Thinking about poly, am I being unreasonable?

Stevefromtexas

New member
Hello to all,

My wife and I have been together for 13 years, married for 8, and have been strictly mono.

A few years ago, we both "lightly cheated" at right about the same time. No actual sex, supposedly, but it did get physical, and if not found out/caught, would probably have eventually got to sex. I have realized we both must have been missing something for it to be timed so perfect. We decided to try and work it out and continued our marriage. Since then, to sum it up, we have both engaged in flirtatious conversations and maybe even some "more than just a friend emotions" with others, which eventually again had means to get deeper if not found out. We are adults, so we have talked about this, and we both think what it comes down to is that we both enjoy the attention, the feeling of being wanted, and the excitement that comes from a new relationship with someone else.

I do still love her, and I believe she does me, but I can honestly say, while we love each other, we are not "in love." Now, after the fact, and even me admitting to my "friendships" with others, I feel that she did worse, because I never actually met up with any of these women behind her back, and she did meet up with her male friends. Granted, it was always in a group setting. It's not like she met up with him at his house all alone at 3AM. We both like the attention, but I feel she was more disrespectful to me, since she met up, and I was just sending texts.

Fast forward to now. She feels I'm cold and heartless and don't love her the way she wants to be loved. I understand this. My profession is one where you get hardened very quickly, and see the worst in people and the world. I don't doubt that I have a very slight level of PTSD. I try not to let it affect me, but it sometimes does. Very slightly, and nothing even worth mentioning in this conversation, so in a way, I feel I cut her a little slack.

Now I feel that she wants all that "love," but I am only willing to give her so much of myself because I feel she has betrayed me and violated my trust. I know I did too, but I feel she did worse, and the first time she had a "friendship" with one guy was before I did anything, and was still so in love with her, and she had 100% of me.

So, in closing, she wants 100% of me and I'm only willing to give, let's just say, 70%. I know that if I give her 100% I probably wouldn't have to worry about her doing anything, but I just see it as, "You fucked me over, and you want me to give you all of me so that you can be happy after you hurt me."

So we're at this stalemate where we both wonder if we are done. We don't want to be, but something's gotta give. So I looked into staying together but trying other things. We talked about open marriage, but we both think the jealousy and constant wondering would be too much for both of us. Then we said well, open marriage but no sex, just open to "date" others. But we thought what if after multiple dates real feelings started developing for the individual? That would that ruin our relationship. So I pitched the idea of us having a girlfriend. Us as in, we would both have to be on the same page.

Playing devil's advocate, anyone could say, well, why not a boyfriend? But to make it easy, that ain't gonna happen, and she doesn't ask that herself. Not to insult anyone, but we both find it easier to see two women together than two men, non-sexually or sexually.

I honestly feel that I can love more than one person without taking away love from the other. She has listened to me and heard me out, but I think it may just be to entertain my "thought" and not have any intention of following through with it. When I had my "friendships" I found myself more sensitive to her needs because my mindset was in the pleasing process due to my new friend at the time.

Sorry for babbling on. I'm just confused and hoping anyone can help.
 
I'd actually just suggest at least a few sessions of couples therapy, where you can determine if the two of you want to still be in a relationship, whether it's the form it is now, or maybe you two would choose to step back from a marriage sort of dynamic, date each other, but also date others. A poly-friendly therapist can also help ask the questions you both might be missing, about if polyamory is a realistic or viable option for the two of you.

I sure wouldn't want to be the girlfriend of a couple who had such obvious issues still, and most people wouldn't. Mainly it's the fact that you are hung up on how "she did worse" than you did makes it seem pretty clear that you two need to work through that problem before inviting other people to get entangled with you.
 
Fix the issues first. Always. It is totally unfair to any third party to be dragged through existing bs.

You feel she did worse. That's totally normal. I would bet money she feels you did worse. That's totally normal. The bottom line is that you each did something that hurt the other. If you want to fix things, you need to stop laying blame or trying to compete on who is worse. Start focusing on what to do to fix yourself.
 
As a person who was unknowingly brought into a fucked-up marriage, and in their case, unlike you, they failed to realize how broken their marriage was, I say, don't do it. I was a pawn in the game and ultimately disposable. I was devastated. You guys know your marriage is fucked up. So what do you really have to offer in the way of love and consideration?

Btw, this whole keeping score: "She cheated worse than I did," isn't going to work for you in the long run if you want to maintain your relationship. You both cheated. Period. The question is: "Why?" You're fooling yourself if you think you're less culpable because you didn't go as far as she did. Once you both stepped over that line, the game changed.
 
You need to do a lot of growing up and taking responsibility. Get into therapy and stop blaming her for this or that, and stop keeping score. You're either full partners willing to own your shit, or why stay?

And no one in their right mind would want to get involved with the two of you with such a mess going on! Marriage broken? DO NOT add more people!
 
Sounds like there are trust issues still. No sex, supposedly.

You've got some resentment. 70% investment as opposed to the 100%? By that math, this doesn't sound like your wife is truly on board. This sounds like pay back, or a backdoor way out of a failing marriage. Might be quicker to just pull the plug. Any kids involved? Staying together for the kids?
 
Let me cut and paste some of your sentences into groups, okay?

I am only willing to give her so much of myself because I feel she has betrayed me and violated my trust.

I know that if I give her 100% I probably wouldn't have to worry about her doing anything.

Consider what you need to heal the betrayed and violated trust so you can give her 100%, so that both you and she can forgive, make amends, repair, and put things behind you, so you can relax, and both be giving 100% to the shared marriage, to get to enjoy this:

I do still love her and I believe she does me.

... in a better way?

I just see it as "You fucked me over, and you want me to give you all of me so that you can be happy after you hurt me."

What about your happiness? Are you happy right now? Do you not want to be happy after being hurt?

Do you not want your wife to experience happiness ever again?

Do you not want the marriage to be happy?

How does holding onto the hurt help any of these, you, your wife, or your marriage move on to being happy?

What do you gain from wanting to keep it "in the stuck," especially when you too cheated on the marriage agreements? Is it that you want to play "blame-shifting" so you don't have to own your part in co-creating this situation? :(

We are at this stalemate where we both wonder if we are done. We don't want to be, but something's gotta give.

Well, if you both don't want to be done with your marriage, don't be! Start tending to it.

How about not engaging in marriage-damaging behavior like trying to figure out who made bigger mistakes? Are both willing to just let it go? Agree to say something like:

"Fine. We both made mistakes here and co-created this situation. Let's not merry-go-round who did what worse and keep it stuck. Let's focus on moving it forward from here."

How does holding back to "70%" help you move it forward and help support your marriage?

I would not begin new relationships with other people at this time. You guys do not seem to be managing a mono-ship well right now. Adding more players to change to a poly-ship is just more stress on a system that is already struggling. This marriage needs more time and attention paid to it right now, not less, because you're both distracted cultivating relationships with others. Spend more time tending and cultivating this relationship. It's been neglected.

(And your potential dating partners deserve to be more than just "filler people" for you and wife to date and avoid repairing your marriage problems if you actually ever open, right? They deserve healthy partners to date, not broken people, right?)

I'd suggest buckling down and doing some soul searching. Again--

  • What do you need from her for you to become willing to give THE MARRIAGE 100% again? (Not her, the MARRIAGE.)
  • What do you need from yourself for you to become willing to give THE MARRIAGE 100% again?
  • What does she need from you to become willing to give THE MARRIAGE her 100% again?
  • What does she need from herself to become willing to give THE MARRIAGE her 100% again?
  • What blocks you from being able to give the marriage 100%?
    • How can you both work to remove these obstacles in your way?
    • How can you work to remove these obstacles in your way?
  • What blocks her from being able to give the marriage 100%?
    • How can you both work to remove these obstacles in her way?
    • How can she work to remove these obstacles in her way?

Focus on that at this time. See what answers you and she come up with and if that helps you sort yourselves out.

Hang in there,
Galagirl
 
Last edited:
First off, thank you for all the honest replies. You all have opened my eyes.

But please allow me to explain my thoughts behind the "trying poly" comment. I may still be wrong, but I just think it might help me sort out my issues.

We have a three-year old son. He is a major part of why we stay together. But I feel we still love each other.

My reasoning behind poly is: since we both mutually like the feelings of being wanted, someone new, etc., I thought bringing someone in might give us both that spark. This is not a backwards attempt at me trying to get back at her, or get my way sexually. May sound weird, but I enjoy the emotional side of it more. If it gets physical, then so be it, but that is not my overall goal.

With a third "in my mind" there would sort of be a mediator at all times, regardless of which two are having a problem, and could maybe help the situation.

I do admit that I never really thought about how the third would be dragged through our problems, so thank you for bringing that to my attention. I wouldn't want to put someone through that.

I don't know if this matters either but, for example, let's just say she had a really close friend, and we were all good together, would this be better or worse than finding a stranger, since we already have that friendship to begin with? For the record, she doesn't have a friend I'm considering this with. I'm just curious.

I will try and take your advice on fixing myself. I know we are in a bad spot. It I would just like to try anything to make it work for us.
 
With a third "in my mind" there would also sort of be a mediator at all times, regardless of which two are having a problem,

That's called a "counselor," not a "shared gf."

You assume the "friend" even has the willingness to play this role.

You assume the "friend" even has the ability, the skills, to mediate/counsel you, which, even if she were a counselor by profession, would be a conflict of interest to treat you while dating you.

If what you want is a "mediator," it seems easier to just hire a professional mediator/counselor-type person from the get-go.

I know we are in a bad spot. I would try anything to make it work for us.

So hire a professional to help guide you guys through this. Decide to invest in your marriage health.

I mean that kindly. I know you are struggling right now and may not be seeing/thinking clearly. But no healthy person wants to sign up to be some broken married couple's "freebie counselor," who smooches and shares sex with them on the side. That's a messed-up dynamic. :(

Have you considered the other ways it could play out? If anyone were signing up with bells on for that, one might wonder if they could be a cowgirl/cowboy person seeking to break you guys up on purpose to rope off one of you. Or it might be a person who is even more broken than you guys are, sucking you both dry. Risking this at this time could help you both attain health and well being in the marriage HOW?

Tread carefully when you are feeling upset, okay? Do not rush into action just to avoid sitting with yucky feelings.

I see that you want to feel "yummy" feelings instead right now, like when you had your "friend." The NRE-crush stuff felt yummier than the feelings you might be feeling right now, and you want to have something "yummy" again.

Sit with the yucky feelings anyway. Let the feelings be felt and see what they bring to the surface. Let time pass even if you feel squirmy waiting. See if time brings clarity to your situation.

Already you have good clues for things you could change. Look --

I honestly feel that I can love more than one person without taking away love from the other.

Great! You could start by loving the 3 you are already involved with, not 70%, but 100%. Love your wife, love yourself and love your marriage. (And love your son. Okay, that's 4.)

When I had my "friendships" I found myself more sensitive to her needs because my mindset was in the pleasing process due to my new friend at the time.

Great! Then get your mind in the pleasing process.

Meet your needs for a healthy marriage. Be sensitive to your own needs for peace, health, and happiness.
Meet her needs for a healthy marriage. Be sensitive to her needs for peace, health and happiness.
Meet the marriage's needs for a healthy marriage. Be sensitive to its needs for peace, health, and happiness.

Stop holding back, dude. Be an active participant.

You are aware she wants and welcomes all of your love. You determine to dole out 70% only. How's this being in the "pleasing process" or being sensitive to your/her/the marriage's needs?

You could take a leap of faith; invest your time, energy and effort in your own marriage. See if that serves you better than the holding back.

You could consider grabbing on to your wife and your marriage and letting go of the resentments, rather than letting go of your wife/marriage by tiny cuts and increments because you grab on to the resentments and hold hard to those instead.

We do have a son. He is a major part of why we stay together. But we still love each other.

You could focus on this. Before you think or say anything, ask yourself, "Is this me doing loving behavior toward me, my wife, my son and my marriage?" Maybe that could help you sort yourself out. It's hard to risk getting dinged again when you were dinged once before. But to arrive at "new trust being built," you could allow yourself to be vulnerable to a new ding. Take the scary leap, and land, and come to find you were ding-free. You find you can trust you wife not to ding you anymore. But to learn that, you actually have to leap at some point.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Is your wife bisexual? Perhaps I misunderstood, but I gathered from your post that she's not. Is it just that you're more squicked out by the thought of being involved with a guy than she is by the thought of being involved with a gal, so you've decided that she can just suck it up and have a sexual relationship with someone she's not actually attracted to? If so, that line of reasoning is all kinds of fucked up.
 
No, she is not bisexual. However, it's not like you assume, where I am trying to force it upon her. We have spoken about this, and while she did not say yes, she did not seem too bothered by it either. I explained, and she played devil's advocate and said, "Well, why don't we get a BF?" After speaking about it, she seemed more okay with a GF. Please don't mistake me. I am not trying to force this. At this point, it was just something that came to mind. Forgive me if I am coming off insulting, as that is not my objective.
 
Why can't you have a girlfriend on your own?
 
Get yourself a therapist, not a girlfriend.

For goodness sakes, your wife is not even bisexual. In what universe could this ever work out well?

Work on getting that wanted feeling back from your wife, or end the marriage. Do not bring some poor woman into your mess.
 
Yep, you are being unreasonable.

No she is not bisexual. However, it's not like you assume, where I am trying to force it upon her. She did not say yes, she did not seem too bothered by it either. She played devil's advocate and said, "Well, why don't we get a BF?" After speaking about it she seemed more okay with a GF. I am not trying to force this. It was just something that came to mind. Forgive me if I am coming off insulting.

Honestly, I don't feel you're coming off as insulting. You're coming across as ignorant. Suppose I were a bisexual female interested in a couple, as you want. Or maybe you don't care if I'm gay, straight, bi, whatever. You think you can talk me into wanting to experiment with you and your wife. You clearly don't really care if your wife is into me, so why would you care if I was into both you and your wife, as long as I'm willing to have sex with both?

But, let's say that I am a bisexual female. Tell me, what's in it for me? To be the plaything of a couple that sees me as an object? Your tone shows no indication that you have considered my feelings. I'm sensing a lot of couple-privilege here. I'm supposed to want to be with a woman who is "okay" with me? Yeah, super flattering. And I'm supposed to be the solution to a broken marriage? Probably expected to develop the same feelings for both of you simultaneously, otherwise I risk the wife getting jealous and discarding me at her whim? Lovely.

So, again, what's in it for me? Are you going to spoil me silly with lots of trips, clothes, jewelry, etc.? Are you going to indulge me in all my bedroom fantasies?
 
"Bring in" another woman to be your mediator?! Holy shit, who the hell would want that? I can't imagine anyone saying, "Here I am, loves. Just fuck me and I'll help you with all your problems. I don't want a real relationship of my own. Don't worry."

It sounds like you are desperate to fix things, but out of desperation are making really ridiculous suggestions that are just doomed to fail.

Therapy, therapy, therapy! Start looking for a good therapist. Do it now. Today.
 
Clearly from all of your responses it shows that I am not thinking clearly. I appreciate the honesty in helping me out. I suppose I was just looking for an option to add some emotional spark to our marriage without considering all the factors involved.
 
If there's a little bit of boredom, a spark can work, like saying, "Let's do more fun things together." But when a marriage is crumbling, and hearts are breaking, what kid of remedy is adding a spark going to be? It would only be superficial and not enough, like putting a little Band-Aid on a huge, gaping wound.

You don't need a spark, you need to go deeper into yourselves and look inward, and be brave enough to share with each other. Don't look for outside remedies like extra sex partners or something like that, which might drive you further apart! The answers you need are all in you, both of you.

I suggest, in addition to therapy, reading this book: Journey of the Heart by John Welwood. It's all about regaining intimacy, deepening love, and communicating in love relationships. Highly recommend! He also wrote other books called Love and Awakening and Perfect Love, Imperfect Relationships, and holds workshops for couples. On his website, John Welwood says: "True intimacy is only possible when two people connect being-to being. The conditioned personality functions in defensive, reactive ways, and is therefore incapable of real intimacy . . . [A] deeper quality of presence-- more than any strategy or technique-- is what provides a true resolution to most relationship problems." I've only read Journey of the Heart. It's a classic, and brilliant.
 
Last edited:
I guess my reasoning was, essentially what drives us apart is fuzzy feelings of something new. If we were to find someone new together as a team and all three of us were okay with it, then we all three get the fuzzy feelings and there's no need to do it behind each other's back. Once again sex is not my motivation. As far as her being our mediator, I feel it's been taken out of context. What I meant was whichever two of us are having a disagreement about any issue that comes with a relationship , the third unbiased person (me, wife, GF) could act as the mediator. It's not "She is our sex toy, mediator, who we truly care nothing about, that was chosen by only me, who is essentially forcing my wife to be with even though she has no feelings for her." This would all be a "team effort" for the three of us.

Once again, I appreciate all your comments.

GalaGirl, you have been awesome!
 
Now how would someone be unbiased if they have a personal stake with the people involved?

Your logic is screwed up on so many levels. You are just looking to torpedo your marriage and sink it once and for all.

Your wife is STRAIGHT, with no interest in pursuing other women, yet you want to bring another woman into the marriage to fix things. WHAT THE DEUCE? Nothing like being forced into a relationship with someone you are not physically or emotionally into. How would you feel if your wife forced you into a relationship with a man?
 
Back
Top