So my partner and I got together while we were both seeing other people, not so much in a polyamorous way as a "monogamous people who haven't defined the relationship" way.
We both had previous polyamorous (or "polyamorous") relationships about two years back that were really hard on us, and I in particular am... kind of still dealing with it, in ways that are impacting both our relationship and some of my friendships with polyamorous friends?
I guess I want to talk it out somewhere where the fact that the relationships were polyamorous won't be as big a deal as the fact that these were BAD RELATIONSHIPS, because right now even though I get it intellectually I still find myself having these - weird feelings of jealousy and resentment? towards successfully polyamorous friends? that are 100% about this baggage and that's not the person or the friend I want to be. So I guess if anyone has the spare energy to give me some insight or advice, I'd appreciate it.
If this is not an appropriate place for this, mods, please do what you need to, and sorry.
My baggage:
I'm bisexual but was raised in the US South in a very conservative area and mostly dated men for the first decade. (I tried to come out to my family and friends, and they weren't overtly hostile, but they just - didn't believe me at all and just told me they figured I was lying, basically).
So I was very used to telling people I was bisexual and then immediately being presumed to be nonmonogamous? And I think I internalized an idea that that was who I had to be, partially because some straight dude going "hur, hot threesome" felt slightly better than people who just didn't believe me at all?
I was in love with one man for four years in a closed relationship, but after we broke up he landed somewhere between "polyamorous" and "dating around a lot" - he called it "polyamorous" but he also seemed to kind of be exactly as polyamorous as worked for him and never do any relationship work with any of these people? Like as soon as someone wanted to define the relationship he seemed to be like "I'm a free spirit!" and disappear?
I guess I believed him at first that this was something he was genuinely trying, so when we sort of backslid into kind-of-dating and he said he wanted to be polyamorous I went along with it. The problem was that I kept trying to say "I don't think this is working, I'm jealous and unhappy and insecure, if this is what you want that's fine but also we need to not hang out and especially not to kiss anymore" and he would sort of... go after me about how that was disappointing because he thought I was more evolved than that, and he'd thought I could feel compersion, and he really valued our relationship and it seemed silly to end it because I couldn't embrace real freedom, blah blah blah you guys know exactly what this was. Polyamory was not his problem, his problem was that he was a jerk and my problem was that I wasn't owning my needs. Monogamous people use monogamous language to be jerks all the time.
But somehow I stopped dating him - and STARTED DATING ANOTHER GUY WHO DID THE EXACT SAME THING. Where did I find two of them? I went on a couple of dates with this second guy, said "hey, I'm getting the feeling that you're not looking for an exclusive relationship, but I am, so it was nice meeting you and best wishes" - and he pulled "but I thought we REALLY CLICKED and WHY CAN'T YOU BE MORE EVOLVED".
AND I BRIEFLY FELL FOR IT. TWICE. OH MY GOD.
This was interspersed with being hit on a lot by "couples looking for discreet casual third" and I think I sort of kept treating myself like because I was bisexual I wasn't allowed to ask for the relationship style I wanted? If I was really polyamorous, I think I would have had a different struggle, but I think I was secretly monogamous and so I just felt like I was being permanently relegated to "side piece" and wasn't good enough to advocate for my own needs?
(Yes, I am in therapy!)
My partner's baggage
I'm not going to get into it too much because it's less my business to share on the internet, but I feel like I had the classic straight-dating polyamory bad fit and she had the classic gay one - namely, instead of a bad relationship breaking up they added more people?
Unfortunately, her ex was also an actually abusive person, and there was a lot of stuff that was really bad, including the ex reallly pressuring people to do sexual things they didn't really sign up for to "make the relationship work". (Consent, what?). Some people use monogamous expectations to trample their partner's consent, this person used polyamorous language instead, again, the problem is that this person was a jerk, but I kind of feel like I have nowhere to talk about it without either feeling like I'm bashing the relationship style itself or conversely without monogamous friends zeroing in on the fact that the relationship was poly.
My partner is a lot more philosophical about the whole thing than I am - she's still friendly acquaintances with her ex-metamour, and they both view themselves as kind of co-survivors of a bad relationship that they're happy to be out of. (For the record it was the ex that added an extra person - she just kind of notified my partner that this person would be attending their relationship now).
(Yes, my partner is also in therapy!)
The problem
We've agreed to have a monogamous relationship - I think even without my baggage I just don't think that dating or romance are generally fun for me, I just really like my partner in particular and am content to call it quits at that. She also says that she's enthusiastic about monogamy.
But whenever polyamory comes up as a topic I have, like, an angry, jealous reaction. If my partner is involved, I wind up going BUT ARE YOU SURE THAT YOU'RE REALLY FINE WITH THIS??? way more than is necessary. If friends are involved, I try my best to hide that I'm sort of mad and feel guilty and bad and don't really know why. It's just this wave of unprocessed emotion that shows up, and I don't like it.
Plenty of our friends are poly, including a couple who've dealt with a lot of prejudice about the whole thing and are really sensitive about it. And to make it worse, I have bonus jealousy because one of the members of that couple used to date my partner (yeaaaars ago), so whenever the fact that they're poly comes up I suddenly go from "these people are so much fun to be around and I genuinely enjoy the depth of history here" to THREATENED AND MAD AND SURE SOMEONE IS ABOUT TO TELL ME TO BE MORE EVOLVED even though they would never do that because they're not jerks.
I guess my question is: poly people who have dated people who were jerks first and poly second, how did you process and get over it? I guess, like, was it hard because you had access to fewer cultural scripts about how those breakups should go? What were the key steps? Where there were problems that were specifically polyamory-flavored, how did you think through it? I even had trouble with a therapist at the time completely refusing to engage with the idea that there were other problems with my ex-boyfriend BESIDES nonmonogamy, and it made me feel very stymied. (But his problem! was that he was a jerk!)
And as world experts in thinking through and owning your shit - how do I actually close the book on this one? I mean, I guess therapy. But I don't even know how to articulate my goals, besides "feel settled and comfortable that everyone gets to choose the relationship style that works for them and it's not a referendum on anyone else" and "not be mad".
We both had previous polyamorous (or "polyamorous") relationships about two years back that were really hard on us, and I in particular am... kind of still dealing with it, in ways that are impacting both our relationship and some of my friendships with polyamorous friends?
I guess I want to talk it out somewhere where the fact that the relationships were polyamorous won't be as big a deal as the fact that these were BAD RELATIONSHIPS, because right now even though I get it intellectually I still find myself having these - weird feelings of jealousy and resentment? towards successfully polyamorous friends? that are 100% about this baggage and that's not the person or the friend I want to be. So I guess if anyone has the spare energy to give me some insight or advice, I'd appreciate it.
If this is not an appropriate place for this, mods, please do what you need to, and sorry.
My baggage:
I'm bisexual but was raised in the US South in a very conservative area and mostly dated men for the first decade. (I tried to come out to my family and friends, and they weren't overtly hostile, but they just - didn't believe me at all and just told me they figured I was lying, basically).
So I was very used to telling people I was bisexual and then immediately being presumed to be nonmonogamous? And I think I internalized an idea that that was who I had to be, partially because some straight dude going "hur, hot threesome" felt slightly better than people who just didn't believe me at all?
I was in love with one man for four years in a closed relationship, but after we broke up he landed somewhere between "polyamorous" and "dating around a lot" - he called it "polyamorous" but he also seemed to kind of be exactly as polyamorous as worked for him and never do any relationship work with any of these people? Like as soon as someone wanted to define the relationship he seemed to be like "I'm a free spirit!" and disappear?
I guess I believed him at first that this was something he was genuinely trying, so when we sort of backslid into kind-of-dating and he said he wanted to be polyamorous I went along with it. The problem was that I kept trying to say "I don't think this is working, I'm jealous and unhappy and insecure, if this is what you want that's fine but also we need to not hang out and especially not to kiss anymore" and he would sort of... go after me about how that was disappointing because he thought I was more evolved than that, and he'd thought I could feel compersion, and he really valued our relationship and it seemed silly to end it because I couldn't embrace real freedom, blah blah blah you guys know exactly what this was. Polyamory was not his problem, his problem was that he was a jerk and my problem was that I wasn't owning my needs. Monogamous people use monogamous language to be jerks all the time.
But somehow I stopped dating him - and STARTED DATING ANOTHER GUY WHO DID THE EXACT SAME THING. Where did I find two of them? I went on a couple of dates with this second guy, said "hey, I'm getting the feeling that you're not looking for an exclusive relationship, but I am, so it was nice meeting you and best wishes" - and he pulled "but I thought we REALLY CLICKED and WHY CAN'T YOU BE MORE EVOLVED".
AND I BRIEFLY FELL FOR IT. TWICE. OH MY GOD.
This was interspersed with being hit on a lot by "couples looking for discreet casual third" and I think I sort of kept treating myself like because I was bisexual I wasn't allowed to ask for the relationship style I wanted? If I was really polyamorous, I think I would have had a different struggle, but I think I was secretly monogamous and so I just felt like I was being permanently relegated to "side piece" and wasn't good enough to advocate for my own needs?
(Yes, I am in therapy!)
My partner's baggage
I'm not going to get into it too much because it's less my business to share on the internet, but I feel like I had the classic straight-dating polyamory bad fit and she had the classic gay one - namely, instead of a bad relationship breaking up they added more people?
Unfortunately, her ex was also an actually abusive person, and there was a lot of stuff that was really bad, including the ex reallly pressuring people to do sexual things they didn't really sign up for to "make the relationship work". (Consent, what?). Some people use monogamous expectations to trample their partner's consent, this person used polyamorous language instead, again, the problem is that this person was a jerk, but I kind of feel like I have nowhere to talk about it without either feeling like I'm bashing the relationship style itself or conversely without monogamous friends zeroing in on the fact that the relationship was poly.
My partner is a lot more philosophical about the whole thing than I am - she's still friendly acquaintances with her ex-metamour, and they both view themselves as kind of co-survivors of a bad relationship that they're happy to be out of. (For the record it was the ex that added an extra person - she just kind of notified my partner that this person would be attending their relationship now).
(Yes, my partner is also in therapy!)
The problem
We've agreed to have a monogamous relationship - I think even without my baggage I just don't think that dating or romance are generally fun for me, I just really like my partner in particular and am content to call it quits at that. She also says that she's enthusiastic about monogamy.
But whenever polyamory comes up as a topic I have, like, an angry, jealous reaction. If my partner is involved, I wind up going BUT ARE YOU SURE THAT YOU'RE REALLY FINE WITH THIS??? way more than is necessary. If friends are involved, I try my best to hide that I'm sort of mad and feel guilty and bad and don't really know why. It's just this wave of unprocessed emotion that shows up, and I don't like it.
Plenty of our friends are poly, including a couple who've dealt with a lot of prejudice about the whole thing and are really sensitive about it. And to make it worse, I have bonus jealousy because one of the members of that couple used to date my partner (yeaaaars ago), so whenever the fact that they're poly comes up I suddenly go from "these people are so much fun to be around and I genuinely enjoy the depth of history here" to THREATENED AND MAD AND SURE SOMEONE IS ABOUT TO TELL ME TO BE MORE EVOLVED even though they would never do that because they're not jerks.
I guess my question is: poly people who have dated people who were jerks first and poly second, how did you process and get over it? I guess, like, was it hard because you had access to fewer cultural scripts about how those breakups should go? What were the key steps? Where there were problems that were specifically polyamory-flavored, how did you think through it? I even had trouble with a therapist at the time completely refusing to engage with the idea that there were other problems with my ex-boyfriend BESIDES nonmonogamy, and it made me feel very stymied. (But his problem! was that he was a jerk!)
And as world experts in thinking through and owning your shit - how do I actually close the book on this one? I mean, I guess therapy. But I don't even know how to articulate my goals, besides "feel settled and comfortable that everyone gets to choose the relationship style that works for them and it's not a referendum on anyone else" and "not be mad".