Unusual conversations

Herringritsgirl

New member
So myself and other gf have been talking
She had balls today to tell me she thought i would be shuffled off to a different bedroom and she would be his primary!
Bf has explained all the poly stuff to her and every aspect she has assumed she is more important than me
He has repeatedly told her no equals
He thought i was misunderstanding her
He explained that to me
I think logically and analyze everything to ensure everything and everyone comprehends
Then she drops that bombshell today
I am pregnant with bf and she has lied and hidden things jealous that i am pregnant
I am confused
Most articles are about primary secondary scenarios
What about co primary???
Like i am chopped liver and technically they have been seeing each other long distance 2 years
He and i co habitated previously 1 year
Then when we got back in touch i am in our room
She is still long distance
Any thoughts or opinions please
 
Any thoughts or opinions please

Polyamory is not a great approach to relationships for people who are possessive, competitive, and jealous (insecure).
 
That sounds exceptionally awkward, painful, and confusing! All I can say is, yes, there are egalitarian relationship structures out there (some which have co-primaries in them) in addition to people who prefer to do a primary/secondary hierarchy thing. I hope you're able to sort this out soon. :(
 
He has made abundantly clear equals
I may use wrong terminology
But
She assumed when he told her i was moving in that it was a weekend fling
Then when we all told her we are pregnant she assumed by another person
Just every aspect she has twisted
And i am confused
And hurt
I understand the entirety of poly and am excited to incorporate her and her kids in all of our home
Now she continues saying that what was explained black and white
I know how he explains himself
Very clear no room for misinterpretation
Yet i am the one she is assuming has to be the "third wheel"
Ty everyone
I want this to work
I invited his other out of town gf over for the night
Going to babysit for her and see if she can help me make sense of all this
Cause right now
I am feeling like she is trying to push me and bun out of the nest.
He has already told her he will not choose between us
I just keep seeing red flags.
He believes the best out of people but with the statement that i was expected to be in a different bedroom goes over like a lead balloon for him
We both thought we had lost a very important live all these years.
And i am not leaving
But wtf is she doing?
He is totally poly
Always has been but had to realize it
And she sounds to me like a spoiled child throwing a tantrum!
 
Hi Herringritsgirl,

It sounds like Other Girlfriend is getting competitive and trying to knock you out of the top spot. That really sucks. Is it Boyfriend's intention to have a co-primary setup, or are you the only primary and Other Girlfriend is the secondary?

I am in a co-primary V. All three of us are considered a primary partner. That of course is what works for us, what works for you is what works for you.

I hope the three of you can get things sorted out.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
He has made abundantly clear equals

She assumed when he told her i was moving in that it was a weekend flingThen when we all told her we are pregnant she assumed by another person
Just every aspect she has twisted
And i am confused


I know how he explains himself
Very clear no room for misinterpretation
Yet i am the one she is assuming has to be the "third wheel"
Im feeling like she is trying to push me and bun out of the nest.

He believes the best out of people but with the statement that i was expected to be in a different bedroom goes over like a lead balloon for him

This Other gf sounds as if she's in big time denial.

Is, or has SHE ever been, polyamorous? Or is your shared partner her only partner and she is monogamous with him?

It's a little bizarre that she'd assume that you were a "weekend fling" since you guys told her you'd be moving in! (Weekend flings do not cohabit - the terms are incongruous.) Just as odd, albeit more understandable, was her assumption - more like wishful thinking - that your pregnancy was the result of a union with someone else.

For whatever reason, she either cannot wrap her head around the idea that:

a.) your shared lover actually loves you and considers you two equal in his heart
b.) the idea of polyamory and sharing the affections of her lover with another
c.) the fact that you're going to have a child with your shared lover, who she clearly sees as "hers" (possessiveness at play here)

As long as you're entirely SURE your boyfriend has not been telling HER a different story behind your back or making agreements with her that you're unaware of... there seems no reason for her not to accept the truth of the situation, unless she has some kind of mental health issue that prevents her from processing the reality of the situation.

As an adult and a mother, she has the right and freedom to make her own choices. If a polyamorous situation does not sit well with her, she needs to bow out of the relationship.

No matter how much good your shared partner tries to see in everyone, he needs to accept that his OSO is not processing this reality well enough and may actually cause both you/bub and herself/children significant stress IF she cannot come to grips with it soon.
 
When you saying moving out of the bedroom, what do you mean?

Who has moved in with whom here? You said they were long distance until now. Are both women simultaneously moving in with one guy?

What do you want? All 3 in one bed(room)? 2 bedrooms and your shared partner splits nights? Your shared partner spends ALL his nights with you, because YOU feel deep down, YOU are the primary (maybe because you're pregnant with his child)?

If bf wants both women in one bed with him, and neither of you wants that, speak up. Ideally there would be 3 bedrooms, or at least 2, and shared bf splits his nights, one with you, one with her. If he has his own bedroom as well, he could also choose to sleep alone one or some nights of the week.
 
Ok
Clarifications
She assumed rather than ask any questions
At this point she has significant other than shared
First poly relationship all around
He made 1000 percent clear he does that with everything in life
She assumed when she moves in that she is top dog all else are beneath her
Since then reiterated and worked thru that aspect
Understands equals
In that same context she has had a hard time accepting me because those are her desires
He and i will be getting married
She is going to accept but will be more to work thru
He and i were together years ago and we were the lost live for each
She assumed a lot of things without researching and totally understanding poly
I shared him previously
Didnt know phrase poly tried to explain to him he wasnt a monogomaus fellow
He just accepted that recently
When we caught back up was like we just picked up where we left off
Due to her never cohabitating with him
I know him like she doesnt at this point
She is coming around to everything poly
But still has some things to learn
I am spending time with her to help ease all her questions and explain things
He sees me daily helping her and her little jealousies and such and falls harder for me
Cute!
Not why i am doing it but bonus
Also being pregnant by bf is why we are getting married
Something we were going to do before
And he has planned this since i got back in touch
I am the only woman who has accepted him and not thought the monogomaus thoughts or implications and encourages him to be himself
 
Move out of the bedroom
That she was only one allowed to sleep in bed with him daily
That i would be the occassional other
She doesnt comprehend all aspects of poly yet
Working on that currently
She is accepting and willing to learn and share
She just needs poly broken down so she understands
She wont research
Why she hasnt moved in yet
Not making extra problems where there is no need to
 
I see plenty of nonmonogamy, precious little polyamory.

There are inconsistencies in your statements. For instance, how is everything going to be "all equal" if you & him marry?

And your situation is still a bit blurry to me. If I have any of the following points incorrect, please clarify:
she lived with him...
you now live with him...
he moved you in with him...
he may or mayn't have given her any notice about this because "she should have just known that's the way he is"...
he also has another "partner" who lives in another city & has kids of her own.

Oh, about that "should have known" thing -- anyone who gets cranky because someone else doesn'tread their mind is essentially saying "I totally SUCK at communication, so kiss my ass, that's YOUR problem."

Someone who sucks at communication will always struggle with polyamory. Someone who refuses to communicate (like denying the responsibility, say) CANNOT BE polyamorous.
 
They never cohabitated
He had a situation when we were together previously and is still desiring to marry me
Yes it will be an equal scenario regardless of my being pregnant
Yes we will get married
She lives out of town
There will be no veto rights either way

Let me check rest of questions!
 
He spells everything out to the letter
Always been like that

Ex
When we told her we are pregnant
She assumed someone else dad
When he told other i am moving in
She assumed weekend fling
Never asking questions or clarification

She takes every conversation as she is primary
Not asking questions

Since then we all have talked and she is starting to get it

She has been unwilling to change her own situation to move in
He has asked her to move in prior to my coming in the picture

She just has serial cheater mono mindset and coming to grips that we are a triad
She is coming around just lots of communication
Being out of town makes it harder for us to all get together due to all involved working long hours
Some things much better talked about in person
 
I'm not sure why you are choosing to do one (incomplete) sentence at a time and not form paragraphs. I find it hard to read.

Edited version:

He spells everything out to the letter, (he has) always been like that. Example: When we told her we are pregnant, she assumed someone else (was the) dad.

When he told (her) I am moving in, she assumed (it was a) weekend fling, never asking questions or (seeking) clarification.

She takes every conversation as(suming) she is primary, and (doesn't ask) questions. Since then we all have talked and she is starting to get it.

She has been unwilling to change her own situation to move in. He has asked her to move in prior to my coming in the picture.

She just has serial cheater mono mindset and coming to grips that we are a triad. She is coming around (after) lots of communication.

(Her) being out of town makes it harder for us to all get together [since all of us work] long hours. Some things (are)much better talked about in person.

OK. So your fiance's OSO doesn't live with him (and you). And now she understands that, even though you and he share a house and a bedroom, even though you are engaged, she will still be a co-primary. So I assume bf will travel to see her as often as possible, despite her being over 2 hour's drive away? I can only imagine that won't be all that often, since you will need help when pregnancy slows you down, and then the new baby will be all-consuming for both of you.

Or maybe you will welcome her into your home with bf on a regular basis, and agree to let him spend nights with her when she is there? Do you have a guest room, AND a room for a nursery?

It sounds like the next thing to discuss, now that she is "getting" polyamory, is how she will fit into your life with husband and new baby. His attention will be split at least 3 ways between wife, gf and infant child. Not to mention work, and more financial pressure if you take time off to be with the baby for some amount of time. Will she resent the baby? Will you resent the time new daddy spends with his OSO instead of with you, when you are sleep deprived and navigating new parenthood?
 
Oh I just saw you post on another thread, you have 3 kids already and bf has 2... Do they all live in the home you now share with bf?? At least part time? Just how big is this house? 5, soon to be 6 kids, and potentially 3 adults? Or does his gf have young kids as well?

How much do the children understand about polyamory?
 
None of the kids reside

He makes time twice a week to ride out and see her
Once a week i ride over and bring her back for the day
She has decided to stay elsewhere because of her own circumstances
She lives with her mom who helps with her kids
I am not concerned whether it stays long distance or she moves in
Either way we will talk our way thru everything all the way around
She will move in our master we are equals!!! He had a bad situation with his middle child where he wasnt married and she left country with the child not being married has made it difficult for him to get any visitation
Both our oldest are over 18
My two middles my ex h has and has made any contact impossible so it will be bf and myself our baby gf and her kids 4 5 bedroom home so things will be fine as for space i hope i answered things better? My adhd makes it difficult to finish a thought before skipping around i apologize for that thank you!!
 
He makes time twice a week to ride out and see her. Once a week I ride over and bring her back for the day.

Wow, that is a LOT of driving. Is she your lover too? If not, it's extremely giving of you to drive a 4 hour round trip every week to bring her to your fiance. On the other hand, maybe you really really like having a "sister wife." (You mention earning Brownie points, so to speak, with your fiance by explaining poly to his other gf.) Can you explain why you are doing this?

You sounded very annoyed with gf just a week ago, and yet here you say you are driving 4 hours round trip while pregnant to bring her to your fiance! Why are you bending over backwards to enable this relationship? Is that really your job?

So your fiance is now gone (nearly) two full days a week to see gf? (Does he have a job?) Does she plan to move into your home before the baby comes? I can't imagine you'd be fine with your baby's father being gone so much. Babies are SO much work.

Rereading the thread, I noticed your fiance also has yet another long distance gf. How will he manage to have healthy romantic relationships with 3 women when one of them is his heavily pregnant wife who will soon present him with a needy infant?

Will you be fine with having so little of his time when you need his help? Or are you kind of ... grooming gf to be a co-parent, to be your helper while bf is working or off having unencumbered fun with his 3rd woman?

She has decided to stay elsewhere because of her own circumstances.

What do you mean, stay elsewhere? You say she lives with her mother and kids, and when she is moved in with you, you've agreed to let her share your master bedroom.

She lives with her mom who helps with her kids.

I am not concerned whether it stays long distance or she moves in. Either way we will talk our way thru everything all the way around.

She will move into our master bedroom. We are equals!!!

Just because you have agreed to be co-primaries, does not mean you need to all 3 share a bedroom and a bed! Does that mean you are attracted to her and will be having sex with her, or with her and your husband as a threeway? Or will you stay out of the bed until he and she are done with the sex and it's time to sleep? And vice versa?

Do you really WANT to share a bed with your fiance's lover, or are you doing it to "be nice" or to prove something? Can't you (plural) all understand you and other gf can both be primaries without sharing a bedroom/bed every night?

Many cohabiting triads do NOT share bedrooms. Especially if it is a V (in your case, the guy has 2 lovers, but the lovers, or arms of the V, do not have sex with each other, because they are not bisexual).

Many cohabiting Vs arrange things so each person has their own bedroom. Or at least the 2 arms of the V does, and then the hinge alternates nights with each arm. Especially if all three are heterosexual and not sharing sex.

Everyone needs some space and me-time sometimes. Sometimes too much togetherness ends up with everyone feeling crowded and getting snippy with each other.

In your case, you seem to be saying you will have 3 adults in one bed, as well as a newborn baby, waking up all through the night... Myself, I breastfed and shared a bed with my babies and their father. I am not sure how a newborn fits into this scenario of 3 adults in a bed all night every night. I can't even imagine it without a baby! I'd feel crowded even in a king bed.

He had a bad situation with his middle child where he wasn't married and she left the country with the child. Not being married has made it difficult for him to get any visitation. Both our oldest are over 18. My two middles my ex h has, and has made any contact impossible. So it will be bf and myself, our baby, gf and her kids. 4-5 bedroom home; so things will be fine as for space.

I hope I answered things better? My ADHD makes it difficult to finish a thought before skipping around. I apologize for that.

Thank you!!

No problem! Thanks for explaining.

So gf has a few kids. Do they understand their mom is going to be sharing a house, bedroom, bed, with their mom's bf and another woman, his wife? Are you OK with them "outing" you to friends or family? Little kids sometimes blab stuff to their friends, friends' parents, or to their teachers. Older kids sometimes don't understand polyamory, and find it gross or threatening. Blending families is usually difficult even without adding polyamory into the mix.

Just some things to think about...
 
I am bi curious?
Not exactly sure how much at this point

1 out of town we travel to or she comes and stays the night more tertiary bi
The other main we are working through all the logistics currently
She is getting used to the poly fam we desire thus why i am doing all i can to help the transition
She had numerous misconceptions and he and i have spent about 4 months getting things worked thru
Yes it is his desire to share bed i am fine with this
We have already started "breaking in" our friends
Mostly they look uncomfortable or jealous that we are making things work! I have no problems giving time or space as needed for intimate times but it truly is his desires to have us all share everything
He is beyond ecstatic about our child and already claiming night duty!! Yes he works i work and so do both others just coordinating which i have been assisting with! It truly is a sister wife scenario
If she cant handle things then we have already talked thru this as well if it is meant to be it will work itself out
If she keeps feeling uncomfortable then things will terminate
Those are his desires to be able to have his sos co habitate and everyone raise our family anyone who cant handle doesnt have space in our schedule ideally a triad where most things are done together go out to eat etc together
 
The reason i am spending time with her and trying to explain and assist is simple
I love him
I want his happiness her happiness
I have compersion and an empath so when things are not going well it affects me i want what he wants as well as inderstanding i dont fill every aspect of him
And will do everything in my power to help us achieve our goals of one big poly fam
I truly appreciate the feedback
And yes she has gotten me annoyed due to her own lack of researching and paying attention while he has explained these things to her
Her answers have mainly been me issues not we
And that has been frustrating as well she shows a different side to him than me i want to add to everyone not be a thorn in the side i want everyones happiness
A happy polycule that works
 
Again, I am going to edit a bit to make sure I understand your thoughts and wishes and plans, OK?

I am bi curious? Not exactly sure how much at this point. More tertiary bi.

I am bisexual, but I have never heard the term "tertiary bi." What do you mean by that? Is there any spark of mutual attraction between the 2 women, or are you going to sort of force yourself to have sex with her to fulfill a fantasy of your boyfriend's?


1 out of town [trip], we travel to [her] or she comes and stays the night.

So, there is one meeting with her per week right now? And when you travel, you and your fiance both go together to see her at her mother's?

What happens when she spends the night now? Who sleeps where?

The other main [thing] is, we are working through all the logistics currently. She is getting used to the poly family we desire. This is why I am doing all I can to help the transition. She had numerous misconceptions, and he and I have spent about 4 months getting things worked thru.

Yes it is his desire to share [one] bed. I am fine with this.

And you are doing everything you can to convince her to do this.

We have already started "breaking in" our friends. Mostly they look uncomfortable or jealous that we are making things work!

I have no problems giving time or space as needed for intimate times, but it truly is his desire to have us all share everything.

We can speak frankly here. I think you are implying, your fiance is determined to have threeway sex with both of you. You are bi-curious and willing to try. Is gf also bisexual or bi-curious? If you are all on the same page, I see no problem, as long as it is something both women really want, and you're not just doing it to please bf. But maybe this should be tried before the gf has torn up her roots, to move in with you two, with her children and all?

Is there any spark of mutual attraction between you and the other woman, or are you both planning to "share the bed" all night every night, including sharing sex, merely to please the bf? Or maybe you think there won't be touching between the women, but you both just focusing on the man?

If it's awkward and unfulfilling for you to have sex with another woman, even if there is no lesbianic touching between you, things could get very uncomfortable. In my opinion, doing it just to please the man is not a great idea. Everyone's needs and desires and feelings need to be taken into account.

What is Plan B, if sharing threeway sex and sharing sleep every night doesn't work out? Is the plan of separate bedrooms for each woman an option?

You could sleep in the guest room when you are hugely pregnant and uncomfortable in bed, and later after the baby comes. There will be times you will not be interested in having sex, or in watching them have sex, or in sitting up in the living room until they are done having sex, etc. In fact, for the first 6 weeks after the birth, while she is recovering, a new mother is not supposed to have sex. You've already had 4 kids. You know this. By the way, if you already have had 2 kids who are over 18, this pregnancy must be coming to you in your 40s? It is more taxing to have a baby at this age.

Alternatively, even without the baby in the equation, there will be times either gf or bf are not in the mood for sex. Someone may be tired, or ill, or in a bad mood, or distracted by other things (work, issues with the older kids, etc.), mad at one or the other of the partners, or just not feeling horny. The option of sleeping elsewhere should be on the table.

There are 3 dyads here, not just a triad.

You + bf
Gf + bf
You + gf

Plus bf has yet another gf.

All dyads need care and nurturing. This takes time. And one on one time. Sometimes a couple needs privacy.

He is beyond ecstatic about our child and already claiming night duty!!

So you do not plan to breastfeed? He will do all feedings at night and still get to work OK? Maybe there can be a bed in the nursery for whoever is doing "night duty," be it you, the husband or maybe even the gf?

Yes he works, I work, and so do both others.

Are you going back to work as soon after the birth as possible? If gf moves the 2+ hours to start living with you, she will need to look for work. Her kids will have to get used to new schools, new friends.

Your fiance is a very busy man. It's funny how most polyamorous men here say they have a hard time finding more than one woman to be with, and your bf has 3.

Speaking of his 3 gfs, he still has that third woman to maintain a relationship with... So he won't even be home every night to share a bed with his 2 "sister wives."

Just coordinating, which I have been assisting with! It truly is a sister wife scenario. If she can't handle things, then we have already talked thru this as well. If it is meant to be, it will work itself out. If she keeps feeling uncomfortable then things will terminate.

Things will terminate! That means if this gf can't handle living with her bf and his wife, sharing sex with him and wife (if she is not bisexual "enough," or kinky "enough"), sharing a bed every night, sharing parenting a newborn not her own, your bf will break up with her, and she will have to haul herself and her kids back to her mother's house?

What if you can't "handle things"? What if she likes the 3 in the bed thing, but you don't? Will your fiance/bf/husband be displeased with you? Will things with you be terminated? It seems you and bf were together before, and broke up before. What if that happens again, and now with a newborn baby in the mix? Where would you go?

Or is there some other solution, such as I keep suggesting, not having a triad where all three are sexually and romantically involved, but a V arrangement, where the man is sexual and romantic with both women, but the women are just friends? Would bf be OK with that? Or is he really invested in the threeway sex thing? It sounds like he is:

Those are his desires: to be able to have his SOs cohabitate, and everyone raise our family. Ideally a triad where most things are done together, go out to eat, etc., together.

And sleep together...

That is a nice fantasy. It is the most common sexual fantasy of the male. Both you women seem to be bending over backwards to make your bf's dream a reality.

Anyone who can't handle [this] doesn't have space in our schedule.

Are you referring to other (platonic) friends, or to the other girlfriend, who will be "terminated" if she doesn't live up to the ideal of constant togetherness?

The reason I am spending time with her and trying to explain and assist is simple: I love him, I want his happiness [and] her happiness.

And I suppose you will do anything to assure their happiness, and their happiness will be your own. All you desire is to serve your bf. It sounds like a Mormon sister wife scenario, or perhaps a Dom/sub thing?

I have compersion. [I am] an empath, so when things are not going well it affects me. I want what he wants. [Also], I understand I don't [ful]fill every aspect of him. And will do everything in my power to help us achieve our goals of one big poly family.

And yes she has gotten me annoyed, due to her own lack of researching and paying attention while he has explained these things to her.

You have said you have ADHD. Do both women have a hard time paying attention sometimes? Do you have trouble coordinating your thoughts?

Her answers have mainly been "me" issues, not "we" [issues].

I think that is understandable and practical of her! She is being required to lay a lot on the line. Her life, her children's lives. She is being asked to take a huge leap of faith, to throw in with her bf with his threeway desires. You are a stranger to her, and it sounds like she is undergoing a lot of pressure from the two of you to conform to a very specific lifestyle. You claim to be empathic, but I don't think you feel her fears.

And that has been frustrating as well. She shows a different side to him than me.

What are the two "sides" she shows? Is it so surprising she tells each of you different things? The guy is her lover. For all she knew, a couple weeks ago, she was his primary and you were some "side chick." She is probably still in shock.

I want to add to everyone, not be a thorn in their side.

But you are a thorn in her side, pressuring her to enter into a triad when that was not her expectation for what she had going on with her bf.

I want everyone's happiness: a happy polycule that works.

If this "polycule" of a triad doesn't work, what is plan B? (Separate bedrooms and no shared bed/sex? A V, not a triad?) Plan C? (Termination of her?) Plan D? (Termination of you?)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top