Thanks for the reply Nadya. You raise a good point about giving them their privacy but if it all goes down, when will it be a good time for me to say "hey, what about me?" I'm not looking to join because I respect her being a lesbian and all but I might eventually want to have my own encounter. Is this even considerd being poly or is it just open cheating? It's all just so confusing
The main difference between poly and cheating, ETHICAL non-monogamy, and cheating, is HONESTY.
If your wife is telling you the truth, telling this other woman the truth, and you are telling her the truth, basically no secrets or broken promises are going down, then you're GOLDEN.
The main cautions here are:
1. Romance with coworkers has its own hazards.
2. Be careful, as beginners to poly, of having expectations, or making promises, that are difficult or impossible to keep.
That last one... So often, a married couple newly opening will try to make rules about the people in the relationship developing feelings for those outside of the relationship. An insecure partner may feel that meaningless sex is alright but feelings are not. The idea might be that both are exploring a kink together, and the additional parties to this are thought of only as "a female" or whatever, not an actual person who also has feelings. The only ethical way I can see, to do the "sex only, no feelings allowed" arrangement, is to engage in activity ONLY in swinger environments or with the very clear agreement that it's a ONS or something like that. You see someone multiple times, there is a chance for feelings to develop, even if all that's happening is sex. Even if we don't mean to, we are human. And then often, the insecure partner gets upset because the one with feelings broke the agreement...when it was an impossible agreement to begin with. A coworker for instance, is absolutely the wrong choice for a "sex only, no emotions" arrangement.
And might be a poor choice anyways, just based on the coworker thing. Especially if they are in the same room or department, etc. Have to see one another daily...what if it all goes wrong? Will there be drama? Think it through carefully and advise them to as well.
As to "what about me?" what is stopping you from dating right now? I take it you understand that this other woman is a lesbian, so you won't be involved in that, and will need to seek your own other partner...the right time is whenever you and your wife are comfortable with you doing it. Now. Today. Whenever. What are you waiting for, if this is the lifestyle you have both chosen and wish to pursue...?