Metamour breakup & sad feelings

MeeraReed

Well-known member
So, I don't see this particular issue come up much...I feel sad and distressed that my metamour (now ex-metamour) is heartbroken over my partner.

My partner Elijah broke up with his other partner, Arabella, this week. They had been dating for about 7 months, I think. I liked her--definitely my favorite metamour in the 8 years I've been seeing Elijah.

For background, I live about 2 hours away from Elijah, and I prefer parallel poly and thus don't interact much with metamours, so I wasn't particularly close to Arabella. But I like her. She's sweet, thoughtful, smart, a talented artist, and struggling with a host of challenging issues (including disability, chronic illness, mental health, housing insecurity, and family-of-origin estrangement/emotional abuse). She's been dealt a shit hand in life, yet still became a caring, self-aware, resilient person.

Anyway, I was rooting for things to work out between her and Elijah. But for whatever reason, they didn't. Nothing to do with me or poly dynamics, as far as I know.

Elijah was expecting that he and Arabella would come to more of a mutual conclusion that things weren't working / they had mismatched expectations / something was off with the physical chemistry. Instead (he told me later), she was devastated and heartbroken and took it really hard. She said she had been falling in love with him while he had started to pull away.

I know that I know way too many details about this! Elijah has been a sad sack all week and leaning on me for advice/comfort. He feels bad, misses her, has doubts he did the right thing, etc...normal breakup stuff. He really liked her, she did nothing wrong, and nobody is angry or behaving badly. It's just super sad.

This is a new experience for me. For long-term relationships since I've know Elijah, he's had his heart broken twice, and another time he had to end a relationship with someone whose behavior had become problematic. This is the only time I've seen him hurt someone who's really quite awesome.

I should add, Elijah and Arabella and I all identify as relationship anarchists and prioritize remaining friends with exes when possible. I know Elijah really cares about Arabella, really likes her as a person and is hoping a friendship will be possible later.

In the meanwhile, Arabella is posting VERY sad things on Facebook and I am a bit worried about her. She's not doing it to be manipulative. Her mental health is genuinely fragile and she is doing her best to manage it. Because of her family history, she feels totally alone in the world. I've been there and I sympathize.

Not sure what sort of advice I'm seeking...Elijah's relationship and breakup with Arabella are none of my business.

But, okay, what should I do about Facebook? Hide Arabella for 30 days to give it time? Click "sad" on her sad posts? (Elijah seems to be clicking "sad" on her posts, and posting his own sad breakup posts...actually I might hide both of them for a while!)

But seriously, I would like Arabella to know that I think she's awesome and I'd like to remain friends with her, totally independent of Elijah. In her place, I would NOT appreciate a metamour doing that, but she's someone who would actually appreciate that. She has a history of feeling that friends abandon her and she's very kitchen-table oriented regarding metamours.

But, I would feel awkward doing that, and I don't know what to say. I feel very conscious that my life in general is going really well right now. And I feel guilty and weird that my relationship with Elijah is so stable...next month we are going on a vacation to a classically romantic European city...which Arabella knows about...I would feel horrible in her place...thinking of how much she's hurting is really making me sad, darn it.

Actually, all week I've been having sort of flashbacks to my own past heartbreaks and how much they SUCKED.

Ack, I just want everyone to be happy and find the love they deserve!
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry you struggle.

But, I would feel awkward doing that, and I don't know what to say.

I think what you said above is fine. Just adjust it to write a note, maybe something like--

"Arabella, while it is none of my business what happens between you and Elijah, I would like you to know that I am very saddened at the news of the break up. I think you are awesome. I'd like to remain friends, totally independent of Elijah, if that is something you would also like."


But, okay, what should I do about Facebook? Hide Arabella for 30 days to give it time? Click "sad" on her sad posts? (Elijah seems to be clicking "sad" on her posts, and posting his own sad breakup posts...actually I might hide both of them for a while!)

If their breakup sadness/grief is bothering you, then yes. Hide both so you get a bit more distance from it. You can always turn the Facebook stuff back on later when you are more prepared and more past your own grief.

Keep this a lot simpler on yourself. Hang in there.

Galagirl
 
You *could* do what GG said. That doesn't mean you should.

Put yourself in her shoes. You don't know her well. You "won." You get to be with the bf she misses so badly. Hearing from you might well make her feel much worse, not better.

Awkward!

If she needs friends, maybe she needs to reach out more to the poly community. Either on this board, or maybe on FB. If anything, you could briefly message her and recommend a way for her to network and make friends with people other than the gf of her ex.
 
Hi MeeraReed,

It sounds like this particular breakup is really affecting you. To the point where you are getting flashbacks of your own past breakups. You need to worry about your own well-being, before you can help others. Make sure you are eating right, exercising and getting enough sleep. If you need to hide Arabella (and Elijah?) for awhile on Facebook in order to feel better, do it. In the meantime you could message Arabella, tell her you are sorry about what happened and that you'd like to be her friend. Kind of a judgment call on that. You are in a tricky situation, it is a delicate balance. I'm sorry this breakup has happened, it seems to be making all three of you sad. Hang in there.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
That's a tough one. I would give it time. She needs time to heal. I don't think he should be reacting either, but that's not what you are asking about. I think after the thirty days you'll find you've moved on (assuming they don't get back together.)
 
I agree with Galagirl.

You seem to want to comfort her, but she's a bit out of your reach, she's two hours away, your relationship is not that deep, and there are layers of weird because you are the ex-metamour.

Right now you are swept away with emotion. I think you could give it a break for 30 days, not only on Facebook but in real life, too. It's also your relationship (although not a sexy one) that is breaking up/changing shape. If, in a few weeks, you still want to be friends, you can reach out then.

Sure, you can also reach out now, and I don't think she'd be displeased. But you're running the risk of becoming a support person not only for your bf but to her also. You're even running the risk of becoming the middle man for whatever misunderstandings might be still unsolved between them. Give her, and yourself, some time to cool off.
 
Thanks for the responses. Good advice!

Tinwen, I think you nailed it: she doesn't live near me, so I can't do very much, and then I would also run the risk of becoming her support person when I really shouldn't be.

I do know she'd appreciate hearing from me that I will always think of her as a friend. But I'll think about the best way/time to get in touch to say so.
 
Back
Top