Advice Needed On Quad Relationship

1of4

New member
I need some help and advice defining exactly what it is that is going on in my head and my heart. Too often I feel like I'm just this chaotic jumble of emotion, and other perspectives are really helpful to me in sorting that out. I suspect that I need to make some modifications in how I handle things--in other words, there is an opportunity here for personal growth. But also, I need to communicate better within my "poly group" and to do that clearly, I want to get clearer in my own head about what it is I want to communicate.

I've posted before, but briefly, I am a part of a quad made up of two married couple.

My husband Jay and I (Em) - in our mid/late 40s, married very young 25+ years ago

The other couple is L (him) and K (her) - mid 40s, married 15+ years

Our quad just celebrated 3 years together. The relationship began as what we intended to just be experimentation with swinging. But we fell for each other very quickly and have been exclusive since we met.

While we've had some experimentation with F/F, same room, and group sex, none of that has happened for well over a year now. These days we tend to break into two separate M/F groups and seek privacy. The two men get along well, but aren't best friends. They don't have much in common and their interaction with each other is more like brothers. The same with K and I. We get along well, kind of like sisters, but in other circumstances we would never be best friends. That said, the 4 of us together are awesome and we have so much fun together - traveling together and all sorts of recreational activities.

We live 1.5 hours away from each other. We've tried multiple times to move closer and came very close to making that a reality last summer, but it didn't ultimately work out. My husband and I are finally (this week, actually) moving to a home 50 minutes from them. Still not as close as we would all like, but closer. We usually manage to see each other at least one or two days each week, and usually with one or two overnights per week.

Our dynamics:

Jay and I are going through a bit of a rocky period in our marriage. We both love each other very much but are having trouble keeping the "spark" alive and now that we are empty-nesters without the daily parenting concerns, are beginning to recognize and acknowledge that we have very different interests and approaches to life. This is a bit hard for us because we have always been very close and done everything together. We won't split up. We agree on that. We love each other deeply. But we are trying to negotiate and work out some sort of arrangement that will satisfy us both while still keeping the door open to at least try to get that intimate spark back.

L and I - We have so much in common and an incredible emotional, spiritual, and sexual connection. We talk daily, numerous times and throughout the day. The NRE finally mellowed (good thing, because it consumed us for a while) but it took a couple of years, and we have been left with this very close, very passionate, very loving relationship. We have very similar approaches to life and many of the same interests.

L and K - Their marriage is quite different from mine and Jay's. They get along well, love each other, are great parents together...but they each are very comfortable with their individuality. They enjoy their time together but have no problem doing things separately either. I've rarely seen any jealousy or insecurity on either of their parts in regards to the other.

Jay and K - They care about each other and have fun together. Lately, outside of our time together as a quad, they usually talk once a week. They had intense NRE for a while too, but that cooled and they were left with what appears to me to be more of a close friendship/casual dating relationship rather than the intense passionate relationship that L and I have. In my opinion, they aren't really compatible together to have more than that casual relationship.

My current anxiety:

I fear that things are really cooling between Jay and K. They talk infrequently and neither one of them seems to have much sexual interest in the other anymore (honestly, Jay's libido in general seems to be gone, so there may be something else going on too). Meanwhile, my relationship with L is still intensely passionate. I can't imagine NOT having him in my life and he tells me he feels the same about me.

I have other personal and professional interests that take up my time during the week, but I LOVE the time we all spend together one or two days each week and I don't want to give that up. But it is starting to seem more and more that Jay and K have "other things" to do and it is starting to seem like they would rather be doing those other things than spending the time together. And this is beginning to be a source of tension because too often L and I end up being the schemers and the planners and maybe even manipulating things a bit, so that we still get our time together.

Meanwhile, I'm starting to get more and more anxious and insecure about the above scenario and I'm scared that somehow L an I are going to get ripped apart against our will. The end result: I am becoming a manipulative person when it comes to Jay and K and a whiny, needy person when it comes to L, and I don't like ANY of that. That is NOT the person I want to be.

Jay and I have had long talks and he knows how I feel about L. I have always been very honest with him. After a recent episode with L in which all sorts of unattractive insecurities (on my part) came out, I've asked him to make some time for he and I to talk about all this too. I've also said that I really think the 4 of us should sit down and have a heart-to-heart conversation about where things are and where they are going.

One of the problems is that Jay and K aren't really acknowledging any of the cooling between them. They are just kind of going with the flow and neither seems too worried or concerned by it. So I don't really know that it is my place to verbally call them out on it. But it really affects L and I and our relationship, so maybe it is??

The other big problem is this: given the quad formation of our group, if that quad breaks down, is there any hope? Or is it inevitable that L and I would have to split up? If not, how would we structure things and how would that work?

Bottom line: I've asked for time to talk all this through, but I don't even know how to approach it and what, if anything, to ask for that would help ease my anxiety and insecurity.

Ugh. Help me sort this out?? I'm open to criticism, perspective, suggestions, whatever.
 
I can see how the apparent change in dynamic would be unsettling given the fact that you have all been working in concert. That said, if J and K's relationship has run its course why would it automatically mean that you and L would have to abdicate your relationship? Couldn't the dynamic change? You could be the hinge between J and L.

If I were you, I would simply point out that you and L still like the frequency of getting together that you all originally established, however, that J and K do not seem to require the same consistency of contact. And that while you have no desire to tell them how they should run their relationship, given that you have all always done things together, their...., nonchalance about getting together is preventing you and L from having time together.

And seriously, your respective partners would have to be exceptionally unfeeling to ask you two to give each other up just because their relationship has run its course.
 
And seriously, your respective partners would have to be exceptionally unfeeling to ask you two to give each other up just because their relationship has run its course.

You mean like 90% of poly, or "poly," couples out there that think they can terminate their partner's relationships if theirs fails? Especially in cases of quads formed with two existing couples.

That happens all the time.
 
You mean like 90% of poly, or "poly," couples out there that think they can terminate their partner's relationships if theirs fails? Especially in cases of quads formed with two existing couples.

That happens all the time.

Nobody is saying it doesn't happen. My point is that it doesn't have to happen. Do you have anything constructive to offer the OP?
 
Last edited:
Nobody is saying it doesn't happen. My point is that it doesn't have to happen. Do you have anything constructive to offer the OP?

With quads? No, I don't offer advice in those cases. Just saying, you needn't make her feel like her partner is the only "exceptionally unfeeling" person out there that would consider making her end a secondary relationship. It's an incredibly common scenario.

He could just be one of the normal guys out there.
 
Jay isn't unfeeling at all. He loves me and cares about my happiness and I actually have no doubt that he and I could negotiate some sort of agreement so that L and I could continue our relationship. But I do think that would be very hard for him. He has a far more conservative and traditional worldview than I have. And I don't really know what K and L would decide. They are the ones who still have young children and have the most at risk professionally if we were ever exposed.

We are probably one of those "poly" groups you are referring to PolyinPractice. None of us planned this or even expected it. We just started spending more and more time together and it happened organically. We've all met periodically to check in with each other and adjust boundaries and rules as we got more comfortable. But we've NEVER had a talk as a group about the individual bonds that were forming between the alternate couples and what that would mean/how we would handle it if something like this started to happen. I guess I wonder if it is even fair of me to hope my relationship with L could continue independently? Is that fair to Jay or to K? I do love them both and don't want to hurt either one of them. Ugh. This is all so confusing and complicated.
 
With quads? No, I don't offer advice in those cases. Just saying, you needn't make her feel like her partner is the only "exceptionally unfeeling" person out there that would consider making her end a secondary relationship. It's an incredibly common scenario.

He could just be one of the normal guys out there.

I never said the OPs partner was unfeeling. Sheesh!

That said, there are a lot of partners that issue ultimatums, and at that moment in time, they are not caring about their partner's feeling for the other partner and what it would mean to have them ripped from their lives.

I do not get the impression that is the case with the OP's relationship with her husband.
 
While you will get a multitude of opinions and perspectives here and some sound... and some not so sound... advice...

The best thing you can do for yourself and your quad is get together and talk about your fears and your assumptions. Nothing... no amount of advice here or any amount of fretting you do silently.. will give you the peace you seek until you sit down with your partners, share your feelings and fears and talk it out with them.

It's not fun, it's not sexy but it is what makes relationships of all kinds work best... communication.
 
Honestly, reading your account, it sounds as though you are more worried (anxious) about the potential outcomes than the other members of the quad.

Your original dynamic evolved organically, could not a new dynamic evolve organically as well?

If Jay and K are satisfied with whatever level of relationship that they have together, then...let them be satisfied?

If L and K are "very comfortable with their individuality" - then perhaps they are also comfortable with the fact that their "outside" relationships don't need to be at the same level?

If K and Jay often have other things to do during "all together" times - can they not do those "other things" (perhaps hobbies or ... seeing other people?) and you get together with L alone? or is that against "the rules" - in which case, perhaps those rules could be re-addressed?

Relationships and feelings can not be forced to fit into careful arrangements just because that would be "easier". People feel what they feel and relationships are what they are...
 
Everyone needs to consider the group dynamics of a closed quad. IMO that's what is at play in this post.

When all the relationships are healthy and happy it's truly magical and blissful. But when someone is unhappy, off or if things not quite equal (ie. passionate relationship vs a causal one) it tends to effect everyone. The others are left not knowing how to act or what to say. mmkeekah said communication is the key and she is absolutely right. Get to the root of the problem (if there is one) as quickly as possible.

I am in exactly the same situation as the OP... I am part of closed quad. 95% of the time things are "wonderful". However, the remaining 5%... well you know :)

~S
 
Last edited:
Back
Top