High school mono-poly relationship

Owliest

New member
I'm posting here as a sort of last-ditch effort kind of thing, so any and all advice is welcome!

My girlfriend and I have been dating for almost a year now, and I've fallen for her hard. It's a naïve thought since neither of us have even graduated yet, but whenever I think of her as a person, I believe that she's the kind of girl that I would want to marry in the future.

In October she came out to me as polyamorous - or, at least searching. She says that she's not completely sure of it yet, but she has done quite a bit of research on it and has even immersed herself in some poly-friendly podcasts. She says that the only way that she'll know if she's poly for sure, is if she tries it out for herself. Assuming that the tile did its job well to be self-explanatory, that's where the major nick in our relationship lies. I'm monogamous, though I've never had any personal qualms with polyamory or those who identify with it. Since she's shared her thoughts with me, I've spent my fair share of late nights doing some soul-searching and researching about polyamory, what it is, what relationships are like. I have seriously thought about what it would be like if I did agree to open our relationship up to someone else, but my personal conclusion is that it would be extremely detrimental to me emotionally-wise. The only thing that I've gained from these nights is a fragmented image of her surrounded by the partners whom she adores, and who adore her in return. She's a wonderful person and deserves to be loved the way that she wants to be, I believe that with all of my heart, it's just the really painful thing is that I cannot provide her all of that as a single person.

I know the solution is fairly obvious: break-up. What makes it so complicated is that neither of us are quite ready to let each other go. The sheer thought of leaving her brings me an incredible amount of heartache that I didn't know I was capable of feeling.

We discussed our relationship openly recently, and when I asked her if she still wanted what we have to continue, her lack of response was muddled with tears. At the end of the night we agreed to, at the very least, hold onto our relationship until graduation. It feels like a ticking time bomb.

I'm sorry if this comes off the wrong way, or if the intention of this post is unclear, but some wisdom, harsh remarks, or gentle ones would be very helpful. How should this situation be handled? I feel at a complete loss of what to do, and some guidance is very much welcomed.
 
Soooo.... I'm gonna be totally honest with you.... chances are that this relationship won't last. For many reasons, but the biggest one being that MOST high school relationships don't last. Of course, there are a few exceptions and in fact my own brother has been married for 11 years to his HS girlfriend that he's been with for I guess about 18 years now. But that is SO RARE. And even relationships that do lead to marriages from that young of an age often still don't last.

People change a TON from teenagers to 20s to 30s. Are you guys planning to both go to college? If so, in the same area or will it be long distance? What about then getting jobs and will those be in the same area?

And now throw onto that the issue of being mono/poly. Basically it's a recipe for "this probably isn't going to work."

I'm not saying that you have to break up now. And frankly, your g/f is saying that she thinks that she's poly, but it sounds like she doesn't really know and there isn't anyone else out there that she's actively hoping to date. I think the fact that you guys are mature enough to really talk it out, and self-reflect shows an amazing amount of maturity, so it's a great start. If you're ok with it, keep thinking. Read articles and books about opening up etc. if you're on the fence as to whether or not it's something you could do. But if you're not comfortable with it and feel confident that you're mono, don't force yourself to be something that you aren't just to please someone else. And she shouldn't do the same either.

What you CAN do is try to enjoy the relationship that you have now while it lasts (IF you think you can do that. Some people prefer to transition to friends or not keep a relationship going once they know it's not going to last because it's too painful to try and stretch it out, so that's a personal decision that you have to make for yourselves). And I think it can be important to remind yourself that if things do end, that it doesn't make either of you bad people, and that break-ups don't have to mean that you can't stay friends, or that the relationship was a "failure." Just that it wasn't meant to be forever. It can still be something that you are able to look back on as a wonderful time in your life.
 
I think the fact that you guys are mature enough to really talk it out, and self-reflect shows an amazing amount of maturity, so it's a great start. If you're ok with it, keep thinking. Read articles and books about opening up etc. if you're on the fence as to whether or not it's something you could do. But if you're not comfortable with it and feel confident that you're mono, don't force yourself to be something that you aren't just to please someone else. And she shouldn't do the same either.

....

What you CAN do is try to enjoy the relationship that you have now while it lasts (IF you think you can do that. Some people prefer to transition to friends or not keep a relationship going once they know it's not going to last because it's too painful to try and stretch it out, so that's a personal decision that you have to make for yourselves). And I think it can be important to remind yourself that if things do end, that it doesn't make either of you bad people, and that break-ups don't have to mean that you can't stay friends, or that the relationship was a "failure." Just that it wasn't meant to be forever. It can still be something that you are able to look back on as a wonderful time in your life.

I really want to reiterate the first part that I quoted. You two are both well o the way to healthy relationships. That kind of communication is very rare. You should both be proud of yourselves.

I agree with the latter too. I know the emotion is hard and difficult, but try to live in the moment. Enjoy your time together. Until she starts actively seeking a second partner and/or you are so emotionally affected by what might happen, there's no need to make changes.

One of the best pieces of advice my therapist gave me is "You don't have to make a decision until you have to." These things have a way of working themselves out without our intervention. in the mean time, enjoy your relationship and enjoy building memories you can treasure for years to come.
 
How should this situation be handled? I feel at a complete loss of what to do, and some guidance is very much welcomed.

I think you handled it well. Both communicated honestly and are leaning into it rather than avoiding talking about it.

At the end of the night we agreed to, at the very least, hold onto our relationship until graduation.

I think that's fair enough. Enjoy what you have for now, then part ways politely and respectfully at graduation. Unless either of you feels the need to part sooner? It's ok to enjoy a relationship knowing a parting will come.

Not all "good relationships" end up at the wedding altar. Some of them end up at good partings. And those are relationships to treasure also -- just because they part doesn't mean that they weren't meaningful or significant in your life.

While there's a poly component to this? Most HS relationships have to face parting ways at grad. If you can approach that in a healthy way? So much the better. Rarely do the two people go off to the same college. The human brain is also not done growing til mid 20's. Who you guys are today as teens might not be the same people you are at 25.

If this is the first serious relationship for both of you? It might also be the first serious break up. It may hurt a lot because it IS the first and you are not sure how to take care of yourself. Subsequent ones go a lot easier because you know what works/what doesn't work for your self care.

So if you guys have made an agreement to enjoy the time you have left in high school together as dating partners and then part ways at grad or soon after grad? I think that's fine.

Galagirl
 
Honestly I think as others have pointed out that you are both approaching this in a mature and healthy fashion already. The open communication you've taken part in is rare in a lot of relationships.

Not all relationships are forever and part of my experience has been learning to enjoy the here and now and be grateful for the impact that people leave on my life for however short of a term they are in it and also accepting that many relationships change and evolve over time. You seem to have a good handle on things. A relationship ending is painful, having a set time where things will come to an end on top of that adds an extra layer of challenge and pain I think.

I wish that I could give you a better solution here, I know that you don't want to end things and that the impending timeline aspect of things is upsetting to think about. Sometimes it's about making the best of what we have and cherishing the people in our lives as they are able to be in it.
 
Hello Owliest,

This time period between now and graduation: I can't tell if it's a test period, or just a time to enjoy the relationship before you break up. If it's a test period, then perhaps your girlfriend could try polyamory between now and graduation. In that way, she could get a better idea of if she really is poly -- and if she isn't, then you could both be monogamous and the problem would be solved. Otherwise, she would know that she really is poly -- and you would know, by the time graduation happened, whether you could stand for her to be poly. If you could stand the poly, then the two of you could continue dating, and if you couldn't stand the poly, then you would know for sure that you should break up.

I know you're going through a difficult time right now, and I am sympathetic. I hope things work out for the two of you, one way or another.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Back
Top