I’m mono, my wife is poly, and since she started a relationship she isn’t interested in me

Status
Not open for further replies.

Florentine

New member
I’ve been with my wife 14 years and married for 7. We have a 13 year old.

About 18 months ago, my wife told me she had a ‘connection’ with a very close friend of ours, someone that we made an ‘earth mother’ to our child because, since she isn’t religious, being a godmother wasn’t appropriate for her. My wife told me about 5 minutes before seeing my family, so I didn’t have time to digest it and said, it’s fine as long as nothing is in front of me and nothing is inappropriate.

A day later, the friend and her husband came over for a regular games night. I was sat on the sofa with my wife and friend and they were very touchy in front of me, which made me feel really uncomfortable. I took myself to bed. When they left and my wife came up, I told her this was unacceptable. She apologised and said it wouldn’t happen again.

Then around 6 months later, she said she thinks she’s polyamorous. This was a hard pill to swallow. She went onto apps and started meeting people.

We spoke about boundaries and she asked me what I want, that she would respect. So I put boundaries in place to protect myself mentally, and our family, such as: no females (a massive insecurity for me, as she has always said she has never fallen in love with a man, but has previously had an affair behind her girlfriend's back with another woman and left her girlfriend for the woman) and to use protection ALWAYS.

We had hard conversations. I told her this isn’t what I want. She said this makes her happy. I told her one of us could likely remain unhappy then. If you are doing this, I’m unhappy, and if you’re not, then you’re unhappy.

She said she would go on a ‘break’ from it for 6 months to see how she feels. This lasted about 2 months and she was back on the app.

Then lo and behold, she said she wanted to re-explore what she has with our ‘friend.’ I told her how this made me feel. After endless arguing, she still decided this is what she wanted to do. I felt like I had lost best friends (my female friend and her husband) and was losing my wife.

We had a holiday booked and she said nothing would happen until after the holiday. When we got back, it was almost like they went into it instantly. (The holiday was in August last year.)

I told her the friends were no longer invited to our house. My wife always said what matters to me is most important. I am priority. But I didn’t feel this way. Then, in December, they had their work due (they worked together) and they were staying overnight. I went to stay at my father's because I couldn’t handle being at home thinking all sorts.

The following day, I didn’t want to go home. I had all sorts in my head, so I kept stalling. When I got home, she was very affectionate and cuddly with me. Into the evening I asked if they had taken the step to go all the way. And they had. This cut me really deep and I said I was out. I wasn’t doing this anymore.

The whole poly thing is supposed to be ethical, but this wasn’t, as I wasn’t okay with any of this. December was a hard month for us, but somehow we were making it through. Then, at the end of December, I had an accident and broke both my ankles. The only people to help were this couple. Against my knowledge, my wife contacted them for help with supplies and they brought them over (commode, zimmer frame, toilet frame etc.). They didn’t stay long. That was that.

I was at my lowest point in my life, as I was always a very dependent person and now I was bedbound (for 3 months). Then one day, flowers came through the door. They were from the ‘friend’ to my wife. I didn’t react well to this. I thought it was insensitive, given the circumstances of how I felt about them and the fact I was in a hospital bed at home.

My wife and I fell out over it and she made it clear she had messaged the friend saying how I felt, and they were both messaging each other angrily about me. I asked her to tell me the messages. She refused, so I messaged the ‘friend’ myself, and as you could imagine, I didn’t hold back. When I woke the following day I had a massive message from her, which still to this day I’ve never read. I didn’t need to see what the message was, and I felt like I’d said everything I needed to say. I did message her and I said please don’t think I don’t appreciate the help you gave me when I came home from hospital, because I am grateful for that. And I left it at that.

Since then, she has distanced herself from my wife, ghosting her, making my wife feel unwanted. Which again is hard for me to get my head around.

So my wife decided to go onto discord poly groups and get back onto the apps. She started meeting people and then regularly started meeting one man.

I’ve been very open with her, as she has with me. I ask questions. We talk about her dates. I’m genuinely interested, and keen to see her happy. I feel like I’ve come a long way since the start of this new journey.

Anyway, back to what I said above. She started meeting one guy regularly. They meet every week. I told her what I expect, protection EVERY SINGLE TIME, no matter the act. She agreed with this.

I came home one day after she had been to his house and I just felt awkward and weird. I’m an adult; I know what happens when two are in a house alone. We had a big awkward conversation and she said she didn’t feel the need to use protection for ALL acts, if you get my drift, without going into too much detail. This concluded with me saying I wasn’t happy and this again isn’t ethical. She said she would take this on board.

Throughout this whole journey, she has always said this won’t affect us, affect our marriage, affect our sexual life, and I should be happy that she is happy.

For the past month, she hasn’t kissed me unless I initiate it. She hasn’t been close to me unless I initiate it. So when I had a chat with her I told her how this is all making me feel. I asked her verbally if anything sexual has happened. She kept saying, 'We haven’t had sexual intercourse.' This went on for about 5-6 times, when she finally said, 'Yes, there has been sexual encounters.'

She had always told me this would never affect us or how we are sexually, but it’s evident it has. I broke down to her and said she is making me feel unattractive and unwanted, and this is what she promised wouldn’t happen if she takes the poly journey.

Last week was half term. We had a chat the week before that week, and she asked if I have a preference on what day she goes to see him. I asked her politely if she wouldn’t mind skipping a week, as I work in a school, so I am off work, and she works from home, so we can spend time together. She wasn’t happy about this, even though she sees him weekly. I ended up going back on my word and what I wanted and saying, 'Okay, go and see him Monday, then.' So that is what was planned.

She told me they were going to a gaming cafe. Then when she was getting ready to go, she said, 'I don’t know if we’re going to his house after, because he’s mentioned he has made a dessert.' I feel like going to his was always planned, but by her saying she didn’t know if she was, was a cop-out, not being honest. Anyway, he cancelled 10 minutes before she left because he had to get a plumber out.

We have been ‘close’ since I spoke to her, and she is initiating. But I can’t help but feel like she’s not doing it because she wants to, but because of what I said, which is, if this continues, then I’m out. I need to put myself first sometimes.

This lasted 2 days. She has now reverted back to not kissing or touching. She does want to cuddle, and tickle back/legs. But that’s it. I’ve tried to initiate kissing, but I’m getting pecks back. Last night she mentioned, ‘Hopefully we can be intimate soon.’ I feel like she’s saying the ‘right things’ because of what I had brought up, but it isn’t materialising into anything.

First, am I out of order for asking her to not plan something during the school holidays, where I only had a week off? (We also had plans with friends, so only really had 3 days off together.)

Secondly, am I overreacting her new relationship with this guy, due to my own insecurities?

I can’t help but feel unwanted, unattractive, insecure and jealous.

If anyone can help or give advice, all would be gratefully received. I’ll aim to respond if you have further questions. Thanks in advance.
 
I'm sorry this happened. I hope you feel better for airing out some. FWIW, this pops out to me. I mean it kindly, okay?

We had hard conversations and I told her this isn’t what I want. She said this makes her happy. I told her one of us could likely remain unhappy then. If you are doing this I’m unhappy, and if you’re not, then you’re unhappy.

I'm wondering why you didn't talk about a peaceful parting. A break-up means some sadness, but then BOTH can heal and move on, become a healthy divorced coparenting family, rather than "taking turns sitting in the miserable box." That might be "fair," but is it healthy? No. it is not.

The rest sounds like just dragging out stuff only to come back to this: square one. Instead of having a single load to deal with, it became this original problem of you wanting monogamy and her wanting polyamory, compounded by the things with EarthMother and the Dude. It's like you're going the long way round just to end up back at the same place, with more loads piled on. :(

Into the evening, I asked if they had taken the step to go all the way. And they had. This cut me really deep. I said I was out. I wasn’t doing this anymore. The whole poly thing is supposed to be ethical, but this wasn’t. I wasn’t okay with any of this.

I think you could have been firm on that from the start.

Anyone can choose to break up. But wife breaking up the old monogamy deal doesn't have to mean you automatically sign up for some new deal.

There is NOTHING wrong with you wanting monogamy.

There is NOTHING wrong with her wanting polyamory.

If you two are not longer compatible, it's best to accept it, rather than drag it all out and make a mess. :(

My wife and I fell out over it. She made it clear she had messaged the friend saying how I felt and they were both messaging each other angrily about me, I asked her to tell me the messages and she refused, so I messaged the ‘friend’ myself and, as you could imagine, I didn’t hold back.

That was not appropriate. I get you were upset that you chose to go along with poly under duress, and were low from being in a hospital bed, but getting this upset over flowers, and then writing to your wife's GF? What were you trying to do? I guess it doesn't matter now, since they broke up, but if you are upset with Wife, going after the person she's dating doesn't solve anything. It's Wife's behaviors that are the problem here.

And it's partly your behaviors. You don't have to stick around in things that are not compatible and don't suit you. You cannot "make boundaries or agreements" your way into a healthy relationship if Wife just isn't going to keep her word or take personal responsibility. You can't do anything about that. Her behavior is on her. What you can do something about is your staying-ness. You can have a limit of tolerance. Once past it, you can quit.

Throughout this whole journey, she has always said this won’t affect us, affect our marriage, affect our sexual life. And I should be happy that she is happy.

Where is YOUR happiness in this picture?

You being in a poly V with your wife as a hinge dating X DOES affect you two as a couple, the marriage, your sex life.

She doesn't handle her NRE very well. You are deep in "poly hell," when you don't even want to be doing poly, from the sound of it.


First, am I out of order for asking her to not plan something in school holidays where I only had a week off? (We had plans with friends, so only really had 3 days off together.)

No, you were not out of line. You can ask her for a date. Couples do date each other.


Secondly, am I overreacting to her new relationship with this guy, due to my own insecurities?

No, you are not overreacting. She's kind of a sloppy hinge and just ugh to deal with, from the sound of it. She made a mess with EarthMother. That does not inspire confidence that she can handle herself any better with Dude.

You may or may not have insecurities, but doing poly with her is far from stable. It's all rickety. I get that you're alarmed. I would be.

And you are trying to control stuff, because this is like riding an emotional rollercoaster you don't even want to be riding. You want SOMETHING solid.

Nobody wants pity sex or duty/obligation sex. You two don't sound especially healthy as a couple, right now, in general. I am very sorry for that.

I can’t help but feel unwanted, unattractive, insecure and jealous.

I wonder if you are ANGRY.

To me, it sounds like she's taking you for granted and off chasing the New Shiny People-- poly hell stuff. If she's basically checked out of this relationship and not interested in being a romantic couple anymore, you do not exist to be her "back-up plan" when she's bored or doesn't have another date going on.

You two could just break up as peacefully as possible, under the circumstances.

None of this sounded like ethical, consenting polyamory from the start. You were not joyfully consenting. It sounds like neither of you did any preparation. She just jumped into poly-dating fast, and lost her head.

If I'm honest, I'm kinda wondering about that "special connection" and if those two were having an emotional affair, and later tried to "whitewash" it with the poly brush, by coaxing the spouses to practice poly. But at this point, that is neither here nor there, since they broke up.

There's just SO MUCH stuff here. Sometimes it's helpful to sort details and other times it's better to call it all wackadoo and pay more attention to the bottom line instead.

If you'd prefer monogamy, you could stop doing this, because it is not monogamy.

About 18 months ago, my wife told me she had a ‘connection’ with a very close friend of ours, someone that we made an ‘earth mother’ to our child... My wife told me about 5 minutes before seeing my family, so I didn’t have time to digest it and said, 'it’s fine, as long as nothing is in front of me, and nothing is inappropriate.'

It sounds like you went along with it because you were surprised, and not thrilled. She brought it up right before a family event. And you admit to being dependent. I wonder if you are a bit of a people-pleaser and anxious? Why agree to things you haven't fully digested? Is that taking good care of yourself?

Rather than saying, "We have a family event. I'd rather discuss this later, when there is more time to actually talk and reflect," you gave an inch. And then she took a mile and kept on taking miles and miles.

If you don't like doing poly with her, STOP, and talk about a peaceful parting.

I don't know if you want to try couple's counseling and a lawyer to work out agreements for a yearlong trial separation. You live apart. You date how you want, or not. She dates how she wants. You both get a taste of life, NOT dealing in these shenanigans, and only coparenting, maybe doing family therapy.

Or, if you are just done and do not want a trial separation, and just want to head to a divorce, a counselor would be more about changing to a divorced coparenting family, while doing therapy things, not seeking a reconciliation. Then you each talk to your lawyers about the dissolution of the legal marriage.

However you choose, I suggest you put your foot down about all these shenanigans. Enough is enough. Stop throwing your own mental health and wellbeing under the bus.

I'm sorry to hear about your ankles. Even after you're out of the casts, it can take a long while to regain full mobility and strength. As you continue healing from all that, maybe it's a good time to heal from ALL the things. Turn the page. Make different choices for the next chapter of your life.

I encourage you to do your soul searching and make some new choices.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hello Florentine,

From your description, this is a really hard situation for you and your wife. Like you said, one of you will have to be unhappy. And I guess divorce is not an option, especially as you have a child. And maybe you are perfect for each other, other than this one little thing. Okay two little things. One, she wants polyamory and you want monogamy. Two, she has lost interest in you. I don't know how to solve these two problems, but you better find a way because you can't divorce. What about the idea of seeing a couple's counselor?

You are not out of order for asking her to not plan something during the school holidays, where you only had a week off. You are not overreacting to her relationship with the new guy. She has not been acting considerate towards your wishes, and she has been breaking her promises. She owed you that week, and she pushed you into not giving it to you. You do seem to be giving in to her a lot when she pressures you or breaks her word. Maybe it would help to have a temporary separation. Live somewhere else for a while, where you don't have to be exposed to her shaky behavior. Then decide what you want to do after that.

I hope you can work this out.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top