Hello, everyone. Thanks for writing down all your wisdom. I still didn't bring anything up with her, as my wife suggested that the mere act of discussing anything related to sex when she doesn't want to might seem coercive.
Kaitlyn wants "sex" though. She's initiating makeout sessions. She's touching your cock, ffs. Don't think that "sex" is just Penis in Vagina Intercourse, especially for younger people/virgins. Deep kissing and touching private parts, getting very aroused, IS sex, or at least sexual.
Kailtyn doesn't let me touch her boobs or other private parts, not even over her t-shirt or skirt. On the other hand, she freely gropes me and plays with my cock (through my shorts). If I try to touch her anywhere that is not her waist or face, she gently pushes my hands away.
It sounds like she is curious about the male body, but wants to keep her own body "sacred." She probably has pregnancy/disease fears. Or she's just enjoying the "foreplay" type of action, so far. And that's fine.
That's why a few good discussions are necessary. You need to ask her sexual status. Is she a virgin or not? If she's had intercourse, has she had a recent STD test or not?
I took
@Tinwen 's suggestions very seriously, I guess. I don't want to talk to her while we were making out, but there is always this sexual tension between us. I am trying to find a good time to talk. We currently have privacy only in my truck, but the moment we are alone she starts making out.
Well, you're the adult here. I know. Technically, she is an adult, but "barely legal," as they say. You can stop the making out, just as any woman could stop a man from kissing and groping her if she were not ready. (Or a woman could stop another woman from doing this, if they were bi or lesbians, or men if they were gay/bi.)
Explain your confusion about her desire to touch you, but not be touched. Ask the questions.
Are you embarrassed to talk about sex? Lots of people are, especially younger people, but it's common at all ages. People would rather "do it" than talk about it. Our culture still carries that prudery, especially if you've been raised in a more right-wing evangelical family/environment.
Since you're older and wiser, use your big head. Try to control Mr Eager down there. It will pay off in the long run.
Don't spend time sitting in the truck alone. Go out on a date. Go for a hike, say. Talk and ask the questions. Get clear answers. Then get in the truck, turn the key, and drive her home. Don't sit there being a victim to her explorations if you're not really sure it's what you want, on all levels.