Need advice on starting Polyamory. Frustrated with wife.

miamikicks27

New member
Hello everyone,

First and foremost, I want to say thank you for all those who contribute to this community. Many of you are pioneers and role models for people like me who just started getting into polyamory. You have all truly paved the path for us and I have learned a lot from many of you.

So here is my situation. I am a 33 y/o male married to my wife (7 years together, 1 year married). Over the last 6 - 8 months, I told her I was*bisexual. I never told her that before we married I had some casual hook ups with multiple men. I was basically very repressed but I had a moment of clarity and basically decided to live an honest life being who I am.

On the Kinsey scale, I rate 2.4. All of my relationships have been with women. Four serious relationships and male encounters accounted for less than 20 % of my total sexual partners throughout my life.

I never cheated on my wife and when I told her she was very understanding and SOMEWHAT open to exploring MMF or MFM further. I have told her my entire past. She is more incidentally homosexual, around 1.4 and never been with a woman and only has fleeting thoughts. She is more inclined to include a male vs a female.

During this time, I probably have consumed over 4 books on a polyamorous lifestyle, to include the big ones like The Ethical Slut and Opening up. I’ve read a ton of posts on forums like this one, scoured Google, etc. I’ve done many of the written activities in the books I read myself and really understand myself more than I have in my entire life.

I’ve also joined FetLife and just viewed a bunch of bi dating sites and craigslist ads. Never contacting anyone, just looking. My wife is aware of these activities as I am not trying to do anything behind her back just looking around.

My wife has expressed *SOME* interest but she is hesitant, understandably. She says “when i get in a relationship, I give everything” and she is afraid what that will do to our relationship. One of my fears is losing her totally but from what I understand when entering this lifestyle is that you must be courageous and I am willing to take the chance. Quite frankly, the status quo won’t work for me long term (maybe for her) because I would probably end up being with another male behind her back and everything thats associated with not being honest. I don’t want to live like that.

We’ve discussed possible scenarios and at least initially she would like to make the encounters less emotional and more physical, which I can deal with since in the past thats all I did with males (physical). I DO have a desire of being somewhat committed or a full relationship with a male vs something casual but I am ok with limits initially. I have made it clear to her about my true desires (she started crying) but as I stated her fundamental fear of her “getting emotionally connected to someone” is very strong and at that moment I agreed a casual encounter is fine.

In the ideal circumstance we would be a triad (all 3 of us love each other) but I know that the unicorn scenario is not easy as the relationships may not evolve the same. I told her to conserve our energy and time we can limit partners to 4 total (including us two) in whatever way it unfolds (although my preference is that we all play together).

I understand that when you start, the direction we expect it to flow may in fact be the opposite. We won’t know until we get there of course.

My wife has tried to understand and learn more about this, but she has not put effort into reading the one book (Opening up) I asked her to, although she wants to, but is overall not a huge reader. We have also started to read the book together but the frequency of reading is very low as we may be tired from work or she may not be in the mood.

Usually I initiate all conversations regarding this topic and she participates but I am getting frustrated with being the initiatior. I have come off as “talking about it too much” per her own words. Early on, I talked about it everyday but I have found myself only discussing it 1x a week for fear of being too “overwhelming” (her words).
Its like I am walking on eggshells but my desires are wild intense flames at times.

One of the things I read is to allow 1 year BEFORE doing anything to allow for the relationship to adjust and for us to learn about this lifestyle. I am fine with that. Although I am not the most patience I do have it. What I am frustrated with is the lack of initiative on her end overall.

Recently, we were on tumblr looking at naked men and she commented with me on the ones she liked vs did not. I saved some pictures over the next week or so and the last time she told me she was not in the mood to look at more pictures of men (although she was interested initially). The next week I did want to show her 15 pics of men but her dismissal hurts and quite frankly I don’t feel that 1 minute of her time about her opinion (although she later expressed stills do nothing for her) on something is too much to ask.

I’ve always been an aggressive and someone impulse person, but I don’t feel impulsitivity is playing a role here now. Our sex drives are mismatched as my libido and desire for kink is usually extremely high. She tends to have a lower libido overall and less creative with sex. I understand that I can’t change her libido, and I frankly have needs that she can’t fill (aside from the fact that I have attraction to men).

One thing I asked her, many months ago, is to use a toy on me anally. She never once made the initiative to do it although I stated my desires many many many many times. I even told her I “needed” it. Recently she did it but I basically had to tell her to do it during the actual act.

I guess in this long rant I am trying to get some advice. Any advice. I have nobody to turn to in real life, as she does not want to participate in any social events (for now) where similar people hang out.

Thanks in advance for your responses and sorry for the lengthy post but I really wanted to lay out everything a clear manner.
 
Stop pushing so hard. You've made your position clear, now be patient. Give it thirty days before bringing it up again, or even thinking about it. Show her how much you love her for a month, strengthen your bond, do things she wants.... And then gently broach the subject again.

You're being pushy & selfish.
 
"Opening Up" is also an audiobook. Perhaps listen rather than read?

To me it sounds like your wife is not all that into it. You want her to be, but she just isn't. Have you asked her straight up if she prefers to stay Closed? If so?

You may have to accept a parting of ways if she prefers Closed and you prefer Open. Just no longer compatible. :(

It stinks...and disappointing that you have grown in different directions. But it is better than cheating. Then you are free to seek partners who want to be Open and she is free to seek partner who wants to be Closed. Both are free to move on in the way they like best without cheating on previous agreements. It's cleaner.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi miamikicks27,

Sorry you're experiencing some frustration with your wife. It sounds to me like you and she have some desires/inclinations that are pulling in opposite directions. She is afraid of polyamory and possibly just hopes it will "go away." You want lots of kinky sex while she wants just a little vanilla sex. You had to really push just to get her to use an anal toy one time. Obviously she doesn't *really* want to do it. That doesn't make you or her a bad person, it just means that you're not as well matched these days as perhaps you thought you used to be.

If you plan to stay married with her and also move forward with this polyamory thing, I think you'll have to get used to being the initiator. You'll have to get used to asking her, "Do you feel like (doing or talking about) (x) right now?" and accepting the disappointment (and frustration) when she says no. If you feel like your brain will burst when you think about carrying on like that for the rest of your life, then you might want to consider GalaGirl's advice and just shoot for an amicable divorce.

It's possible you're more intense than she is, and/or more proactive and wanting to get things done, whereas she just wants to sit back and be comfortable. Again neither of you is a bad person just because you're different from each other. But you should think about what would probably make both of you the happiest in the long run. And maybe staying married will do that for you, but it depends on those other things.

I applaud you for the diligent work you've done to learn about poly (and open relationships) and hope you'll be able to enjoy a bit less frustration in the months/years ahead.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
She doesn't have to have multiple partners just because that is what you want. She can still be monogamous and you can be polyamorous. It sounds like you expect her to go along and do what you want to do. Why does she need to be involved sexually or romantically with anyone else you hook up with? That is just nonsensical. If you want her to give you room to be who you are, you should also extend her the same courtesy. Maybe she only wants to be with you but is agreeing to a triad out of fear of losing you - that is a very common reaction.

I agree with whoever said to stop pushing. Stop putting so much pressure on her and your marriage to get this going now-now-now. Why hurry? Poly is a big step, and will change the entire dynamic between you two, even if you are the only one with a lover. Some couples take a year or more of discussing, looking inward, and strengthening their bond before ever making any moves with someone else. Basically - slow down, dude!
 
She is afraid of polyamory and possibly just hopes it will "go away."

Afraid of it? Maybe she just doesn't want an open marriage. That doesn't make someone 'afraid' of something. There are plenty of things I have no interest in doing, and it has nothing at all to do with 'fear.'
 
I feel your situation is not that different from mine, though in my case it's my boyfriend who has been hesitant about opening the relationship. Much of what you've written in your initial post has a familiar feel to it.

I believe that Kevin T.s advice has a lot going for it. Also: of course you don't have to be afraid to not want something but my boyfriend definitely seems to be. In monogamy the sense of being secure in a relationship is largely based on sexual fidelity. Right now this sense of security is being shaken - especially if she herself isn't that interested in having relations with others (as is my boyfriend as well). It's my belief that it is possible to find other foundations for security but these probably have to be built in time and can't expected to be present from the word go.

I hope you can resolve your situation!
 
Why don't you just date a man/men and leave your wife out of it? She doesn't sound interested, and really, this is for you and about you, not for or about her. Plus, just because a man is bisexual doesn't mean he'll be interested in both you and your wife. Maybe he already has a wife of his own, you know? If your wife wants to give her all to her marriage, she should be allowed to without being expected to put out for guys so you can feel like you're "including" her. There's no reasons this needs to be about threesomes, and it might be more fulfilling to everyone if it isn't.
 
Hi miamikicks, and welcome. :)

I think that it's somewhat accurate to say that polyamory takes courage, but I also think that it takes bucketloads of compassion.

I understand your fears about losing your wife if you decide that this path is an absolute must for you. This is no doubt petrifying for her too. I understand your needs in terms of exploring relationships with other men. I think it's completely fair that you want to - the question is whether or not you can explore whilst keeping your current marriage a happy and secure one.

One thing does concern me. You have already identified that your real desire is to eventually have a full relationship with another man. The next time you sleep with a man, it's likely to feel so fantastically liberating that I'm not sure polysexuality is a realistic initial agreement. I have a niggling feeling that it would be better to reconsider the polysexual starting point and instead discuss starting out as polyamorous. Painful, yes, and scary too - but less painful in the long-run than the broken guidelines and forbidden love issues that tend to go with polysexual beginnings. This is only my opinion, and it is only something to think about.

I understand your frustration in terms of your wife not picking up 'her end' and doing the research. In my experience, this comes down to a simple lack of interest/willingness, no matter how many excuses are thrown out there. I really believe that when people want something, they'll take action to start making it happen. Simply put: this is your baby, and your wife is overwhelmed. Listen to what she's actually telling you with her lack of action.

I understand that you are eager and that you want to talk about it. I am also like this when something is on my mind - I won't let it rest. I can be like a dog with a bone. This is a great quality to have in certain situations, but it can emotionally bombard and exhaust other people.

In terms of the looking at guys on Tumblr thing, let's look at it another way? Your wife's world has been turned upside down and she's feeling OUT OF CONTROL. When *she* gave you feedback on guys, she was TAKING CONTROL. This allows her to feel safer. You want to build intimacy and share this side of yourself with her, which is why you then got excited and brought more pictures to her. However, this is only going to threaten her, which leads her to feel out of control again, which is why she bristled. She wants to feel safe, and poly/guy things are threats to her right now. Let her approach with caution, rather than bringing the threat right to her.

Also, remember - every time gives her approval on a guy or reads a poly book, she's metaphorically giving a thumbs-up to you going ahead with polyamory. Every poly-friendly action she takes is symbolic of her moving away from her old monogamous life with you. So, she digs her heels in, because she's scared and doesn't know if she wants to commit to that yet.

I'm hearing that with your sex life and with your poly aspirations, you have been telling her "I want, I want", but her lack of action is telling you "I don't, I don't". Do you really take the time to listen to her? Have you checked your own behaviour and owned it?

Overall, if I were in your position, here's what I'd do. I would be real with yourself and your wife and scrap the polysexuality idea. You ideally want a relationship with a man - start with polyamory. It would be unfair of your wife to drag her feet forever, or to tell you she's fine with polysexuality when she isn't. It would be unfair of you to push her to move faster than her comfort level (this includes looking at guys on Tumblr, etc.). If you're committed to your marriage right now, both of you need to do things to strengthen that commitment to it. On your side, this means giving her time to really explore at her own pace. Allow her that little bit of control. On her side, this means accepting the reality that polyamory IS going to be part of YOUR future, whether she's along for the ride or not.

Your wife is scared that becoming polyamorous will negatively impact your relationship. If *talking* about polyamory is leaving her feeling pressured, scared, and ignored, she sure as hell isn't likely to want to actually *become* polyamorous in the end. However, if you can show her that you are patient, that you genuinely care about her comfort, and that you are willing to put your commitment to your marriage above everything else right now, this is much more likely to build trust and security between the two of you. Does that make sense?

So, I'd sit down with her and build intimacy. Tell her that you are so grateful that you could be honest with her, and that you feel closer to her for it. Own up to your pushy behaviour, and explain to her that you only want to share yourself with her. Tell her how much you admire her for the things that she has done so far, and for how brave she's being. Tell her that although polyamory is something you want, that you really do want her to be there with you. Tell her that you fear losing her too, that she's important to you, and that you want to do what you can to have her with you on this particular journey. All of these words build love and trust.

Do go ahead and agree to a timescale, if you both want this. 6 months? A year? Agree to leave it be for a while, if you are willing to do that. Can you leave her to think about this and research it at her own pace? Can you give Craigslist etc. a rest until she's decided whether she's on this path with you or not? Are you willing to hit pause for 6 months of your life, which means not bringing it up and letting her come to you during that period?
 
So, I'd sit down with her and build intimacy. Tell her that you are so grateful that you could be honest with her, and that you feel closer to her for it. Own up to your pushy behaviour, and explain to her that you only want to share yourself with her. Tell her how much you admire her for the things that she has done so far, and for how brave she's being. Tell her that although polyamory is something you want, that you really do want her to be there with you. Tell her that you fear losing her too, that she's important to you, and that you want to do what you can to have her with you on this particular journey. All of these words build love and trust.

Do go ahead and agree to a timescale, if you both want this. 6 months? A year? Agree to leave it be for a while, if you are willing to do that. Can you leave her to think about this and research it at her own pace? Can you give Craigslist etc. a rest until she's decided whether she's on this path with you or not? Are you willing to hit pause for 6 months of your life, which means not bringing it up and letting her come to you during that period?

I 100% feel where the Original Poster is coming from. I found this info above to be the most helpful advice because I have recently started making this (building love and trust) the focus of my Sig's and my own conversations and it seems to be working. I also recently read a piece about writing agreements (what is okay behavior, what is not, as I move forward exploring/expectations for moving forward as the more impatient poly person while Sig remains comfortable moving less slowly) and feel in addition to the timeline idea above, we can continue to move forward together with neither one of us left twisting in the wind. Like the OP's wife, I don't think that Sig is against anything just yet; it's more a fear of the unknown. Anyway, I hope something similar will help OP too.
 
Back
Top