Can your spouse *not* be your primary? (Help!)

Arabella

New member
A little background: The hubby and I have been poly since 2011. We now have two kids together. The last time I wrote here, the hubby was dating a mutual friend and this caused some issues because we had just decided to conceive our second child. I felt emotionally unprepared for him to be dating and had told him prior to him entering that relationship that I was putting my other relationships on the backburner for now to focus on getting and being pregnant, and raising a child for a few years, or until my feelings changed, at which point we’d talk about things again. I had told him I didn't expect him to do the same, but I was also disappointed when he chose to date during my pregnancy. He had dated before as had I, so this wasn't especially new territory for us.

But whatever, we worked on stuff, and acknowledged the places where we could have used more honest communication between each other and more honesty with ourselves. That other relationship ended before I gave birth, and for the past almost 2 years now, the two of us have essentially been monogamous with each other and focused on parenting and other life stresses. I have an ongoing relationship with the man I first started dating 5 years ago, Mr. C. although it was understood that I couldn't give our relationship as much time and energy as before as I needed/wanted to allocate much of that to the new baby and our other child. We didn't break up, but he wasn't someone in our lives, basically. I communicate with him maybe once every 2 months, it's almost ad if we’re not involved at all.

The hubby’s job was pretty stressful for him and we encountered numerous issues with his company messing up his leave of absence and accidently dropping us from health insurance multiple times causing me to deal with stacks and stacks of medical bills, and I'm addition to that, our social security office made a mistake with my disability payments…. Eh, long story short, we had many financial stressors imposed upon us while we also were caring for a new baby.

As usual for us, our marriage became strengthened through these hardships and although it was draining for us, we were able to lean on each other. Things became brighter once he applied for and was hired at a new job and put in his 2 weeks notice. Finally, we would be able to be HAPPY with each other instead of barely above water, always stressed and tired and worried. Our sex life picked up, our relationship with each other improved even more, and even our kids were happier.

Right before leaving that job, he told me that a co-worker was interested in just making out with him once before he left. He had told me about her for the past year, that she knew he was poly, and they had admitted attraction to each other but he also admitted with all his current stressors, he was just not in a place to date. Additionally, it was our hope to conceive a third and final child once these current issues were delt with. But basically, this other woman’s request was not a surprise to me.

I expressed to the hubby my slight disappointment and unease at this arrangement but also sort of gave my blessing and even encouragement, as I knew he wanted to just at least connect with her for some time. So then quickly, just in his last week at his job, they kissed, slept together, and began spending a ton of time communicating with each other, as is normal for NRE for a lot of people. After that first week, I again expressed how I was uncomfortable with the speed things were going. It had been 2 years since he had been seeing anyone else, and even longer for me, and I felt we needed to have a good sit down and discuss basic things like boundaries, expectations, scheduling of quality time, and all that. A regular check in of sorts, but also with new baby happening, things may have changed and we should talk about these things. He verbally agreed, but within another week told me that they were both deeply in love.

This was distressing because I still really felt unprepared, and as a stay at home mom, my day is filled with school scheduling, feeding a toddler, getting a grade schooler to his activities, homework, housework, family time, friend time, and my own personal pursuits, rehearsing once a week in my community chorus. Barely squeezing in marriage time too, but partly due to the fact that the hubby job was so stressful that he didn't have time for anything except work, worrying about work, and sleeping. We were both looking forward to almost celebrating his new job, and I felt I was jipped out of that because here we are, poly again, and I'm not ready. I'm really not ready, I feel blindsided.

I requested he pause or slow down. So that we could have our discussions and both be comfortable with this new arrangement. I felt like this was reasonable. This was met with tears and anger and frustration from him, as he was genuinely happier now, the job was great, he was more present and involved in parenting and our marriage. And his general health improved, why did I want to get in the way of his NRE that he now had emotional room for?

We went to our poly-friendly counsellor, we talked with each other a lot, but I feel like we’re getting nowhere. I feel angry and betrayed, I feel coerced to just go along with everything when I feel very uncomfortable with this, I'm also learning that his desire for kids has changed because of how it would affect his current relationship. I get things are always big and dramatic in the beginning of the relationship, but it hurts to feel like I'm suddenly on equal footing with this stranger (to me) who just entered my life without my consent and is now a huge factor in how I live with my husband. I feel like he didn't give my feelings any weight, and I feel like in part I allowed it to be this way and that maybe *I* give my own feelings less weight, too.

I'm just so angry. It's not fair, I hear myself saying a lot. I love her too, he spends all his time saying and didn't seem to understand that I didn't need that shoved in my face in every conversation as if I didn't know. As if that wasn't part of why I have such an aversion to just demanding he alter his involvement with her. I feel as if I were getting dressed for a nice stroll in the park with my husband on a finally beautiful day, but before I finished getting sundress and cute heels on, he and this other woman have suddenly started running a race, hand in hand and I'm expected to take his hand and keep up, when I didn't even put my running shoes on, i don't have the right bra on for this, I didn't know we were suddenly taking off and not sure I even want to. I didn't know this was happening, I didn't stretch beforehand, and here they are, halfway down the track already, and he's starting to ask how I feel about fluid bonding! Slow down! Stop! Wait for me to catch up, I want to yell! I am not ready yet, I can and probably will be, but if you can’t even pause to let me get my bearings, how much do you really care about my well being? I feel almost betrayed, and that we're trying to work on the marriage while he still sees the woman he cheated on me with. (It's not like that, really, I just mean it in the way that it blocks any healing from occurring while hurt is still happening). He is really invested in spending quality time with me (now, of course) and is taking on a lot more of the emotional work in the marriage now that he has room for it. He's working hard at this, but it still seems like he's working hard at dragging me down the running track with him untiI can finally run myself. I don't feel like I'm consenting to this, which is why it feels close to betrayal. He has suggested boundaries he wants to put in place with him and his relationship which he agrees should have been there in the first place.

But in the end, I guess I need to take care of myself first, right? I need to honor my own feelings which I don't do as often. And I feel like I need to be not so enmeshed with him and all this to do that right now. I want to be…. I kinda don't want to be his primary right now. I almost want to be alone, to first lick my wounds and then to get myself on the right footing before I start dealing with us living a polyamory lifestyle again. Since he's already *there* I need to do this on my own.

But we live together, we co-parent, we are close with both of our families, we are of limited financial means, so physically separating is impossible. I can weather the NRE he’s in, but i still need to feel like my feelings and needs are being given weight, and I just can't with him right now.

Is that possible? Can we be married and co parent and be as involved with everything as we are and still have emotional time for myself? I want to be *out* of it all right now, and even our counsellor suggested I first need time away from active parenting and alone time more. I'm having trouble getting my alone time when it's filled with anger at being betrayed and his refusal to slow down. Slow down how, he asks? We’re so deeply in love, etc.

I guess what I'm asking for is suggestions for how to work this all in. How to I make sure i'm valuing myself? How do I separate myself from my hubby’s relationship, especially when I'm also his best friend that he comes to for advice on these things “Do you think she’ll like it if I give her this drawing I made?” “Can you put the kids to bed while I go to her work and bring her some chocolate because she had a hard day? When I get back I want to watch a movie with you,” etc. I love being there for him as a friend, but I'm still so angry. I want to be alone, but I'm mad at him for taking away our expected honeymoon from stress and instead making feel like being alone is the best option.

Sorry, I know this is a lot, but can someone give any suggestions on how I can work through these icky feelings?
 
Wow, it sounds like your husband has gone a bit nuts. NRE will do that, but most people who have been poly for 6 years will have learned something about controlling NRE and not behaving like a teenager in their first puppy love.

It sounds like Work Girl and he were actually growing their attraction and closeness for a good year. But hubby was too stressed to act on it.

I saw a red flag when he asked if he could "make out just one time" with her. Yeah right! Like that ever happens.

Now suddenly he's "in looooove" and running roughshod over your feelings, and not being a responsible adult, and probably neglecting his children as well.

It is so gross that he is using you as a soundboard to grow his relationship with Work Girl, whom you resent. And what the hell is she thinking? She knows he's a father, she knows he went through hell financially, and needs to rebuild his life with his wife, enjoy some well earned respite, and yet she's taking over most of his energy. Does she even know how poly works? Does she want to cowgirl him away from you and the kids and the dream of a third kid?

He needs a good (metaphorical) slap in the face. He is, imo, approaching the "throw his clothes onto the lawn and change the locks" mode of treatment.

I had a similar thing happen to me in my marriage. Just when I thought things were going great, kids were getting older, more time and money for dates and sex and vacations, hubby and I tried poly and he "fell in loooove" with another woman and kept throwing that in my face! Suddenly I no longer felt like his primary! Ms New and Shiny took up most of his emotional energy. She was so frickin exciting. :mad: It really really really sucked. We also did couples and individual counseling for several years, but it didn't mend our marriage. It helped me grow more independent though, and I finally divorced him. He never fell out of love with Ms New and Shiny. I moved on. It was very hard. I am way better off now. I found someone who does poly right and who loves me and treats me way better than my ex h ever did.

Something I wish I'd done was move out sooner. (even if it's temporary). Sometimes you have to take drastic measures. Men can be so dumb.
 
I expressed to the hubby my slight disappointment and unease at this arrangement but also sort of gave my blessing and even encouragement, as I knew he wanted to just at least connect with her for some time
I think you could have been less "mixed messages" and just plain "no, not at this time"

Because it had been a while, new baby, and needing to talk about new poly agreements first.

But in the end, I guess I need to take care of myself first, right? I need to honor my own feelings which I don't do as often.

Yup. You need to put your own oxygen mask on first.

I want to be *out* of it all right now, and even our counsellor suggested I first need time away from active parenting and alone time more. I'm having trouble getting my alone time when it's filled with anger at being betrayed and his refusal to slow down. Slow down how, he asks? We’re so deeply in love, etc
.

I suggest you take your counselor's advice.

Schedule time away from the family so you can be on your own. See friends. Or see a movie by yourself. Take a class.

Step away from his emotions. Stop asking him to slow down his emotions. Feelings cannot be measured. Ask him to do BEHAVIORS. Those can be measured. They either get done or not. You could say "I want to do what the counselor says and make time on my own. I want to do it by taking a painting class. I can do the Mon/Wed or the Tues/Thurs class. Which one works better for you to watch the kids?"

Watching kids is something he can DO that does not involve his feelings for his GF.

How do I separate myself from my hubby’s relationship, especially when I'm also his best friend that he comes to for advice on these things

You learn to say "No, not at this time."

“Do you think she’ll like it if I give her this drawing I made?”

"No. I cannot help you or give you input on how to run your other relationship at this time. You have to sort it yourself without my input. Please do not ask me things like that again for the next X months. I'm trying to do what the counselor says to do."

It comes up again? Play the broken record. The only way to stop being so enmeshed in it is to notice when you are getting sucked back in and stay out.

“Can you put the kids to bed while I go to her work and bring her some chocolate because she had a hard day? When I get back I want to watch a movie with you,” etc.

"No. I cannot do your chores for you. This is too short notice to negotiate a chore swap. I need our agreements for family chores and family calendar to be stable."

Alternately? "No. Attend to your children first and do your share of the chores as scheduled. After the kids and and house are closed down for the night if you want to go out again, that is your business."

You do not have to be left holding the bag with ALL the kid and house jobs.

Why would watching a movie with someone you are mad at be a "reward" for doing their chores for them? He doesn't even ask you if you want to do a movie. He announces what he wants -- that HE wants to watch a movie with you.

Be more fun to NOT do the chores of the person you are mad at. And NOT watch a movie with person you are mad at.

He's being kinda fresh.

I love being there for him as a friend, but I'm still so angry. I want to be alone, but I'm mad at him for taking away our expected honeymoon from stress and instead making feel like being alone is the best option.

You could be honest with him about this.

"Husband, I endured a long stress time with you and was looking forward to a honeymoon period after you changed jobs. Getting to enjoy being free of bills, reconnecting, and so on. Being a COUPLE and not being parents, or roomies, or coworkers at the Life Company.

Instead, you are taking the honeymoon time to spend with your new partner which you said was going to be a one time deal. Instead it became a long term thing. To me that is like bait and switch. I feel disappointed and hurt. I need time to heal from that. So no. At this time I cannot be your best friend and help you develop your other relationship when I struggle with envy that she is getting the honeymoon time and the honeymoon you I wanted for myself."

Speak plain.

He may or may not adjust his behavior but then you are not going around with bottled up anger. Keep working with your counselor.

If you cannot afford to move out, consider putting away for a hotel stay over a long weekend in the near future. You don't have to leave town, but it sounds like you need a breather on your own. Go sleep a lot, eat nice things, hang by the pool, REST. Take the newborn if you are nursing and stuff and it is easier that way, but leave the bigger child and husband at home.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Hi Arabella,

It sounds like your husband is moving too fast, in a relationship that you did not want. I am thinking that whenever you and he are thinking about conceiving a child, he needs to put his poly relationships on hold (until the child is born and gets to be at least a year old). The two of you need to not be poly during a pregnancy or while there is a baby in the house.

Honestly, I wonder if poly is really your cup of tea at anytime, you don't seem to be thrilled with the idea in general, you want your husband's attention and devotion and you can't get those things when he is all caught up in NRE with someone else. Maybe it is time to withdraw your consent for poly, he can still do it but at least know that he is acting against your wishes.

It must be frustrating, having your husband race ahead of you with his girlfriend, when you did not sign up for a race, and were looking forward to enjoying some down time with him. I'm sorry he is acting that way.

Are there things about your marriage that you still enjoy? Are there things about your husband that you still love? What are some of his good points? I ask just for my own perspective.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
So let me get this straight. You guys are supposedly poly. You have kept up a relationship this whole time, though not a very intense one. Your hubby put poly on the back burner for a period of time due to being in a stressful situation. Things get better and he starts something up. For some reason you feel the need to "keep up".

I get that you don't need to hear from him about how great that relationship is. Perhaps tell him you don't need to hear all that info. Is he neglecting you or your kids? Did you two have some sort of veto power in place?

But the answer to your question is yes, it seems like it's done all the time. I had a partner who was actually divorced but still shares the house with her ex. They do that to keep a stable home for the kids. At first they alternated times at home in order to not have to bring people over, plus they weren't getting along. Now I think she spends most of her time there.
 
Your own boundaries appear to be total bullshit.

1. You need to stop saying yes when you mean no. No one else can fix this for you and it is looking like a dysfunctional pattern between the two of you. He wants to date a mutual friend while you're trying to conceive a second child. You don't like it, but agree anyway or he goes ahead anyway. He wants to go ahead with an interested woman while you're trying to get home finances together and conceive a third child. You don't like it but you agree. What nonsense is this? If you are in an adult relationship that is in a phase where you need to be committed to each other and his external interests are causing you distress, why are you saying yes?

2. He asked for and you agreed to be with this woman "once" - so how is it progressing to a relationship in spite of your unease? Did you agree to this? Why are you discussing scheduling and boundaries if you agreed to "once" and have only expressed discomfort and unease about this?

3. It seems to suit him to simply take your agreements at face value and leave you to cope with whatever discomforts you state. It is insensitive behavior, but you pretty much walk into it, from the sound of it.

4. If he is in love with this new woman regardless of your agreement, you should take a relationship break and co-parent in a manner that shares responsibilities so that he takes up part of the responsibilities allowing you a breather.

5. If it is not fair to you, why are you in this scenario?

6. Him talking about her is actually the easiest to fix. When he does it next, tell him to shut up. Talking about his new romance to you only works if you make a big fuss over it, discuss problems, give ideas and what not to make it work better for him. Tell him you didn't consent to this and are reconsidering your relationship with him over him proceeding without your consent and you are really not interested in hearing about his disregard to his commitment to you and family just because he is on a hormonal high over it. There is a time for politeness, but when you are being walked all over is not it.

7. Sadly (and I've seen this more with men than women, but does happen with both), when one partner earns the/more money and sees a dramatic increase in his/her ability to provide (particularly if finances were tight before), there is often a certain arrogance that comes in. It is like the earning partner sees it only as his/her own rise in status and the economically weaker partner as not equal to his new status. It is an ugly process that takes the other partner for granted, is blind to any contributions by them (particularly if they are non-monetary) and essentially is an entitled perspective where the non-earning or economically weaker partner is seen as someone inferior. When, in reality, he is acting juvenile on an adult subject. Pointing out the lack of appreciation for the other partner and their contributions should help in theory, but rarely does. Not much you can do about this other than learning to draw your own boundaries which are already dubious. Distance yourself from him, follow your own interests, create your own space, friends, support system and ideally, source of income. All that is time consuming. Insist that he care for the home and children so that you have time to do these things.

8. You probably should leave him at some point unless he sees how his actions are clearly a betrayal of your relationship, stops irresponsible and insensitive actions and works on rebuilding your relationship. Continuing in this manner is not going to result in any joy for you.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Mags, GalaGirl, and kdt. I was hoping for feedback from you three especially!

Showing The Hubby what I had written seemed to have struck a chord in him. Maybe this is a better way for us to communicate really important things, as it seems a lot of specifics and intent gets lost in our verbal conversations. Explaining the jist of the feedback I had gotten helped a lot, too. Also it helps a lot to be "heard" here, so thank you.

I agree that I probably had been giving mixed messages. I need to be more clear to myself as to what I want so that I can be with him as well. Thanks so much for the guidance in that regard.

Kdt, I was the one all gung ho for poly in the beginning, and I really like a lot of the benefits we've seen from the lifestyle both individually and as a couple. However, I suspected my feelings might change being pregnant and even after child #2 and they did. I think I see us, in the future, when kids are not so little, continuing this, but it doesn't seem compatible with the kind of mother I want to be right now. In short, I think you're right in that poly's not for me right now, but I can see a time in the future that it would be. I DO want The Hubby all to myself right now, while the kids are little. Not forever, but right now, that is the kind of support I need.

We are both musicians and although we perform vastly different styles, our strengths compliment each other, and we've always been able to come together and heal through music. He's so passionate and I am too, passionate, broke artists, but just saying that makes me smile. When we started dating in Jan 2000, we both declared that we didn't care what we did with our lives, we weren't even sure what roads to go down, but as long as we walked our own paths with the other's support, that was all we needed. A little Pollyanna of us, to be sure, but we were 20 and 21 at the time. :)

I love how wonderful a father my husband is. He wanted kids way before, and more strongly than I did. He loves deeply and our boys benefit from that. That may be part of why I want him "here" more. He's so good at it and our oldest is starting to get to the age where he needs a male role model more than his mother.

I enjoy healthy debate with him, I enjoy how we educate each other on social issues and how as one of us grows, the other is inspired to, also. I love the even, measured cadence to his voice when he tells a story, I love how he can mimic everyone's laugh at a party, I love how he is a generous and thoughtful lover, I love when he speaks Italian to me, or other words in foreign languages with genuine accents.

I love how he decided he needed to educate himself on every Star Trek episode ever, and how I can remember my own adolescence with those shows and share that with him as an adult. I love how he is true to himself and stands up for what he believes in and passionately defends and protects the people he loves. I love how when I first got sick 15 years ago, he never left me and still wantes to be with me even though over 50% of people with my condition end up in a wheelchair.

I just enjoy *being* in this marriage with him.
 
Last edited:
...he never left me and still wantes to be with me even though over 50% of people with my condition end up in a wheelchair.

If you are at risk of ending up in a wheelchair due to your condition, and your husband who was enthusiastic about kids is now interested outside the home, it becomes all the more important for you to establish responsible behavior with regard to the home and relationships on the part of both of you. It isn't fair to him to agree to his relationship and then grudge it either, just like it isn't fair to you to be shoved into having to cope with a poly partner when you don't want it.

I just enjoy *being* in this marriage with him.

All the more reason to ensure that it stays healthy and being honest instead of making unhealthy compromises. If you need him to be all to yourself in this phase of parenting, you should not agree to the opposite. When our own words speak our highest truth - no matter how inconvenient or embarrassing ("We were poly, but right now I need us to be mono"), they ring with authenticity and invite honest dialogue in turn. There are no guarantees it will work perfectly, but if you begin with a dishonest agreement, it is guaranteed that real needs will not be discussed in a useful way.

If this marriage is precious enough to keep, then it ought to be precious enough to do hard things like be truthful about your needs, even if his are different. Or you may end up keeping it, only for the nature of the marriage to change to something you don't enjoy.
 
So let me get this straight. You guys are supposedly poly. You have kept up a relationship this whole time, though not a very intense one. Your hubby put poly on the back burner for a period of time due to being in a stressful situation. Things get better and he starts something up. For some reason you feel the need to "keep up".

This is not really accurate. I did not keep up a relationship the while time, quite the opposite, *I* told my boyfriend we were essentially done for now. The Hubby is the one who has continued to date. Even while in the stressful situation while I was pregnant he took a new lover, and now again too. I don't want to keep up, I don't want to date. I just want more family and couple time and we hadn't talked about opening up again. What bothers me is staring somethi gup without us being able to touch base and talk again, and now it's "whoops, sorry its too late, we're already in love, can't go back now."

But for the other examples, thank you, that is helpful.

Edited to add, my signature has not been updated yet, so these relationships are not current and was the situation before getting pregnant back in 2015, sorry if there was confusion.
 
Last edited:
1. You need to stop saying yes when you mean no.

Yup, I feel this is at the root of what I need to fix on my end. I liked to think of myself as fairly good communicator bit it's becoming apparent I haven't been honest with myself.

I agree with many of the other points you made, too. Thank you!
 
This is not really accurate. I did not keep up a relationship the while time, quite the opposite, *I* told my boyfriend we were essentially done for now. The Hubby is the one who has continued to date. Even while in the stressful situation while I was pregnant he took a new lover, and now again too. I don't want to keep up, I don't want to date. I just want more family and couple time and we hadn't talked about opening up again. What bothers me is staring somethi gup without us being able to touch base and talk again, and now it's "whoops, sorry its too late, we're already in love, can't go back now."

But for the other examples, thank you, that is helpful.

Edited to add, my signature has not been updated yet, so these relationships are not current and was the situation before getting pregnant back in 2015, sorry if there was confusion.

My confusion came when you claimed in the OP you did not break up with Mr C.

To clarify from my side, my poly philosophy does not allow for a partner to dictate to me whether or not I can practice poly. In other words, a partner does not get to make an arbitrary decision that we are no longer poly.

BTW, the platonic co-parenting thing doesn't always work out so be prepared for that. At one time I moved into an ex's house to help take care of our daughter and to help her out with rent. I had my own entrance and we weren't romantic at all. That ended when I started seeing the woman who would become my wife. My ex asked me to move out. Even though we weren't romantic, she still had a jealous streak ten miles wide.
 
Vince,

Ah, thank you, this helps a lot. The garbage was confusing for me too at first, since Mr. C. didn't want to call it a break up. We had been good friends since high school (which was now 20 years ago!) and suggested we not "break up" but instead go back to being good friends who occasionally flirt and see each other at group gaming nights, but not actually make concrete plans to see each other one on one.

So basically, in my head we were done for the near future, but in Mr. C' s. mind, it was just me being busy with pregnancy and child bearing for the moment and we'll pick up again later when I'm ready. I'm not ready yet, but he insisted we not call it a break up. Semantics, I guess *shrug*

Re: poly philosophy, this is where I have been running up against my own interests, too. We don't have "veto power" and I don't really believe a partner should make an arbitrary decisions as to whether or not "we" are practicing poly. So I guess we both need to clarify what exactly this means to us.
 
To clarify from my side, my poly philosophy does not allow for a partner to dictate to me whether or not I can practice poly. In other words, a partner does not get to make an arbitrary decision that we are no longer poly.

But then you wouldn't be agreeing to monogamous phase in order to conceive little children with one partner, would you? If you read OP, they were monogamous for two years when he asked her if he could get involved with this woman who wanted to be with him "once"... which morphed into "I am in lurve, therefore NRE, plans, scheduling, blah blah"

Edit: Maybe it is a controlling thing, but if a partner agreed to monogamy in order to willingly shoulder a shared responsibility - kids - for example, to me that amounts to writing away autonomy to decide on poly till that responsibility is assessed and poly is renegotiated. A chap who simply takes advantage of the fact that a partner can hardly cancel existing kids if he goes back on his part is a dishonest creep. In my view, the responsibility is shared and one of them doesn't just get to bow out of exclusive commitment to the family unit unilaterally if they agreed to it to begin with.

It is all to easy to trap women like this. Biology often necessitates economic dependence as well as greater attachment to children at least in early years and whether mono or poly, it is all too common for men to take this for granted in the name of their "freedom". On the part of the woman, she enters into consensual plans to create babies, but once the diapers start stinking, she's left holding the whole show with the man picking and choosing the extent of his participation. This isn't autonomy or freedom, it is basic dishonesty by backing out of a commitment at a vulnerable juncture.
 
Last edited:
But then you wouldn't be agreeing to monogamous phase in order to conceive little children with one partner, would you? If you read OP, they were monogamous for two years when he asked her if he could get involved with this woman who wanted to be with him "once"... which morphed into "I am in lurve, therefore NRE, plans, scheduling, blah blah"

I didn't say nothing is negotiable. I may or may not have agreed to that. My point is I want a choice.

Edit: Maybe it is a controlling thing, but if a partner agreed to monogamy in order to willingly shoulder a shared responsibility - kids - for example, to me that amounts to writing away autonomy to decide on poly till that responsibility is assessed and poly is renegotiated. A chap who simply takes advantage of the fact that a partner can hardly cancel existing kids if he goes back on his part is a dishonest creep. In my view, the responsibility is shared and one of them doesn't just get to bow out of exclusive commitment to the family unit unilaterally if they agreed to it to begin with.

I didn't get the sense that was a formal agreement. It reads more like it just sort of worked out that way.

It is all to easy to trap women like this. Biology often necessitates economic dependence as well as greater attachment to children at least in early years and whether mono or poly, it is all too common for men to take this for granted in the name of their "freedom". On the part of the woman, she enters into consensual plans to create babies, but once the diapers start stinking, she's left holding the whole show with the man picking and choosing the extent of his participation. This isn't autonomy or freedom, it is basic dishonesty by backing out of a commitment at a vulnerable juncture.

Or trap a man like that? But you just got done telling the OP her boundaries were BS, then blame him. He isn't backing out of any commitment. Where has he indicated that he is not committed to the relationship? She is the one who wants to back out now.
 
Or trap a man like that?

Sure, women do that too, but in this case, the choice to conceive appears to be mutual.

But you just got done telling the OP her boundaries were BS, then blame him.

Her boundaries being BS doesn't mean he isn't dropping his end. She has stated her unease repeatedly. She hasn't agreed to him getting into an entire new relationship because "love happened" - he'd asked about a one off thing, if one is to go by OP's posts. It is rather glaring that with two young children, OP has limited options if he chooses to change the rules on her. There is plenty of stated discomfort as well, that appears to not be mattering to her partner.

He isn't backing out of any commitment. Where has he indicated that he is not committed to the relationship?

Um... the part where he negotiates and gets into a one off thing that seems to be snowballing into a full blown relationship that has the wife blindsided? The part where she tells him where it is going too fast but .... NRE? If that isn't changing the rules from a "couple taking time with each other to raise children", hard to imagine what is.

Do you hear any conversations here about opening to poly again? Or a fait accompli?
 
So basically, in my head we were done for the near future, but in Mr. C' s. mind, it was just me being busy with pregnancy and child bearing for the moment and we'll pick up again later when I'm ready. I'm not ready yet, but he insisted we not call it a break up. Semantics, I guess *shrug*

Not semantics. You defined your relationship with C differently from how you saw it because he wanted it. It isn't semantics whether you call yourself on with a partner or not - regardless of whether you are meeting frequently.

It is another example of you saying yes when you mean no.

You can't prevent him from calling it whatever he wants, but if it was "done" for you, why are you adopting his description when speaking with unrelated others? He decides your relationships? At best he was "I'm done with poly for now, but C is preferring to see this as a break. We occasionally interact"

The difference between a current partner and an ex is not semantics!
 
Do you hear any conversations here about opening to poly again? Or a fait accompli?

I am not seeing any conversations at all. Just assumptions, until after the fact. If the two of them sat down and decided to remain monogamous, then I see your point. I'm not seeing that happened though.
 
I never understand the hurry people are in in NRE. If you’re SO in love you’ll still be SO in love a year or two down the line when things have settled and you can take it as slow as slow can be and you’ll still be SO in love.

On the other hand if you’re not that compatible as people or friends and you need the trappings of romance and all the things to keep up the illusion of compatibility then maybe I can see why you’d not want to slow down. Kinda ruins the excuse though.
 
I never understand the hurry people are in in NRE. If you’re SO in love you’ll still be SO in love a year or two down the line when things have settled and you can take it as slow as slow can be and you’ll still be SO in love.

On the other hand if you’re not that compatible as people or friends and you need the trappings of romance and all the things to keep up the illusion of compatibility then maybe I can see why you’d not want to slow down. Kinda ruins the excuse though.

To me there is no fast or slow. There is only whatever speed at which it moves along. To have a third party dictate that speed is artificial.
 
It's very easy to update your signature. Mr C is definitely NOT your bf now. Own that.

There doesn't have to be this discussion about a veto. There has to be several adult conversations about "Closing the relationship for now, during the intensive parenting stage, whether we both ID as poly or not."

Either the husband agrees to Close while raising young kids, or he doesn't. He has that choice. It's not a veto. He went ahead and started a new relationship without the wife agreeing it was the right time to do it. I'm sure he knew conceiving a 3rd child was a strong possibility. He wanted that too? Then he shouldn't have had this apparently very flirty thing going at work. Sounds like the "work wife" idea... and it got so intense they felt they needed just one good makeout session. And then realised that was SO GOOD, they needed to fuck, and fuck and fuck, again, and again.

Totally wrong of him to do this without his wife's consent. This needs to be talked over, maybe with a therapist, if the partners are unequal to the task on their own.

If he needs to fuck his work wife more than he feels compelled to be a good husband and father to young children, so be it. Break up. Forget about the 3rd child. 2 is enough. He's doing a bad job with just 2 kids. Break up, and be a single mom, and be open to finding a good man who wants to be a good (step) father. Don't settle for the crumbs he's offering right now. That is bullshit. It's disrespectful and insulting.
 
Back
Top