Am I being unfair?

Storiwyr

New member
My husband and I have been married for almost six years. From the very beginning of the relationship, we'd talked about not being monogamous. The type of open relationship we've lead has morphed over time. Initially, we didn't look for anyone else, and we worked exclusively on our own relationship. I think we'd both agree that our ideal relationship format would be as a triad. Going into the relationship, I was the one who identified as Poly. He'd never really thought about it before, but was open to it.

With time, we've both gotten more comfortable with the idea that it doesn't have to be a mutual relationship for both of us. That each of us should be able to have partners outside the relationship if we want.

There's some things at play on my end, for sure. First, I have some serious self-esteem/confidence issues. I'm aware of them, and I've been working steadily on them with great improvements. Essentially these are of the "If he finds someone else, he'll love her more than me, and leave me" variety. I'm aware these thoughts aren't rational, but I've always had them, and we've both held off on outside relationships while I was working on these issues. Second, I was brought up in a very oppressive religion, and though I stopped attending over a decade ago, it did a lot of damage to my sexuality in terms of how comfortable I am around sex in general. It really, really sucks to love sex, to be kinky, to be a masochist, and yet to feel intense guilt after sex, and be extremely jumpy during the initiation of intimacy until I reach the point of 'too turned on to care'. Neither of these things was ever good for our sex life.

About two years ago, things took a really terrible shift in our marriage. My husband had a mental break of some kind. Out of the blue, he told me he wasn't happy. The way he phrased it, and my mental state at the time, made me feel like all of it was my fault and I'd messed up, and I made some serious changes in my behavior to try and make him happy. This really pulled the rug out from under me, though, and a lot of my work on my self-confidence was completely destroyed. A few months later, my husband said he was feeling better, and he loved me, didn't want me to worry, we'd be fine, etc. etc. Just a month after that, there was a night when he was sitting in bed on his computer, chatting with someone else--this had been happening basically every night for weeks, and I was starting to feel really neglected. He'd been complaining about our anemic sex life, and it was frustrating to feel like he was complaining about this when he wasn't giving us space to work on it. I was upset, and not quite ready to talk about it yet--I left the bedroom to go down and sit on the couch and think. When I came back, he was asleep. The next day when I got home from work and asked to talk to him about it, he asked for a divorce.

To make an already long story marginally shorter, he moved out of the bedroom. We stayed together. He said he didn't mean it and he wanted to work on things. Then he essentially ignored me for a year. I mean, really, really ignored me. Stayed in the other bedroom, sometimes didn't even come out to say hello to me when I got home from work, etc. During this time, he was working very part time and neglecting to turn in his hours, so he was making no money. I was working full time and supporting us both. It felt very much like the only reason he was saying he wanted to stay with me was because he couldn't financially support himself--without me, he'd be homeless. He doesn't have and has never had any close friends, and his family doesn't have the financial means to support him. During this time from hell, I caught him webcamming with another woman. This was a direct violation of the agreement we had--which was that if either of us wanted another partner, it needed to be a conversation with the other person.

There's some serious health and mental illness issues going on for him. He is seeing a therapist, a psychiatrist, and a neurologist (for his narcolepsy). About six months ago, I found out that he'd had a nearly obsessive friendship with someone going on, and she was taking up all of his time, essentially. As far as I know, it wasn't anything more than a friendship. She pulled away from him, and essentially started treating him exactly the same way he'd been treating me for a year. And that's when our relationship started to get better again. We actually spend time together now, playing video games, watching TV, working on the apartment, etc. The thing is that what we have right now is sort of like a friendship, and not even a close one at the moment. He rarely hugs me, we don't have deep conversations. I am desperately, horribly lonely for both emotional support and physical touch. I want to be able to see other people outside our marriage--that would be the case even if things were good between us, but it's especially the case now. I want to have friends, and potentially partners.

My husband is absolutely the gatekeeper on our lack of intimacy. We aren't intimate because he doesn't want to be. I'm willing, he is not ready. I have been working on my self-worth again, dealing with my own depression, and trying to improve my life and take responsibility for my own happiness. As part of this, I'm working on making some new friends, and finding community to spend time with. I am the sort who doesn't deal in absolutes, and with my familiarity with guilt (thanks, religion!) I like to have all the lines down from the very beginning so I know what the expectations and boundaries are. I have been specifically seeking friends who are poly. This is not necessarily because I want to have a romantic relationship with someone else right away, but more because I want to be around people I can be completely honest with. I also wanted to talk to my husband, though, readdress our limits/agreement and make sure I understood how he was feeling, just in case romantic feelings should arise in a new friendship.

He said he thought it was only fair if we had the same rules. I agree, but I feel like it would be extremely unfair to me for him to have other romantic partners right now. He is not romantic with me, and I am his primary partner. If he can't be intimate with me, but he wants to be intimate with someone else, I feel like that says something really not good about our 'relationship'. He thinks this is unfair, and I'm at a loss. Am I wrong to feel like, as his primary, he should be working on building an actual relationship with me before he builds with anyone else? Whereas, on my side, I am ready and able and trying to build and he is actively keeping me in pause because he doesn't feel ready. This is all really academic at this point, because he's not got any friends. But it would really bother me if I found out he was out trying to find a romantic relationship with someone else, under our current circumstances. At the same time, I feel like (given that I am willing and able to give any and all my energy to building our relationship, but he is not because he's working on his own health right now) I should be able to pursue whatever comes my way.

If our relationship were good right now, I'd have no issues with him seeing other people. But it's not good, and the ball is in his court and has been for months and months. I'm suppressing a lot of myself to meet his needs, and I cannot do that indefinitely.

He talks about things now like he plans on staying with me for the long haul. That said, I cannot stay in this marriage if I'm not allowed to get my needs met anywhere else, and he won't even touch me. I also don't feel like it's fair to hold it over his head that either he gets intimate with me soon, he lets me get intimate with someone else if I want to, or we get a divorce. I don't want to divorce him, I love him, but I deserve to feel loved in return and I want to be able to live a life, rather than waiting and waiting and waiting on the off chance that he eventually wants to be in a romantic relationship with me again.

I'm very confused and extremely lonely. I really hate that my first post here is a plea for help, but I really don't know where else to turn. I would love to talk to my therapist, but she's not versed in Poly relationships and issues even though she is supportive.
 
I am sorry you struggle. To me this isn't really about polyamory. This is about a dead/dying marriage because the spouse checked out long ago.

If our relationship were good right now, I'd have no issues with him seeing other people. But it's not good, and the ball is in his court and has been for months and months. I'm suppressing a lot of myself to meet his needs, and I cannot do that indefinitely.

I think you have waited long enough. You sound done. You could move on and be free of waiting around for him to want you again. He doesn't. Whether you choose to poly-date after that is up to you but the main issue seems to be dealing with this unhappy marriage.

What I got as highlights from your story?

  • He asked for a divorce.
  • He said he changed his mind and wants to work on things.
    • You think he only changed his mind about the divorce because he cannot support himself.

Did he actually work on things with you? Nope.
  • He moved out of the bedroom and ignored you for a year.
  • He is not interested in a sexual relationship with you any more.
  • He's only kinda friendly after the other online woman disappeared. Like he's making do with you cuz you live there and are handy, rather than wanting to be with you for you.
  • You caught him webcamming. Which is cheating on agreements.
  • He doesn't want to date you, but he also doesn't want you dating other people.
  • Even if you DID date other people to make dealing with your checked out spouse easier? The problem is still there -- you have a checked out spouse.
  • He wants to you stay in the marriage for what? To support him financially and that's about it? You don't seem to get much back out of it.

I just don't see how that offer is awesome for you. :(

I also don't feel like it's fair to hold it over his head that either he gets intimate with me soon, he lets me get intimate with someone else if I want to, or we get a divorce. I don't want to divorce him, I love him, but I deserve to feel loved in return and I want to be able to live a life, rather than waiting and waiting and waiting on the off chance that he eventually wants to be in a romantic relationship with me again.

It's is fair to state what you need to be willing to continue to participate in the marriage. If he's checked out and not participating or working on things? It IS fair for you to decide to seek a divorce. You could divorce with regrets. It's ok to love him but end it anyway because he no longer participates and does not hold up his end of the marriage stick. The marriage has ground to a halt.

You DO deserve to feel loved and live your life and not be "on hold" forever.

I would love to talk to my therapist, but she's not versed in Poly relationships and issues even though she is supportive.

This is about dealing with a spouse who has basically checked out, and has no interest in keeping the marriage healthy. Not so much about poly.
You could talk to your therapist about dealing with an uninterested spouse, prepare to make a clean break , and then move on.

If you want to talk about poly things with your therapist later? You could give your therapist this or seek a poly therapist at THAT point in time.

But the core issue TODAY is about the state of the marriage and you seem to recognize that.

  • The marriage is not not good. The ball is in his court and has been for months and months. He's not doing anything with the ball.
  • You think you are being used financially.
  • He cheated on agreements / does not hold up his end of the marriage stick.
  • You are suppressing a lot of yourself to meet his needs, and going without yourself. You cannot do that indefinitely.

Conclusion? I think...

  • You could stop waiting.
  • You could take action and take the ball back in to YOUR court. You gave him ample opportunity to do something with it and he has not.
  • You could consider ending the marriage because you are unhappy here.

The one keeping your life on hold is not him -- you are the one doing that. If you are no longer happy waiting around on him? You could stop waiting around.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
... and I am his primary partner.
Are you, or are you his housemate? You're married, but it doesn't sound like you are partners. Thinking about your situation in poly relationship terms doesn't help if you're not even in a relationship with him.
 
Last edited:
I agree with GG. If you leave off the first 2 or 3 short paragraphs, this isn't about polyamory. This is about a marriage gone bad, a husband who is checked out, and just using you for your paycheck.

I'd recommend stop sleeping together again. Tell your therapist what you said here, heck, read it to them. It's not about poly at all. Get their advice, but it will be similar to GG's.

Get out of this dead end relationship. Rebuild your life as a single woman. Work on your issues around sex/kink/guilt. Keep building things with your poly friends, and find a nice single or poly guy (or gal if you're into that), and start over. You deserve better.
 
"Relationship broken, add people" never works. Polyamory will not fix your broken marriage.

Just because you love someone doesn't mean the relationship is worth staying in. Love is not enough for a marriage and partnership to be healthy, nurturing, and joyful. You need more and it seems obvious that you ain't gonna get what you need from your husband. Why do you want to hang on so tightly to something that is so clearly dead? If you divorce him, you can stay friends and play video games together after that, but at least you won't be constantly hoping and wishing the man you live with would live up to being a true partner to you.

I say you need to be brave and leave this man so you can have the life you want. It isn't easy, I know, but it would seem the necessary thing to do, in your case. You deserve a life and people in it who support you being the vibrant, loving, sexual person you are. Financially supporting an immature man-child who gives back next to nothing in return does you absolutely no good.
 
Last edited:
Hi Storiwyr,

I think I understand your reasoning. You are willing to work on the marriage but your husband is unwilling, so, you should get to seek poly relationships and he doesn't deserve that privilege. And maybe you are hoping someone here will know words you could say to your husband that would convince him to adhere to your reasoning, or that would convince him to start working on the marriage. I'm sorry to say that I don't know of any words that could do that, and, I'm doubtful that any others know of such words but I could be wrong.

For the most part, I agree with what the others are saying. This man is using you for your paycheck. You'd be better off without him. You can still love him without being married to him. And then you'd have the freedom to pursue better partners.

Whatever you decide to do, I'll still try to help if I can. Keep us posted as your situation evolves; we might be able to think of additional advice.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Well, welcome anyway, but...

I would love to talk to my therapist, but she's not versed in Poly relationships and issues even though she is supportive.
FWIW: before there was such a thing as a "poly-friendly therapist," I had pretty good luck at random. The best was a clinical psychologist working as a family therapist, assigned by our HMO; maybe late 30s, patient listener, & not quick to take sides.

One therapist I had was very experienced with gay relating (in Minneapolis of the time, this often involved emotion-bonded couples who were sexually open); she tried her best, but the penny didn't drop for her.

The LSW (licensed social worker) was clearly baffled by the multiple-relating thing, yet caught on quickly, & gave me some stark insights into a self-sabotage tendency I'd accidentally developed that was poisoning my relationships.

I'd bet that if your therapist has any range of experience, she'll be able to step back & examine the dynamic you've got going with your husband. I mean, it sounds like he's got any number of things going on, maybe OCD, maybe ADD, maybe depressive bipolar -- that's HIS stuff, of course, but it affects YOU on a minute-to-minute basis, & it certainly sounds like there's a lot of cleanup to do.

And of course there's plenty to work on with YOU, right? being the enabler & all? If she's not up to it, then for your own sake you need to find a therapist that's more useful.

But if you're feeling abandoned in your marriage, then "the solution" is NOT to "go poly." That's you speaking as The Enabler. :eek: As you may have noticed from various threads here, polyamory is NOT a "fix" for failed monogamy. Yet, a lot of people figure that they can't hack a one-on-one relationship, so they'll "become poly" & instead have a whole clutch of shallow, superficial interactions.

(Is your therapist working with you on your enabling...?)

Why do you need to go outside the dyad to get your "needs" taken care of, only to go back home & resume slogging through the same old shit? Do you see yourself as a martyred saint, suffering "for love"?
 
Back
Top