Update from a mono/poly newbie. More advice?

kwags27

New member
Hi everyone! I'm back with an update. Back in April I joined for some guidance and I want to thank everyone for their responses. I took some time to think about everything and decided I still wanted to move forward with my relationship. WARNING: this is very long and I apologize.

Recap: my bf is a new poly, I am mono, and his other gf is bi and claims to be mono but wants to be able to be with other women. She hates me, I'm not a fan of hers, but we get along in each other's presence.

Last time I shared here, they had broken up, but got back together with the understanding that the two of them were in a relationship and that he and I were in a relationship. So here we go, right? Ugh.

First, after posting here, I stopped by to see him one evening and she was there so he met me outside. I wanted to spend 5 minutes and he said it was fine (I never show up without permission). As we were getting ready to say goodbye, she comes outside, completely ignores me, and says "It's been more than 5 minutes. Are we going to watch this movie or should I just go home?" Then she stalks back inside. So she and I just avoided each other. Then in May, he and I went on our annual vacation. We spent 2 days (1 night) together in Chicago. The first day there, my bf asks me if I said anything to her. Nope, haven't contacted her at all. He said she had been texting him nonstop about what we were doing together and commented about us enjoying our couples massage (um, there was no plan for a couples massage, but sounds nice). The next day a friend of his that we visited pulled him aside to let him know she wanted him to spy on us during our trip, but he didn't want to get involved. I was pissed, but my bf and I talked about it and I let it go. When we got back, I asked him if we could have a talk about what each of us needed from the other to make our relationship work. She called him when she was a few minutes away to let him know she was coming over and he told her he was having a conversation with me and she can't just show up without letting him know. He told her he would see her when we were finished and no, she could not come to my house. She started texting ME to find out what was going on. When we were done talking, I let her know he was on his way back to his place and she said "maybe his actual girlfriend should know if he's gonna be with someone else." I let him deal with that one.

I invited her over to spend Memorial Day with us. We were having a BBQ at my place and I said she was welcome to attend, but I would understand if she declined. I was trying to be open-minded and build a relationship between all of us. She accepted, then backed out, then changed her mind again. It went fairly well until our bf started paying more attention to her and ignoring me. Perhaps trying to make her more comfortable? He told both of us beforehand that we were not allowed to fight so I, again, let it go.. He and I discussed the situation later to make potential future gatherings better for all of us.

In June, things fell apart. They had been having issues ever since they got back together, but it had been getting worse. One particular incident: They went on a week long trip to Bonnaroo (a music and arts festival in TN for anyone not familiar) and at one point she got upset and started shoving him, telling him to get away from her and she was going to leave, but they had driven there together. She started yelling and hitting him so he pushed her into the car and got in and told her she could keep yelling or shut up. She started kicking him so he restrained her. When he let her go, she slapped him. He very calmly told her never to hit him again and she said "Then don't tell me to shut up." He was abused by his father growing up and he said he was not going to put up with another person who hit him while claiming to love him. When they returned from the trip, he sat her down and basically said, I love you and I want to be with you, but we need to get help. If you leave me again, we are done for good and I will not fight for you. She agreed to see a couples counselor and they made an appt the next day.

Friday of that week, he and I had plans, but she showed up unannounced and when I arrived she was taking a nap, so I left not wanting to make her angry. He wouldn't kiss me goodbye because she wasn't feeling well. If he couldn't kiss her because she was sick, he couldn't kiss me because that would make her feel like I was getting more than she was. He stayed with me Saturday, we spent Sunday apart for family stuff, then we were both busy until Wednesday. He said I could come over for a few, but he had to leave at 845 to meet his gf. I had been there 5 minutes and she shows up, again unannounced. She was angry that he was seeing me before her so she came to let us know. She said "Did you touch her? Did you kiss her?" And when he said yes, (we hugged), she said "Then I'm leaving." He went to calm her down and I left. Later that night, she messaged me again "If you're not going to f***, the whole reason why you can't just be his friend, then get the f*** out of our lives. And if you are, then f***ing do it so I can get out of yours." (He and I have not been sexually intimate this entire time. She wouldn't allow it, then she said just do it and get it over with, then she started threatening to leave him if he was with me.)

The next day, he and I met to talk about what had happened. They had had their first counseling session and she kept texting him to see what we were talking about, and she didn't want him to be with me that night. He said she did all the talking, despite the counselor trying to ask him things, but overall it went well. He didn't go into details with me, but said she has a lot of issues she needs to deal with. They had another appt Monday.

He and I didn't talk much over the weekend, he was busy with work, and Monday, as he was heading in to their 1pm couples session, he said he had just found out his dad was in the hospital and he was going to visit that evening. At 222pm I get a message from his gf. "I won't be bothering you anymore. Have a nice life together." An hour later he messaged me saying "Just FYI, ** and I are done."

He and I haven't discussed their breakup. I don't need to know the details, but I'd listen if he wanted to talk. I was upset the other day because he and I had plans and as I was getting ready to leave my class and head over, he said, "can you not come right over? Maybe park down the street for a few?" So I immediately think, she's there. They're getting back together, again. He and I had a nice evening, though it was short because he had to work. I called him later to ask about it and he confirmed that she was there. She was having a hard time and needed to talk. He said they are not getting back together because he needs to do what is best for him and that relationship was not going to work. He also said that she understands what the situation is.

So last night, he says he doesn't want me to get upset if she's around or for me to be afraid he's going to leave me for her. She texted him saying I'm probably ecstatic that they broke up and he ignored it. He said he knows that I'm not happy because he's not happy. And it's the truth. I wasn't looking for their relationship to end. I would actually very much like for them to be able to remain friends if possible.

And here we are. I told him I don't know how to do this, I don't know what I'm doing and he said "welcome to my life." Both he and I are new to this, so any advice for a new poly and a poly/mono relationship? I have a feeling things will be quite different without a metamour and he doesn't fall that hard for just anyone. I know it will be long time if he ever finds another partner to become that prominent in our lives. How do I become ok with him having other partners? How do I have that much self confidence and trust? What should he expect? I do not want other partners outside of our relationship; however I have considered being with another woman and letting him watch. It would be far outside my comfort zone, but neither experience would technically be new to me. (Gotta love college, right?) How do we ensure both of our needs are met and that we are both happy with the arrangement?

I'm sure there will tons of comments about communication..... advice on how to get that started would be very welcome.
 
How do I become ok with him having other partners? ... I do not want other partners outside of our relationship....

Why would you be pretzeling yourself into another poly configuration when you know that poly is not for you? The more clear you are about what you want, the more you attract partners who are clear about what they want. Life goes much, much better the more you know yourself and stand by your own preferences and values. Why would you even for one minute be considering poly again if you know your heart longs for a monogamous relationship?
 
Wow. :eek:

That was exhausting just to read. Way too much drama for me. I cannot imagine what it is like having to live it out. (Why do you choose to do this?:confused:)

So basically they finally broke up and you and BF are dealing with the aftermath wanting to know how to move it forward from here and continue with mono-poly. (Mono on your side, poly on his.)

I will presume you love to do mono-poly and you aren't secretly wishing this was just mono.

I called him later to ask about it and he confirmed that she was there. She was having a hard time and needed to talk.

Doesn't have to be with him. He could have firmer boundaries and say "Yes, I see that you are having a hard time and want to talk. It cannot be me. I have my own healing to be doing. I suggest you continue with counseling. If you call or show up next time you can expect me not to answer. I am hanging up/closing the door now. " Then he could just be done with all this drama. Stop enabling poor behavior and point her to professional care and to the road to wellness. She might not LIKE it, but it sounds like that is what she actually needs. To be on the path to wellness. Not continue on this unhealthy path she's on.

That may be a condition of yours for agreeing to continue with him in mono-poly. You do not consent to continue dating him if he's not exercising strong personal boundaries and cuts ties with Drama Lady. Because you cannot be doing more of same and expect different results. If he doesn't have the sense to come in out of the rain? You can.

I apologize I cannot think of a nicer way to put this. I'm exhausted after reading all that. So forgive me it it sounds less than graceful, ok? :eek:

Drama Lady sounds like an emotional vampire. Most likely gonna keep draining you and sucking you both dry because he allows her in. She needs actual care and actual help. Not an enabler BF.

If he doesn't develop the sense to keep unhealthy people out of the network? Then HE is the problem because he brings vampires into the house.

And you could stop picking him out to date so YOU at least, can get off this drama roller coaster and out of this network. You don't have to be riding it just because he keeps buying a ticket for the vampire ride.

You have legs. You can walk away. Do mono-poly with healthier people.

So last night, he says he doesn't want me to get upset if she's around or for me to be afraid he's going to leave me for her.

Um...no. He's not the boss of your feelings. You can have whatever feelings you want about things.

If what he MEANS is... "I choose to keep Drama Lady around in my life. I don't want to you leave me because I choose to keep her around. And I don't want you to be upset I choose this. "

Well... he's not the boss of you there either.

He might be up for keeping her in his life and up for new future drama unfolding later down.

But you don't have to be up for that just because he is. You are in charge of your own willingness and where you participate. Not him. And maybe you hit your limit of tolerance for shenanigans.

(What IS your limit of tolerance? You do have one, right? There is a point where you say "I love you. But not even for you will I continue in things that hurt me." Are you able to say that? :confused:)

She texted him saying I'm probably ecstatic that they broke up and he ignored it.

Why is he telling you about her new drama? For what purpose? He could block the number rather than "pass the buck" drama on to you. If he needs to process, he could keep seeing a counselor. Not dump on you. You have your own load right now.

You have YOUR own healing to do and maybe YOU want a counselor. You cannot be assisting him with his healing when you have your own to do. You put your own oxygen mask on first, then when you are ok, you help other people. Not the other way around. You cannot be a martyr, his life raft, or burn yourself out.

He said he knows that I'm not happy because he's not happy. And it's the truth. I wasn't looking for their relationship to end. I would actually very much like for them to be able to remain friends if possible.

Not possible. She's Drama Lady with serious issues. Remember?

The next day a friend of his that we visited pulled him aside to let him know she wanted him to spy on us during our trip, but he didn't want to get involved.

...at one point she got upset and started shoving him, telling him to get away from her and she was going to leave, but they had driven there together. She started yelling and hitting him so he pushed her into the car and got in and told her she could keep yelling or shut up. She started kicking him so he restrained her. When he let her go, she slapped him.He very calmly told her never to hit him again and she said "Then don't tell me to shut up." He was abused by his father growing up and he said he was not going to put up with another person who hit him while claiming to love him.

Why would you want to keep this drama person in your life? How does that serve you well so your own mental and emotional health is not going down the toilet? :confused:

Are both you and BF conflict avoidant / people pleaser types?

I'm not saying that to be mean... I'm saying to examine this area and if you are? Work on this so you can move forward with better personal boundaries so people like Drama Lady don't just run right over you. She needs care. You two are not therapists. Even if you were, it would be a conflict of interest so you would refer her to someone else. You two do not have to personally escort her down the road to wellness. I don't wish her ill or think badly of her because she has problems. But she does have problems. Big ones. :(

It's ok to bow out because it has become too much for you. You could thrive in your relationships and not simply survive them. You could want more for yourself and your life than mere survival.

Both he and I are new to this, so any advice for a new poly and a poly/mono relationship?

He could learn to walk away from Drama People faster and stop being so "nice" because it doesn't help them learn to stop being Drama people, it sucks for him, and by extension it sucks for you. He could develop a higher personal standard for who he dates and not just take anyone who comes along. Set a higher bar.

And if he doesn't learn this skill? You could be willing to be more firm. Tell him to stop telling you about Drama People on the other side of the V and move to a more "separate V" thing. Def stop inviting the Drama people to your house for BBQ! And stop taking everything so meek and mild. Advocate for yourself more.

It's like you keep on "keeping the peace" rather than saying "BF, I have had enough. Your other GF is being rude to me / disrespectful to me/intrusive/whatever. I expect you to deal with that so it's not leaking over on to this side of the V. If you cannot handle it, I can."

And it is true. You CAN handle it. You can bow out because you prefer your own life not to be so much Drama. Not deal with his Drama GF, or deal with his meh response when his other partners cross lines and step on toes.

You can bow out. Problem solved -- at least for you. He can keep on with the wacky if he wants. No longer your concern and it isn't dinging you any more because you removed yourself from the line of fire.

He doesn't seem to really put his foot down with her, and allows way too much to leak over on to you. Sometimes he's the one doing the leaking! Telling you drama stuff you don't really need to be hearing. Like you don't have a BF. You have a case load. BF is patient #1, and Drama Lady is patient #2.

Is that what you signed up for? :confused:

If you enjoy doing a mono-poly "V" thing, you could pick your OWN dating partners better. Those that aren't sloppy hinges / attracted to Drama People. So doing "mono-poly" with them is less wacky and more to your liking.

How do I become ok with him having other partners? How do I have that much self confidence and trust?

Kinda hard to trust him if so far he picks out wacky people to date. Maybe this time was a fluke, but if it happens again and again you could decide you don't want to be with someone who keeps picking out wackies. You don't trust him to pick out healthy people. Because his track record shows he doesn't.

You could develop a higher personal standard for who you date and not just take anyone who comes along. Set a higher bar. If a dating partner doesn't make the cut? You bow out.

How do we ensure both of our needs are met and that we are both happy with the arrangement?

You know your own selves first. So you know what you want/need from a relationship. You develop a personal standard for what you will and will not put up with in a dating relationship. And you articulate that to your partner. He does same.

If you match up? Keep dating.

If you don't? Let dating each other go. Not everyone you date will be compatible or a long haul runner. That is part of what the dating process is FOR. To sort out the compatible ones.

And this is college -- you don't have to get tied down at this age. College age is a good time to play the field and get some life experience. You might decide you have had enough of THIS particular experience and move on from the Drama People.

Either with him -- because it's been a learning experience for both of you and he firms it up on his end so he's not letting vampires into the house.

Or without him -- because it's been a learning experience for you and you learned you cannot be dating a vampire fan.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
FallenAngelina: I've heard mono/poly relationships can work, so the fact that I am strictly mono doesn't exclude the possibility of being in a relationship with a poly. I have never considered being in a non-monogamous relationship before now, but I have been in love with this man for 14 years. I am willing to be more open-minded and re-evaluate my position on monogamy for him. I have been doing as much research as I can and came to this site for constructive advice.

Galagirl: Quite exhausting! To be fair to all of us involved, they have been involved for 2.5 years up until now, and she just turned into psycho bitch very recently. Turns out she has some mental issues (severe uncontrolled depression and anxiety) that she has previously sought treatment for, but she says her meds aren't working. She didn't let that side of her show until she lost control of the relationship. Until she broke up with him in March, she controlled what kind of relationship he could have with me. When they started talking about getting back together, he made it clear that if they did, she would have to allow a relationship with me. She took about a day to "think" about it and agreed. Personally, I don't feel she truly knew what she was agreeing to. Or she saw things going very differently at the very least.

I appreciate your comments. I guess I need to figure out what my limits are and know what it will take for me to walk away. Or to know when I should. I don't foresee him entering into a relationship with anyone else anytime soon, more just friends-with-benefits type hookups. He doesn't like one-night stands and prefers to have an established friendship with those he is interested in being intimate with. We will have to seriously discuss the type of women he is going to attach himself to.

He does have a difficult time letting people go and losing her is going to hurt him for a long time. I don't want her leaving (because of me is what she says) to hurt his relationship with me.

Thank you for all of the things you pointed out. Sometimes it takes someone on the outside to make you take a hard look at things.

Wish me luck!
 
Thank you for all of the things you pointed out. Sometimes it takes someone on the outside to make you take a hard look at things.

You are welcome. Glad it helped some.

I guess I need to figure out what my limits are and know what it will take for me to walk away. Or to know when I should.

Yes. That is part of learning how to do healthy dating. Whether in a mono shape thing, a mono-poly shape thing, etc. A lot of colleges do healthy dating classes -- they hand stuff like this healthy dating/relating wheel out.

https://www.clemson.edu/campus-life/healthy-campus/documents/equalityWheel.jpg

As well as learning how to spot unhealthy dating/relating with this wheel.

https://www.clemson.edu/campus-life/healthy-campus/documents/PowerControlWheel.jpg

Maybe you want to check student health services and see what yours has to offer? Learning how to date healthy is a common college age experience. If your campus doesn't have anything like that, you could Google to help you develop your personal standard for dating. What is acceptable to you and what is just not. What the deal breakers are and when to walk away from something.

He does have a difficult time letting people go and losing her is going to hurt him for a long time.

Not everything in life is a "win-lose" kind of choice. Some are "this choice stinks and this other choice also stinks. Which one stinks LESS then?"

Grief is a part of life. Learning grieve with the pot OFF the burner is better than keeping it ON the burner. Who wants never ending shenanigans and grief?

Some people? You are better off loving them from far away than up close because loving them up close hurts too much. You have to get yourself OUT of the line of fire. With regrets maybe but out of the line of fire all the same. Both of you could learn that. We are not put on this Earth to be other people's punching bags or emotional dumpsters or whatever. Have to love yourself too.

I don't want her leaving (because of me is what she says) to hurt his relationship with me.

That is not your stuff. She is blaming or blame storming or whatever it is. She's upset. Let her handle her stuff over THERE with her professional care team.

Learn to have better emotional/personal boundaries. Don't take her stuff on board for yourself. You don't have to carry her baggage for her.

She chose not to continue with her medication/ patient management stuff. She chose not to stay broken up. She chose to enter into a V thing with you guys while unhealthy/unwell and not really wanting to be in a V. If she chose to do that in bad faith wanting to cowgirl him off and found it did not work? Rather than act out and blame you for existing? She could OWN it: She made a string of poor choices for herself.

If he picks out wonky people to date and later he's upset and blaming you or acting out at you because they broke up? Well, you weren't the one picking her out to date! Do not take his stuff on board for yourself.

You can learn to be kind but FIRM. You can be sympathetic without taking his stuff on board for yourself. You state what you are and are not up for. Something like...

"I see you are upset and grieving. No break up is fun. I'm willing to listen and be supportive as you heal.

I am not willing to take responsibility for your choices. You chose to date her. Part of the risk of dating someone is that it might not work out and you have to deal with break up feelings.

I'm going to give it a pass this time. In future? Do not blame shift, act out, or tantrum your upset at me. Take responsibility for your stuff and express upset appropriately. I am not willing to be your punching bag."​

We are all free to choose. We are not free from the consequences of our choices.

Each one of you could hold your own emotional baggage rather than flinging it around passing the buck.

Some stuff is your stuff and only your stuff. Some stuff is his stuff and only his stuff. Some stuff is "our stuff" -- the things you and he both share responsibility for. Learn to tell the difference what kind of stuff is what.

http://outofthefog.website/what-to-do-2/2015/12/3/understand-my-stuffyour-stuff

I do wish you luck. It's been a whirlwind experience.

Take the time out you need to heal.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
I have been doing as much research as I can and came to this site for constructive advice.

Again, I'll ask you what you want in a relationship, besides wanting him. You said "I do not want other partners outside of our relationship" and although you want to do what it takes to keep him, which very well could involve opening your heart to other partners, it has to be a joyful growing experience for you in order for this to work. Stretching oneself to accept poly in order to hang onto a partner very often doesn't work as a long term solution because there's nothing in it for you except the partner. That usually sows the seeds of resentment and the partner, in and of himself, is usually not enough to sustain a person's enduring participation in a relationship model that doesn't speak to her heart. Whether the parters are poly or mono, we often say here that both have to be a "Hell, yeah!" in order for poly to work.

Is your BF even sure that he is poly? For many people poly is a choice, not something that is hard wired. Given all of the dramatic behavior you've three been involved in, has "poly" been his way of explaining his difficulty enforcing and even recognizing his own boundaries?
 
Last edited:
Hi kwags27,

You've been through an incredible amount of drama, and come clean through to the other side. Perhaps you could endure just about anything in the future. But you have to decide if you *want* to endure that much. It is, after all, your life, and in my belief system at least you only get one life. Live it well! Don't let yourself be sucked into another ordeal if you can help it. Your time is worth more than that.

I think you can stay with your boyfriend if you want, you just have to guard against drama in the future. And he does need a higher standard for whom he will date.

Good luck and hang in there.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Recap: my bf is a new poly
I'll stop you right there. No, your boyfriend -- emphasis BOY -- might want to be nonmonogamous, but he totally SUCKS at polyamory.

He makes himself increasingly spineless, moment by moment, in order to please That Chick, who has no reason to become a decent human being because she's already in charge of his life, & by extension yours.

You are NOT going to be able to fix him; it's up to HIM to stop filling his life with garbage.

Your choice lies in whether you want to wait around in hopes of an empty husk when Other Girl gets bored with him, or whether what's there this moment is even worth salvaging -- does he really WANT this sort of abuse & manipulation, & are you willing to learn to do it properly?

Kudos to you for trying to understand this within a poly paradigm... but it ain't poly. You can certainly do better.
 
Others have given feedback in many areas, but I had a question:

You've been in love with this guy for 14 years? And somehow ended up dating him finally now, while he is dating this other woman for 2 1/2 years? How did all that come about? Has he also been in love with you for a long long long-ass time? If he loves you, why is he with her fully (having sex) but not having sex with you?

What prevented you two dating up til just recently?

I am guessing you still haven't had sex with him because he's still letting her come around and whine at him or whatever she's doing.

I hope you can get all this sorted out!
 
Back
Top