Recycled Dates?

himherandme

New member
So, last summer my girlfriend surprised me with one of those paint and sip classes for my birthday. She had mentioned that her husband kind of got jealous so she told him she would take him to a class one day. She never did. A couple months later we went to one of those room escape competitions and she did end up taking her husband to the same one we went to. I took my bf to a different one, but with the same concept (and again...months later). It's no big deal to me.

Fast forward to today, I told her me and my bf are going to a painting class Friday and it seemed like her feelings were kind of hurt that I "recycled" a date she took me on since now I'm taking him (not the same exact place, not even in the same city).

She made the comment "I hope you don't take him to everything I take you to." I really just enjoyed these things and wanted to have fun with them both. I think over time, it will be impossible to not do one thing that I've done with the other. Am I being tacky by "recycling" dates? If I am, how do you all solve this problem?

____________________________________
Me: 27 bisexual female
My guy: late 20s straight monogamous
My girl: mid 20s bisexual married to her husband
 
If it were me in those shoes? I would solve the problem by asking her if there's something she would like to keep special for just (me and her). Sometimes I find I have to listen for the feelings underneath the words and not so much the words themselves.

Because the actual words? "I hope you don't take him to everything I take you to."

That makes no sense to me. You probably don't take him to everything. And you waited a few months. It's not like she took you to paint and sip one day and the very next day you go do it with your BF too like copycat. This is months later.

But the feelings underneath seem to be about specialness.

I like sushi. If I go to sushi once with my husband, that means I can never go eat sushi with another partner? Sushi can only be with him? That's not being realistic.

Now if he really digs the "all you can eat" contest at the Annual Sushi Festival? Ok. I can promise I'm his partner for that contest. I might go to the festival with other people, but I only do that one contest with him cuz that's our "special thing" once a year. That's realistically doable. I can have other "special things" with other people.

Was it a special paint and sip? Like Valentine's or something? Maybe that's the special thing to share with just her then. Every year you do the special Valentine's paint and sip?

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your input. I guess looking deeper into the conversation and past the one comment, I can see its about more than just taking him where she's taken me.

She took me for my birthday, so maybe I'll tell her we (me and her) will only go on my birthday so she feels that it's something unique with us. Great idea.

Thanks again for your advice!! I'm sure it will help.
 
I took my GF to a restaurant because I enjoy eating out. I also took her to a gallery because I enjoy art. Just because I've done both of those activities with my wife doesn't mean I'm recycling anything.

Be IN the moment with your partner and don't worry about anything else.
 
I can see having one special thing for a partner, but I "recycle" normal dates often. Boy and I go out to eat much more often than Hubby and I do (Boy has more "fun money" so he takes me out - Hubby and I don't have a lot of fun money since we had a baby so we do cheaper things). When Hubby and I DO have a chance to go spend more money than usual? You bet your ass I recommend some of the awesome places that he hasn't tried yet! When it's a once in a while thing, I want to make sure Hubby enjoys wherever we go, which sometimes means going to a place that I've been before on a date with someone else.

Then again, there is a specific beach that Hubby loves that hosts an event twice a year. I would never dream of going to that event with anyone else. That beach? Sure. A similar event elsewhere? Maybe.

If something is fun, it's fun. I wouldn't want to limit my partners just because I'm not a part of it. I may have a stab of envy when they go do it with someone else (or by themselves), but I'll get over it and be happy that they get to do something enjoyable.
 
I would think it very cool that someone liked something that was my idea so much that they would want to share it with someone else. My partners in Seattle have turned me on to some cool places. I have a whole list of places I'd like to take Cat if/when she visits Seattle, just like I have a bunch of places in Florida I would take people who visit me there.
 
Hi himherandme,

I see nothing wrong with "recycling" dates. If we didn't recycle, we'd end up with nothing to do. I know I'm being logical, while your girlfriend is coming from an emotional place, but with all due respect I think she should curb her emotions about this issue. A relationship can be perfectly special without exclusive rights to this or that kind of date.

My 2¢,
Kevin T.
 
We recycle dates all the time. Real sees most movies twice. It's a totally different experience with a different person. That being said there are a few guidelines. Don't force one person to fit your other persons mold. He and lady and I all enjoy visiting the same picturesque town nearby. We do many of the same activities (your wineries, go hiking, eat at foodie places. But we experience these differently due to our preferences. For example real has taken us to the same winery/bnb. But they go on the romantic couples thingies with couple massages and candles because that's her thing. When we go it's for the local music fest. Because that's my thing. Not that we are restricted from the other, but more that the experience is planned for each person.
 
Yeah I totally don't understand this concept at all. People don't own activities. They don't own your time. They don't own your enjoyment. If you like doing something, do it. Do it as much as you can, with everyone you can. Share the fun!

If someone I was with was getting jealous that I'm doing the same thing with other people that I did with them? I would have zero patience for that. If I really really really liked them, I might be willing to just not tell them if I do that activity with someone else. But there's no way I would save it just for them. That's just too possessive for my tastes.

Especially something like going to an establishment. I mean it's one thing if someone plans out a multi-location date where every place has special meaning, is chosen specifically for me because of something in our mutual history... and then I go take someone else on a date to the same set of locations. That would just be weird. But I wouldn't do that, because those places wouldn't be meaningful to the other person. But if someone introduces me to something cool like sip and paint (whatever that is, I'll have to look into it, must be fun if you wanted to take someone else there...), of course I'm going to share it with other people.

ETA: $50 and you have to bring your own wine? Screw that, I can paint at home and have $35 left over...
 
Last edited:
I sometimes see the same movie multiple times. Yesterday I saw 10 Cloverfield Lane with WarMan, and I am going to see it again tonight with PunkRock and DarkKnight together. We'd run out of restaurants if everyone called "MINE!" lol
 
It's not really recycling if it's with a different person, if you think about it. The dynamic I have with one person is unique and not like what I have with another, so the experience is very different.

It was quite childish for her to say that to you, especially because she was totally fine taking her hubs to do something she did with you. If I were you, I'd bring it up and ask why she has a double standard.
 
There's only so many "favorite" restaurants (or whatever) that I have, & choosing one is often a spur-of-the-moment thing, so somehow dividing the list up between my lovers & friends just seems like a logistic trainwreck, at best.

And does the degree of sexual closeness we have / used to have / might have someday / will never have somehow determine whether I'm allowed to indulge in a particular activity...? :confused:

Now, when I make a date to check out a new restaurant or a current movie or a gallery opening, & that person "accidentally" goes with someone else a day or two before, then I reserve the right to ask some pointed questions.
 
Be IN the moment with your partner and don't worry about anything else.
Thank you for this. I explained to her that even if we do similar things, the experience can be entirely different because my dynamics with each person varies.

If something is fun, it's fun. I wouldn't want to limit my partners just because I'm not a part of it. I may have a stab of envy when they go do it with someone else (or by themselves), but I'll get over it and be happy that they get to do something enjoyable.

I think maybe this is what she was experiencing, "a stab of envy." It was momentary because after reading these responses, I approached the topic again and she ended up wishing me well and hoping we had a good time.

I would think it very cool that someone liked something that was my idea so much that they would want to share it with someone else.

I actually used this logic with her in hopes that it would make her feel better. Not word for word of course, but I told her it was a really good idea and that she should feel good that I got inspiration from her idea. So thank you for this!

Hi himherandme,

I know I'm being logical, while your girlfriend is coming from an emotional place, but with all due respect I think she should curb her emotions about this issue. A relationship can be perfectly special without exclusive rights to this or that kind of date.

My 2¢,
Kevin T.

I agree, I don't think there would ever be much of a relationship if she had "dibs" on certain places. Thank God we don't live in a small town!

For example real has taken us to the same winery/bnb. But they go on the romantic couples thingies with couple massages and candles because that's her thing. When we go it's for the local music fest. Because that's my thing. Not that we are restricted from the other, but more that the experience is planned for each person.

I like this. Even if you all went to the same exact bnb, each experience was vastly different because it was tailored to the individual instead of being exactly the same for the both of you. I can definitely appreciate that. Thank you!

I mean it's one thing if someone plans out a multi-location date where every place has special meaning, is chosen specifically for me because of something in our mutual history... and then I go take someone else on a date to the same set of locations. That would just be weird. But I wouldn't do that, because those places wouldn't be meaningful to the other person.

Yes, I would never do that, especially if the date was meaningful for both me and her. But if it's a really good restaurant or something really interesting I think they both would enjoy, I don't see the harm in that.

I sometimes see the same movie multiple times. Yesterday I saw 10 Cloverfield Lane with WarMan, and I am going to see it again tonight with PunkRock and DarkKnight together. We'd run out of restaurants if everyone called "MINE!" lol

Exactly!!! I think even in monogamous relationships, that would be impossible. "Don't take me anywhere you've taken your exes." It just wouldn't work. BTW...how was 10 Cloverfield?! I've been dying to see it!

It's not really recycling if it's with a different person, if you think about it. The dynamic I have with one person is unique and not like what I have with another, so the experience is very different.

It was quite childish for her to say that to you, especially because she was totally fine taking her hubs to do something she did with you. If I were you, I'd bring it up and ask why she has a double standard.

I completely understand what you mean about dynamics. I think once we dove deeper into the issue, she could see where I was coming from and acknowledged that it was an unrealistic expectation.

There's only so many "favorite" restaurants (or whatever) that I have, & choosing one is often a spur-of-the-moment thing, so somehow dividing the list up between my lovers & friends just seems like a logistic trainwreck, at best.

And does the degree of sexual closeness we have / used to have / might have someday / will never have somehow determine whether I'm allowed to indulge in a particular activity...? :confused:

Now, when I make a date to check out a new restaurant or a current movie or a gallery opening, & that person "accidentally" goes with someone else a day or two before, then I reserve the right to ask some pointed questions.

I agree with all points. It would definitely be a headache trying to navigate between those logistics. I only have two relationships, so think how restrictive that would be if I was with more people! Luckily, she understood without too much conflict. Hopefully, it won't come up again.

I, of course, wouldn't do something with one a couple of days after doing something with the other. That's just out of simple respect. I try to give it a substantial amount of time before "recycling" so it doesn't take away from the "originator" of the idea.
 
Back
Top