I'm sorry.

[…]
Which leaves you with these choices in return:
- let go of the vision of a future you hoped for badly. Stay here and have your first close fatherhood experiences with her and the OSO's baby instead.
- Keep the vision, let go of the relationship. Seek someone else to share family life with so your first fatherhood experiences ARE with your biological child. You just won't have them with her.
- You move out. Go do something else for the next 2 years and then come back after she's done being pregnant and the baby has hit 1st bday. So you get to keep some of the vision and not deal in "first year memories" with the OSO's baby. But know it comes at a risk of growing apart, so this choice might be worse than just ending it outright so you can know where things stand.
[…]
Galagirl
Thank you for writing so empathically and clearly, it does help to have a bit of an overview. It is clear that one choice smells definitely the least, and that would be number 1. I do care about DNA, but I wanted to be a teacher/mentor/guardian since I was fourteen, and have studied both pedagogics and applied psychology, because I find it interesting to deal with people, their problems and finding a way to help them reflect and grow. This feeling was always even more powerful when I thought about being a parent, regardless to whom. If I think about picking up a drifting child, a baby left at my doorstep, a wandering teen, my sibling’s children, my own or whatever, I feel happy, I feel like I want to love that person, regardless of their age, and want to help them to be the best person they can be.
Option 2 would be an option, but to find someone who feels the same about everything else in life, who shares my vision of parenting, life and poly-families is rather small. Add to that the problems of where to move, where to work, and how to pay for it all (living on your own can be rather expensive) with no savings left…that seems a huge setback that would cost me a few years to establish myself well enough to even venture forward in my life I guess.
Option 3 is very much possible, and I guess I would then just walk out into the world and maybe go meditate somewhere in the east for a while, but that would still be no guarantee for me to have a place when I come back. So, should I walk out, I would need to make clear to myself that if I close the door behind me, it might be the last time ever in that house, with that family.
As for my feeling, I know my vision of life finds most comfort in option 1. I would like to live my life in an open environment, a commune even, with people who share beliefs and love each other for whatever they are. Where we don’t assign roles like “father” and “mother”, but see us as parents with different identities. Still, in the eyes of the law, I would have –no- leg to stand on should something go awry (like one of the parents growing a dislike of me, or people seeing a practical use in me moving out).
It is with these obstacles that I’m trying to deal; both with the emotional side of accepting that the first child might not be mine, and the purely practical ramifications that might follow.
I would definitely respect myself most for it, should I be able to handle that. I think it would make me a great person, if I can get over these pre-conceived notions (maybe even spoon-fed by my cultural background or my past) and love each person for how they are.
Hi Winston,
[…] Shouldn't EF move in with you guys and be part of the family?
That aside, how much of a problem is it for you to be a surrogate parent to the first child you raise? […]
[…]
Others will say it's too soon for EF to be moving in with you guys, but if that's true, then isn't it also too soon for him to be fathering a child with AB? Hopefully my logic makes some sense here ...
[…]
I hope this helps.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
Thank you so much, your post was very comforting to read.
I’ve addressed the practical problem to them both. EF thinks mostly from an emotional perspective and says I should in no way feel obligated, and should distance myself whenever I feel like it (so, someone’s crying in the middle of the night and I can just ignore it? I’m still skeptical about that remark…). AB and I have already started making this house very EF friendly, and we both would like it if he feels rather free to come and leave. We have a guest room that he can make his own, to a certain extent, but we had too always planned that to be the children’s room, so I have no clue how AB has planned that in her head. AB has also often said that when she visits EF’s home, the child could join her there (we all work flexibly). I don’t see a problem with this for the first few years (although I don’t know how healthy it is to be a few weeks a month in a 1 room apartment and the other weeks in the building it should feel is “home”), but when the child goes to school, has dentist appointments, etc. etc. I see it to become rather problematic. EF would definitely need to move to our vicinity in the near future.
Raising the child is in essence no problem, I wouldn’t mind being a surrogate parent, but I would definitely someday hope for a biological child of my own. I have more of a problem with the practical side towards my family (meeting the pregnant AB, and I don’t want to feel uncomfortable when I explain things, going to our meetings with my larger family, taking the child there, being vetoed when making decisions, possibly having to distance myself from certain occasions because of laws. Can I be in the birthing room for example? I think they have regulations against non-family here.) Sometimes, it can seem that I indeed get the joys of people raising children, and I get a lot of the responsibility and arduous tasks too, but I don’t have any ‘rights’ apart from what I can trust them to give me. But yeah, trust, can be a fickle thing.
Having practice was something EF and AB also mentioned. Should I indeed feel more special, or still feel a different “first” feeling with the second child, that would of course be completely beneficial. Right now, I’m really leaning towards seeing the benefits in this light too.
Your logics do make a lot of sense, but AB says she would have him move in any day, it feels right to her. I do like him a lot, we get along great, but I also sometimes feel like I’m being replaced a bit. But then, that’s an understandable feeling since we know each other –well- and EF is still rather new to her. That will wear off in time, and AB sometimes already realizes that I’ve changed in time too, and that she should get to know me again. I’ve planned a first date already, because I refuse giving up on us : P
When I talk to them about it, it seems like the decision has long been made, but AB can be quite changeable (in good ways). She has recently stopped taking contraception, but it can take a year or more before her hormone levels allow for her to be pregnant, so I do have time to maul it over I think. She also stated that whoever wants to have sex with her should wear a condom from now on. I do wish to speak more clearly to both of them on this matter, but I also find it difficult to bring it up every time we meet or see each other.
Do you think your depression and diagnosis of a personality disorder is in any way a factor here? Not in terms of your emotional or mental fitness to be a parent, but in terms of your biological fitness? I'm just throwing it out there as a thought. I know some people whose own mental health issues have been such a struggle that they have actively not wanted to have children in case they pass on the condition.
Well, as far as I know my “conditions” are not hereditary, and so I do not fear any of this passing on. I am very aware now of my pitfalls and the ways to deal with them. Luckily, these ways suit my lifestyle and so I can adjust myself rather well. I know that AB has no problems with it whatsoever, and EF has suffered from depression a long time himself and is completely understanding of the matter. The medication works (I think) rather well against it though, and through exercise and focusing on self-development (both intra-, interpersonal and knowledge) I’ve been able to find a huge outlet to channel my fears, angsts, energy and re-establish myself. In the last three months I’ve discovered I have some major issues with certain things (mostly inhibition, not sexually but interpersonally, like eye contact) and have been making strides with therapy and intrapersonal reflection.
[…]
I'm going to disagree a bit with the folks that say DNA "shouldn't" matter. I actually really, really HATE it when other people say how I "should" feel about something.
[…]
Those who say that DNA "shouldn't" matter likely feel that it's a "good thing" I am barren, since I don't want kids for the "right reasons"...they may be correct.
JaneQ
Well, anyone saying that would be a horrible person. A lot of how a child is, is based on DNA. How that is molded is parenting, peer-pressure and whatever, but people thinking it’s purely Nurture and no Nature, are bullshitting themselves. They should read into studies on identical twins growing up apart from their twin.