What is the best way I should handle this..

StrugglingAs3rd

New member
Hello and thank you for any advice to offer. This is a long story but I will try my best to make it concise. I was asked by a married couple to be their third. My understanding is the relationship was to be a triad. I am new to the scene so this was my first couple, Jennifer and George I will call them. I had almost no experience with women but knew this was the right situation for me.

From the beginning there were rules that I was only allowed to have intimacy with the couple, together. I learned later that George had been engaged in a secret affair, less than a year prior. Jennifer had trust issues. I felt I was at the mercy of their boundaries, so I agreed to what made them comfortable.

Feelings grew, there were words of love exchanged. I was committed to them, as I thought they were to me. Then it was discovered George was still having affairs. Jennifer had a hard time dealing with this, pushing me aside for some time. I was angry but willing to forgive. They agreed to seek counseling. However Jennifer's jealousy grew and she no longer wanted to me involved intimately. George however also started growing jealous, as he started to feel I was becoming "competition" of some sort because his wife enjoyed herself with me when we were intimate. I was asked to step aside for a month, to let them work out their issues. I was asked to remain committed, without any sort of physical relationship. I was willing to do this because of my feelings.

Then it turned out George was caught lying AGAIN - he lied that he had given up drinking and had addressed his alcohol issue. I told him I can't be in a relationship with someone who is continuously dishonest. A day later we all spoke on the phone, they had engaged in some discussion and I knew that for the best, we should part ways. We agreed to stay friendly and in contact. Once the call ended, he told Jennifer he never really cared about me. Two days later I received a text from George stating they missed me. Jennifer came to my defense, as to why the mixed messages. He then forbade her to contact me. She asked me to stop contact until she could work out issues in her marriage more or less. I agreed out of respect. Later that day she started texting me. And the following day. George started checking phone records, wanting to know what was going on. He and I appeared to be getting different stories from Jennifer. I confronted them both, asking why they were putting me in the middle of all of this nonsense.

This morning there was a Facebook post, insinuating that last night, they were with a different person. I was told I could not be intimate because Jennifer felt jealous and George was jealous and disinterested. I am heartbroken and dumbfounded. I lavished them with gifts, constantly thinking of them and making time in my work schedule that fit their lifestyle. I never asked them for anything. They have said over and over that I never caused them any problems. Yet I told them I didn't deserve to deal with whatever was going on between them and being punished for it. Jennifer doesn't want to speak to me anymore and I dare not call.

Should I just let them be? I love them dearly however it appears there are way too many issues going on....
 
Sounds like you are better off without them. Yes. Leave them be. I have no idea why you'd still be attracted/in love with this couple after all of that. If one of them texts you, just ignore it. There are more considerate, caring and competent people out there, and you don't need to involve yourself with their drama any longer.
 
I am sorry you hurt. Break ups are not fun.

I never asked them for anything.

I think in future you could learn to ask for the things you need to feel safe in a realtionship up front. List what you are and are not willing to do.

Not just accept an offer "as is" from naiveté. Get your own stuff on there and negotiate for what you need to feel safe and articulate what the deal breakers are.

They have said over and over that I never caused them any problems.

Not to put too fine a point on it... they have said a lot of unreliable stuff. Up and down and all around. I would not trust their word. In fact, guard against them coming at you together or separately with a lot of "sweetie pie honey bunch" designed to suck you back into their crazy. Say NO. Steer clear.

Yet I told them I didn't deserve to deal with whatever was going on between them and being punished for it.

Correct. You don't deserve to be treated this way. The way to solve it when you cannot trust them to behave decently toward you is for YOU to decide not to be around untrustworthy them and their drama.

Should I just let them be? I love them dearly however it appears there are way too many issues going on....

Yep. Leave them be. Mourn the beak up, but allow the detachment process to kick in so over time you can heal and feel better.

Again, I am sorry.

Galagirl
 
Forget them. They are both seriously fucked up. They fucked with you, and each other, and were acting like assholes, not ethical polyfolk! Nor were they considerate of you at all. What a train wreck. Block them, ignore them, keep walking and never look back. You can do better!
 
Hi StrugglingAs3rd,

Re (from OP):
"Later that day she started texting me. And the following day. George started checking phone records, wanting to know what was going on. He and I appeared to be getting different stories from Jennifer. I confronted them both, asking why they were putting me in the middle of all of this nonsense."

And? What was their answer?

Re:
"Should I just let them be?"

Yes. You should.

M'dear, you have been victimized by a classic unicorn hunting scenario. If you'll open a dictionary and look up "unicorn hunters," you will see a picture of George and Jennifer. Which is not a good thing!

It sucks that you were repeatedly penalized for their issues and shortcomings. I know it feels like this breakup is a bad thing, but in my opinion they did you a favor. Now that you have your freedom back, read and learn as much as you can about polyamory. Start with "More than Two: a practical guide to ethical polyamory," by Franklin Veaux and Eve Rickert ... as well as the wealth of stuff you can read on this forum. If you have more questions, don't hesitate to ask us.

I hope you'll get feeling better soon.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
Clearly, they're relationship to each other is what matters to them, and you are just a "secondary." They set the "rules" so that you couldn't be an equal triad, the fact that you could only be with the husband if the wife was present, that you were expected to "step back" when they needed to resolve something between them. People like them are exactly why most mature, experienced bisexual and polyamorous women will NOT get involved with couples. So sorry you've had this experience, and yes, break it off with them. If you want to explore a relationship with a woman, do so on your own. You don't have to sleep with her man too, assuming she has one. Likewise, if you want to experiment with polyamory, you don't have to do it by joining a couple. Best of luck.
 
Back
Top