A triadic history and a question of compersion (a small tome)

PhoenixStGeorge

New member
It’s been a while since I’ve been on here. I joined back in January/February when my now-nearly-nine-month-long triadic relationship was new and I had never considered myself polyamorous (just playfully open minded, *wink *wink, perhaps generally non-monogamous). I was enjoying what was happening but trying to find context and vocabulary for this new dimension of my world. I still, btw, consider myself non-monogamous but only polyamorous for our GF, not poly by nature.

Back then, I was sorting through the experience of expanding vague ideas into more articulated ideology (i.e. where I stood on sharing, compersion, etc) in order to either feel more comfortable going forward with my new relationship or decide whether evolving the definition of my marriage would ultimately be unhealthy or unwise for us.

Now we’re nine months into our love. I don’t know how to express, especially succinctly, the beauty of the triad we discovered. None of us has been in a poly relationship before. None of us were looking for one. But the draw of the unbelievable personal connections between our three natures, the combination of somehow actually all falling evenly in love with each other, is irresistible to all of us — anything is possible, but I’m not sure a triad like ours could ever happen to any of us again: a perfectly partnered married couple with a girlfriend who so exceptionally meshes with the various natures/interests/desires of each person in the marriage, which affords us what I think is an insanely rare gem of evenness, where not all angles of, well, us are equal but are somehow even.

Of course, the exponential joy requires exponential work. It’s worth it, but we talking about things like the sustainability of the relationship - making sure it’s additive and not detrimental to our lives. Anyone reading this, I’m sure, is familiar with the temptations of amazing intense relationships and their effect on the responsibilities in the rest of our lives. And because none of us were looking for this, there are a lot of unanticipated elements to our lives, whether an evolution/greater understanding of outside open friendships or the creation of the vee that is now my GF’s world, she has us, her couple (who are also separately her BF and her GF—we spend time as three different couples and as a triad) at one end of the vee, and her long-time other-BF on the other end. (So less shaped like a V and more like a molecular structure: a V with a triangle on the end of one leg.)

[Gosh - this is hard to do without pronouns - I’m going to do my best here but if it’s confusing please just say so kindly and I’ll clarify!]

It’s the ‘outside open friendships’ part that brings me back here now. When I was last hanging out here at good ol' polyamory.com/forum, I was wrapping my brain around the concept/articulation of compersion, and exploring the variety of ways poly ‘ships are carried out via writings here— informing myself on the lifestyle potentials based on the existing culture surrounding the ideology, so I could decide for myself if this was something I wanted to pursue. In the process of all of this articulation, we (intended as the triadic we unless otherwise noted) ended up needing to define a long-standing intimate friendship of my husband’s. His longest, actually. Over two decades. They are BFFs. She was his best [wo]man at our wedding. He and I have a history of on/off play with her(BFF) and her husband(BFFhusband). He(mine) has a history of play with BFF, spanning the spectrum of cheating on people with each other to being parts of each other’s open marriages.

[Let me interject - I said we are not self identified as poly people by nature, and by that I mean our default preference is not poly over mono relationship, and here I reference his and my relationship being open. There is an evolution of our(his+mine) path from monogamous to various degrees of open to current poly triad. So there were times he and I did not play with even her(BFF), also there were times BFF+husband were having sex with my husband+1stWife. I too was at times having sex with my husband+1stWife, but that’s mostly just a tasty tidbit and only pertinent here in that I did not come into this with expectations of monogamy.]

Back to the recent (Feb ’16) articulation of this long standing intimate relationship between my husband and his BFF. The articulation was painful in that it happened in waves of personal revelation to myself, my husband, BFF, and GF, all at different times leading to a great deal of “serious conversation” and a fair bit of confusion. To me, it revealed an intimacy that I had not fully realized always existed between them (mine+BFF). I was put off by being so blind for so long about the intimacy of their “I love you.” They had each compromised my trust through actions unrelated to each other, and this was the icing on the cake. My response was not to limit their relationship, but to remove myself from the sexual intimacy of it (sex and sext) entirely, intolerant of even flirting that involved me or was in any way demonstrative in front of me. (They both love me and were instantly sensitized by my reaction to the point they’d assume any given thing was not ok or not welcome, and I appreciated that but also felt overbearing.) This is differentiated from the emotional intimacy that I had previously been ignorant of and was never a part of so separation wasn’t necessary. (I think they also were ignorant of the fact I was never actually a part of said emotional intimacy- not exclusive, just unaware.)

Also, removing myself from the sex balanced things well so that when mine+BFF were together (rare, long distance geography), elsewhere my GF and I were together, no one was on their own. Eventually this all settled into a space where I was no longer attracted to BFF (there is another conversation that could be had about to what degree I was specifically attracted to her vs open to being intimate with her because she was my only female lover for a long time when I didn’t yet identify as bisexual). I knew she wanted in my husband’s pants, my GF’s, mine, all of ours together, any combination she could get her hands on and that put me off along with the original issues of ignorance and blindness. My trust issue with her was unresolved too. My GF was not comfortable with the nature of their(mine+BFF) relationship either which validated my disillusionment and did not inspire compersion.

Now, many months later, my GF is comfy with their (mine+BFF) relationship, based on inclusivity in the intimate details of their relationship (though as yet undecided on whether she’d ever jump into bed with them/all of us), perhaps even compersive but for my lack of it. My husband’s BFF and I have put effort into clear and honest communication to the point she’s grateful even when my honesty is IMO brutal, and I feel there is no ambiguity in our understanding of each other and our boundaries so future ignorance shouldn’t be a problem on either part - we’re on par with casual friends who know a metric ton about each other over more than a decade. My husband and BFF are flirty and probably sext each other to orgasm a couple times a week, besides all the rest of the talking-every-day-about-all-your-news kind of friendship. My husband has decided he won’t be physically intimate with her until/if/when I am completely 100% compressive for him/them, but has made it clear he hopes I’ll get there because he is definitely interested in continuing their sexual relationship in person (when geography allows). And I…… am not compersive. I want to be, and yet am constantly triggered (unpleasant heart racing kind of trigger) by the idea of their intimacy. I want him to have this relationship he’s always had, that is part of the fabric of him, unchanged, and to not be the wife who says no (after a decade of being nuetral-to-welcoming of it). I want to be ok with something I was once ok with. I recognize that nothing has changed, BFF and their relationship is not a threat to me in any way or detrimental to my marriage...

I feel like I need to stop there, at least for now. What comes next is a bunch of conjecture about feelings I haven’t sorted out yet, and you and I don’t know each other, so that’s maybe not stuff I want to dig into here until I’m sure it’s true. I’m interested in perspectives of all sorts — I know I’ve kind of skipped posing any question, and may have left you feeling unfinished (certainly not my reputation:) — I’m thinking someone might respond in a way that helps me language something differently and then I can continue this to fruition in another post…. or something….

Thanks!
Phoe, triadic wife + girlfriend
 
I am sorry you struggle.

I have a hard time with no nicknames so I have taken the liberty of naming them generic names. You change them if you like, ok? I am happy to go with whatever you choose.

I am going to repeat the highlights that I just read. You tell me if I got them wrong, ok? I quote just to visually block it off. Maybe it helps you to sort if you see it written in a different way.

CAST
  • Me
  • My Husband – call him Apple
  • Our GF – call her Banana
  • GF's other BF – call him Berry
  • My Husband's Best Friend – call her Mango
  • Mango's Husband – call him Mushroom

BACKGROUND

  • I am non-monogamous. (open/polysexual)
  • I am only polyamorous for my GF.

  • The triad between (me, my husband, our GF) is 9 mos old at this point.
  • None of us have ever been in a polyamorous relationship of any kind before.
  • She also dates her other BF, Berry.

  • My husband has a female best friend, Mango.
  • We have a history of on/off sex play with Mango and her husband Mushroom.
  • Apple and Mango also have a history of cheating on people with each other.

RECENT PAST

While I was aware that Apple and his best friend Mango had a long sex share history together? I did not know there was also love share between them until Feb 2016. Apple and Mango each compromised my trust separtely in different ways. Finding out in Feb 2016 that they also had secret love share between them was the icing on the cake.

Those things turned me off – the trust betrayal, and not telling that there was also love share here.

I decide to stop sharing (sex/group sex/sexting?) with Apple and Mango. I didn't want them flirting in front of me or involving me in any way.

Removing myself from sex share with (Apple+Mango) ended up balancing things well. When Apple was off with Mango, my GF Banana and I would spend time together. Nobody was on their own.

I am not longer attracted to Mango as a lover. I know Mango wants to get into Apple's pants, Banana's pants, my pants, all of our pants in any combo she can get her hands on. That is another turn off to me.

My GF Banana was not comfortable with (Apple + Mango) behaviors any more than I was at that point in time.

CURRENT CONCERN

Many months later, my GF Banana is now more comfortable with (Apple + Mango). I am not sure if she's more compersive/sympathetic toward them or if she eventually wants to share sex with them.

Mango and I have made efforts into clear and honest communication.
I think we understand each other and our boundaries quite well. So there shouldn't be any future ignorance or crossing lines.

Apple and Mango are flirty and sext.
Apple has decided not to share sex with Mango until/if/when I am totally ok with it.
Apple says he hopes I'll get there because he'd like to continue sex with Mango when the geography allows.

I have made peace with all the drama from before and can live with Mango being around and him flirting/sexting with her.

I want to be ok with them being lovers again, but I am not.

The Apple + Mango relationship is not a threat to me in any way or detrimental to my marriage... but I have a bunch of unsorted feelings still.

I want to know if anyone has experience anything like this before or has persectives to share.

Is that where all this is at?

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
uhYup. Thanks, that's kind of you to do :)

Yes also, to the part in blue, about what I stopped sharing -- all things sexual. And I requested (of both of them) to not be the involuntary object of their fantasies/flirtations/sext.
 
Last edited:
Hi PhoenixStGeorge,

I am wondering if there is any way to separate yourself from the triggers that cause your discomfort about Apple/Mango (your husband and his BFF) having sex. I am also wondering if your trust in Mango is still damaged, it sounds like it is. We can't always dictate our emotions, but sometimes we can make choices that modify our emotional environment. Do you have any such choices you could make?

Just some thoughts,
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Ok. Looks like I get most of the story correct.

Could you be willing to clarify this part of the post?

And I…… am not compersive. I want to be, and yet am constantly triggered (unpleasant heart racing kind of trigger) by the idea of their intimacy. I want him to have this relationship he’s always had, that is part of the fabric of him, unchanged, and to not be the wife who says no (after a decade of being nuetral-to-welcoming of it). I want to be ok with something I was once ok with. I recognize that nothing has changed, BFF and their relationship is not a threat to me in any way or detrimental to my marriage...

Why do you think you have to be ok with them being lovers again?

Something HAS changed. Your limit of tolerance has changed.

Like before... you knew they cheated on others with each other, but maybe thought that was in the past and they weren't pulling anything with you. Only now you found out there were lies of omission and some trust betrayals. You got dinged.

So... maybe you can forgive. But you don't necessarily want to be dinged again.

I'm not hearing where either of them is doing anything to make amends and rebuild trust. Apple's like "Ok, tell me when you are ok with it again because I want to have sex with her as soon as geography allows." And Mango's basically "I want in any of your pants in any combo." That does not sound like either of them taking personal responsibility for the trust breaking behaviors and making amends. That sounds like "Ok, we will humor you for now. Let us know when you are over it."
Or so it seems to me.

Maybe that's why you are hesitant? :confused:

How do you know they simply aren't telling you one thing and doing another? What behavior happened to make them trustworthy to you? How are they working to be in right relationship with you?

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi Kevin,

Thanks for your thoughts.... I wonder if you would elaborate on the idea of separating myself from triggers? I am a week or so into a month of radio silence I requested from both my husband and my girlfriend on any significant conversation about Mango. Our girlfriend had been working through her own questions on the subject, and had recently involved me in some of her process on that, exacerbating my feelings on the subject. I decided if I was going to make any forward progress I needed to not be triggered every few days by something or other, dragging down my baseline.

I am actually a firm believer in the positive effects that can come from consciously manipulating one's own emotional sphere. I'm practiced at it, and have used that kind of perspective to help me in similar situations in the past to great success. That's one of the things that has me here talking to a broader sphere because my usual techniques are not working.

But I will think more on your question of choices...

-Phoe

Hi PhoenixStGeorge,

I am wondering if there is any way to separate yourself from the triggers that cause your discomfort about Apple/Mango (your husband and his BFF) having sex. I am also wondering if your trust in Mango is still damaged, it sounds like it is. We can't always dictate our emotions, but sometimes we can make choices that modify our emotional environment. Do you have any such choices you could make?

Just some thoughts,
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Why do you think you have to be ok with them being lovers again?

I don't think I have to be, but I do want to be. I want to feel fewer negative feelings about this. I want my husband to have something he's always had that is important to him. I want to give him this.

Something HAS changed. Your limit of tolerance has changed.

Like before... you knew they cheated on others with each other, but maybe thought that was in the past and they weren't pulling anything with you. Only now you found out there were lies of omission and some trust betrayals. You got dinged.

So... maybe you can forgive. But you don't necessarily want to be dinged again.

I'm not hearing where either of them is doing anything to make amends and rebuild trust. Apple's like "Ok, tell me when you are ok with it again because I want to have sex with her as soon as geography allows." And Mango's basically "I want in any of your pants in any combo." That does not sound like either of them taking personal responsibility for the trust breaking behaviors and making amends. That sounds like "Ok, we will humor you for now. Let us know when you are over it."
Or so it seems to me.

Maybe that's why you are hesitant? :confused:

How do you know they simply aren't telling you one thing and doing another? What behavior happened to make them trustworthy to you? How are they working to be in right relationship with you?

Galagirl

Hmmm. Well, I see their efforts to be restrained and communicative to be amends for being historically unrestrained and their lack of articulation of intention in the past. I feel pretty strongly that for a long time they weren't either honest with themselves (and consequently each other and me) about their intimacy and/or never had inspiration to articulate it all before recent times so just hadn't done the deep thought on it. Their concept of BFF-meets-FWB worked well for them since they were too young (freshly open in college) to fully appreciate deeper dynamics. Your question makes me wonder if I ponder the concept of amends, either defending what they've done or defining what amends would settle the issue for me, might help me feel good about all this.

I have more reaction but have to go for now....
 
Hi Phoe,

You might want to start by identifying your triggers. What types of events lead to you feeling upset? Presuming you don't want to feel upset, identifying your triggers gives you an idea of what types of events to avoid.

Hope that makes sense.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Your question makes me wonder if I ponder the concept of amends, either defending what they've done or defining what amends would settle the issue for me, might help me feel good about all this.

Maybe it could help. What kinds of amends would you like to see?

Direct Amends -- I don't know what the betrayed trust stuff was, and you don't have to list it here. But if there's direct amends to be made -- they could make them. Repair the car, replace the lost DVD, etc. Fix the physical things that were damaged.

Indirect Amends -- repair damage to non-physical things.

Living Amends -- change how you live to show you have changed (for the better) as a person and won't do that thing anymore (whatever it is).

Like if someone was a chronic liar in the past? Now they have turned over a new leaf. They don't tell lies any more and work on being up front and honest.

You mention this...

Well, I see their efforts to be restrained and communicative to be amends for being historically unrestrained and their lack of articulation of intention in the past.

Sounds like life amends. That could be a start. Maybe after thinking on it you could list what other "make amends" behaviors you would like to request from each one.

Galagirl
 
Back
Top