New Poly Relationship - In Limbo?

Kris14

New member
Hi all,

This is my first time doing a message board...on any site. But today, I am in need of advice that I doubt I could get from any source that I regular.

My name is Kris (she and her) and I recently ended a relationship with my girlfriend of 9 months. We were open and most days I was okay that. But there were days that I let my insecurities get the best of me and I wasn't okay with it. This relationship structure is new to me and I did not know what to expect from my girlfriend or from myself.

In July, I found myself being hyperaware of how she related to other people, how many people were attracted to her, and how many people were almost obsessed with her. To be fair, these were just my perceptions. I got really squirmy and started to doubt if I was secure enough to handle it. Even though, she was with me every night, and even though she was reassuring me about our relationship, and even though she was so patient with me. I still doubted my ability to navigate this relationship.

In August, for the first time in the history of our relationship, I slept with another woman. Initially, I felt okay about it. I think that my girlfriend was fine with it too. Until it happened again and I started to feel off about it. It felt dishonest, it felt wrong. I still haven't pinpointed why. Shortly after, I told my girlfriend that I couldn't be open. She was once again, very patient. Told me, that we could go slow. She told me, that she wanted to be with me and that right now, we could just build. I pushed the issue. Eventually forcing her hand. I look back and I recognize immediately that I worked out of fear of losing her.

Right now, I am not scared but I am sad. Sad that I bailed and didn't communicate more. I'm sad that I do not think that I will have the courage to dial back my pride enough to say these things to her.

Last night, we talked. I told her a lot of things. But not that I was wrong, scared, or that I just needed a minute. I told a lot of shit that didn't really matter.

It's hard to say that I was wrong and unfair, aloud. But I was. I may not get to correct this and/or try again with her. Guess I'll have to be okay with that.

Any advice or encouragement would be greatly appreciated. I'm flailing in emotions and not doing a very good job keeping boundaries with my girlfriend or ex-girlfriend (my doing, not hers).
 
Don't beat yourself up so bad. It's not an easy transition. For some it is impossible. In the end, if you are not compatible, you are not compatible. It's not a failure.
 


When I first told my husband that I was poly, I felt kind of scared that he'd be mad, angry, or scared of losing me, and I was scared of losing him, so for a while I didn't see anyone else for fear of his reaction.

I think maybe this is somewhat what's going on in your situation, only you're more in denial. You said yourself that the first time you were fine, but it was the second time you felt dishonest, so I feel like without worry you'd be fine. Maybe someone to talk to, wether it be your ex or someone else, it will help.

I'm 99% sure that any active user would be willing to talk with you, I know I would.
 
I'm sorry to hear about the break up. Those are never easy even if the best thing over all.

It's hard to say that I was wrong and unfair, aloud.

What were you wrong about?:confused:

To me it sounds like you don't want to be doing Open. You tried it and it is simply not your thing. It causes you a lot of stress.

You seem to prefer to relate in 1:1 model. Not like 1:1+

You did not bail on her. You stopped going against your own grain. You told her you did not want to do this any more.

You can love someone a whole lot. But not even for them should you bend yourself into pretzels and do things you don't really want to be doing. You are allowed to say "I love you a whole lot. But not even for you will I do things that hurt me. I have to stop." And then you stop doing whatever it is.

I may not get to correct this and/or try again with her. Guess I'll have to be okay with that.

Yes. You will have to be ok with parting ways. You could still tell her that Open is just not for you if you want to. But trying to keep flying a kite that just won't fly? You could stop doing that.

I'm flailing in emotions and not doing a very good job keeping boundaries with my girlfriend or ex-girlfriend (my doing, not hers).

It's ok to fee a lot of roller coaster emotions post break up. Let yourself grieve.

What are the boundaries you cannot keep? :confused:

If your exGF is not giving you enough space and trying to rush being exes and friends you can tell her that you need some space and that you want to go no contact for a month to heal. After that you can try being exes and friends. But not everything all piled up together stressing you out. You need a period of quiet and no stimulus. Sounds like you have been enduring a lot of up and down.

If you current GF is trying to get more serious than you want just because you ended things with other GF, you can tell her you need some space too.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi Kris,

I get the impression that there are things you want to say to your ex-girlfriend, that right now you don't feel like you can say. I would suggest working up the courage as soon as you can, say what needs to be said so you can get some closure. Even if the two of you remain broken up. You can still get some closure.

Just some thoughts ...
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Back
Top