Which way to turn?

Is it odd that it never even occured to me to think about it from that perspective?

Yes and no. It's hard to see it from the outside in when you are so involved. It's even harder to remove yourself from a situation when it was so vital to who you are now.

People become attatched to firsts. She was the first to help you fully feel, she was the first to try this open honest communication thing with, she was the first to make you go "oh maybe theres more here than sex".

That's a lot to have invested in someone. And you had no healthy end to it. Because everything was dodged around and not discussed you left at the end hold the pieces of your heart that she smashed going 'WTF?'.

It's hard to move past someone you have had that many firsts with and that much invested in.

That's where coping skills come in, and since you've only dealt in anger most your life, you don't have the means to do that.

It's not odd, I don't think. Maybe others have better insight. But personaly it makes sense that you wouldn't see it that way. I'm just not sure why it hadn't dawned on me to say something. It might have helped with the healing, to know why you were so attatched and had such a hard time letting go.
 
Oh my goodness!! Okay, so admittedly I didn't read through your whole Blog. That's just a lot of pages of reading lol. But, I did read the first few and the last couple, so I've got a pretty good idea of what's been going on.

When you start out, your story couldn't be any closer to ours if you were us. J is a serial cheater. But, like you, I have always forgiven him. I liked your answer to RP when she asked you why, because it's the exact same answer that I give people when they ask me why I forgive J. I have chronic pain issues which really have eaten up a lot of my time and attention from him over the past 8 years as well. But, we are now talking and realizing these things and working on them. I have come to the realization that he is poly and that him having sex with or loving another woman, doesn't mean that he loves me any less or her any more. And, I can honestly say, I'm okay with it!!

He still has a long ways to go about the lying, because like Karma, J has gotten really bad about the lies. Anytime I ask him why he lies to me so much about these things, he always replies, "Because I was trying to protect you. I didn't want you to hurt and I knew that if you knew the truth, you would hurt badly." Well, there's a lot of truth to that statement. Before, I was trying to force him to be something that he wasn't, monogamous. Truth would have really hurt me. Now though, I know who he is and I'm perfectly fine with it and am actually being very encouraging for him (have even been trying to find him a girlfriend lol). And in return for me realizing who he is and encouraging him that way, he has been so much more open and completely honest with me. I love it!! I have this board to thank for a lot of that. It has been a huge help!

On the teasing note, we are exactly the same way!! We tell each other along with friends and family, "If we didn't tease ya, you wouldn't think we loved ya!"

Yeah it is a bit of a book isn't it? But it is a good idea of how things went from begining to current. Some things happened that we didn't post, more to save feelings than anything else. But they don't really change the general idea of it all.

I don't know if Karma and I would have worked things out if it hadn't been for everyone here. I started out here because Karma had said Cricket was someone he had recently met and had feelings for. We had just agreed to start looking outside the marriage, so I was all for exploring where things went. Little did I know the history of it all.

Well I had some idea, like I had some idea he was lying the other night. Just not the details.

I hope things progress for you guys in a positive way. Honesty and communication are the two things I will preach on forever. Not just in the Poly relationship. In all relationships. Our marriage is as strong as it is now because we talk to eachother. And sometimes we say things that hurt, but it's better to get it out there than to hold it in and letting it fester into something horrible years later.

Sometimes that honesty needs to wait until emotions are a little less raw (I am horrible at this) but it still needs to be put out there and talked about. And as much he needs to be honest with you and work to rebuild things, you need to provide an atmosphere where he feels safe to do that. Not saying you aren't or you haven't, just expressing what I've learned.

For me it was lying that hurt, not the actions taken. Honesty is and has always been, such a big thing for me I felt he didn't respect me, didn't love me and didn't trust me enough to be honest. Not saying it wouldn't have hurt. I'm sure it would have. But I think the healing process would have been easier had I known. Because then we were not only dealing with this new demension of our relationship, but I was also dealing with the lies, the betrayal, and this woman who was brought into my home under false pretense. It was a giant cluster fuck that I am so happy to past.

I look forward to meeting Karmas new friend an I hope things work out for them. It's nice to be involved from the begining and to share the NRE instead of wonder about who he's going off to cheat on me with. I can be there for him as a wife and a friend this time round and honestly it's only made me love him more.
 
Last edited:
That's awesome!! It really give me hope for our future. I really needed to hear that, because a girl that he had wanted to bring in and she didn't agree AT ALL, just sent me a message saying how messed up I was for letting him do this and that I was "NEVER AND I MEAN NEVER going to be happy with him". She followed that statement up with "I know that hurts to hear, but it's the truth". It didn't hurt to hear, because I know it's not truth and I won't accept those words into my heart. But, it did really piss me off lol.

Lies are the HARDEST!! I too hold honesty so dear and near to my heart. When people speak honestly to me, whether it hurts or not, it speaks love to me. So, I completely understand how it made you feel, because I feel those same things when J lies to me, and I always know when he's lying. I have told him, "I know you better than any other person out there, sometimes even better than you know yourself. You cannot expect to lie to me and me not know it." Yet, he still does it.

But!!! On a great note. He has been nothing but honest with me for the past week now. He has come clean about everything. There's a girl that he's been flirting around with for a couple of months now from work. I kept asking him, "What's going on? Where is this going?" And he would swear up and down that there was nothing going on, he just enjoyed talking to her, blah, blah, blah. Well last week I told him that it was okay to go ahead and see her, but we needed to bring her in. He finally opened up!! He told me that yes, they've already been seeing each other and sleeping together. He also said, "But, we can't bring her in." Why? Because he lied to her to get the relationship going. He told her that we were in the middle of a divorce, so as far as she's concerned, I'm not part of the picture. It hurt to hear that, but I loved it so much that he was being honest. I didn't even get upset with him. I've allowed him to go ahead and continue seeing her because it's not something that is going to last. She leaves for college in 2 weeks and we move from OK to NM not long after that (and he'll even be gone for 8 weeks for training for this new job in upstate KS). So, it's about to end very soon. I have a very hard time with him lying to her, but with all of us going separate ways very soon, I'm just letting it be. She can count it as her fun for the summer before college and not be destroyed by finding out that he's lied so much to her.

On our end though, he has told me every time he is going to meet up with her, what they are doing, where they are going, what they have done (even sexually) afterwards, etc. He even talks on the phone with her in front of me now. I LOVE IT!! Yes, I have moments where he does something for her or says something to her that I have jealousy rise up, but I beat it with a stick and kick it right out. It's mostly just silly NRE things that I tend to miss from when we first met and had NRE lol.

I look forward to the next girlfriend and being there from the beginning!! I just have this excitement about it that brings me peace to know that everything is going to be alright and wonderful.

I have worked very hard over the last year to make things comfortable enough for him to be honest. Admittedly, I have failed many times by trying to force him instead of inviting him, but it's getting better. I'm getting there. We're getting there. :)
 
Last edited:
I responded on your blog cuz I saw it before this...but the point is the same regardless of which blog :)


You and you can decide if you are happy with things. I had plenty of people tell me I should leave, or how could I put up with that, or I was too pathetic to find anyone else so I stayed with him.

None of that is true. For us.

Doesn't mean it is or isn't true for anyone else.

Yes you have to make a safe place for him to be honest, but he needs to be honest in order to fix things.

I'm not going to tell you to stay or leave or any of that. I'm not in your marriage. But I am going to say, that you should be happy, healthy and sane. If your not, then something needs fixed and you both need to be willing to fix it. If not, you either decided to put up with it or you don't.

Karma and I both put in a lot of work in the last year and a half. We decided together how we needed/wanted things to be and we've worked on making that happen.
 
I can honestly say that we are both in this TOGETHER. Since the honesty has come out from him and I've told him that I now realize who he is and what he needs, and that I'm more than happy to let him be the real him, things have been great! We have laughed and had more random conversations (in depth ones too) than we have in a couple months. We are really enjoying our marriage right now and the level that we've come to already. I know that we won't always have an easy road from here, it's life, there's bound to be bumps, but we are really working on this together, so I'm sure that we will be wonderfully happy. This is one of those growing moments where we'll look back and say, "That really sucked at the time, but look at how far we've come! Wouldn't change it for a second."
 
I relate a lot to both of you. :)

My hubs and I were nonmonogamous from the start. I'd been nonmonogamous for about 5 years with my previous husband, and he was just not a monogamous person, which was obvious! I told him from the start that honesty was the most important thing, not the rest, but it still took YEARS for him to be able to be honest with me. It was a definite learning process.

I also always knew when he was lying to me. He could never figure out how, as many times there was no real reason for me to think so other than I just knew in my gut. After a while he realized it was stupid to continue lying, but even then it was like an automatic reaction sometimes... his first instinct was to lie -- to make it easier, to not hurt me, to not deal with the problem-- many reasons I'm sure.

We're finally past that, but we were close to leaving each other a few times. We actually broke up about 6 years ago (before we were married). I came home from a trip to my best girlfriends and told him I just couldn't handle his dishonesty. It was making me into a crazy person because I was second guessing everything he said, and looking for clues that he was lying-- just crazy stuff I didn't need. I think he was happy at first--freedom and all that-- it lasted about two months until he realized absolute freedom to do whatever you want comes at a price and it isn't all that it's cracked up to be.

Anyway... it's still work sometimes, but we HAVE come such a long way. He's really stepped up this past year, opened up more, communicated more, he's going to go to counseling as soon as he gets home (for himself)... these things are the reason I've stayed. I don't expect anyone to be perfect, but there does need to be a certain amount of self-work and progress and growing -- for myself as well!

But I agree... happy, safe and sane-- VERY important.
 
Karma's lies were to cover his own ass. In some small part I think there was some worry of my feelings. But the overall deciding factor was "she won't let me do this, she'll be mad if she finds out, I want to do this, so I won't tell her and I'll lie"

Same thing he did the other night. We have no money right now. That's what it is to college students. That will be changing soon, but for now, we're fucking broke. So the club he frequents had a free night to celebrate being open for however many years and we were supposed to go together. I ended deciding it was too hot for me to breathe outside (when the weather ppl say code orange to red my asthmatic self stays inside). So off he want to hang out with friends.

Somewhere in there he decided to take out money to drink. Then when I called to find out where the hell he was, he said he was sobering up. Lieing about where the alcohol came from.

I knew he was lieing. And he did fess up when he came home. We had a long night of talking. At one point I was so sick of hearing exscuses I almost told him to get out.

But we are all human and we do make mistakes. and the point of all of that was yes, for Karma as well, it is an ingrained reaction to "cover ass". I thought we were past it. I didn't realize it was a constant thing. To choose to be honest. I'm proud of him for the work he's put in and what we have accomplished so far. I guess if he was gonns slip up I'd rather it be over beer than something else.

Once again communication saved our asses. We talked it out and after cooling off we had some amazing make up sex.

It was frustrating at the time. But I realized I had to take it for what it was and move on.
 
I'm completely convinced that lies (between spouses) have NOTHING to do with "protecting" the other person, they are to protect the liars ass. My husband used this line on me "I didn't want to get you to be upset". Yeah, not to save my feelings, but to save him from dealing with an "upset" me. I understand that it is ingrained and takes constant effort to changed that. I have to remind myself that he needs to know that I appreciate it when he does fess up immediately and doesn't try to hide something, no matter how hurt I am at the time. Not easy to remember.:p

Here's the money conversations at my house. :rolleyes:
me: "How much did such and such cost"
him: "$30"
Then a week later I find the reciept and it was $39.95 plus tax and a replacement part to hook it up, etc. So the total reciept was more like $60. He's getting MUCH better, but I'm at the point where if he gives me a round number, I always ask "Is it $30 or 38.95?" When it comes to money being spent, I'm not sure who he is trying to decieve more, me or himself.
 
I do this thing with my husband where I'll say "I guess enough time has passed that I can tell you about this now..."
 
Hi!
Been lurking for a few months and have followed your thread and others, with interest.

Karma called Saturday night, admitedly thinking with his other head. Recapping tonight we saw exactly why we put the call first rule into play. He just met her, he knows little about her. I wasn't okay with them having sex. Playing around, sharing the tent, coming home with a hickey ;) no issues.

I am looking for some insight. How can you be sure that playing around and getting a hickey is all that happened, even though you didn't want him to? Or when you say they played around, do you mean they fucked after he called to ask and you're okay with that? Or... how do you know he didn't fuck her anyway and just said nothing happened?

This is what is so confusing to me - how do you trust someone who has lied and cheated so many times before? It has never been an issue in my relationship, but I have friends who have also tolerated dishonest partners before. One in particular started trusting her husband again, only to find out he was lying and pretending all over again. Plus she discovered he was stealing from some of our friends, which adds another dimension to realizing what a liar he is. Now she feels like such a fool, because essentially he pulled the wool over her eyes as usual. We (her friends) are doing all we can to support her as she gets through this.

So, I'd love to know how you managed to get to this trusting place. Don't you ever wonder if you're being made a fool again?

... he stayed up all night talking to her and is at 5pm he is still asleep.

... I was a bit upset that he seemed to pull away from me. Getting him to tell me anything about her was like pulling teeth. But I'm chalking it up to campout fatigue cuz we talked the other night and he was very open.

Fatigue from... camping or sex? See, if my partner was that difficult to get information from, I'd wonder what he was hiding. But you do not have no doubt AT ALL about what went on between him and her or anyone else while he was away (or another time)? What if you found out later that he broke boundaries again and just knows how to lie so well that he makes you believe he is reforming? What if you found out that he badmouths you and your illness to get away with fucking others? These things could happen. This is what my friend is going through with her husband who has been completely untrustworthy but had her fooled. What would be your plan of action to protect yourself?

I hope you don't mind me asking all this, but I find your story really compelling! I want to understand the issues in polyamory from every possible angle. It seems that, from what you have said here in this blog, you always let him come back. I don't think I could do that after one fuck-up, never mind numerous times!

It's hard for me to grasp - how do you manage to hold onto your dignity and be able to face all those people who knew what he was doing and didn't tell you? In the beginning of this thread, even other members here asked you asked you why you forgave him so easily and stayed. And yet here you still are, quickly forgiving his lies and certain he will be honest from now on. I'm sure we all could learn something from you! What a lesson! Thanks.
 
Last edited:
How can you be sure that playing around and getting a hickey is all that happened, even though you didn't want him to? Or when you say they played around, do you mean they fucked after he called to ask and you're okay with that? Or... how do you know he didn't fuck her anyway and just said nothing happened?

I can't be sure. Can we ever be 100% sure of anything? I can't continue to live a life of second guessing. He's put in a hell of a lot of work to show me that he is trying. All I can do is believe that he is genuine in what he says.

This is what is so confusing to me - how do you trust someone who has lied and cheated so many times before?
How do you continue to be in a relationship with someone who became so reclusive they never left their room and your only communication was over pain pills? The lying and the cheating is not the whole of who he is. For the most part it was a symptom of something being wrong in our relationship, and his past. We as humans often assosciate our spuses with the role models we had growing up. Karma often compared me to his mother and the results of situations with her. He didnt trust me to be okay with certain things, or to mean what I said about honesty, because his mother often said "if you tell the truth the punishment will be less" but then it would result in an even larger tantrum and punishment. Having had that as a basis his entire life, it was difficult to trust that any woman really meant what they said. With all that in mind, we started working on that. Are still working on that. It's not an easy thing to let go of when it's become a survival mechanism. He needs to have trust in me just as much as I do in him. He never gave me a chance to prove that I could be taken at my word. Something he learned very quickly as we ventured into this.

Don't you ever wonder if you're being made a fool again?
Is it me being made a fool? Or is if it were to happen again, is it not Karma makin himself look like an ass? Part of my healing was to let go of the 'being made a fool' thought process. My love for him allows me to forgive him. My understanding of his actions allows for me to forgive him. My strength in myself allows me to forgive him. If he were to cross boundries, cheat or lie again, it is not my fault, it's his. I am not at fault for his actions he is. I have provided a safe place for honesty, I have done my share of the work to repair our marriage, if he is being deceptive he has no reason to be and therefor it is on him not me. He can choose to live a free life out the open where he can have not only my love but that of others, or he can lie and be deceptive and take advantage of who I am what I have to give. Again that is not on me, that is on him.


Fatigue from... camping or sex? See, if my partner was that difficult to get information from, I'd wonder what he was hiding. But you do not have no doubt AT ALL about what went on between him and her or anyone else while he was away (or another time)?

I was a bit curious as to why the pull back. But after sleeping in his own bed, the next day I expressed my concern and we talked about it. He went into any detail I asked for and on his own accord went through and showed me pictures and talked quite a bit about her. Could he have been hiding something, sure. Again anything is possible and nothing is ever 100%, but I have no reason to believe otherwise.

What if you found out later that he broke boundaries again and just knows how to lie so well that he makes you believe he is reforming?
Karma is a terrible liar. But if by some magic intervention he was able to begin lying in such way, well there isn't much I can do without the truth of the matter. If I were to find out it was all a lie, then he would be packing his bags. There is only so much I can forgive and when I've given so much and worked so hard to fix ou problems, if that still wasn't enough to warrant his honesty, well then it's time to move the hell on.

What if you found out that he badmouths you and your illness to get away with fucking others? These things could happen. This is what my friend is going through with her husband who has been completely untrustworthy but had her fooled. What would be your plan of action to protect yourself?

This is again his problem and not mine. If he is that pathetic and shallow that he needs to bad mouth me in order to get laid, how is it my problem? My illness has been very hard on both of us. And there is a difference between venting and badmouthing. I have no doubt there have been times hes needed someone to listen. It is very difficult to be a caregiver to your spouse. If that venting led to other forms of compassion, well good for him. It's really good for the soul to have someone give a damn about you. But again this is on him. These are his actions and choices. As far having a plan in place to protect myself...when I love I love fully. It would hurt to find out that all we've worked for was a sham. But I know I have put my all into making it work.

I hope you don't mind me asking all this, but I find your story really compelling! I want to understand the issues in polyamory from every possible angle. It seems that, from what you have said here in this blog, you always let him come back. I don't think I could do that after one fuck-up, never mind numerous times!

I don't mind at all that's why it's out there. I never thought I would forgive it. But when your faced with it, it becomes a different story. There are reasons and realities that aren't in place in hypotheticals.

It's hard for me to grasp - how do you manage to hold onto your dignity and be able to face all those people who knew what he was doing and didn't tell you?
Again Karma's actions are not a reflection on who I am as a person. My dignity is not effected by my husband. I am my own person and in charge of my own choices and feelings. Just as he is his. Some of those who knew and never said a word, I no longer speak with, because there were promises there that were broken. And when it came down to it, their own guilt made it hard for them to face me, not the other way around. Others didn't know me well enough to feel it was their place, and in that I can't blame them. But that doesn't change who I am. There will always be naysayers in this world. There will always be people who say I should have left the first time. They do not live my life. For all the hurt and pain there has been much more joy in our 9 years together. I liken to the Garth Brooks song The Dance "I could have missed the pain, but I'd have mised the dance." I'm not willing to say the dance we've had hasn't been worth the pain.

A few years ago my dad was very ill and sitting in the hospital waiting room his sister told me I was better to marry someone who could take care of me than to marry for love. "Do you think your mother would have married him if she's known their lives would be rocked by his medical problems over and over?" I was stunned that his own sister could say this. Of course I think my mother would have married him knowing that. They have a love that has survived 31 yrs of what life could throw at them. Including the first 3 years of their marriage having them assigned to military bases hundreds of miles apart. My dad had 3 heart attacks and my mom who wanted to be a stay at home mom, went to work fulltime to cover bills while he recouped. They are not perfect people, but they love eachother and they have weathered lifes storms by clinging to that love. I don't see what I am doing as any different.

You don't marry for ease. Honestly marriage would be quite boring if we did. You marry for love. And in that love you learn to care for eachother, faults and all. Mistakes happen. It's hard to relearn how to live when you were living to survive for so long.


In the beginning of this thread, even other members here asked you asked you why you forgave him so easily and stayed. And yet here you still are, quickly forgiving his lies and certain he will be honest from now on.
The forgiveness was not quick. It took a lot of work. And when I found out about the last round I was seriously considering divorce. Had been for sometime. We decided to give it a year. To put in the work and in a year we'd decide if it was worth keeping. We celebrated that year this past May and we are obviously still together. It took a lot of self work, a lot of healing and a lot of work together to get to where we are.

I stayed because I love him. Because he is so much more than a cheater. Because he gets me, to my core he understands me. I can fully and completely be myself with him. I can share my dreams with him and I can share my sorows with him. And in that he is fully present. He is protective of me, even when some of his actions say otherwise. There is no one I can be as completely me with as I can with him. He says he's not a teacher, yet he can help understand things in a way that doesn't make me feel like an idiot. When I got sick with one of my many issues, he was at every dr's appt and took it on himself to learn about female reproduction so he could fully understand what I was going through. He takes care of me. He aside from my mother, is the only person I feel safe and comfortable enough to be completely vulnerable with. So why did I stay, why did I forgive? Because there is so much more to a person than their mistakes.


I'm sure we all could learn something from you! What a lesson! Thanks.
I hope there is something to be learned from it all. No matter how small the lesson.
 
I stayed because I love him. Because he is so much more than a cheater. Because he gets me, to my core he understands me. I can fully and completely be myself with him. I can share my dreams with him and I can share my sorows with him. And in that he is fully present. He is protective of me, even when some of his actions say otherwise. There is no one I can be as completely me with as I can with him. He says he's not a teacher, yet he can help understand things in a way that doesn't make me feel like an idiot. When I got sick with one of my many issues, he was at every dr's appt and took it on himself to learn about female reproduction so he could fully understand what I was going through. He takes care of me. He aside from my mother, is the only person I feel safe and comfortable enough to be completely vulnerable with. So why did I stay, why did I forgive? Because there is so much more to a person than their mistakes.


BEAUTIFUL!!! You have expressed exactly what I have shared with others about our situation and our relationship. While J does do some things that are hurtful and so on, he is so much more than that. J has also been to all of my doctors appointments. If I'm not feeling well and having a bad pain day, he is the first one at my side to see how he can help and what he can do.

J saved my life when I had my accident. There is a depth added to a relationship when you go through something like that, that wouldn't be there otherwise. We know beyond a shadow of a doubt that we can't live life without the other so long as we have a choice in it. He stole my heart the moment I met him and he tells me all the time that I stole his that moment as well. Nobody is perfect!! We all do stupid stuff time and again. But, it's really wonderful when we know that we have someone in our lives that loves us regardless and is willing to help us better ourselves and work through it so that we can try to avoid those mistakes again in the future. I am a better person because of J. While things do hurt that he does sometimes, I wouldn't change it one bit because it has helped us both grow to be the people that we are today, to have a depth to our relationship that we never thought possible.

Yes, he's made mistakes, but he is as well, so much more than that. He is an amazingly beautiful human being that truly loves me.

Beautiful responses M!!
 
I'm glad you have the strength to see it that way so early on.

Some people choose to see Karma as this horrible person who is only out for himself. People have claimed to love him and then turned their backs.

When I love, I love fully. And I am not going to run away simply because there are problems. When you love someone you work through the issues. Those that see him that way, never understood the gift they really had by having him in their lives. That's their loss.

We've hurt eachother, in different ways. But we've given eachother the chance to move past that. That's what love is.

All I can do is be honest and true to who I am. This is the path I've chosen to walk, and I'll walk it proudly.

The other thing that comes to mind is how do you ever know if your partner is cheating? I would rather have it out in the open than be one of those couples that divorces after 20yrs b/c one of them has been having an affair the whole time.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for answering my questions so truthfully and directly.

Regarding your last post... it is admirable to stand by someone who has made mistakes, even terrible ones, and to do lots of work on a difficult relationship with someone you so deeply love.

But do you think there is ever a point where the disrespectful treatment you receive (lying, cheating) tips the scales too much toward a painful direction - so that trying to fix the relationship is no longer an option? Do you have a personal "mile marker" or threshhold which means the absolute end if he crosses it? Or is your willingness to forgive never-ending? To me, there's got to be a realization that allowing too much is just setting oneself up for abuse. And also, do you consider his treatment of other people (poly relationships) when you look at how he is and the kind of man you want to be with?
 
Last edited:
But do you think there is ever a point where the disrespectful treatment you receive (lying, cheating) tips the scales too much toward a painful direction - so that trying to fix the relationship is no longer an option?

If it were to appear more a personal desire to be deceptive rather than in ingrained response of survival that he had grown up with. I would probably readdress things. I cannot honestly say "this is the thing that will be the end all" I won't know unless I'm there. But now that I have a clearer understanding of why things went the way they did, I only slightly see it as disrespect. He had to live for a very long time in cover your ass mode, just to survive his home life. This was all he knew. You cannot take a fish and put it on land and demand it breathe the way you and I do. I s it possible, through evolution, adaptation, outside help? Yes, but with none of that support the fish will flop around and freak out trying to suck in water that isnt there.

Do you have a personal "mile marker" or threshhold which means the absolute end if he crosses it?

No I don't. Because every situation is dependant on the circumstances. I have a childhood friend who I lost contact with for several years. The last time I saw her, her dad was being hauled away by the cops for beating the shit out of her mother. Shortly after, they moved. I had always assumed her parents had split. That is for many the end all. After years of abuse, he almost killed her. I thought in my inexperienced mind, that he obviously could not change and they had divorced. I got back in contact with her a few years ago and was surprised to find out that not only had her parents stayed together, but her dad had been sober for 10 + years and had never laid another hand on either of them. Her family was finaly healed and whole.

For some, they would have left at the first sign of abuse, for some the instance of him almost killing her would have been the end all. But for her mom, she knew this man, she knew that he was more than an abuser and she knew he had the desire to change. So she stayed with him, supported him and for them, they are now living a happy ending.

I think every person in a relationship needs to take stock of their situation and decide for them what the best option is. No one knows what it is to live that persons life or to live in that relationship.


Or is your willingness to forgive never-ending?
I will always have a willingness to forgive. I've had a lot of shit happen in my life and have always found the strength and ability to forgive. Do I have a breaking point, most likely, but I haven't reached it yet.

To me, there's got to be a realization that allowing too much is just setting oneself up for abuse.
I will be no ones door mat. But I will also not walk away from someone who is trying. I've made several repetitive mistakes in my life. Had my parents walked away,I'd be dead by now. Instead they showed me the meaning of unconditional love and allowed me the chance to learn how to grow through love and forgiveness.

And also, do you consider his treatment of other people, too, when you look at how he is and the kind of man you want to be with?

Absolutely. He is loyal to a fault-even when he has been repetedly betrayed or treated unjustly. He puts himself out there and tries to save the world when he's got his own shit to be worried about. He is a loving Uncle and Godfather. He is fiercely protective of the women in his life. He has a personal moral code that I admire. He has personal beliefs that he will do whatever it takes for. He has never treated another in a way that has made me question the man I am with. It is in fact how he is with others, that adds to why I love him as much as I do. The sacrafices I have seen him make for those that are important in his life, make me step back and feel honored that he chose to ask me to be his wife.

Like I said earlier, I would rather go through what we have and be aware of it and have the chance to fix it. Than be in a marriage with no comunication whatsoever.
 
In response to your edit-of how he treats people in poly relationships, yes in that as well from what I saw he attempted to give the one relationship he had, all he could. He did all he thought was expected and needed. From what I saw of their relationship, I saw a man deeply in love and willing to do whatever it took to make it work. How could I not love that man? He tried to learn and grow as things went, as most people do. Once we were open, he followed boundries and did what I needed to make the transition easier. He treats the women he is with like princesses, I don't see how that could possibly be a deterant.

Not to say that he's a saint. He obviously makes mistakes like every other human being. Things went took a bad turn with Cricket when they both failed at communication. Any relationship is doomed if you bottle things up instead of working on them.

But in his relationships he has never shown me anything to make me question why I am with him.
 
Last edited:
Wow, I've become quite the topic of conversation all the sudden :)

You seem to have a lot of questions, Secret, and I'm glad you're asking us - well, Mo anyway - because we both have an open book policy here. In other words, feel free to ask whatever is on your mind, because we're both notoriously difficult to offend and bluntly honest, even if the honest answer to a question you pose is "I don't know", you're not going to ask something we (or her, you haven't asked me anything yet) aren't comfortable answering.

In the beginning, a lot of my personal issues and reasons for the cheating/lying was that I didn't believe I could trust Mo to be as honest as she clamied she would be. In spite of being with her for years, that level of honesty was just something that I couldn't even comprehend, much less buy into. I grew up hearing one thing from the people in my life, and then when I acted on what they had told me, all the sudden the situation or their reactions were in no way what they had told me they would be, and I had just assumed that everyone was that way. It's what I had seen my entire life - not making excuses for my actions, but I literally didn't know that things could be any other way.

Once I came clean to Mo about everything, and after our infamous Night of Complete Honesty (yes, that's a proper noun), I've done my best to keep everything about my other relationship (there has been only one until very recently) above board and honest, from both Mo's perspective and my exes perspective. I didn't cheat on either of them after that point - there was no reason to do so. The issues in our marriage that had led me on my stirng on one night stands before I met and fell for my ex were either fixed or being worked on, and I had two women in my life that I was head over heels in love with. I never felt the need to look elsewhere for anything, and no one else ever caught my eye in that way, aside from the occasional "hey, she's hot!" that every guy does. There was something of an exception made for someone who had been in my and Mo's life for a long time, but even then I was honest with them both about things - and also honest with her husband about it. In the end, that turned out to be a mistake and we both realized it, but that's a topic for another discussion.

The key thing here for both me and Mo was/is trust. I never trusted her enough to be honest with her about our issues, which led to me hiding things from her when I went elsewhere to get certain needs met, because I didn't trust her to be OK with me looking elsewhere for those needs. I think the wierdest part of that, from my end, is that I never even REALIZED that I didn't trust her - it had become so ingrained into my nature that the distrust was no longer a conscious decision on my part, it was just how I lived and thought on a day to day basis.

When I told Mo that I had fallen for Cricket, her response to me was "You're an idiot for thinking that you can only love one person, and a bigger idiot for hiding it from me." That one line was like a wrecking ball right through my whole outlook on life. I was absolutely floored. "She wasn't pissed off about me being with other women, she was pissed off at me for lying about it? HOW DOES THAT EVEN WORK? WHAT PLANET AM I ON?" It shattered the reality I had been living in - but in a good way. Messy to be sure, but good.

Hopefully we're being helpful here. Any more questions?
 
I haven't posted in a long while, but decided to come out of my cocoon for this.

I can so relate to the following

This is what is so confusing to me - how do you trust someone who has lied and cheated so many times before?
How do you continue to be in a relationship with someone who became so reclusive they never left their room and your only communication was over pain pills? The lying and the cheating is not the whole of who he is. For the most part it was a symptom of something being wrong in our relationship, and his past. We as humans often assosciate our spuses with the role models we had growing up. Karma often compared me to his mother and the results of situations with her. He didnt trust me to be okay with certain things, or to mean what I said about honesty, because his mother often said "if you tell the truth the punishment will be less" but then it would result in an even larger tantrum and punishment. Having had that as a basis his entire life, it was difficult to trust that any woman really meant what they said. With all that in mind, we started working on that. Are still working on that. It's not an easy thing to let go of when it's become a survival mechanism. He needs to have trust in me just as much as I do in him. He never gave me a chance to prove that I could be taken at my word. Something he learned very quickly as we ventured into this.


My husband of 15 years was abused as a child, actually through out his relationship with his mother. This has finally come out in our relationship, he doesn't trust me not to be her. He has actually replaced me in his mind as her and lies all the time over stupid stuff either out of getting away with it as it is easier and less scary to trust me or less conflict or just because he has decided things I need in place are stupid so he will hide them like he did his mother.
He had all this blow up in his face right before memorial day and we are now separated until he can get his head togather and we can go to marriage counseling. He now sees his our relationship how he was tainted in his thoughts over money and relationships with others. Money I just asked him to take responsbility and know how much was available not to spend like he was rich. Relationships I asked for a heads up no more. He acted in a manner of me being controlling, by me saying there is x money available I was a prision warden, by asking for a heads up the same. I know he is under stress with my chronic illness. But I deserve better.

The irony is i am the poly one, and he is mono. I can relate so much and yes I do continue to forgive and Mo struck something with me with the how do you except a fish to breath when it knows, no different.

Thank you Mo! He was understanding my stance of no one more chances, just work on your stuff. I told him I expect him to fuck up and but I need to see action of trying to learn to breath. Thats all an effort and him reading your post helped him understand. So that you both Karma and Mo!
 
Beautiful posts Mo.

It's really nice to see the work the two of you have done this past year, as my hubs and I are in the middle of doing that as well. Not so much with the honesty (we got through that one finally a few years ago), but with the honest, open communication ALL of the time. It's definitely a process, but it's so worth it.

It's not always so easy to find somebody who gets you so completely, ALL of you, and loves you.

As far as the trust and honesty-- yes, my husband was the same way in that he didn't fully trust me to be open to honesty, either. I can't say I blame him either, I know enough people who say they want honesty and then flip out when they get it. It took quite a few years for him to get it. And believe it. And still, I think his first reaction sometimes is not to tell me some things-- it's like a bad habit, it's been automatic so long it just wants to happen right away. But he's worked so hard in the past couple of years, and especially this past 6 months to open up the communication and to really open himself to people in general. There's still work to be done, but then really-- how many of us DON'T have work to do?

But my life is so much more complete, and honest, and so many other things now than it ever has been. Do we still have issues come up? Yes. Do we still have communication problems? Yes. But we're learning how to deal with them better and better each time.

A few months ago I read your whole blog, Mo... and I've kept up with it. Mostly because some aspects really resonated with me, but also because seeing people do the work, and go through the process-- it's helped me sometimes when things get hard to see the ups and downs are part of it all, and what you do about it is the important part.
 
Back
Top