My boyfriend's other girlfriend can't accept our relationship

Devon

New member
I know it's none of my business in other partner's relationships, but we've gotten to a point where I feel like I should have intervened by now.

My boyfriend and I have been together for five years, three in a polyamorous relationship. During that time, several people have come and gone in his life and there has never been anything that has irritated me. I even hung out with those people and we had friendly relationships.

I've sometimes had a problem with him starting with girls who weren't completely mentally stable and him pulling them out of their problems. After they disappeared from our lives, they ended up in a monogamous relationship. I knew even then that what my partner was doing wasn't quite right. But I got over it.

However, now there's a girl in his life that I can't get over. I feel like I'm losing respect for my partner because of this, and I've even thought about leaving the relationship because it reminds me too much of my own traumas. (I'm working on them.)

He and this girl have known each other for a long time. He has long been her emotional support when she hasn't felt comfortable about her relationship. One day, my boyfriend told me that he would like try it with her sometime, in case her relationship doesn't work out. Around that time, she started talking about the fact that she was also polyamorous and that she would like to give it a try.

I was still okay with it at the time. But then came the turning point. She started asking mutual friends about my relationship with my boyfriend, if it was okay between us, if it looked like we were going to break up, etc. We were dealing with a little drama at the time, so she got the impression that we were on the verge of breaking up.

She broke up with her partner to be with mine. They have been in a relationship for six months. She has taken the attitude that my boyfriend is her priority relationship. Even though there were other men in her life who lived closer, she never prioritized them. (I know this from a partner who talked to her about it and when she got the response that he couldn't give her what she was asking for from her primary partner, it gave her a three day breakdown.)

Along with all this, her hatred towards me is growing. She's constantly putting down our relationship. She can't even deal with the fact that we occasionally post a picture together.

I gather she's gotten herself into an unhealthy relationship. She spins in circles, where everything goes according to her plan, and then gets slapped when she finds out it doesn't and nothing has changed. It's not comfortable for me or her when there is someone who is just waiting to see if my relationship will last or not. It's even worse when it's a person who's in our polycule.

Our partners have always had a very good relationship with each other and our polyamory was also based on that. Once when it looked like my boyfriend and I were going to break up, they helped us work it out. But she just doesn't fit in and doesn't want to. She's under the illusion that she's the one.

It affects me even more because I was in a similar position and it's completely destroyed my mental health. I've felt the need to spare people from this ever since. I don't think she or he are bad people. I still like her in my own way and I understand her.

I've kept my mouth shut until now, but with the way things have been going lately and the more I see myself in it, I feel like I can't be quiet anymore. It has an extremely negative impact on all our relationships. But my boyfriend still believes it can work and he's unhappy about the situation.

What would you do if you were me?
Thank you for any advice. ❤️
 
Breaking this down, it sounds like prior to this woman, you and your bf have done "kitchen table polyamory" (KTP), where all the metamours know about each other, and are friends, and hang out together. It sounds like new woman wants monogamy, and is threatened by you (and probably any other partners your bf has).

She wants you two to break up so she can have him to herself. We have a term for this: cowgirl. She's trying to rope him off from the herd.

I would also be wary that bf has White Knight Syndrome, if he's always "rescuing" women with mental health issues. It sounds like his tendency to operate like this has led him to this new woman who is mono-minded and not secure enough to be just one of his partners, and not even his primary.

Your problem is with bf, not with this woman. As a hinge, it's up to him to be honest with her that you and he are not on the verge of a breakup, and he and she are not going to be monogamous together. You can request he make his clear to her.

You can also request he just tell you less about this woman. I know you're used to KTP, where everyone is up in each other's business, but in this case, it sounds like there should be parallel poly. You don't need to be up in her business, as you said you are aware of.

Maybe just let bf and her do their thing and let it run its course. Keep yourself out of it as much as possible. Don't be bf's sounding board about his issues with her.
 
I'm sorry this is happening like this.

She started asking around with mutual friends about my relationship with my boyfriend, if it was okay between us, if it looked like we were going to break up, etc.

Who told you this?

Along with all this, her hatred towards me is growing. She's constantly putting down our relationship. She even deal with the fact that we occasionally post a picture together.

How do you even know this?

If I were in your shoes. I'd tell BF he's the one dating her, not me. And that I'm going strictly parallel. Apart from info required to maintain sex health, I'd rather not know much about her.

I'd tell friends/polycule people that I am going strictly parallel. They can be friends with her how they wish, but don't invite me to hang out in a group. I will decline. I'd rather not know much about her.

I'd unfriend/block her from my social media so I can't see her things and she can't see mine.

If I happened to bump into her out in public, I'd do "basic polite." The same as you do with the bank teller or store clerk. "Hello. Good morning" type stuff but nothing too deep. I'm not going to be mean, but I'm not interested in more.

It affects me even more because I was in a similar position and it's completely destroyed my mental health. I've felt the need to spare people from this ever since. I don't think she oř he are a bad persons. I still like her in my own way and I understand her.

If I needed to talk this out? I'd seek a counselor. YMMV, but you could try:


I would make an effort NOT to get involved with her and her choices, even if it reminds me of myself in the past.

I've sometimes had a problem with him starting with girls who weren't completely mentally stable and him pulling them out of their problems. After they disappeared from our lives, they ended up in a monogamous relationship. I knew even then that what my partner was doing wasn't quite right, but I got over it.

However, now there's a girl in his life that I can't get over. I feel like I'm losing respect for my partner because of this,

If my partner was going around "white knighting", had poor partner selection, or he's frequently going for people with mental health issues, and I have lost respect for him, I'd consider ending it and walking away. I can't be with someone I don't respect.

HTH!
Galagirl
 
Hello Devon,

It sounds like your boyfriend's new (six months) girlfriend is jealous of you. Or she sees you as a threat, like you will steal your boyfriend from her. Perhaps it is time for you to speak up, and tell her that you and your boyfriend are going to stay together, and she will just have to deal with that. Or tell your boyfriend to say that to her.

I'm sorry this is happening.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Back
Top