Struggling With Non-Monogamous Relationship

Tnamas

New member
Hi All,

I'm struggling to deal in a non-monogamous relationship. No one in my life, apart from my partner, is open to a non-monogamous mind-set.

I like the idea of being in a non-monogamous relationship. In fact I think that I need it. I love my partner more than anything, but the idea of never being able to share experiences with another person just plain freaks me out. I don't have a desire to enter into a long-term relationship with anyone else. More so to explore experiences with other people, platonic or otherwise.

I have a history of physical, sexual and psychological abuse. I suffer from PTSD, which is a constant process and I’m trying really hard. I've been struggling with chronic health issues for the last four years. As a result, my current relationship, even from a monogamous perspective is difficult for me to navigate. When I'm in my body/emotions I struggle with sheer terror and physical/emotional pain. So, I spend a lot of time in my head. I can revert to a very distanced and analytical approach to life, because it feels manageable there. This leads me to really withdrawing in my relationships. I really struggle with what I'm feeling and what my needs and wants are. Therefore, it's hard for me to understand what my boundaries are and when they're being crossed. I withdraw and protect myself without even knowing it.

I do everything I can to alleviate the burden this puts on my partner. We get each other on the deepest of levels, we love, respect, admire and are there for one another. Our communication is generally excellent. It breaks down when we argue - it becomes circular and neither of us feels understood/validated. My emotional withdrawal has been causing problems for a few years. It has led to a lack of intimacy, which really hurts her! She thrives on touch and desire, it's the language of love that she best understands. Being stuck in my top-down analytical view of the world; I can give her touch, and support, but the desire takes long periods of absence. Sometimes only to re-surface in a moment of crisis, kind of like now :(

Irena has supported me the best she is able over this period of time, but could no longer ignore what she we wasn't getting in our relationship. She feels intellectually and emotionally full-filled, but has a burning need to explore other relationships sexually. I support her as best I'm able, but I'm afraid that I'm falling short. We've taken tentative steps forward in that time, and with each step forward I tend to have a freak-out/melt-down, which is really hard on her.

Two weeks ago she first dated and slept with another man. Literally the day after this I was hospitalised and almost died from a surgical complication. As much pain as I was in, and as close to death as I was, the pain of her being intimate with someone was right up there. We talked about her experience, I was generally interested to hear all about it. It also ripped my heart out. At one point Irena commented that she could see how much this was hurting me, and that stress was the last thing I needed right now. She asked how I would feel if she just saw women. I'm completely ok with her seeing women for some reason. So I said that would be great, so as long as it sits right with her. My understanding of where we left off was she was going to only see women, and she would tell me if she felt like she needed to start seeing men again.

A couple of days ago she told me that she was supposed to go on a date with a guy that afternoon. She'd been talking to him for nearly a week and I hadn't known. I've expressed that not being kept in the loop is a huge trigger of mine. I felt hurt and angry, and then rapidly shut the feeling down - so rapidly I can only register it in hind-sight. Instead I tried to be supportive and interested. First mistake. I spent the rest of that day emotionally catatonic. Irena was really supportive.

She went on her date and had a good time. I wanted desperately to be supportive the next day. Instead I hurt and anger kept coming up. I tried hard to express it in a healthy way, but I couldn't. It came out in an accusatory fashion and we ended argued. Second mistake. She felt not listened to, shut down and withdrew. I'm the kind of person that likes to move through the argument and resolve it right then and there. Irena needs time and space. I could see her shutting down so I gave her space and went away to be in my hurt. I had an epiphany whilst I was in the depths of my own hell. I don't express anger. Ever. I mean sure I get angry and I argue, but I don't let myself sit in a space and actually be angry with someone. So the anger never moves through, I never actually get to express and dislodge it. It's only intellectual anger that gets expressed. I knew right then that I had to express it, it was one of the things that was making me push her away. One of the boundaries that I wasn't aware of until now. So, I expressed it. I didn't fly off the handle, I didn't shout. I expressed it in the same healthy way I always aspire to, but this time I let myself feel angry as I was expressing it. Lo and behold I felt like I'd taken some power in the relationship that I was missing, and not having it was draining me. I didn't take power from her. I took my own personal power that was being misdirected out of fear. Unfortunately, probably crap timing for such an epiphany. She was already feeling overwhelmed and needed space, this just compounded it. She withdrew completely. I was left feeling like I was out on a limb, waiting for a juror to come out on our relationship. She's been at this point of shutting down before and has broken up with me. I resolved to let her come to me and talk when she was ready, I was giving her as much space as possible. I didn't want to push her over the edge and lose her.

Six hours of my own hell later, I had another realisation; It's a running thing in our arguments where I feel like I'm left waiting for her to take accountability for her part in an argument, or apologise for a wrong doing. It's not that she isn't sorry, or aware of her own part in things. We have two different styles of communication. She states that it's a given she's considering her part in things, and that she's sorry where applicable. Whereas I need to feel it. I need to experience that softening in the other person, where just for a second they stop trying to defend themselves and take on-board what you're saying. A hug and an I'm sorry don't go astray either, but just the understanding would be enough. I feel like I'm quite good at apologising mid-argument, a pro of being able to enter that clinical mind-set. I don't expect anyone to do this to the same extent. I just feel that I don't get this in my relationship until days or weeks later, sometimes never.

Anyways, she completely forgot about our discussion pertaining to not seeing men. No way would I have tried to stop it if she told me. But she didn't, she just plain forgot and was talking to the dude for a week without letting me know. This really hurt/hurts me. I know she can't be beholden to my physical state, she has her own life to live. I just can't understand how your partner can be close to death, so you make the call that we should mitigate stress for a little bit, and then completely forget. I just feel completely forgotten and not cared about at the most fundamental level. She was going through hell at the time too so I can intellectually understand how she could forget. But emotionally, god-damn it hurts!

As I mentioned earlier, this has been a triggering theme in our exploration into non-monogamous relationships. In our first experience, my flatmate told her he was really into her - in a very back-handed, malintent kind of way. They texted back and forth for a week, met up in a bar and engaged in minor intimacy. She told him that the only way that they would hook up is if I was made aware of the situation and was okay with it. All of that is cool to me, except for being kept out of the loop for a week. Especially considering the nature of my flatmate's intention. Irena had no malintent in not informing me. I was stressed at the time and my flat-mate conveyed that he had genuine feelings for her - so she wanted to be sensitive and supportive to him. She honestly thought it was better to wait before telling me. When she told me she prefaced it with 'I forgot to tell you...'. I get the logic, but it triggered the hell out of me. I feel like I was put second.

At another time we were broken up, still living together, still sleeping in the same bed and being intimate, but broken up by discussion. She arranged a date with another person and told me by preface of 'I forgot to tell you...'.

Hell, the first girl I ever truly loved broke all contact with me immediately after saying 'I forgot to tell you, I've been seeing another guy for the last three months'.

I have a sensitivity around being forgotten.

I don’t know if I’m making a something out of nothing. I only know how I feel and what hurts me. It’s really hard to trust that. I’m terrified of doing the wrong thing and ruining something beautiful. All because I can’t move past something that was all in my head and didn’t matter in the first place.

Thanks for reading rant. In summary I guess;
My self-worth is crushed. I feel like I can’t explore relationships with other people. What does a chronically ill man struggling with PTSD have to offer anyone?
I feel unsafe and power-less in my relationship.
I feel alone.


Thanks for allowing me the forum to piece together my own thoughts and feelings,
Tim
 
Welcome to the forum. It sounds like you have a lot of things going on. I would recommend talking to a professional.
 
I hope you feel a bit better for airing out. Some of the issues (abuse, PTSD, almost dying in hospital, emotional flooding, etc) you might want to process with an individual counselor.

"When she told me she prefaced it with 'I forgot to tell you...'. I get the logic, but it triggered the hell out of me. I feel like I was put second.

For the communication thing with Irena... that might also need couple counseling if you guys have problems resolving conflict more calmly. You have a LOT going on.

I just feel that I don't get this in my relationship until days or weeks later, sometimes never.

One thing you could do right now is to stop using "feel" in place of "think" or "observe."

  • "Feel" is for emotions you have.
  • "Think" is for thoughts you have.
  • "Observe" or "experience" is for things you have observed or experienced directly.

If you observe that in your relationship with Irena that you don't get an apology until days or weeks later, and sometimes never? That's how it is with Irena.

That is not an emotion ("feel") That is not a thought. ("think"). That is what happens there in life with her. It's "observe/experience."

It may sound persnickety, but with SO much going on with you, I think it might help lower confusion/stress if you become more strict about what words you use for what and not use "feel" for everything from feelings, to thoughts, to observations.

Untangling all the things has to start somewhere. Right now all the issues are mixed up in one bucket. Nothing is clear, a lot of things are muddying up other things, etc.

Another thing I think you could do right now to help yourself and to cut down some on the misunderstandings with Irena is to make it a habit to ask

"Ok... could you please repeat back what I said in your own words so I know you got it how I meant it?"​

If what she repeats back is not quite right it gives you both the opportunity to calibrate so you are both on the same page before bigger misunderstandings happen.

At one point Irena commented that she could see how much this was hurting me, and that stress was the last thing I needed right now. She asked how I would feel if she just saw women. I'm completely ok with her seeing women for some reason. So I said that would be great, so as long as it sits right with her. My understanding of where we left off was she was going to only see women, and she would tell me if she felt like she needed to start seeing men again.

Had you asked her to repeat back she could have said something like "Ok, so at this point we agree that I will date women only. And I will tell you if I want to start dating men again before I actually move on to dating them."

Then if she doesn't stick to the agreement, you know she's breaking agreement.

You no longer have to worry about any of this...

I don’t know if I’m making a something out of nothing. I only know how I feel and what hurts me. It’s really hard to trust that. I’m terrified of doing the wrong thing and ruining something beautiful. All because I can’t move past something that was all in my head and didn’t matter in the first place.

...like it is all in your head or you are blowing things out of proportion.

You will see that she says one thing and then does another. Which is not great, and it's a problem to solve.

But at least you don't have the problem of doubting your own mind on top of it any more. You can be more sure that you recall things you observed or experienced correctly because you double checked when the agreement was first made.

If she repeated back in her own words what the agreement was, she cannot make claims later that she "forgot" about the agreement.

It's not "forgetting" if this is chronic behavior. It's choosing to ignore or disregard it, and then claiming "forgetfulness" as a means to avoid taking personal responsibility for actions. Always trying to "coast" or "slide off the hook" or take a "pass" or something.

That would get annoying to me. I don't like playing "slippery fish."

At another time we were broken up, still living together, still sleeping in the same bed and being intimate, but broken up by discussion. She arranged a date with another person and told me by preface of 'I forgot to tell you...'.

If you stay in a relationship where you feel unsafe and power-less? How is that you taking good care of you? It's going to be hard to feel proud of your behavior if you are keeping yourself in harm's way. That is not self honoring or self respecting behavior. :(

It's hard to hold yourself in high esteem if you are choosing behavior that is less than self respecting. I can see why your self worth is taking a ding. You could value yourself higher than this.

If you guys broke up before,why did you get back together? :confused: Esp since it still sounds so trigger-y and tumultuous for you?

Could it be possible that you want to practice non-monogamy, but are finding out that THIS partner is just not the partner to do that with if you want to practice non-monogamy in a healthy way? You guys are not deeply compatible?

I guess you guys could try couple counseling for the couple things and see if it pans out or if it is better to part ways.

However that works out? I strongly encourage individual counseling so you get help with the rest of your stuff. You are under a heavy burden. For that I am sorry -- I hope you find some uplift soon.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
“Could it be possible that you want to practice non-monogamy, but are finding out that THIS partner is just not the partner to do that with if you want to practice non-monogamy in a healthy way? You guys are not deeply compatible? “

Everything Galagirl just said was SPOT ON for me! Especially this last quote (which I don’t know how to quote the right way in my reply...sorry.

I was going through the worst kind of hell about a new girlfriend I even thought I was falling in love with. She is/was the first woman My wife and I have dated together and the first woman other than my wife I had done anything romantic with since about 15 years ago. Her communication, often not replying to a text, when talking on the phone continuing online chats simultaneously, periodically dropping off, unreachable and no contact from her... all of this had me in knots.

I didn’t know how to reconcile my strong attraction with the way I was feeling overall. Then it occurred to me when non-romantic friends would reply within 5 hours to a day of a text that perhaps my “lover” and I are not compatible in ways that effect my self worth and self respect. We had “broken up” before and our most recent resolution was she was willing to reply to texts within 24 hours.

I hate Facebook messenger for many reasons but the worst for me is seeing she read my comment and not replying. Or seeing her log in and not even read my comment. As soon as I made my mind up that this was a problem of incompatibility my knots went away. There is no doubt that I need a more responsive, attentive and engaged lover. This person who I have quickly developed quite strong attraction for does not meet these needs. Done.

Disappointed, sad, heart sick. Yes, all of those. But I’m no longer experiencing the crazy self doubt and second guessing of what to do. Going forward, any new relationships will have to be at least 70% positive, possibly 99% in the beginning when I’m blind to flaws. Any new lovers should be at least as respectful and mature as me, hopefully much more. I want to feel like I am a better person because of my interactions with this person not, alternating btwn crazy excited and panicky.

Perhaps the attraction for me was so strong because of the elusiveness... something for me and my therapist to look at :)

My heart goes out to you in your unique situation. I hope sharing my recent experience and realization is helpful.
 
Hello Tim,

I am doubtful that your partner really "forgot to tell you." It sounds to me more like, she didn't want an unpleasant situation, so she chose not to tell you until it was more convenient. I know this sounds cynical on my part.

I hope the two of you can work things out.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Hi Everyone,


I really appreciate you all taking time to reply to the post of a stranger. I have processed all of your points of view and they have helped me challenge perceptions that I held.

Seeing a professional came up several times. Sage advice. I'm seeing a counsellor when and as I'm able to afford it. It's my top priority (other than food and shelter), but it's hard as I'm self-employed and sick. I can't see her as much as I'd like to.

Vleit - Thanks for sharing your experience, and for your kind words. I too had that same experience with my previous girlfriend. The constant excitement and panic, as you put it, drove me absolutely mental! I stayed in that relationship way too long as a result of it. I think the dynamic is a bit different in this relationship. There is still the push/pull effect going on. But generally it's me doing the pushing and then freaking out that I'm going to lose her and panicking to get her back :(


GalaGirl - Thank you so much for the post.

One thing you could do right now is to stop using "feel" in place of "think" or "observe."

This really, really resonated with me! I'm so glad you managed to get the work persnickety in there. That cracked me up for some reason! I honestly feel that you hit on something very important to me with that statement. Stating that I 'feel' something that is actually an experience or observable reality really conveys a lack of trust in my own perception of reality. Something I've always struggled with, I think in part to gas-lighting and abuse. How can I have self worth and happiness if I'm not trusting in my fundamental perception of reality. It's going to be difficult learning to trust in my own experiences, but it's something that I'm going to be much more aware of.

"Ok... could you please repeat back what I said in your own words so I know you got it how I meant it?"

Two-fold - It helps validate my own experiences and clears up potential miscommunications. Love it!

It's not "forgetting" if this is chronic behavior. It's choosing to ignore or disregard it, and then claiming "forgetfulness"

kdt26417, thanks for your insight. I was resistant to this view point at first. It really just doesn't seem like her, but I made myself sit down and consider it anyway. I opened a dialogue with her this morning to discuss whether this was the case or not.

I hope this doesn't come across as some kind of relationship derived Stockholm syndrome. I honestly don't believe it's a conscious mechanism on her part. It's a hard thing to describe without knowing her. She's easily the most empathetic, nurturing and moral person I've ever met. Almost to a fault at times (if such things could ever be considered a fault). She can be almost Asperger in her interpretation of situations and emotions at times. An example would be in how she experiences jealousy. The whole insecurity pertaining to open relationships just doesn't occur to her on any level. So she really has to work hard at being conscious of what it is that triggers me. She really just can't relate. Literally not at all. As a result she just misses things that are obvious to me. I can see how much it hurts her when she feels like she's hurt me in some way, half the time it's because she's trying to protect my feelings but just gets it completely wrong. No matter how I look at it though, this is definitely an area of our relationship that needs continued attention.


If you stay in a relationship where you feel unsafe and power-less?

Spot on here too. I think that the issue here is more to do with myself. There are certain actions that Irena takes that hurt me and leave me feeling unsafe. These actions certainly need to be addressed, and when I actually become aware of them (reference boundaries and not understanding my own feelings) we address them together. Sometimes they re-occur, but it's consistently getting better. I think that a large portion of my feeling power-less and unsafe stems from me not understanding where my boundaries and triggers are. Therefore I can't communicate them effectively, I just switch off and withdraw instead. I see it manifest in all of my relationships in exactly the same way. I've literally been conditioned by my upbringing to hold no power, it was too dangerous to do so. Now that I'm becoming aware of it I have a steep learning curve ahead of me. I have never/don't think I will ever feel safe with anyone until I address this fundamental issue.

Our break up/getting back together could be summarised as;
I put her through months of torment by withdrawing emotionally/intimately.
She dealt with it as long as she could. Told me that she loves me and wants to be with me more than anything but can't deal with months going by without sex or feeling desired. So, she needs to see other people for her sexual needs.
We stayed best friends.
I cried a lot, and then put a lot of work in to dealing with my sexual abuse issues.
I've gotten a lot better with intimacy so we've naturally started to gravitate back toward one another.

She's young (25), has only been with 2 other guys and has a strong desire to explore sexually, with men and women. I'm a 36 year old dude with epic commitment issues that feels trapped when in a monogamous relationship.
I find that I start perceiving every moment as eternity. I can't just be present with someone. There's many facets to this. One that springs to mind is that I feel like I'm doing something wrong by the other person if I'm being intimate with them, unless I'm 100% certain that I want to be with them forever! It's an unreasonable expectation to put on myself.

There's so much positivity in our relationship. We're best friends. I have no doubt that she cares for me deeply and would do anything for me. She's held me whilst I've been on the edge of death several times now. She's supported me through countless freak outs and meltdowns that had nothing to do with our relationship. I think most importantly, were constantly growing together. I have learned more about myself in the last 2 years of our relationship than the rest of my life combined. I'm open to the idea of us not being together romantically. But before it gets to that point I want to know that I've done everything in my power to make it work. I feel I owe that to myself and Irena.


Thanks, you all are awesome.
Tim
 
Glad it helped you some.

I hope you are able to get to counseling in the way that you want in time.

A few things that stuck out to me...

I honestly don't believe it's a conscious mechanism on her part.

Does it matter if the behavior is conscious or not?

If she's Asperger, that might explain why she dings you sometimes without realizing/caring or forgets things. But you still get dinged. Whether the jug hits the rock or the rock hits the jug... the jug still gets it.

The bottom line is -- you can ask for her to change the behavior. If she forgets often -- to write things down. Form new habits.

Or if she's not going to change it? Stand further back so if she continues to behave that way you are not in the line of fire. You may also need to not take things as personally and change your expectations. Or a combo.

If you are coming from an abuse background and in your recovery you are extra sensitive/vigilant right now, and she's coming from an Asperger background where she's not esp "tuned in" to other people - there's a lot of places there where you can bump heads. Being aware of that might help dissipate some of the tension. That it isn't the people out to bug each other on purpose -- it's the situation. You are both patients AND caregivers for the other one. That's a tough load.

I think that a large portion of my feeling power-less and unsafe stems from me not understanding where my boundaries and triggers are. Therefore I can't communicate them effectively, I just switch off and withdraw instead. I see it manifest in all of my relationships in exactly the same way. I've literally been conditioned by my upbringing to hold no power, it was too dangerous to do so. Now that I'm becoming aware of it I have a steep learning curve ahead of me. I have never/don't think I will ever feel safe with anyone until I address this fundamental issue.

I am confused. Are you saying that you will not feel safe until you learn to speak up when people are stepping on your toes? But at the same time... you do not feel safe speaking up? So you end up stuck -- not happy being stepped on and not happy not speaking up about it?

Could you be confusing "safe" with "comfortable?"

Certainly there are times where one is not safe and it is not safe to speak up. I get that remaining silent was how to be safe in a certain period of your life where you were abused. Nobody wants more abuse raining down on them as a result of speaking up.

If you do not know yourself well, do not know your triggers are, do not know how to set personal boundaries -- I could see where you might not feel especially comfortable speaking up for yourself if someone steps on your toes. That's the price of admission to get to "comfortable speaking up for myself." You have to do it a few times while feeling uncomfortable. The skill is growing through DOING.

Could think about "safe" vs" comfortable." Like with being persnickety about how you use "feel" you might learn to become persnickety about how you use "safe." One is not comfortable sitting in a dentist chair getting work done on their teeth. One is usually pretty safe -- just not excited to be there nor thrilled to be having teeth worked on. But people get their cavities filled for the greater good -- so they can keep their teeth.

You might not be excited or thrilled about speaking up... but could do it all the same for your greater good. So people don't step on your toes in the short term and you get more comfortable advocating for yourself in the long term.

Abuse recovery takes times... but part of it might be learning to stop being extra sensitive/vigilant. Being able to relax again. You may have lived life before with ALL THINGS ON HIGH ALERT AT ALL TIMES because you did not know when more abuse might come. It sounds like you left the abuse. Things don't have to be so black and white like "abused right now" and "not abused right now." You don't have to live on high alert.

There can be more colors now. Figure out what is "dangerous" and what is "safe but uncomfortable" and what is "safe and comfortable" and whatever shades in between. Hopefully counseling can help you sort all that out.

I put her through months of torment by withdrawing emotionally/intimately.
She dealt with it as long as she could. Told me that she loves me and wants to be with me more than anything but can't deal with months going by without sex or feeling desired. So, she needs to see other people for her sexual needs.

It's ok to take a time out to think things through or just take a break. Could say "I need a time out. I will check back in a week. If it goes past that, you can check in with me." And then take the time out. Not just "disappear."

Don't withdraw with no info at all and leave Irena hanging. This way she knows what to do. Give you space for a week, and if you do not check in first, she can check in. That's better than "Wall of Silence for Who Knows How Long." If she's had to endure that before, you going into a time out could be triggering for HER because she doesn't know what kind of time out this is going to be.

I know counseling is most likely best here to unravel the deeper issues... but until you get there perhaps that is a small step you guys could try if you need a time out again? Let her know you are not going incommunicado for ages. At least let her know there will be a check in somewhere.

I feel like THINK I'm doing something wrong by the other person if I'm being intimate with them, unless I'm 100% certain that I want to be with them forever! It's an unreasonable expectation to put on myself.

Glad you see it is unreasonable expectations. The nice thing about recognizing that as an expectation you think you have to do is that you can change your mind about doing it.

I'm open to the idea of us not being together romantically. But before it gets to that point I want to know that I've done everything in my power to make it work. I feel I owe that to myself and Irena.

Hopefully Irena feels the same way and will also be doing her fair share of the work. If the shared stick has two ends, each one of you could carry your side of it so you can proceed together.

GL!
Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Back
Top