Girlfriend of 6 years wants to have 1st child from “new”, other partner. What now?

WinstonSmith

New member
Will post TL;DR in the first post below (character limit)

Long version

-Years leading to opening the relationship-
My S.O. (who I will call AB from now on) and I got close rather quickly, even though we both lived in different countries. AB moved to my home country (let’s call it PA), learned the language extremely easily and started a study there. After three years of a lot of self-exploration, a lot of good opportunities and a myriad of created and supported insecurities (we both have/had issues that we confirmed in each other at times), we decided to pursue our studies in a different country (let’s call it BX) where we both were not at home. Meanwhile, we had already had huge ideas about moving to a different country after the study in BX (which had always been my dream, migrating and raising children). We even planned all of it, went looking for homes, visited the “dream country” a couple of times (it’s rather far away), but ultimately decided, whole-heartedly from both sides, against it.
In BX we got into very dark water because of, what I always assumed ‘me being me, being different’, really hit hard home once again, but since I now lived with someone, there was someone to notice. I spent less time going outside, going to university, developed severe social anxiety, panic attacks, and in general a heavy depression. In this time the physical aspect of our component started to disappear completely and AB started to have sexual dreams about her past relationship, with whom she barely had any connection any more. There was no interest in him from AB’s side, save sexually. I was supportive of the idea, but of course we had our speed bumps along the way. Meanwhile, AB helped me (where I did not fell at ease at all) seek therapy and to approach tests correctly (I had had therapy off and on the decade before, since my early teens, all to no avail because I could philosophise and talk too well to people for them to make any diagnosis). After eight months AB realised that the therapy was not going anywhere (severely incompetent psychiatrist) and sought help from a specialist, specialised in personality disorders and diagnoses. Within two months a diagnosis was formed and I was diagnosed with a personality disorder (which I don’t completely relate to any more) but also a severe, chronic depression; estimated to date back since my early teens or even pre-teens (at that time around 15 years). Needless to say, I did not know the world any different than I was experiencing it at that time. It was in the same year that AB’s study came to a close and her relative died, granting us the opportunity through an inheritance to move away from BX and to her home country, even the house where she grew up in, (let’s call it ST).

-Moving to AB’s home, which now was to be my home too-
We spent an entire summer, while still living in BX, renovating the home in ST. AB’s mother would still occupy a storey in the same building while we’d live in the two storeys upstairs from it. AB and I would share the garden with her mother, some communal duties and living costs were all arranged too. All in all, AB’s mother was/is very supportive and generous to accept us living there (technically, it’s her inheritance). The renovation took all my savings, and all of AB’s savings, and moved me about 400 miles away from the home I grew up in, my family, and friends.
Meanwhile, I was still struggling with the depression, finding therapy and medication. At first we sought for therapists in English, but after 8 months of disappointments (people claiming to speak English and then struggling to form sentences…) I started searching for German therapists.

-AB finding new love, I still struggle with depression and finding help-

At the same time, AB fell in love with her now partner (let’s call him EF). They started off very physically, exploring each other sexually in new territories (that I was also relatively interested in), but AB kept the relationship close to her heart out of fear I wouldn’t be able to handle it. I understand that completely, but at the time it made me feel I was excluded, and couldn’t get any closer to her anymore. Our physical relationship was still almost non-existent, with AB showing no interest and making it clear any initiative would have to come from my side. I tried, and got sometimes pushed back in extremely hurtful ways, which made it even more difficult to approach her. In this year, many mistakes from both sides were made, ultimately leading to a final confrontation and sit-down, with both sides agreeing to a policy of being flat-mates for a while, until we both can straighten ourselves out.

-Me finding help, AB and EF growing ever closer, me meeting EF-
Shortly after this time I managed to find a therapist, my medication started working (I had started medication a few months earlier, a very trying time since I was very adverse to medication), and I managed to go outside more and started exercising daily again.
Shortly before I found my therapist I met EF for the first time, and as I expected we got on like crazy. We share a sense of humour, can enjoy the same kind of music, games, and books and in general think rather alike at times. Naturally, we are plenty different too, but there is no animosity at all from either side. Since then, we have met three times, and AB and EF have been together for about a year (and have met more often at his place a few hours from here).

-AB breaking the news of wanting a poly-family-
It was obvious to me that EF, who lost his relationship of six years a few months ago, and AB got on very well, shared a very intense connection (like AB and myself, AB is a wonderfully intense person). The subject of children was sometimes a topic between AB and me when we lived in BX, but I needed to always halt that because our flat was tiny, we lived in a city we both didn’t feel at home, and at my worst time in the depression I was mentally gone for three months (I still barely have a recollection of the time, and think I might have set foot outside the home twice in nearly the whole season), which for me was enough of a reason to not start children. We also had no definitive idea of a future home.
When we did move to ST and settled down, AB expressly stated having no interest in children for at least some more years, because she began exploring herself. Naturally, it came as a surprise, when I had finally started coming back into the world with completely renewed energy, to learn she now did want to start a family, but her first child would be EF’s.

-My feelings for EF and EB-
I love EF. I think he is both mentally and physically a beautiful person. He is warm, stubborn, funny, emotional, cold, childish (in a good sense), adventurous, homely, thoughtful and caring. All qualities and pitfalls I recognise in AB and myself too. I love AB more closely than I have ever loved anyone in my life. She is beautiful, intelligent, extremely wise (although that’s often blocked by trauma, which I have not once attributed to her as a person, but always see as a point of her parents not knowing the first thing about raising children or loving people), sexy beyond measure, creative, utterly driven, more energetic than anyone I’ve ever seen, sometimes hasted, funny, warm, accepting and never stops growing. We’ve been together six years, shared deaths in family, our weakest moments, sexual exploration to a small extent, deep insecurities, fights close to storms in intensity, and in general push each other every day to be better people.

-My issues with not being the first father-
Even though EF will be more and more at home in the building AB and I currently live in, he would still have his primary residence a few hours away (unless he moves). The child would, most of the time, live with his/her mother and me. I, unlike AB and EF, have a rather large family (one of my siblings has own children already) and come together with all people from one of my parent’s side once a year (35+ people). Naturally, a child of my partner would be welcome there (or at least, I’d want it to be welcome there), even if it’s not my biological child.
I have huge problems facing the prospect of my first diaper change not being my biological child, the first steps I see, words I see, the first time I see a child grow, the first time I see my partner pregnant, the first time I feel feet in her belly, the first time I see her glow, the first time I hold a person I will raise, the first time I will sing to a child, the first time I show a child I raise to my parents and siblings, the first time I send a child to school and make it breakfast, the first time I read the child bedtime stories, the first time I tuck it in, the first time a child crawls in my bed because it is afraid at night, the first time a child asks me any question to which I have no answer, the first time I see the child I raise laugh, the first time… not being mine biologically.
 
TL;DR (for the complete story, please scroll up)

I’m ready to have children in the sense that I am emotionally stable enough, can afford it both time-wise and financially and have been wanting to have children for more than ten years. My partner and I have been together long enough, but due to a heavy phase of depression, diagnostics and neurological test and moving through three countries, I didn’t find the situation suitable.
Last year we have settled down in a country I’ve never lived (S.O.’s home country), and had to start working on myself after finally getting diagnosed, medicated and found good therapy (all in a foreign language). Meanwhile S.O. found another partner and has become serious with him too. I’ve met him three times now and she broke the news she wants to have children with both of us, but wants to bear his child first because of a “connection” they have and a “gut feeling”.
I am completely supportive of a poly-family, but find it difficult to experience her first pregnancy with another man, living with a child that is not biologically my own, dealing with my family (they both have a single-parent, smaller than average family, whereas I have 5 people in my closest family, 35+ members on 1 side, about 10 on the other side) and coming to grips with the fact that I have spent 6 years building for a future with my S.O. that I now have to put on hold, because she first wants to explore it with another man.
 
I see the purpose of being a parent as this: to love and nurture a child, to keep the child safe, and teach the child how to be a caring and productive member of society. Why does it matter whose DNA the child has?

To worry about who fathered someone's child first, or stupid things like whose name or bloodline is continued, is shallow and doesn't satisfy any useful purpose in relation to raising a child; it only satisfies your ego.

It takes a village to raise a child - remember that.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile S.O. found another partner and has become serious with him too. I’ve met him three times now and she broke the news she wants to have children with both of us, but wants to bear his child first because of a “connection” they have and a “gut feeling”. I am completely supportive of a poly-family, but find it difficult to [come] to grips with the fact that I have spent 6 years building for a future with my S.O. that I now have to put on hold, because she first wants to explore it with another man.

It seems to me that your SO's choice of mate is what is upsetting you, not that the child wouldn't have your DNA. People adopt kids all the time and love them thoroughly without issue and I suspect you would, as well. The problem here seems to be that your SO wants kids with this new guy right now and not with you. Your issue is with her choosing this new man over you, not with the baby's genetics.
 
Last edited:
I see the purpose of being a parent as this: to love and nurture a child, to keep the child safe, and teach the child how to be a caring and productive member of society. Why does it matter whose DNA the child has?

To worry about who fathered someone's child first, or stupid things like whose name or bloodline is continued, is shallow and doesn't satisfy any useful purpose in relation to raising a child; it only satisfies your ego.

Thank you for replying. I guess everyone has a different view on what they want from life, and everything you do is to satisfy your ego in my opinion. Claiming these things to be "stupid" and "shallow" is rather disrespectful in my opinion and I find it hard to see how your reply contributes to this topic. Basically, what you said to my emotional problems here is "What does it matter?". Well, maybe it doesn't for you, but maybe it does for others. Maybe you drive a fancy car, got married, value complete and utter freedom, grow your own food, have 17 cats... Who am I to say your choices are 'stupid' or 'shallow'?

How we feel about our relationship with children, and the other family and friends in its circle, does influence the child. So, a child can feel a more direct connection to people only for sharing a name, location, or blood-line. Again, thank you for reading, but your calling my worries "shallow" and stating "facts" seems rather narrow-minded to me. But, of course, your writing could also come across differently than you meant it, so if you feel like rectifying your statement I'm open for it : )

It seems to me that your SO's choice of mate is what is upsetting you - not that the child doesn't have your DNA. People adopt kids all the time and love them thoroughly without issue. The problem here seems to be that your SO wants kids with this new guy and not with you. Your issue is with her, not with the baby.

That's an interesting perspective, thank you for sharing.
My issue is indeed not with the baby, I'm sorry if it came across that way. It is not a problem for me to raise children that are not biologically my own, should I not be able to have any of my own (biologically speaking). The problem lies indeed in the fact that she wishes to have her first child with the "new" guy and not with me, and me being a part of a poly-family where I feel it would be more difficult for me to move.
 
i am afraid i can not be to any real help in this matter, but have you already brought this up with your SO?

I have. She sometimes says things in the vein of 'Whoever gets me pregnant first...' (our sex life is rather... absent, so yeah.), sometimes tries to give me rational reasons ('He told me I'd look beautiful pregnant the first time we were intimate' / 'He is a few years older than you and he would find it difficult being forty or older when his child is 5 or 7') and other times says 'It's him, because of just a gut-feeling'. A week ago it gave me the feeling nothing is set in stone, yet when he came by last weekend and we discussed it briefly again, they seemed to both be talking as if I had a choice of living with their proposal or leaving the relationship.

Her other partner and I have talked about it at some length too. He is completely understanding, also of the biological side and the fact that I feel I've worked so hard to be where I am with my S.O., but he ultimately stands at the argument that it is her decision and he would also accept whatever she chooses.
 
I am talking from my point of vieuw now, what i would do (off course i am not you, but hey you ask advice and ponder about it and then take the action that sound the most logic)
I would take a moment to discuss it, talk it through. ask her to make up her mind. it feels to me that she doesnt really know what she wants or something.
That i feel left out, that you took a long time to build everything up and feel like you get pusshed aside, ask her how she would see everything.
if she sees you all living together in one house or seperate ect ect.
That would make her think thngs true more too. and go from there
Hope this makes some sense and helps

Sadly i am still wet behind the ear on alot of poly stuff, but i bet you get some other great pointers!
Hang in there!
 
Frankly, I suspect that if she has his child first, you won't have a chance to have your own with her. It sounds like they have a greater connection and better sex life than you do with her. She is making a DNA argument in his favor (he would find it difficult being forty or older when his child ...), but if DNA doesn't matter (and to most of us it does!), then why shouldn't yours have priority as you've been together longer. Maybe he won't even be in the relationship in a couple of years. Anyway, I question her commitment to her relationship with you, and that needs to be discussed before this decision is made. You need to decide what works for you, without simply caving to her wants.
 
You need to decide what works for you, without simply caving to her wants.

Well, it's her body and her choice as to whom she wants to be impregnated by. He can't dictate what she does with her body. All the OP can do is choose whether or not to remain in the relationship and if he will co-parent a child fathered by someone else.

The problem lies indeed in the fact that she wishes to have her first child with the "new" guy and not with me, and me being a part of a poly-family where I feel it would be more difficult for me to move.
Hmm, but why? WinstonSmith, I am curious -- would you be okay if, say, she had two children and yours was the first? Then you would be fine with co-parenting both kids as long as you got first dibs on her womb? Or do you not want to be involved with co-parenting his offspring at all, even though the mother is someone you love? What if you had met her and she already had a child with someone else, would you resent not being first at having fathered a child of hers? I'm just asking these questions to understand your logic system and reasons for your objection to it.
 
Last edited:
Hmm, but why? WinstonSmith, I am curious -- would you be okay if, say, she had two children and yours was the first? Then you would be fine with co-parenting both kids as long as you got first dibs on her womb?

Again I'll venture to read his mind and say that Mr. Smith would feel much more at ease getting first dibs, not for territory marking reasons, but for what that says about his relationship's value to his SO. As it is, the new guy has jumped over Mr. Smith in seniority and has gotten the promotion, even though Mr. Smith has put in many more years with the firm. That's what Mr. Smith cannot abide - from his point of view, what this says about the SO's esteem of his relationship with her.
 
Last edited:
I am talking from my point of vieuw now, [...]some other great pointers!
Hang in there!

I have taken plenty of moments to talk about it, but one of my S.O.'s traumas is that she feels extremely quickly attacked when people address her on her behaviour or discuss matters in which she can establish "guilt", even though there is no guilt at all. Me telling her that I feel rejected, has quickly been translated to her as me blaming her for her rejecting me. This makes it rather hard to discuss it, but all in all I think we have talked about our points of view, and me discussing it more with her now would just be venting and whining.
Thank you for thinking along : )

Frankly, I suspect that if she has his child first, you won't have a chance to have your own with her. It sounds like they have a greater connection and better sex life than you do with her. She is making a DNA argument in his favor (he would find it difficult being forty or older when his child ...), but if DNA doesn't matter (and to most of us it does!), then why shouldn't yours have priority as you've been together longer. Maybe he won't even be in the relationship in a couple of years. Anyway, I question her commitment to her relationship with you, and that needs to be discussed before this decision is made. You need to decide what works for you, without simply caving to her wants.

Thank you for your perspective, it's great to get food for thought.

Why won't I have a chance? Of course they have a greater connection and better sex life. It's called New Relationship Energy, she's developed a lot during the last six years, making it very easy to start fresh with other people and not have this baggage we might have together, but also not this history. We may have had our struggles, but we have fought through them together.

The DNA-argument in his favour is absolutely irrelevant, and I think she knows that too. We even discussed her giving me reasons, and I said she shouldn't try to find any (because they were all unsound) and that if it's a "gut feeling" she'd have to let it be a gut feeling. I would like to have an explanation, but I fear there is none to be had. Maybe she just needs to get a chance again to see how great of a person I am, and how much I have changed in the last months.
The chance that he won't be in the relationship is of course a realistic one, but so is the chance that he will stay. Since I like him a lot, I wouldn't like him to leave, but I also have told her that the week she told me about wanting to bear his child, she told me about her doubts about their staying together because of a life-altering decision (financial investment) he is discussing with his ex-partner who he still runs a business with.

Her commitment to our relationship has indeed wavered. The past months, due to fights and her wanting to be able to explore, she has become more and more focussed on "whatever she wants to do should be possible, and people have to stay with her because they like what she does"; a rather hard motto to get along with, I find.


Well, it's her body and her choice as to whom she wants to be impregnated by. He can't dictate what she does with her body. All the OP can do is choose whether or not to remain in the relationship and if he will co-parent a child fathered by someone else.


Hmm, but why? WinstonSmith, I am curious -- would you be okay if, say, she had two children and yours was the first? Then you would be fine with co-parenting both kids as long as you got first dibs on her womb? Or do you not want to be involved with co-parenting his offspring at all, even though the mother is someone you love? What if you had met her and she already had a child with someone else, would you resent not being first at having fathered a child of hers? I'm just asking these questions to understand your logic system and reasons for your objection to it.

I agree with you. It is her body indeed and no-one can dictate what she does with it. That has also always been the first thing I have told her and her other partner. It's AB's decision, and I can only say how I feel about and what it might mean for our relationship.

Thank you for asking those questions, it helps me reflect on myself if I have to think of answers. The matter of her already having children and then meeting her I've thought about already too, and I would not have a problem with that so much because I'd know that when meeting her. I'd have a choice to be with her ánd her children if I wanted to.
I also don't mind her having his children and mind, and all together creating a big happy family. If possible, it would even be more perfect if I also have another partner with home I'd feel comfortable having children and sharing that experience.
The "first dibs on her womb" is maybe a summary of what it is about. The funny thing is, that I care less about her pregnancy and that experience, then what comes after. I want that fresh new experience of being a father to be biologically mine, and she has exactly the same desire, but to the other partner. The funny thing is, that she always tells me she thinks I would be the best man to be the father to her children she's ever met, and that she would feel most comfortable going through the pregancy with the other partner. It's again trying to find reasoning and an argument in the matter, from her side, because when I think about that, then it wouldn't matter if it's my seed in the womb, because he could, and of course would, still be there all steps of the pregnancy; just as I would if it were his seed in her womb.
What I've heard most is that it would "feel right having his child first" and she doesn't want to risk any damage to the child, and having my child first could cause damage because it would be against her will. It's a reason that goes in a viscious circle, and I don't seem to make any sense of it. I have the feeling they need not discuss the matter at all, because of course his wishes are being tended to.

To understand my system: I want the first experience of having a child, in my home, that I worked -so- hard for to get, that I have lost and will lose nights of good sleep over, to be my biological child and not that of another. If only already for the security of being involved, of having a say in matters. I trust them completely, but am also very aware of how quickly things can change. If push comes to shove, I have -no- security in this situation, just blind faith and hope...

Again I'll venture to read his mind and say that Mr. Smith would feel much more at ease getting first dibs, not for territory marking reasons, but for what that says about his relationship's value to his SO. As it is, the new guy has jumped over Mr. Smith in seniority and has gotten the promotion, even though Mr. Smith has put in many more years with the firm. That's what Mr. Smith cannot abide - from his point of view, what this says about the SO's esteem of his relationship with her.

This is indeed quite right, although I really don’t feel right using words like “seniority” but it’s a very apt analogy. I’ve discussed this with him too, that I feel she’s changed a hell of a lot through all we (she and I) have been through together, and he comes along and gets the star prize. To which he responded that other people have helped him change too, but I told him I’m not getting the benefit from it by seeing them or raising a child with them. I don’t mind people learning and growing because of other people, but there is a reason you stick with people, and now it seems that part of that reason is indeed being jumped over and given to someone else. My SO and I have agreed to work on our relationship after I wrote her a long letter in which I explained my feelings that I did not feel as if I was being treated as a different person; that she has explored all these new ways of living and made it very clear how she has changed and wants to live, but still treats me like I was six years ago, brings up arguments of things I said six years ago (once claiming that I said back in BX that I wasn’t ready to have children, so the fact that her other partner immediately wanted to felt good to her).

“what this says about the SO's esteem of his relationship with her”, writing and reading all of this, I guess that exact line is indeed what it comes down to.
 
I'm sorry. :(

It sounds like you are grieving a loss. You chose to move 400 miles away from your people and to invest all your savings into renovating her mother's property where you and she currently reside in the hopes that this would be the nest for building family in. You had a certain vision of a future you hoped for badly and thought both were working towards. Your first experience of fatherhood would be with your GF and a shared baby.

She has the right to do as she pleases with her body/her life. However she maybe didn't keep you as in touch with that as you may have hoped.
  • She first said she didn't want to deal in babies for a few years.
  • Now she's recently told you that she prefers to be pregnant with her OSO instead.
  • She's chosen something else for herself than baby with you

Which leaves you with these choices in return:

  • let go of the vision of a future you hoped for badly. Stay here and have your first close fatherhood experiences with her and the OSO's baby instead.
  • Keep the vision, let go of the relationship. Seek someone else to share family life with so your first fatherhood experiences ARE with your biological child. You just won't have them with her.
  • You move out. Go do something else for the next 2 years and then come back after she's done being pregnant and the baby has hit 1st bday. So you get to keep some of the vision and not deal in "first year memories" with the OSO's baby. But know it comes at a risk of growing apart, so this choice might be worse than just ending it outright so you can know where things stand.

Could go around in circles, but I think that's the heart of the matter: All routes entail a deep loss of some kind for you.

You want comfort from you partner. It isn't forthcoming. You want to talk about how you feel, but it sounds like she does defensive listening rather than active listening. She takes it personally and makes it be about her rather than seeing your in your context. You maybe end up comforting her when you yourself are run down emotionally and do not have it to give. Or staying silent so as not to make waves. Which adds to the feeling of isolation you had already been struggling with.

It's a rough spot to be in. So I'm sorry.

There's no rose smelling choice here. All choices stink. In the end you can only choose "which one stinks less?"

I think given your depression history you could be best off choosing the most self respecting choice that helps you keep depression at bay.

I hope in time you feel better -- whichever path you choose.

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
Sounds like she's made her decision. You want a child with her, she wants a child with him instead, id likely move on. There's no way I personally would want to deal with anyone else's child.
 
Hi Winston,

I've read all that's been written so far and there's a lot to be said, and this might be a little off-topic, but it troubles me somewhat this idea that EF is going to father a child but someone else (you) will be doing all the work of actually raising the child. Shouldn't EF move in with you guys and be part of the family?

That aside, how much of a problem is it for you to be a surrogate parent to the first child you raise? I get that it is a problem, but is it something that you can stand? If you can, you may find that raising EF's child is rewarding enough to make it a happy experience overall. I presume after that AB would be willing to get pregnant by you, and you would still have many joyful firsts with your own child even if it wasn't the first child you had cared for.

Think of it as a very intense babysitting job. It is not your child, but you are caring for it as a way to support AB. Your own child is your own child and that is still going to feel special in a different way. You even have the advantage of having some practice at parenting by the time your own child is born, which might make parenting your own child easier.

These are all options, and none of them are obligations. AB has decided she wants her first child to be EF's. That's her decision. She has the right to make that choice. You, in turn, have the right to choose whether you're willing to be that child's surrogate father. Are you willing to support AB to that extent? If not, you simply tell her "No." Then she has to figure out for herself how and whether to provide a day-to-day father for her child.

Which of course brings me back to my first point; in my opinion if EF is going to father the child, then EF should move in with you guys and parent the child himself. Others will say it's too soon for EF to be moving in with you guys, but if that's true, then isn't it also too soon for him to be fathering a child with AB? Hopefully my logic makes some sense here ...

Regardless of what EF does, and regardless of what AB does, the only person's actions, and direction in life, that you can choose, are your own actions and your own direction. You'll have to decide what your own boundaries are: what you are and are not willing to be a part of. Then choose a course of action that honors your boundaries. That could mean breaking up with AB. It would be a tough decision, but it's a decision only you can make. Decide carefully.

I hope this helps.
Sincerely,
Kevin T.
 
I'm joining the conversation a little late...initially I was going to "cut and paste" a lot to reply but it got overwhelming.

I'm going to disagree a bit with the folks that say DNA "shouldn't" matter. I actually really, really HATE it when other people say how I "should" feel about something.

I wanted children. My own children. Preferably mine and MrS's children; but, when that didn't happen, mine and Dude's children. (I've written about this here before, I'll try to find the link to the long version).

For me, the experience of pregnancy and childbirth was the initial draw. Secondarily, I was curious to experience watching "our" child grow - seeing what traits were expressed in a new person and which traits they developed that were different than either of us!

If this sounds really clinical - well, that's the kind of person that I am. I don't "love babies" or "love kids" just BECAUSE they are babies/kids. I'm sure if I had kids I would love them. I love our sisters' kids and would happily raise them if called upon.

If MrS and I had happened to have children (or I had children with Dude) then MrS would have been the primary caregiver. (Dude was happy to be a sperm-donor, but no particular interest in being a father, whereas MrS would have been a terrific parent!)

When it turned out that my own biology thwarted my desires. Well - that ended it. I wasn't willing to endure the roller-coaster of fertility treatments with the, strong, possibility of failure. MrS would have supported any decision, including adoption. I admire those who adopt, but that wasn't an answer to my desire to bear a child of my own.

Those who say that DNA "shouldn't" matter likely feel that it's a "good thing" I am barren, since I don't want kids for the "right reasons"...they may be correct.

JaneQ
 
Well said, Jane, and you're right: DNA does matter, to a lot of people. I mean you said it yourself: You'd happily raise your sisters' kids if called upon, but that doesn't change the fact that having your *own* children is an experience that can't be duplicated.
 
I love my children dearly. But I am so not a fan of most other people's children. I couldn't be the primary care give to a child who is not related to me.
 
I love my children dearly. But I am so not a fan of most other people's children. I couldn't be the primary care give to a child who is not related to me.

Same here. This is a huge reason I wouldn't be with someone who has kids with someone else. I don't want to be forced to deal with people I don't want to oe baby mama or kids I don't like.
 
This thread really highlights how different people have different ideas about parenting. Personally, I'm actively trying to get pregnant. I'm a lesbian in my late 30s, relying in donated sperm (which brings a new perspective to DNA), and recognizing that my age might impair my ability to conceive. My partner has some medical limitations that could make it difficult for her to conceive. And given our queerness and the conservative area where we live, adopting a baby would prove challenging and very expensive.

But what I want most of all is a baby, and while it would be interesting to have a genetic connection to it, it's not that important to me. I will be co-parenting with someone who won't have a genetic connection, but will be every bit as much a parent (and we'll get the legal paperwork to establish that, if our state doesn't recognize the marriage by the time we get there). I just want a baby, to care for, to love, to raise, to show the world to. I would adopt one today if it were an option-- I would absolutely choose that over having the experience of pregnancy and giving birth!!! It's just not a simple option.

So I don't feel the same way as people who want a genetic bond. But I *am* very much in touch with the need to have a legal connection to the child.

To the OP, you seem to be in a situation where you may end up co-parenting (or group-parenting) a child where you are not the legal parent. If you don't want that, the time to be clear about that is now. If you aren't going to be available to play the role of a parent if you don't have the genetic and legal connection to the baby, be clear about that with your girlfriend, so she knows what to expect.

At the same time, just because you've been there longer does NOT mean that you have a claim to her, her uterus, or her future life. If she chooses to parent with this other partner, she gets to make that choice. If that means that you will step back from her in order to make room to build the family you want with someone else, she needs to know what to expect.

This isn't the time to float along, trying to make the best of it, pretending that you can be a part of someone else's ideal poly structure, if that doesn't fit you.

But if you think you might be able to grieve for the lost hopes that you had, but still adjust, step up, and be a part of an extended poly family, contribute to group parenting, be a part of this, and let go of your hurt feelings, that's still an option. But I recognize that there is some grief there-- I hear you on that.
 
Back
Top