Spork
Active member
I really love Avatar too. I saw in in the theater, and recently it was on TV. Pixi and I have a big projector TV and it was just as good there as on a theater screen. I didn't see it in 3D.
We had planned to go see Rogue One on Xmas Day but it didn't work out. We got a rain check and I want to go see it very soon! I've been hearing nothing but great feedback about it.
Honest opinion here...
I am NOT a Star Wars geek, as I've mentioned before, if anything I find the whole "light versus dark" and "hero gets the girl" themes to be simplistic and annoying (though they were not so heavy handed with that shit in this film.) My children liked the movies when they were little. I was ok with the first set, saw them a crap ton of times in life, so fine. Then that next trilogy...which, annoyingly and confusingly to me, as prequels, are called "the first three movies" (the fuck??) came out, and aside from the fact that Young Man version of Anakin/Vader is cute as all get out, in general I was beyond unimpressed. I don't give a damn if he's secretly a Sith or not, Jar Jar was the stupidest thing I've ever seen. But I guess if you're trying to rope in the age 3-5 demographic and sell them plastic toys...
I was so put off by those, that I didn't bother to see whatever the most recent film that came out last year before Rogue One. I just completely lost my ability to give a damn about Star Wars by that point.
So that's where I come from to the point of sitting in a theater watching Rogue One. And I was low on personal energy, so during a long period of relatively slow plot-buildup for like at least the first half of the movie, I dozed off several times, and came-to feeling that I had not missed anything.
But the end is great, and there are a number of scenes, characters, and technologies that do redeem it and make it a decent film. I really don't think it has the epic grandeur of the original three, I'm not sure they'll ever properly recapture that. But you get, on rare occasion, a whiff of it, like an elusive perfume... And there wasn't anything that Jar-Jar'ed me into any irrational urges to throw objects at the screen, so that's good.
It's a decent movie. Not the BEST MOVIE EVER, but pretty decent.
Movies I liked more, personally, in recent-ish years:
Avatar
Crimson Peak
Doctor Strange
Deadpool
(Note: I'm not a Marvel geek, either.)
But I am in it for the eye candy, more than anything.
This... Hellboy II: The Golden Army, I mentioned it, that is one of my favorite movies of all time. This scene:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-rl8q9jezU
...with the Angel of Death, is what I want in a movie, Guillermo Del Toro's general creepy as fuck aesthetic, made perhaps more famous by the creature in Pan's Labyrinth (although frankly I found the Pan to be just as impressive as the Pale Man monster.) It's stuff like that, and other iconic imagery, that just thrills my mind. I could see myself crafting sculptures and getting high res prints of some of my favorite creatures and scenes from films. Heck if I were an autograph collector like Zen is...? But I would love to have sand worms from Beetlejuice protruding from walls, and I already own art inspired by the Dark Crystal.
That's it--That's it precisely, I grew up with Labyrinth, The Dark Crystal, and the Neverending Story, filling my mind with those stunning practical effects and costumes. That is the stuff I am nerdy for. It's frickin' magical, man!
And I don't know if it makes me kind of hipster-ish, but overblown merchandising is a huge turn off for me. The more cheap plastic junk I see riding the wake of a film, the more sick of it I get, quickly. And that's a tremendous reason that I have difficulty with Star Wars...even when I was a kid, it was all about selling toys and lunchboxes. It stops feeling like art, or just a good story, when you feel like you're cowering in the shadow of a tsunami of plastic toys, t-shirts, and Pez dispensers, commercial voices loudly demanding that you BUY, BUY, BUY!! ....ugh. No. Stop it.
And they did that to Doctor Who! Damn them for that! I like Doctor Who, but the fucking merchandise is out of control. Calm your tits, BBC America! Don't fuck this up for all of us!
*sigh*
It's one thing too that has challenged me as a parent. I'm burned out on the unnecessary consumerism. Have been for ages. I'm really glad that my older son is turning 18 and my younger son isn't far behind him. I've done my best with it, and I adore my sons, but it wasn't my dream to be a mother. I don't really feel like it's the pinnacle of what defines me. And it's one of those things where I put a lot of pressure on myself for a lot of years, to "give them a good childhood" by giving them a ton of stuff. Whatever they were into this year, come Christmas, I'd bury them in it. And it was a mistake. And I think I knew that when it was happening, too. But I didn't know how else to be, or what else to do. Had to make the magic happen and everything. Well, I'm not doing that anymore. I couldn't afford it if I wanted to. And I don't want to.
So anyways. Again, I ramble. Point is, I carry my feeling of being trapped and oppressed by mainstream American mass consumerism and instant-memorabilia-production mills as baggage into a movie like Star Wars, so I suspect that my appreciation of it is always going to have its limits.
But it was alright! I'd go so far as to say that it was pretty awesome for a modern Star Wars movie. *shrug*