New to Poly, need advice

Barnowl

New member
Hi,

My situation feels very long winded as it has been a chaotic and emotional few days, so I'll try to keep it succinct.

My wife and I have been married for over 10 years, and like all marriages there have been ups and downs. When we first started, we were the very typical Mono relationship with all the angsst and values that go with it. Years have now past, things have changed and we still love eachother very much, but as we have gotten older, so too has our views on things evolved too. We have two beautiful children, we have just bought our second house, life is pretty good.

About 2 years ago she met another person and one of our kids extra curricular activities. He always struck me as a bit of a salesman and bullshit artist, but either way i respected the friendship they formed. I was immediately suspicious when their first non kid pickup-dropoff activity was a pool date with the kids, and we had a good laugh about that but again, all was good.

Fast forward to a year later (1 year ago prior to now) and we are at a restaurant and she tells me that while she was interstate, she got a very sexy message from the other person, and she delayed in telling me because she was kind of interested. This bothered me immensely, but we had already started hearing and discussing polyamorous topics and values (I'm all for turning pre-conceived values on top of themselves. Very much a non-traditionalist), but this news sent me over the edge. At the time, i was open, nice and kind but 24 hours later it hit me and i lost it. The feeling of rejection (we had been having issues in the bedroom at about this time), fear of loss / being replaced just took me over. Shed more tears than i have in a VERY long time. powerful and awful. We worked though it, things got better pretty quickly and a few days later i said that I'd done some research, consolidated my feelings and that i would be okay with it all if she perused a relationship with him. Things were really good, we moved past it, life improved and went on.

Now to today. Over the last year, i got hints that something might be up. At social gatherings, he was unusually distant. When she went interstate, i plugged a camera into my home PC so i could monitor the house while i was at work (because she normally works from home). When she saw the camera, she freaked out and told me she felt it was violating her privacy, even though I unplug it when i get home on the day she gets back. Several times i had told her that I'm okay with her perusing a relationship with him, but to please be honest with me if she does. When we had talked about Polyamory, and i said that "Honesty and openness" was important to me, she got very defensive saying that she shouldn't have to ask for permission if she was in a relationship, and demanded what i meant by it. Over the last few months she observed that i paid particular attention to another female friend and asked me lots of questions, essentially encouraging me to peruse a relationship but as my work has me busy 9-5 each day and i come home in the evenings and take over with the kids and then weekends are spent renovating or taking the kids to places. Such a thing can't really work for me so i dismissed it. Each time i suspected something was up with her, i dismissed it because i trusted that she would have told me if something was happening because i made it clear that's what i wanted.

Last weekend, we discovered another friend was polyamorous when we invited my Friend and their partner out to dinner, and their partner told us they were bringing the fiance. My wife got defensive about polyamory discussions coming up saying that she didn't want to have to talk about her relationship with the other person. I twigged and asked her directly if she kissed him, she then dropped the bombshell that they had been having sex for the last year. She tells me it started some time after the initial time i lost it (and the first time i would have told her I'm okay with it), but now my head is in a spin. The freaking out about the camera was because she didn't want me to find out "that way", and that she couldn't bring herself to tell me because she didn't want to ruin our relationship.

I am in an absolute dichotomy for a list of reasons:
- In her head, it was okay because she could love both me and him in different ways. However,
- He is in a Monogamous relationship. In his situation, it is very much an affair.
- This meant that he encouraged her to deal with it in the same way he does it by keeping it all a secret. I don't know for sure if she was encouraged BY him (I feel she is easily influenced by him) but i know for a fact he certainly didn't say at any stage "Well, if your [husband] believes in polyamory and so do you, then you should be honest with him. Don't do it the same way I'm doing it"

I feel so angry, hurt, betrayed but at the same time, i feel angry at myself because she really does care about him, and i do believe that he cares about her too, and that i should be able to move on and let these feelings go because its all out now.

I'm having some real trouble what i should do. I feel lied to, i feel betrayed and threatened. But I'm happy for her too. I feel jealous because i will never have the same opportunity, and i feel angry at myself that i feel jealous about that i won't ever have the same opportunity. I feel like we have broken down a big wall between us that i didn't know was there, but i feel more alone than ever before. I only have her to talk to and I'm a total wreck. I feel like if i don't get over this soon, I am going to lose her and the connection i have and what we have will be replaced by the other person who has been in on it for the last year.

My most recent thought is that i feel so insecure with myself and my own qualities. I feel like attraction / affection for me is under threat, because i feel like i have very little (no / minimal) assets worthy of affection / attraction. I have always been anxious about making love and feel it is something i am weak at. The fact that she is now making love to someone else almost seems to confirm my own fears. i.e If you already have something you really like, why would you seek it elsewhere? Therefore, conclusion is that the current quality is low and not worth pursuing / investing in. She is pretty much the only person i have ever been with in my adult life, and i can't think of any way to validate my own qualities without having an experience with someone else, something that i know in my heart is an opportunity i will never get.

I don't really know what I'm asking, but i feel like i need answers. I don't want to lose her, but i feel that I'm racing against time to sort myself out and get with the program.
 
I can relate to your story in many ways.

I think newbies sometimes hide new relationships because they are still in that mono mindset. They are afraid of how their partner will react. This feeds into the insecurities of their partner. I also think the fact that her new guy was having an affair fed into her mono mindset. Plus, she could have been feeling guilty about what she was doing.

You need to do some work on yourself. Plenty of people have jobs and are poly. There is no reason you can't find something similar. You are just using that as an excuse to feel sorry for yourself. Been there, done that.
 
You are just using that as an excuse to feel sorry for yourself. Been there, done that.

Yeah, you might have me there. Don't know how i could possibly work it with my current lifestyle, but who knows what the future holds.

I also feel it would be a disservice / disrespectful to my wife and to someone else if I am doing it to validate my own insecurities, or is that an acceptable starting point for a relationship?
 
I am sorry you struggle.

So in a nutshell... and correct me if I get it wrong...

  • You and wife agreed to Open. But did not discuss how/when to tell if a relationship "has gone lover." (So might have not covered safer sex practices, STD prevention, accidental pregnancies, and so on. )
  • As a result of Opening, you've been experiencing some jealousy and some poly hell. You were still processing and coming to terms with that first load.
  • You noticed some weird behaviors and asked if she'd kissed him. Then you wife dropped a bomb that they'd been sharing sex for a year. In addition...
    • Her BF is dating her on the side even though he is in a Mono situation.
    • He's basically cheating on his other partner.
    • Your wife is the cheating affair partner.

I think you could take a deep breath. And then tell your wife these things...

1) Thank you for telling me. In future, I prefer you tell me when one of your Open relationships is about to go lover before it happens. I don't like bombs dropped on me like that.

You are free to share sex with who you want. Hopefully from a place of full information so you can know who you are sexually linked to. I hope all your partner are honest with you about their sex partners and sex history.

I want the same. I want to share sex with you from a place of full information so I can know who I am sexually linked to. You did not inform me about all your sex partners and sex history for a YEAR. I am disappointed in how you chose to handle that.

I think part of being Open and Honest is being emotionally courgeous and transparent. You could work on being more emotionally courageous and transparent. (Go get your STD tests. And talk to wife about what safer sex practices she's using and what safer sex practices you want to use.)

2) I am sorry to learn your BF is basically having a cheating affair. And that you have chosen to be his cheating affair partner. I'm disappointed you would allow yourself to get sucked into that kind of thing. This is not being Open and Honest. This is helping him keep his other partner totally in the dark while keeping me in partial dark.

4) What are you planning to do at this point in time?
  • Do nothing.
  • Ask him to come clean so this can be on the level?
  • End it with him because he's cheating?
  • Something else?

Wait for her answer and then take a time out to think about your options. It's ok to be new and make mistakes and LEARN from them. It's not ok to keep ON making messes that affect other people dinging them left and right!

If she plans to continue to date a cheater... do you still want to be with her? Does this take away from your ability to trust her?

I don't know if this would help any of the people in the mix.

http://felislunae.org/relationships-love/coming-clean/

I am sorry you are dealing with this. One load of poly hell things to sort out is load enough without adding the cheating load on top of it.

I think you feeling upset about it all is natural.

I don't want to lose her, but i feel that I'm racing against time to sort myself out and get with the program.

Get on board with WHICH program?
  • One where you encourage wife to become more ethical in how she practices Poly and stop being so messy?
  • One were you help wife keep her cheating affair a secret?
  • One were you walk away?
  • Something else?

I also feel it would be a disservice / disrespectful to my wife and to someone else if I am doing it to validate my own insecurities, or is that an acceptable starting point for a relationship?

Dude. Don't be adding more people to a wonky sounding network. Clean your network up first.

  • You
  • Wife
  • The BF
  • Apple --- generic nickname for the "in the dark" partner of BF

As it stands, this is not an ethical, open, honest, poly network.

  • This is two people having a cheating affair (wife and BF)
  • With you having been kept in the dark to some degree.... and now knowing about it.
  • And Apple being kept TOTALLY in the dark.

I suggest you square things up before adding more players.

FWIW, I think it is fine to date other people so you learn some confidence and aren't so dependent on your wife for validation. You can learn to validate yourself by learning that others appreciate what you bring to the table. You can also learn to self-validate by not judging yourself. Some people have that constant "inner critic" voice -- if you do, you could work to lose it.

But I don't think it is ok to be adding more people to a network that is a mess. No healthy person would want to touch that. And why would anyone want to add unhealthy people to it? :confused:

Sort your network out, and if you want to start dating when it's sorted? Get on with dating.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
I am sorry you struggle.

Thank you for you detailed reply. This is really helping.

Get on board with WHICH program?
  • One where you encourage wife to become more ethical in how she practices Poly and stop being so messy?
  • One were you help wife keep her cheating affair a secret?
  • One were you walk away?
  • Something else?

This is hard. She chose to pursue it separate from me, so my ability to demand anything is limited. Considering she lied to me for so long, and considering she did it even though she feared "It would end our marriage" says to me that any sign that I'm not happy with it will only serve to make her lie to me again. She is a natural risk taker, and it has always been part of her personality, i just didn't quite expect this to be one.

She has already told him that i know, and that i have said that I'm okay with her pursuing another relationship. I'm in a awkward spot because I do believe that his relationships is his own problem and if he's going to be an idiot and hurt his partner, then that's his stupid problem, just don't hurt mine. She really cares for him and from what i can tell (to grumpy at him to really sympathise with him ATM), he cares about her too. She has now told me that word "love" has been used between them an "unknown number of times". They have passed a point of no return. I am kind of left with no choice but to keep the secret, which is easy for me cause there is no crossover with social groups but i would be lying if i said it didn't make me feel uneasy.

I think the only outcome here that has the good outweigh the bad in my world is to encourage her in future to be honest and open with me.

But I don't think it is ok to be adding more people to a network that is a mess. No healthy person would want to touch that. And why would anyone want to add unhealthy people to it? :confused:

Sort your network out, and if you want to start dating when it's sorted? Get on with dating.

You are so right about this. However, i don't ever seeing this working out in a way where there isn't mess. She really likes this other guy, and i wish i could say "Not him because for him its an affair", but i know that will make her sad and like i said, she already spent a year lying to me before. Now she knows what gave it away, she will be able to hide it from me even better. Not only do i NOT want to tell her to drop something in her life that makes her happy, but it would be ineffective anyway.

Sigh. Being an adult sucks.
 
You don't sound happy being lied to and being railroaded into a cheating network due to Wife doing lies of omission.

Considering she lied to me for so long, and considering she did it even though she feared "It would end our marriage" says to me that any sign that I'm not happy with it will only serve to make her lie to me again.

Well... what stops her from lying again anyway? Even if you are "happy with it?"

You guys were Open. Her having another relationship wasn't going to "end the marriage." I don't see how her being his cheating affair partner for a year and not telling you about it is going to HELP the marriage relationship any. As a result of her actions you might trust/admire her less now.

You cannot demand that she dump him. You COULD request that she clean this up so there is no more cheating in the network and things are on the level.

If she does -- great. Problems solved.

If she doesn't? You get to choose from 2 basic choices:

1) Stay in the cheating network

2) Bow out of the cheating network

Your consent to participate in things belongs to YOU and only you. You are responsible for your choices. It sounds like you are leaning toward keeping silent and overlooking the cheating. I guess you could try to wait and see. Either it will get easier to live with or your discomfort with it will come to a head.

I am kind of left with no choice but to keep the secret, which is easy for me cause there is no crossover with social groups but i would be lying if i said it didn't make me feel uneasy.

If you want to practice "Open and Honest" relationships, you have to be willing to be open and honest with yourself. I suggest you not tell yourself stories. I suggest you call it what it is.

It isn't that there are no other choices. It's that you are not willing to consider other choices at this time:

  • Asking her to clean up her mess. The agreements sound like you were up for her having other consenting relationships, not for her to become part of cheating affairs.
  • Breaking up with her until she gets it together -- like a separation.
  • Permanent break up.

If basically you are at

"I am not happy about my wife's cheating affair stuff and lies to me. But at this time, I don't want to ask her to clean up her own messes. I am afraid that she will dump me instead. At this time, I choose to let it slide even though it bothers me"​

then that's where you are at at this point in time. No judgement from me on that -- you have to make your own decisions based on what you are currently willing/able to do.

What bothers me is this "I am so helpless, I have no choices" tone you are taking. Which only fuels your insecurity. I thought you wanted to work to get rid of that? :confused:

I only have her to talk to and I'm a total wreck.

Could you see a counselor? It sounds like you could use the extra support right now.

Even if you are going to let it slide for now, you could say to wife...

"I am overwhelmed with emotions. I am going to let it slide for now because of that, but this conversation is not finished. I am going to take a time out to cool off. I am going to consult with a counselor and figure out next steps for myself."​

If you teach others that it is ok with you to lie to you, cheat on a agreements, or take up with wonky people.... of course you won't feel secure in the relationship. You will keep wondering when the other shoe will drop and when you will get dinged again.

It's also not self respecting behavior to let people treat you this way.

Good self esteem comes from being able to think well of yourself and be proud of your choices. It will be hard to have good self esteem if you choose things that are less than self-respecting.

CONCLUSION

I suggest you take a time out since this is so fresh. It's ok to feel upset/hurt by it all.

Tell wife you are overwhelmed and are going to let it slide for now, but this conversation is not done.

Think about seeing a counselor for more support and helping you find your way. I can imagine your mind is a swirl right now.

Put your own oxygen mask on first before you try to deal with anything else.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Vinsanity, the OP was lied to and cheated on. I'm not sure your criticisms are very kind. All he wanted was for his wife to be honest with him, and she wasn't. All this talk about her still being in a "mono mindset" doesn't take away from this fact.

"You need to do some work on yourself. Plenty of people have jobs and are poly. There is no reason you can't find something similar. You are just using that as an excuse to feel sorry for yourself. Been there, done that."


I think poly is the perfect relationship structure for many people. I just feel terrible for all the monos I see being basically coerced into a mono/poly relationship, or be faced with losing the relationship, period. A "like it or lump it" attitude. Yes, monogamy has been the default for a long time and yes, society is biased towards mono relationships. This does not excuse cheating, lying, and emotional blackmail. The OP has every reason to feel upset, and doesn't deserve to be told to feel bad about himself for doing so. He is concerned about the wisdom of finding a secondary relationship himself, along with feeling insecure that he may not be able to. These concerns are VALID; his feelings of self-worth have really taken a hit.
 
Last edited:
You two are not on the same page regarding the way you want your relationship to function, you do not sound like you have cohesive communication styles, and it doesn't sound like either of you trust the other. These are pretty huge problems for an association. To add to this, you have your own self-doubt issues that are proving your self-fulfilling prophecy of being inadequate.

I don't usually go in for couples counseling, but you two are going to need to figure out some way to sit down and have an honest and constructive conversation about this. If a mediator might help, I say give it a try.

If you already have something you really like, why would you seek it elsewhere?

In the world of open relationships and polyamory, this "why am I not enough?" mentality is a killer. I recommend doing some work on your self-image, therapy/exercise/self-help reading/etc.
 
Yes, monogamy has been the default for a long time and yes, society is biased towards mono relationships. This does not excuse cheating, lying, and emotional blackmail.

Unless I'm misunderstanding the timeline, these two talked about it, the OP blew up and then calmed down, and the conversation ended with his verbal approval. This happened a year ago and the relationship (as far as we know) started a year ago.

I don't see any mustache twisting villains here, just two people who have starkly different communication styles and *lots* of incorrect assumptions.
 
Hi Barnowl,

It sounds like you're very concerned that any "wrong" move would result in you losing your wife. You are kind of being held hostage; your insecurities are feeding into that. The fact that she and her boyfriend are cheating on his partner is rather scary. If his partner ever finds out about it, the whole thing is likely to blow up, and you may end up being accused of being an accomplice. I think that your wife and her boyfriend need to move into an exit strategy ... a way out of the cheating. Perhaps this means the boyfriend starts negotiating with his partner about poly. I don't know.

You're in a really tight spot. I hope things improve a little.

Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
I hear you feel very insecure right now.

You lack sexual skills and fear your wife cheated on you to get her sexual needs met.

Your wife is dating a cheating bf and you think you have no right to object to this unethical behavior on both their parts.

You fear losing your lying cheating wife if you express any discomfort with any of this.

Do you feel enormously grateful to your wife for being with you for 10 years when no one else would have you? Since you're so bad in bed and all... Do you think you will "do anything" to keep her, including putting up with the cheating and the lies?

Others have given good advice. I will add, what has stopped you, in these 10 years, from improving your sexual skill set? Sounds like you've had plenty of time to practice, to get new ideas, to be creative, to give her deep pleasure and fulfillment.

I understand doing poly is very hard with kids in the mix. I hear you feel responsible to your job, to your kids, to your wife. What about being responsible to taking good care of YOURSELF? I know some people (especially those raised Christian) are taught to put others' needs before their own. But if no one is taking care of your needs, sooner or later you will begin to resent that. You start to feel like a martyr.

The solution is to identify your needs and start to take care of your own needs as you can, and also request your loved ones meet your needs. You can't demand they meet your needs, only request. Then it is up to them to consent or not consent to meeting your needs. Once you see what they are willing/able to do, you move on from there with clear information to guide you.

You may start to respect yourself more, and your wife may respect you more, if you stand up for your rights and request others meet your needs. If you act like you don't have any needs, they will never be met. If you act like a doormat, people will step on you.
 
You all have been awesome. Thank you so much. The kind and the tougher responses are good. Helps me get things in perspective.

There was some development over the last few days. I came to the realisation that she proceeded with the "cheating" relationship at a time where she thought i would not approve of it. Things kind of blew up fairly un-fantastically after that. The fact that in her own head she was actively lying and doing something she knew (as far as she was concerned) would hurt me was just too much. It has taken some time for things to come down and a lot of apologising on her part. She has come to the realisation that a lot of the points I have brought up have demonstrated a break down of her own values and she feel very ashamed. She has acknowledged that her actions indirectly had me taking risks that i would not have been comfortable with (their sex was not safe). She also tells me she feels like she let herself be "lured" into his lie and he has definitely encouraged her to keep up the lie. For this reason, she has decided to call it off with him. Her words are "He is toxic to my values, and the relationship i have had with him has not complimented our relationship like he said it would but rather, has killed me piece by piece". I have broken down the patterns of his behaviour and it really is questionable at best. I think I am going to get tested for my own comfort.

Do i trust her right now? No way. That is something that is going to take a lot of time if at all, but she has decided we are still worth it and at least for now is going to stick around while i try to repair myself while she does a lot of work on herself too. I don't know if i will ever be able to really trust her, i think I'm going to have to find a way to operate in this relationship without any trust for quite a long while, and no guarantees that she will be able to live like that. Regardless of what has happened between us, she still has her own rights and i will have to accept that she cannot live in a relationship where her partner has no faith in her.

The only trust i really have right now is that she has called it off with him, and i think her ashamed feelings are legit. She is embarrassed and angry with who she has become, and while he was not the cause of it, he was certainly a catalyst for her lack of morals in this situation. She is no longer comfortable in being with someone else who is having "an affair" (i hope).

At least one interesting thing is that we recently caught up with an old friend of mine who as it turns out, his relationship was poly and he was the OTO. Only really came to the realisation a few days before our dinner that there was 3 people not two and that his GF was engaged . I think it was an interesting insight into seeing a poly relationship that wasn't healthy. Yes, they were open and honest, but there was a clear violation of boundaries (joking comments about how "she got in the shower with a spider before" clearly made the fiance uncomfortable).

We've had lots of discussions and chats since then and for the first time i feel like I'm getting some honest answers now. Knowing that our previous discussions about poly were corrupted with her hiding the lie of her other relationship, this has been good.

We may come at poly in the future, and i hope we do. It sounds fun, and could open up a new interesting chapter in our lives... but not yet. Its going to take some time for my wounds to feel less tender, and some time for her to get her head in the right game so that if it happens, it is something open and welcoming and not secret and forbidden.

Will keep trawling this forum and keep learning more.
 
Glad you guys talked.

I hope your STD tests come back clean and that you and wife are able to repair from the cheating now that she's chosen to walk away from the cheater BF.


We may come at poly in the future, and i hope we do. It sounds fun, and could open up a new interesting chapter in our lives... but not yet. Its going to take some time for my wounds to feel less tender, and some time for her to get her head in the right game so that if it happens, it is something open and welcoming and not secret and forbidden.

I hope you get your hope then. And are able to practice poly in a cleaner way at that future point in time.

GL!

Galagirl
 
Ugh! She wasn't even using condoms while she cheated? Good grief.

She may have STDs. If her bf has cheated on his wife in the past and not used condoms, who knows what he's got? If his wife is also cheating on HIM, and seeing what kind of man he is, I think it's quite possible his wife is just as unethical, who knows what she's picked up from her partners? Your sexual network is totally fucked.

While she cheated and practiced unsafe sex, you were basically having sex with all her lover's current and former partners, and possibly all his wife's partners too.

If you really want to repair your marriage, you have a right to request she gets tested too, for starters in rebuilding trust. Maybe go together so you know she's done it. She must also now have complete transparency with you, in every way.

I don't usually approve of reading partners' texts, emails, etc., but in this case I think you are justified in asking her to allow you to read all of hers from now on, for as long as it takes for you to trust she's not messaging and meeting up with this dude, or any others.

I see you're still focusing on what would make HER comfortable going forward. What about what it takes for YOU to be comfortable? You're the wronged party, not her.

What would it take for YOU to trust her again, knowing she lied and cheated for an entire year, and didn't even bother to use condoms while she did it? What behaviors do you need from her? I'm glad her words reflect her guilt and shame... but talk is cheap. Ethical behaviors are required.
 
Back
Top