Also, my partner seemed to be bimodal when it comes to poly, potentially happy either way. So it was a known risk this would happen, but not a foregone conclusion.
She was trying it out as part of getting back into dating again, and while being loved by and loving two people brought her happiness, having two new relationships in the same timeframe with two different sets of needs was too much. And she was ‘r willing ng to cause stretching pain constantly to either of us- it made her feel like a failure. And that threw her into a really hard emotional space that she did not want to repeat.
We really were different.. We had my meta, the beginning, struggling with poly and would rather be mono person on the one side, and me, the bimodal but currently poly and poly long enough to have lost some of the sympathy for the beginning predicaments that let you tolerate stuff like hierarchy or couple privilege or mistreatment of one partner to create space for the other.
She wasn’t willing to cause pain, and my meta was struggling- and so was I, with having to advocate for being treated like an absent partner when I was an absent partner, not something lower than a friend.
Meta’s preference was no contact at all when they were with eachother, even in three day holiday weekends, the kind you reach out to absent loved ones for, or if there was good reason of the emergency type for a brief text- the temporary split attention being too jarring for her- and expected perfect remembering of schedules so that I didn’t accidentally text asking if my partner was around during time together. (Which only happened once, when I was overwhelmed starting a new job in remembering anything.)
Mine was for mutual grace and support and if that wasn’t possible, there being space to being treated by my girlfriend the same way you would a close friend or relative, not a shameful hidden secret. And our partner’s preferences and needs being the important ones when it came to eachother, not ours. Which the break up did- got her out of the middle.
Thank you all for your words. The sympathy helps. Despite it not being a perfect poly situation, and the risk being known, it still hurts. But there is peace in the “at least my girlfriend isn’t torn anymore” aspect.