyfidelitous. The other triad is child-free by choice, and have opened up some in the past few years.

Each of these triads started with a married couple who were open to and interested in finding a third shared partner. One had this intent from before they were married, the other I'm not sure about. I'm fairly certain both original couples only wanted a third they could both eventually fully commit to as to a spouse, and I don't know if they had many false starts (I don't know of any, and I knew one of the couples through the growth into a triad, and have heard a first-hand history of the other triad that didn't mention failed attempts.)

Their families of origin and peer groups are all aware and supportive. They are all involved in their (various) communities and successful in their professions. They don't seem to do relationship drama - they love and communicate and support each other in shared and individual goals. I love seeing their full and pleasant lives play out, and I have had occasion to envy the wholeness they have. Though I'm pretty happy with the V shape my own family is growing around.
 
SlowPoly thank you! That is exactly the sort of thing I was hoping to hear. :D
 
You're quite welcome.

I'll add that, while I don't consider my vee across two households to be a "triad," it's been developing into a more and more "solid-lined" V (as opposed to dotted-line, with an obvious primary relationship) for about five years. I've loved both Mitch and Woof (separately, and with varying levels of contact and commitment) for over 20 years, so each "arm" love story has its own arc. Success? Well, we're happy and together and growing (separately), so ... I think I'm gonna call success, no matter what happens tomorrow. Longevity is just another objective characteristic of a relationship - not a definitive measure of success.
 
You have to remember also that people come to these forums when they are having issues and in need of advice. The ones who are doing okay have little or no reason to post. :)
 
Last edited:
Lol Bookbug I have realised that, hence why i specifically asked to hear the good things because I decided what I was reading was likely to be biased.
 
I’m not sure how to define ‘successful’. Is it time together? Integration/entanglement of lives?

My partners and I are in a closed triad and have been for 2 years, (we just had our anniversary). We’ve known each other about 12 years, and I knew them individually, before they got together and subsequently married. We were friends for 10 years, spending time doing vanilla-friend things, watching films, hanging out and laughing.

During that time, I fancied the pants off her (she’s gorgeous!) and he ticked all my BDSM boxes. They were looking for someone to play with them both. I was looking for a couple. But I never thought they would be interested in me in that way. He has certain body type preferences and I don’t really fit those. So the subject was never really broached. A good few years back, she & I hooked up for play but it fizzled out. The reason for that was I began to have feelings for her. However, I did not want to be ‘the other partner’. It didn’t feel right to me and it wasn’t the relationship structure I’d wanted since I was 14. It was a very odd feeling. Unbeknown to me, she was having similar deeper feelings for me, but thought when I broke it off I wasn’t interested in her. She jokes that she’s been stalking me for 10 years. (How she and I met is a whole other story!)

Anyway, fast forward about 7 years. We’re still friends, laughing and hanging out. Then one night, during a risqué conversation via facebook status comments, he messaged me and asked me if I would be interested in playing with them both. I joke that he caught me on a good night. I’d been closed off and single for pretty much 10 years (her and I’s brief interlude notwithstanding). He and I talked a lot over a couple of days. I had absolutely no qualms that she was fully aware and involved in the conversation and everything I said to him, she knew and vice versa. I knew them well and their relationship and so I knew there was nothing underhand going on. We negotiated for a few days. I was quite clear that it was a casual play thing, nothing more. They would continue to look for what they wanted in a third and I would continue to look for my dream couple. I put lots of ‘rules’ in about no emotions and that we would remain friends no matter what. I couldn’t afford to lose such good friends. We arranged for me to go up for a weekend.

About 4 months later I realised I had fallen in love with her all over again. I didn’t know what to do about it. The following easter, I realised I had fallen in love with him too (and not for the same reasons). I knew that it wasn’t reciprocated from either of them. I didn’t know what to do. I was a coward and emailed them both (we lived 200 miles apart, it wasn’t a conversation I wanted either of us to drive for, then drive home again). I told them how I felt. I told them I knew they didn’t feel the same, nor did they want the same relationship things I did and so now was a good time to end it.

Long story short, they phoned me (darn that distance), told me they felt the same, wanted to have a relationship with me, and all that entailed and we went from there. We haven’t looked back, except to marvel about where we are now, from casual play.

Earlier this year, while I was looking for new work opportunities, she sent me some adverts for contracts up near them. Somehow, without any real discussion, I got a contract near them and I am pretty much living with them. I retain my house and go home every other weekend, for my family and to give them time alone (which I think is important). We do the usual relationship stuff of planning trips to take together, how we’ll share and spend our lottery win. We are pretty much living together full time and our lives are about as entangled as any other couple. We do have to keep it quiet at work due to the nature of our jobs, but our families and most friends are in the know. I am fumbling my way through living with people again, after so long on my own. But I cannot describe the happy warm feeling in my stomach when I think about them, or when I think about going home to them at night.

We built our relationship on the foundation of being friends, having shared morals and ideologies, shared interests and a deep trust in one another that has developed over time before we got anywhere near sex/play. We also knew, though conversation and seeing each other at events in clubs that our kinks were fairly well aligned/matched. Each couple share things that the third may not and we share a lot as a three. We are very careful to ensure that each couple relationship is nurtured as well as the threeway relationship. We are all deeply invested in one another and our relationship, there is no one ‘going along with it’ for the sake of one of the others. I did fall in love with both of them, but at different times and for different reasons. The relationship I have with each of them has developed at different rates and in different ways. They’re relationship has also changed in subtle ways and they tell me that I am a positive influence ;) but there was no expectation of loving them both the same. We don’t generally ascribe to equality but to balance.

We often wonder why it took us so long to get together because it feels so good and right, and my conclusion is that we were not ready before now. We still had lessons to learn. I don’t find the relationship hard work, but we do consciously work at communication issues – there’s more room for miscommunication, assumptions and misunderstandings when there’s three people all viewing a single set of circumstances!

Not sure that the sort of thing you’re looking for :)
 
I consider what I have to be pretty successful, but who determines what "success" means. I'm in a triad where we all date each other individually, plus as a trio. Me/Husband. Husband/Girlfriend. Me/Girlfriend. All3 together. And we've been doing this over a year - just celebrated our 1 year anniversary this past Friday.

Communication. Honesty. Being fair to others (i tend to have spoiled brat issues). Love. Laughter. Silliness. Cuddles. Sincerity. Generosity. .... All good ingredients to a healthy triad.
 
I have had a few successful V triads, but not any closed (triangle) ones. Then again, I haven't yet been in a situation where everyone was dating everyone, or wanted to.

Is that your question? Are you looking for triangle success stories?
 
There was this nice thread about working triad relationships a few months ago: Closed triad

Many success stories there.
 
Thank you :)

Mignonne yes I guess thats what I'm asking, more the closed triangle triad than a V.

My own new closed triad has gotten off to a pretty nice start so I am hopeful. :D Lol

Nadya thank you for that link. It was a lovely thing to read!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top