Beware of tribal shame

I came across this post on Facebook just now, and thought it might be helpful for people here.

It was on Facebook...
https://facebook.com/GilbertLiz/pho...3952/?type=1&source=48&refid=17&_ft_&__tn__=E

------------------------------------------------------------------------

BEWARE OF TRIBAL SHAME!

". . . I recently came upon the work of one Dr. Mario Martinez, who is a clinical neuropsychologist, and the author of a book called THE MIND-BODY CODE, which you can find [by searching the internet for it].
(You can also listen to a fascinating interview that Dr. Martinez conducted on the SoundsTrue network with Tami Simon, if you download the INSIGHTS AT THE EDGE podcast. A lot of the information in this post comes from that interview, which you can also find [on the internet].

Dr. Martinez has spent his life studying the ways that our thoughts and emotions affect our physical health. He is particularly interested in the harmful ways that SHAME affects the mind and body. And he is especially focused on the powerful and negative effects that TRIBAL SHAMING can have on the human body, and on our emotional lives.

What is tribal shaming, you ask?

OK, here goes:
Walk with me through this…
So...we are all born into a certain tribe, right?
This tribe can be our family, our religion, our neighborhood, our nationality, our culture, etc.
Tribes are important to human beings — in fact, they are essential. There is arguably nothing more vital to the ongoing existence of the human race than the cohesion and protection of a tribe. Our ancestors endured the fight for survival in the ancient world only because they clung together and shared resources. Even today in the modern world, tribes are still absolutely essential. Tribes keep babies alive and old people safe. Tribes care for the sick and the weak. Tribes provide protection, nourishment and warmth to vulnerable individuals (and we are all vulnerable individuals at some point or another)…but most importantly, tribes provide MEANING.

Simply put: Our tribe of origin tells us who we are.
Our tribe tells us what to believe and how to behave.

. . . Maybe as you grew up, those rules continued to make sense to you. If so, then you got lucky. Because then your life’s course is clear — all you need to do is obey your familiar tribal rules (and pass those rules down to your offspring) and everything will be safe and clean and simple.
Or maybe not.

Maybe as you grew older, you found that your own values and morals and standards and aspirations were completely different than those that had been taught to you by your tribe of origin.

. . . SHAME is the most powerful and degrading tool that a tribe has at its disposal. Shame is the nuclear option. Shame is how they keep you in line. Shame is how they let you know that you have abandoned the collective. Violence may be fast and brutal, but shame is slow…but still brutal.

. . . Tribal shaming also sometimes causes people to sabotage their own lives — to abandon their own callings, and to jettison their own true paths, and to forbid themselves to be happy. It is often the case that people simply cannot endure tribal shaming any longer, and so they fail on purpose, in order to be welcomed back into the tribe — in order to “balance things out” again, and in order to become “one of us” once more.

Because here’s the really crazy thing about a tribe, as Dr. Martinez points out: THEY WILL ALWAYS TAKE YOU BACK IF YOU FAIL.

. . . So here’s what people often do — they sabotage themselves, in order to come “home” again.
We make ourselves sick, weak, humbled and broken, in order to be welcomed home.
THAT’S how much we long for the approval of the tribe; we will even ruin our own lives in order to achieve it.
But at what cost?

. . . Dr. Martinez spends a lot of time working with people who have left their tribes of origin, or who have exceeded their tribal expectations, and who appear to have done very well in life, but who are suffering the consequences of “reaching too high” and doing TOO well in life (from their tribal perspective.) His goal is to liberate these people from the prison of shame, so that they can feel contented and easeful about themselves.
He does an exercise with them that I think is AMAZING, and which you can do at home. I did it. It’s pretty transformative.

It goes like this:

Sit quietly in meditation. Allow your mind and your breathing to settle. Then ask yourself this question:
“Who is the person in the world — living or dead — whom I would most need to abandon, in order to live my own true path with happiness and peace?”
It’s a heavy question.

Really think about it.

The answer may shock you. But allow that person’s name to rise up in you mind. Be 100% honest. Be 100% brave . . . there is something that you must say aloud to . . . the IDEA of this person.) Here are the magic words:
“I am going to abandon you now. I am going to betray you now.”


Then comes the next step.
You must now (in your imagination) become the other person — the person who has been shaming you for years. And you must say to yourself (in the voice of the other person) these powerful words: “I completely understand. I forgive you. All I want is for you to be happy.”

. . . Dr. Martinez reports that — after people have done this exercise — their cortisol levels and stress levels drop dramatically, as do their levels of inflammation and disease.

. . . Then comes the next step.

You now have to rebuild what Dr. Martinez calls your own “field of honor”.
You see, tribal shaming works because it attacks your deepest sense of your own honor. Every tribe is governed by its own code of honor, and once you have broken that honor code, the tribe will accuse you (overtly or subtly) of having no honor at all. This accusation is what makes you sick. This is what makes you suffer. Without a code of honor, after all, we are NOTHING — worse than dirt. So you must rebuild your own field of honor, in order to make yourself healthy again.

How do you do this?

You must do an accounting of your own life, and make a list of all the times in your life that you have been honorable . . . Write it all down. Focus on the true history of your own honor — for it is all in there. You are truly an honorable person. Honor is within you.

. . . Once you have done that, the last step is this: RIGHTEOUS ANGER.

. . . You will know that you are standing firmly within your field of honor when your first reaction to attempts at tribal shaming becomes RIGHTEOUS ANGER. You will know that you are on the road to emotional health and recovery when a member of your tribe tries to shame you, and rather than absorb that shame and turn it into sickness and poison…you instead react with RIGHTEOUS ANGER.

Now, a quick word on anger: It is not healthy, obviously, to spend your life feeling furious, or to be constantly simmering with unspoken resentment . . . Righteous anger is a fast, hot fire that burns up the poison of tribal shaming, and protects your own field of honor. This is the anger that rises up like a dragon and says, “Don’t you DARE try to shame me!”

This anger is correct and just and fair….and totally necessary for your health.
You are entitled to it. You must lay claim to it.

You are a person of honor who does not deserve to be shamed.

. . . So learn to get angry, whenever you experience the toxic wrath of tribal shaming.
Be righteous about it.
Strike back.
Defend yourself — from both the living and the dead.
When you can do that…that’s when you will know that you are on your true path at last.
That’s when you will begin to be FREE.
That’s when you will have a chance at happiness and deep, satisfying health . . .

ONWARD,

Elizabeth Gilbert​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for posting that. It was truly powerful. I'm not sure I agree with it completely but I can definitely see how freeing the mental exercise can be. Do you happen to have a link to the blog where it came from?
 
It was very hard for me to leave "the tribe of the church." I had many opportunities to leave over the years, including one particularly golden opportunity where a friend's parents would be willing to adopt me as their own.

I had to realize, many years later, how precious that opportunity was. I had to become appalled by my past decision, before I could seriously start the process of leaving. I had to realize that the church had betrayed me.

Tribal shame held me hostage. Shame made me sick even when I was trying to serve and do good to the church. But tribal fear held me hostage even more. I had to realize that the church had no power to guarantee an afterlife, let alone eternal rewards for tribal loyalty and eternal punishment for sin.

Realizing all this resulted in a lot of anger. It took me a lot of years to get over that anger, and I don't think I was really free until I got over that anger. Now I can finally look on the church and its members with sympathy and compassion, even while being at peace with my own position as an outsider.

My relatives were deeply involved with the church, so leaving meant betraying the family tribe as well as the church tribe. To do this, I had to become (or felt like I had to become) infernally enraged at my parents. I could not forgive them until I felt the full extent of the damage they had (inadvertently) done to me.

I had to (or felt like I had to) betray everything I had ever been loyal to, and start rebuilding my life from the ground up. That was a dark time in my life. I still have guilt and regret over how I treated certain loved ones during that time. Perhaps my method of escape wasn't the easiest method I could have tried. But at least I am grateful now for the tribe that embraces me now: my poly companions, and a handful of friends and family members. And of course, my online poly friends.

Thus and so is the story of my experience with tribal shame.
 
Thanks for the link Journey! I will check that out.

I hear a lot of people in my circles who want to 'build their tribe'. And I understand they mean it positively and are not necessarily talking about the dynamics discussed here. But I always think about anthropological studies of tribes engaged in murderous violence against each other - and, of course, nations are just really, really big imaginary tribes. (Imaginary as in it is impossible to actually know all Americans, for instance, the way one could in a classic tribe. But it is possible to believe and endorse typical American beliefs and thoughts about what an American is.)

I don't really want a tribe. A network is a much better mental image for me.
 
It was very hard for me to leave "the tribe of the church." I had many opportunities to leave over the years, including one particularly golden opportunity where a friend's parents would be willing to adopt me as their own.

I had to realize, many years later, how precious that opportunity was. I had to become appalled by my past decision, before I could seriously start the process of leaving. I had to realize that the church had betrayed me.

Tribal shame held me hostage. Shame made me sick even when I was trying to serve and do good to the church. But tribal fear held me hostage even more. I had to realize that the church had no power to guarantee an afterlife, let alone eternal rewards for tribal loyalty and eternal punishment for sin.

Realizing all this resulted in a lot of anger. It took me a lot of years to get over that anger, and I don't think I was really free until I got over that anger. Now I can finally look on the church and its members with sympathy and compassion, even while being at peace with my own position as an outsider.

My relatives were deeply involved with the church, so leaving meant betraying the family tribe as well as the church tribe. To do this, I had to become (or felt like I had to become) infernally enraged at my parents. I could not forgive them until I felt the full extent of the damage they had (inadvertently) done to me.

I had to (or felt like I had to) betray everything I had ever been loyal to, and start rebuilding my life from the ground up. That was a dark time in my life. I still have guilt and regret over how I treated certain loved ones during that time. Perhaps my method of escape wasn't the easiest method I could have tried. But at least I am grateful now for the tribe that embraces me now: my poly companions, and a handful of friends and family members. And of course, my online poly friends.

Thus and so is the story of my experience with tribal shame.

I became angry and then abandoned them. And it felt good, and it is right for me.
 
Some black holes pull on us so hard I wonder if anger isn't a necessary part of escaping ...
 
I have just left the church, and I guess it depends on the church. I've just had messages of concern as to why I haven't been there recently. If they feel the need to pray for my soul then that's their choice. I will happily still see the people and visit the church building in the week (they have a coffee shop). I just don't want anything to do with 'religion'.

I'm also reminded of a quote which says "No one can make you feel inferior without your permission". I don't give that particular tribe permission to make me feel shame. I'm just following my heart and being true to myself. And if people can't respect that then that's their issue not mine.

However it's a bit different when it comes to my family...
 
Im glad you have made this move.
The poeple who stay your friends after youve left are your true friends.
 
if you don't have permission from the author to repost the text that takes up the first three posts in this thread, then it should only be summarized and not quoted verbatim. Please let me know if you received permission. If not, I will have to redact a large chunk of those posts. In addition, this all sounds like an advertisement for the book and any links allowed to be posted here should be poly related, so I will have to remove the links to the book.

Edit: I merged and redacted the posts, leaving the essentials intact.
 
Last edited:
if you don't have permission from the author to repost the text that takes up the first three posts in this thread, then it should only be summarized and not quoted verbatim. Please let me know if you received permission. If not, I will have to redact a large chunk of those posts. In addition, this all sounds like an advertisement for the book and any links allowed to be posted here should be poly related, so I will have to remove the links to the book.

Edit: I merged and redacted the posts, leaving the essentials intact.

Sorry I only just saw this! I understand and thank you :)
 
Back
Top